Huge line because people know this is the place! And the iced coffee had a variety of milks for your liking. read more

Seaford Bagels - Light veggie cream cheese on an egg bagel - Bagels Near Me - Seaford, New York

I guess the expense of renovating, or maybe NEW OWNERSHIP gets put on the customer. I've been going there once or twice a week for years for a GREAT Bacon Egg and Cheese sandwich. Well last week was my LAST time there. Price gouging is for REAL. Just bought a dozen eggs for $1.99 not $7.99 when the prices were up. Bought pound of bacon for $4.99, not $8.99. Cost of those items went down but SEAFORD BAGELS prices went up. Just under $9 for a BEC on a bagel with 1 egg. There's plenty other bagel stores with the same sandwich for around $7 with 2 eggs. I'm done, good luck. read more

Picked up an assortment of bagels, all with a good schmear amount of veggie cream cheese or plain cream cheese. They were all excellent! The bagel had a good amount of chew, just the way we like it. Highly recommend if you like this type of bagel! read more

Been coming here my entire life. A majority of the staff are friendly & courteous. Two particular women always have sour nasty faces but the bagels are great so I over looked it. Today 10/23 one of the nasty employees (heavy set, early 30s, blue unflattering speckled leggings) made my egg sandwich. Please see photos attached. There is absolutely no excuse. Immediately I called to explain the situation & was told the grill was off and I could not receive a replacement. I was too disgusted to want one anyway. Update 10/24: called to have issue addressed by owner. "Manager" states he is on vacation, coming back & leaving again. I explained the issue & that it was unacceptable. She did not seem to think it was a big deal at all. (Maybe they regularly act this negligent???) She advised she would take my number & he would follow up. LOL Not the best business practices. If you are still interested in potentially ruining your day here: Small cramped parking lot available behind Seaford Bagels. There is additional free street parking out front on Merrick Road. read more

See all

$24 for a breakfast wrap and ice tea is crazy work. Very high priced for what it is. It's shocking

I have been coming to this bagel store forever and it pains me to do this. In the last year it seems like I have had too many mistakes made on what I ordered. Mistakes that could have been life threatening to others. On several occasions I have ordered cinnamon bagel with cream cheese and once home found cinnamon/raisin/walnut cream cheese on my bagel. I HATE walnuts and thank God I am not allergic to them. But today was the final straw when I ordered a bagel with the olive cream cheese only to find what ended up being Jalapeno cream cheese! WTF?! Seriously? Today was a new staff person, short with dark hair. Normally I would not do this but it has been happening all too frequently especially with the newer employees. I'm not sure if they don't understand the English language well or they just can't tell what cream cheese is what but this is crazy. Now I will have to check my bagel every time I order when I am already usually in a rush. Ladies, get your act together or find work that you're better suited for. read more

Huge, Beautiful selection of bagels, muffins, salads. sandwiches. I knew I wanted a bagel with cream cheese when I walked in but suddenly became indecisive when I saw the incredible selection! So many choices! There are plenty of tables & booths if you choose to dine in. I had to grab & go. A lovely lady asked what I wanted as soon as I got to the counter. She quickly made my egg bagel w/ scallion cream cheese and I paid $4.32. A bargain if you ask me. The bagel was so soft and fresh. The cream cheese full of flavor and abundant! Next time I'm trying one of their sandwiches! read more

Seaford Bagels - Egg bagel with scallion cream cheese - Bagels Near Me - Seaford, New York

The service was amazing the bagels were fresh and came out very quickly and were amazing. I tried many bagels before and this was my favorite. My order was a sesame bagel with cream and lox. The interior was also very nice very came and homey. read more

Been coming here for years. Early morning crew is on point. After that it's 50/50. Over the years quality and service has gone down as prices have increased. Some great people and some bad eggs but that's anywhere. It's just that the high pricing isn't worth the wait or a mediocre sandwich/bagel. Many other places around that are 100%. read more

Love this place. Delicious bagels. Good prices. Wonderful Employees who are so kind and efficient! read more

Seaford Bagels - Bagels Near Me - Seaford, New York

Vegan/Dairy Free Friendly! I didn't see any tofutti cream cheese on their menu so I was disappointed. However, I still asked if they had and luckily they did! I was so excited that a local bagel place was catering to differing dietary needs. My sister and I got tuna as well and wow it was good. It wasn't too fishy and had the perfect amount of flavor! Loved it :) I will be a returning customer for sure. read more

Over priced. Can't take an order correctly to save their life. Terrible staff attitude. Don't waste your time.

