I follow other yelp reviews to this restaurant and found them to be spot on. I had the lamb sliders for dinner and did not regret a single bite. The pub environment is dark and very British. The service was personal and attentive. I would have no hesitation in recommending or returning to this restaurant for another try at the same thing or something different. read more

The Cellar Pub - Pubs Near Me - Ketchum, Idaho

My wife and I were recently in Ketchum for a music event. We ate dinner here after the event. We really like the atmosphere and vibe. Our awesome server made this a 5 star experience. Nice selection of beers on tap. I was able to get an actual black and tan with Guinness and Harps, and it was well made. My wife had the fish and chips. The fish was very good, crispy outside and well cooked. Fries and coleslaw were very good. My wife typically doesn't eat a lot of coleslaw, but she finished hers. I had their hand dipped beef corndog with spicy Guinness mustard. It was delicious, as was the side of slaw I had with it. Our server was over the top great. Friendly and just the perfect amount of attentiveness. We really enjoyed chatting with her a bit. We won't hesitate to stop in here again. read more

I am a local and I also know what a good bar is like and this is the best bar in the entire world. And, I have traveled the world. Best music, Best vibe, most authentic, nicest bartenders, but most of all the best bar food I have ever had in my entire life. I highly recommend. You wouldn't expect great pasta at a bar but you will find it here. Always remember to ask what the specials are. Their hamburgers are unbelievable as well as her french fries but their shrimp tacos are off the charts. This is the pasta Primavera. I asked for as much effort as he would put on until his hand hurt. I've never had too much pepper read more

The Cellar Pub - Yummy - Pubs Near Me - Ketchum, Idaho

Service is meh, prices are good for the town, the place has a nice a aesthetic instead of going the typical this is a dive bar. Id give it 4 stars but the older lady working the bar was so drunk she accused me of having a fake ID because it was an out of state license. Luckily someone else was working with her. read more

Super satisfying! Got the Poor Man's Surf n Turf, take-out. I inhaled it all, the sausage was smoky and yummy. The mashed potatoes were well-seasoned and the fried fish was crispy on the outside and perfectly cooked on the inside. Will definitely be back and look forward to dining in, sometime! read more

We have been coming here for the indescribably good fish and chips. Giant chunks of flaky white fish cooked perfectly. Last night had the calamari and was blown away at the flavor and uniqueness if the fish. The staff is professional and prompt. Expect it to be busy when you visit. Really popular spot. They have shuffleboard downstairs. A great place to gather with friends. read more

See all

OUT OF TOWNERS, listen up! This is a must go-to! The owner Paige is extremely accommodating and very helpful. COVID guidelines are in place of wearing masks, but the atmosphere is definitely a pre-covid feel. They have games downstairs and the food is amazing. Definitely worth a visit! read more

This is my 3rd time here, great service, very friendly staff and everyone remembers your name which is really cool. Erin was my server, amazing service, and great to chat with. The Guinness here is top rate, expertly poured and served at perfect temp. read more

The Cellar Pub - Amazing fish and chips. I highly recommend them. - Pubs Near Me - Ketchum, Idaho

Place sucks, bartenders suck, staff sucks. Bartender took 2 shots before "getting" my drink. Then he questioned my ID and when I tried to leave wouldn't give it back. Never asked for verification like my credit card or anything only assumed I was under age when I used my ID card and not my drivers license. Wouldn't go here if you're just looking for a couple casual drinks and a good time w your significant other or friends. *BTW this all happened on the night of my anniversary* read more

Not sure this is a place you want to patronize. Apparently the staff is unable to recognize a real ID as opposed to a fake one. I understand their need to make sure they aren't serving under age drinkers but if you are unable to recognize a real versus fake ID you probably shouldn't ruin a patrons weekend, especially a special occasion like an anniversary. It may also be a good business policy to not get hammered behind the bar so you can recognize real or fake ID's. All in all for a good time it may be a good idea to seek fun elsewhere. **As you can see by the response of an establishment rep they are choosing to not take responsibility for misidentifying a legitimate ID and also not addressing the behavior of apparently a drunk owner. Other patrons verified that it was a legitimate ID that were not associated with the person this happened. I also happen to know the patron whose ID was in question and he encouraged the police be called. FYI it wasn't me. With such poor service why would anyone stay even if the ID was verified. Being wrong isn't a problem but when you treat your customers with arrogance after they are pleading with you that it's a valid ID is why I'm posting this review. Also nice try on the snatching the ID and running out. The customer took his ID back and advised them he wasn't staying because of how he was treated. Like I said do your due diligence on verifying ID's but don't take a position right off the bat that the customer is lying. That's where your issue is. read more

