Their warm lobster rolls are the best on L I ! Chowder is…read morefull of seafood and delicious. Lines may be long, but it's worth the wait.

Decided to visit this place with some friends during our trip due to the extensive gluten-free…read moreoptions available. I made a reservation on a Sunday night, which wasn't needed. I had no idea there was outdoor seating, or I would've requested that. The atmosphere was very casual with hits playing on the speakers and football reruns on the TVs, but none of that took away from the experience. Now onto the food... I ordered the hot lobster roll and a lobster bisque cup. The roll came with fries, but they gratuitously let me sub them out for sweet potato fries at no extra charge. They'll also throw in another roll if you notify the server you plan to split the hot lobster roll with somebody. I've never had one before, but I thought it was good! The roll could've been sliced better since it was difficult to pack the lobster on the sides, but that seemed to be a one-off since others in my party had a better sliced roll. The lobster bisque was thick and creamy. Thicker than what you'd expect, but still very good and they did not skimp out on the seafood. They came out quickly after ordering, which I guess is due to them just having to pour it into a cup in the back. I was expecting it to come with the rest of my meal, so I saved a little once my entree came. Overall, we had a fun experience, and I recommend this spot for a casual meal that can satisfy everyone, due to the plentiful menu options.

Food is great. No lines. Outside appearance not the greatest. If you're looking for a jewel in…read morethe rough, this is the place. My compliments to the chef.

If you're looking for good food in Montauk keep looking…read more My girlfriend and I recently decided to take advantage of a deal for a hotel in the offseason in Montauk. We were looking for dinner Saturday night and of the limited options this place looked potentially good. I was terribly wrong. We walked in to see one other table occupied. Sure, it's the offseason, whatever. We ordered a couple of frozen drinks and the problems immediately started. The bartender used way too much ice in the blender. The drinks were obviously undrinkable but served anyway. The drinks did not melt by the time we left. Maybe the food would be good. Wrong again. The lobster in the lobster pasta was tough. I almost hope it wasn't fresh because it would have been a waste. The linguine with clams was no better. At the end of the meal my girlfriend remarked that she had never seen me not finish my dinner. We both knew why I hadn't. Awful restaurant. The owners should be ashamed.

Again, wish I could give 1/2 stars because I would give it 4.5 stars…read more If a place ever earned the phrase "don't just a book by its cover", it is this place. I had chosen this place to have dinner with friends from out of town that were vacationing in Sag Harbor. Reviews looked pretty good and fit what they were looking for: good food, water view, not too far from where they were staying. When we drove up, I was seriously questioning myself. The outside looks like a little dated and small. But as other reviewers have said, the interior is very nice and spacious! We were lucky to get a window table although it was foggy so we could not see a lot of the water; just the parking lot and dock. But still better than nothing. I forgot to take pictures of the apps but we shared multiple orders of the burata, fritto misto and salmon tartare (yes, you read that right). All were good and I did enjoy the tartare. For entrees, I got the fish and chips, Cathie got the bouillabaisse, friends got the chicken Milanese special (what a deal!!), Scottish salmon with ramen, burgers, and another bouillabaisse. We all loved our choices but highlights were definitely the chicken Milanese dinner special (because even with slight up charges for certain items, it is an amazing deal!!); and the bouillabaisse. As some other reviewers have said, this is a MUST ORDER! The broth is not too tomato forward but instead is very flavorful with other spices, not just saffron, and the same food is generous and prepared so well! I will come back just for this! My fish and chips were good, even the Cole slaw although I prefer meatier French fries (although these were still good, nice and crispy). Desserts were also very good and service was good after a couple of bumpy starts.

Bell and Anchor is located outside of the Nautical town of…read moreSag Harbor. The food is scrumptious and the service is ideal. Securing one of the tables by the window overlooking Noyac Bay is definitely a splendid bonus, especially when the summer sun is setting, making it a picture-perfect time to capture the spectacular cotton-colored sky. Reservations are almost mandatory during peak season; wanting to book same day is challenging, however, late evening oftentimes works. A long, dark bar sits by the entryway with cheerful bartenders awaiting. The Bouillasse is a favorite, with clams, muscles, fish, shrimp and lobster in an an unbelievable pinkish-red stew flavored with lovely saffron. I was slightly disappointed the lobster didn't budge easily out of the shell. Nevertheless, the Bouillasse still remains a favorite. Without a doubt, I'll be back for more.

They have it all. This shallow beach is great if you have kids but also caters to the adults…read more Live music nightly and bar in the summer. Beautiful sunsets and shell combing.