I came here for over 15 years. Every time i come in here i order the same sandwich and get a different price. Basically whoever you get makes a price up and the price can swing from $ 2-3 dollar difference plus they charge a credit card fee. I know eggs are expensive but $20 for 2 egg and cheese on a croissant? Oh yea they don't tell you that you get a free small coffee already built in the price. They are banking on people not knowing about it and saving money that way. Also it would be nice for the employees who seem like they have a hard life working in a bagel store to stop speaking spanish behind the counter. They speak spanish loud. THIS IS AMERICA!!! seems like some of them have an attitude. I cant can't believe the owner allows this. Place has gone downhill. read more

Have had their egg and cheese on a roll a few times and is always consistently fresh. Coffee is good too. The downfall is lack of parking availability on weekends. Don't park in the bank next door unless you want a ticket. My husband has gone for egg sandwiches on the weekends and drove right home because the line was out the door and the parking sucked. read more

Seaford Bagels - Bagels Near Me - Seaford, New York

Best LI bagels! Been coming here since my teens and this place has the fluffiest yet crispiest bagels anywhere! I no longer live on Long Island and stink up the plane when I fly home as I always take home a dozen (and they give you 6 free!!!) then freeze em! Score! read more

See all

My sister asked for an egg sandwich with cheese. She Received this. (An egg sandwich with an order slip placed right on top of the eggs and cheese under the roll) This is negligent and NOT acceptable! How does this even happen? It looks intentional! She called to explain what happened and was told they could mot remake her sandwich (why would we even want that?) and was offered a refund or credit. The person who made this should not have a job. read more

Seaford Bagels - Egg sandwich served with paper - Bagels Near Me - Seaford, New York

Best bagels on Long Island! Worth the half hour drive! The staff is so friendly and my favorite bagel is the poppyseed with cream cheese. I strongly recommend it! read more

This is a great bagel spot. Came here with my wife's family. Inside is organized chaos but the sandwiches are soooo good. I haven't had an egg-everything in years. Love it. Only thing I noticed is all the coffee is flavored. They didn't seem to have regular coffee. Will be smuggling some bagels back to Tampa! read more

Seaford Bagels - Bagels Near Me - Seaford, New York

So disappointed with my delivery. Received my dozen bagels on a Wednesday night at 7pm. Separated cut in half and got ready for freezer as instructed. Within hours my bagels were white molded! Had to throw them all away! What a waste of money! read more

See all

Bagels were fresh and the cream cheese has a lot of variety. It definitely is a must try.

Great fresh dense bagels, line may be long, it moves quickly. Staff friendly and helpful. Nice seeing High school or college age staff, friendly and quick. read more

I am leaving this review because I am Absolutely disgusted with what I just heard I just ordered Three bagels and cream cheese from Seaford bagels and it cost me $16 no problem as I always have a great experience w the bagels here and love them they are usually always my go to bagel store and always worth the wait!! Definitely not today this is my bagel today.. now I never ever complain unless I really feel the need too.. and I really feel the need to Bc it's very comical that I'm posting this.. but with how expensive everything in this world has become I had too this time I feel businesses are hurting and in return are jeopardizing their business So apparently there is a cream cheese shortage and There was absolutely no cream cheese put on my bagel today and when I asked the woman who made my bagel (who was the manager) she said that this is the new norm These days on how much cream cheese they are allowed to put on their bagels that they owners told the girls working there to cut back on cream cheese because there is a cream cheese shortage!! and that they as a store are only allowed two blocks of cream cheese from distributors.. I was still charged the same amount as I was a month ago But given 90% less product this is absolutely ridiculous to me .. How do places plan to stay in business with a business plan like that??? If I could give Seaford bagels no stars for this review I would read more

Seaford Bagels - Bagels Near Me - Seaford, New York

See all

Always delicious fresh bagels. I love their mini black and white cookies their chocolate chip cookies and their mini apple turnovers. They have a great team of loyal employees that have been there for a long time. Always my go to bagels. Bring them to Florida every month for the family. read more

See all

Great selection of bagels and bialys, in my opinion they are the best. I remember years ago having workers that were diligent and hard working people. The service now is horrendous. There was no line and I waited. I wasn't even acknowledged standing at the counter for what felt like eternity. I'm sure it wasn't, But the personal conversations made waiting so much more frustrating. I guess in these times it's hard to get good help. read more

One of the best bagel places on Long Island great bagels, variety of fish, great selection of coffee.