It's a bit pricy, but that's all the Beach Huts everywhere. Staff here are fast & friendly. Ashley…read morethe manager and her staff provide service with a smile, which I really appreciate when it's a crowded, hot & sticky summer day. Great place to have a meal and enjoy the view. Outdoor bar, you can take your drinks back to your beach spot which is awesome. I can't wait to come back one evening to enjoy some live music and a great view. Ashley and her crew are working hard for you to have an enjoyable day on the bay. I will be back soon!

The Pike is a local owned Food Truck in the Hamptons. The saddest thing about the food truck is not…read moreknowing where it is all the time because I love the food! That being said the head chef is constantly cooking up soul food that is truly made with love and passion. The food is fresh and made to order. I love that they can accommodate food allergies with no real obvious compromise. My favorites are the crab cake burger and the blackened fish sandwich. If it's not fresh or in season it's not for sale and I love that! Each meal comes with fries and Cole Slaw as a side. Fries have always been crispy and delicious. Next time out in the Hamptons and you need a fresh meal give The Pike a chance.

Fried fish sandwich, fries & slaw hit the spot! Definitely going back. Super friendly & greeting…read moreyou with a smile. I love it!!! Come out and support a local business. Thank you!

Pink going here for gear since I was little such great I was in Montauk once and I was starving so…read moreI got a burger and fries so inexpensive and great. Feels like family owned. They treat you like family.

The food is very good, the fries taste as if grandma and grandpa were chewing tobacco in the yard…read morepeeling potatoes talking about w/they were young and the ambience is old times Happy Days " ayeeee, it's an old staple in Montauk but it's never changed the taste and the kindness and cleanliness of the establishment. Service is always good and handed with a smile.

Amazing food! A little pricey but not out of the norm for the area imo…read more Service was very attentive. We were a large group but everything came out quickly and they were very accommodating.

We didn't have a reservation but were seated outside fairly quickly--right on the street, which…read morewasn't ideal but worked out fine. The service was friendly and attentive throughout. Note: they did charge for water. The food was solid. The fish tacos were tasty but came as just two small tacos, so the portion felt a bit underwhelming for the price. The sweet potato side was also flavorful and well-prepared. Street parking was available nearby, which was convenient. The interior of the restaurant is beautiful, and it's clearly a popular spot in Southampton--worth visiting, especially if you can get a table indoors.

After attending a practice round of the U.S. Open golf championship yesterday at Shinnecock Hills…read moreGolf Club in Southampton, New York, with my daughter, we planned to pick up lobster rolls at the Shinnecock Lobster Factory, which is located on the Shinnecock Indian Reservation and was on our way home. We stopped, were greeted cheerfully, and quickly found parking before heading to the window to order. My daughter had been there before, but this was my first visit, and we were both treated very well by the staff, including the Vice President of the Shinnecock Nation, who teased me for comparing their lobster rolls with ones I had tried previously at the original Lobster Roll in Montauk, Lunch in Southampton, and Cousins' Maine Lobster trucks back in Pennsylvania. He said theirs use fresh, not frozen lobster meat and are better. We both got the four ounce "Guppy" served Hamptons style - warm lobster topped with warm butter and chives over a bed of arugula served on a toasted brioche roll that came with a generous portion of classic shoestring fries and a pickle. Our sandwiches and fries were terrific, and I even got to try a Montauk iced tea, a local favorite that has half the sugar of Gold Peak sweet tea and came highly recommended by one of the private chefs in the Hamptons that I follow on social media. Overall, we had a great experience.

The reason why I gave a 4th star?…read more The Lobster Bisque was the best Lobster Bisque I had in my life! Seriously, huge chunks of lobster meat and was that a little heat as well? I was in heaven enjoying this soup. It was nice to have indoor seating. I didn't notice any picnic tables outside? I placed the order on the digital menu board and grabbed my cold beer on the side window. I waited for inside for our food, listening for our number to be called. First impression: Shinnecock Lobster Factory Lobster Roll Bread? Stale The Lobster Roll? I can never find the perfect Lobster Roll on Long Island. I don't get it, New England is kicking our tails (See what I did there?) Lobster: It wasn't coated in butter but a mayo-y mess I ordered the biggest, baddest Lobster Roll they offer. It was meaty but with filler meat like parts of the claw. After I ate the big chucks of cold lobster coated with mayo and was left with cheaper part of the lobster, IMHO the roll wasn't worth the expensive upcharge. My wife ordered a Fried Fish platter. It came with three large pieces of fresh fish. The fish was lightly coated in batter and fried gold brown. The french fries were good as well as the fish, no complaints. The potato chips, I'm assuming they were homemade but after a few minutes became cold and oily, it didn't want me craving more. The Shinnecock Lobster Factory got the lobster bisque down, if they can work on the lobster roll this place would be 5 stars hands down.