Went there on a lazy sunday morning not for egg sandwiches, but for half a dozen bagels with nothing on them. No butter, no cream cheese, no PB. 6 plain bagels $9. None of the bagels were made of gold, so I was confused. Also, at 6 bagels, not 1 add in? Yikes. I hadn't been to Seaford Bagels i ages. And they reminded me why. read more

Worst service, rude, awful. The crew that worked here when I grew up was amazing. With every year it seems they become more and more lazy and nasty and entitled at this place. Lost a lifelong customer today. Also quality has downgraded. Might as well go to park bagel. read more

Honestly the best bagels on Long Island. They are what you think of when people talk about New York bagels. The staff is super friendly and they have a lot of food options here with a large assortment of drink options as well. The line can be a little long and you may have a longer wait than your typical bagel store; but there is a reason for that and it's because these bagels seriously are so good. Parking can be a little bit difficult sometimes as well, but usually never a huge problem. My go to place for a nice morning bagel and I'm not even from Seaford. Highly recommend! read more

i've lived in Seaford for 3 years now and Seaford Bagels was the first local bagel shop i tried in this area- have been to a few others in the area since then, but this is THE spot for fresh hot bagels with any cream cheese you could want! just picked up an order i placed over the phone, and they do curbside too! i got a special today when ordering a dozen bagels (18 for the price of 12) which is a great deal glad Seaford Bagels is open again after closing for two weeks of quarantine! read more

Seaford Bagels - to go order placed over the phone, ready in 5 mins. - Bagels Near Me - Seaford, New York

We walked in and my guy from Strong Island looked in the cases only to ask me, "What is that?". ME- from Las Vegas in disbelief a New Yorker didn't know, "That's schmear!" There were thick piles of beautiful schmear, or as the Bagel undereducated folks would call "cream cheese", in the case to choose from. Some were covered in berries, some were covered in fresh herbs - either way, for a connoisseur of cream cheese it was Disneyland! I have been doing time in San Diego so the treat of a New York style bagel was definitely on my agenda for a surprise Long Island visit. Being from Vegas, for those of you who do not know, I have always had access to New York style Bagels since there is a large population of New Yorkers who have relocated to my hometown. Not to mention New Yorkers helped start the Vegas strip, they also started a lot of restaurants there too. I was never absent of good food. Nonetheless, in San Diego the story is much different. I have literally been starving and everything taste like quinoa topped with twigs and berries. Trying to find a decent Bagel or Italian food = forget about it! My guy took me to Seaford Bagels after a park walk to get food for the moving crew. When I walked in I was delighted with all of the options of schmear. Furthermore, the choices and bagels including the tie-dye bagel were enough for me to take a picture for my food connoisseur friend in Las Vegas. I had to make her jealous! I opted for the Lox and schmear with red onion, no tomato because the texture kind of grosses me out. I forgot to ask for capers which would have set the entire sandwich to a level of perfection only my four cow stomachs would appreciate. The Bagel was exactly what I expected, BLISS. The schmear was fresh and creamy, it was oozing out of the side in abundance. The Lox were also fresh; a heavy helping was piled on my bagel. You have an option for a small side salad which is a tiny cup with your choice. I opted for the macaroni salad which was not too mayonnaise or mustard ingredient overwhelming. It was a clean palatable salad I enjoyed. The pickle tastes homemade, it was clean and crisp not the most favorable I've ever had but I will eat it again for sure :-) What I liked best about Seaford Bagels is the layout of the restaurant/deli. You can go in to order your bagels (I would call ahead), and on the side counters you have plenty of coffee options. From flavored coffee to coffee the temperature of the sun, Seaford Bagels has it. That is to be expected of a bagel spot, but what I didn't expect was a convenience store style refrigerator with milk, juices, and other options for purchase. I was dying for orange juice and I certainly didn't want a child-size cup of it. I grabbed my large orange juice and was pleased it wasn't overpriced for the convenience. Altogether the price to feed the entire crew was very reasonable! For me, the bagel was filling enough to eat half now and half later. I can't say the staff was overly friendly, they were "New York" friendly and I wasn't a local. However, it seems they knew everybody and was very friendly to those who frequented the establishment. New York friendly is basically too busy to smile. #realtalk I look forward to coming back and drooling over all of the schmear I would love to try. I was told by my long time Long Islander pop - On the weekends I should call ahead for my order because the wait in line is about an hour long. I believe it. REASONS TO VISIT: 1. Parking 2. Reasonable Prices 3. Fabulous cream cheese variety 4. Amazing Bagels 5. Coffee options 6. Booth seating 7. Convenience store style refrigerator with more options for beverages read more

Seaford Bagels - I forgot to ask for capers, other than that there is no place like Seaford Bagels in San Diego. Yum! - Bagels Near Me - Seaford, New York

See all

All I have to say is wow that was an excellent egg sandwich I am very impressed I have literally tried every praise place on Long Island the girl did not cry about taking the order over the phone on the weekend it was ready when I got there there's parking right in front and my egg sandwich was perfect thank you. The price was also better than mosy. read more

Seaford Bagels - Chicken sausage, scallion cc, scooped out WW everything - Bagels Near Me - Seaford, New York

I used to go there all the time. Post-COVID, don't bother. They raised their prices and reduced the quality of their food and bagels. $10 for a small turkey sandwich and it was dry with very little turkey. I would've gotten a better sandwich at a lower price from any deli. read more

Seaford Bagels - Bagels Near Me - Seaford, New York

Very good bagels and sandwiches id rate them second best in the area (wantagh, seaford massapequa & amityville) that i have tried, and i have tried a lot. helpful & friendly people, decent parking in the back. deff give them a shot if you haven't yet. just be careful, theres a red light camera in front read more

Bagel with lox and cream cheese on everything flat was great. The store made potatoe salad was really good too!!!! read more

Seaford Bagels - Everything flat with scallion cc and lox - Bagels Near Me - Seaford, New York

This is probably the best bagel place in the Massapequa-Wantagh-Seaford area, but the reason this isn't a 5-star review is because they are getting very expensive. It seems every time we go in, the price goes up a dime. Bagels are now $1.20, and if you want a rainbow bagel? $2.40. Yes, $2.40 for a rainbow bagel. A bagel with no seeds and no flavor, but sadly, my toddler is obsessed with it. Most other places have no surcharge for a rainbow bagel, but Seaford thinks it's worth double the price for the food coloring. By that logic, shouldn't an everything bagel be more expensive than a plain bagel? read more

Food is great however one of the workers that answers the phones is extremely rude. I want to place an order of one sandwich and with an attitude she told me she's not taking orders because there's not enough people working right now and she has a line. I asked her if she could just please put in this one egg sandwich and she told me "I'm busy and we don't have enough people working, just come in and wait on line" rude!! I won't mention names but besides her everybody is extremely nice and their food is great but bad customer service can ruin a place for someone! read more

They are never willing to take phone orders, always "busy". When you drive by, there's no line ‍

My wife and I moved to Seaford three year ago, and This quickly became our go-to bagel spot. The bagels are always fresh, the coffee is delicious, and the counter-people are always so welcoming. The prices are reasonable too. It's a perfect little bagel spot with a great vibe. read more

I don't usually leave reviews but, Don't go here !! The service is terrible and the workers are extremely rude. They all have attitudes and roll their eyes at the customers. And after all that the egg sandwiches were cold. 0/10 read more

Sad to say, but I have been going to Seaford Bagel so as long as I remember and lately they have really been disappointing me. Twice my boyfriend has pick up and bagels/ sandwiches and the orders have been incorrect when we open them at home. Most recently, I went with my mom to grab breakfast and we ate in and our sandwiches were horrible. They both incorrect (no cheese and only one egg, instead of two). I don't know what has happened but hopefully they step up their game. Until then I will take my business elsewhere. :( read more

Seaford Bagels - Egg sandwich. What is this?! I ordered two eggs with cheese. And I got one egg with no cheese. TOTAL DISAPPOINTMENT :( - Bagels Near Me - Seaford, New York