Wow....My new favorite place in Ketchum !!! From the atmosphere, to the service, food, drinks, and outstanding vibe, this place is awesome. Me and the boys fresh off a 1200 mile motorcycle ride ended out trip (last night of trip) in Sun Valley. We picked this place from the many great Yelp reviews, and it did not disappoint. The place is a pub style eatery. Very dark, and homey feel, but with a definite upscale vibe. I started out with a Manhattan, and ordered appetizers for the crew. Lamb sliders (OMG), Calamari, and wings. All excellent. We ordered dinner, and I had the flat iron steak. Cooked, and seasoned perfectly. I will make an excuse to return ASAP. read more

Fun bar at night and a chill spot for dinner. Try the surf and turf and the buffalo wings.

One of our favorite spots in the Valley. As a full-time resident, my husband and I have been patrons of this wonderful establishment for many, many years. This is the perfect spot for a quick drink or a full night out. You can't go wrong with anything on the menu, but my favorite has to be the fish & chips or lamb sliders! Grab a stool at the bar and you are sure to have a good time and meet some great people! read more

Such a great place and a solid 5 stars. Service was fantastic, food was great too. The food actually looked Instagram worthy and the taste lived up to the presentation. We had the bangers and mash and the steak salad. Bangers and mash stood up to some of the better Irish pubs I've been to. Got extra gravy because it made the bangers taste that much better. The flat iron steak salad looked like it was posing for a picture. The steak was juicy and the matched perfectly with the dressing. The onion rings on the side made for the perfect pairing and might have been the highlight of the meal. Next time I'll order an entire side of them. Prices were very reasonable and the quality surpassed expectations. Definite recommend and will visit again. read more

My first night in town visiting myself and my girlfriend went around to many different bars and restaurants to check the area out. This place was recommended to us. It is a downstairs pub style place. Had a good vibe and we enjoyed it. Two bar tenders that were there were both very nice. We just had basic mixed drinks. Drink prices were very reasonable. Seemed like you could get food here too. There was a seating area for maybe light food and also very small outside patio. read more

This was our first experience at this pub. The server and bartenders were amazing and knowledgeable on the food, beverages, and the area. The local crowd was fun. We tried the calamari and the clams. The clams were in a rich broth that was very flavorful. The calamari was beyond amazing. It came with sautéed onions, peppers, and tomatoes that was very delicious. It was not the typical fried calamari with a dipping sauce and the calamari came in large strips. Best calamari I've ever tasted. read more

Awesome drinks, great vibe, and some pretty awesome games in the back room. It's a must-go place for anyone visiting Sun Valley for sure.

...distinctly local...wonderful fish & chips...frequented by youth...how marvelous...when the majority in town are near death... read more

The Cellar Pub - Pubs Near Me - Ketchum, Idaho

yeah pretty awesome. great atmosphere. VERY friendly and real Ketchum folk running the joint. Food is quick, good and very reasonable in price. I'll be at this bar alot. read more

*back in Ketchum and had to go see kitten and crew at the cellar, just an awesome spot! *Love love love that they carry Manny's and cannot say how awesome the staff is, freindly and upbeat and super fast on the draw *Their food menu is even bigger and very much under rated, you owe yourself a visit! read more

I come to Ketchum every couple months for business. The Cellar Pub is one of my favorite places to hang out in the evening! The staff is always courteous and professional and friendly! The cozy and inviting atmosphere helps take the sting out of a stressful day! The food is to die for from the Appetizers to my favorite main course the Fish and Chips! Everything I've tried is fantastic. Love to take my clients here to close the deal! Thanks Pub for making this my home away from home! Thumbs up read more

I'm a little torn how to rate this, so I'll stick with 4 stars, since I am a fan, and let the pros and cons speak for themselves: Pros: -Big Buck Hunter -people are generally very friendly -cheap-ish drinks -no cover -probably the place where the youngest/best looking people in ketchum congregate -crazy, drunk people occasionally dance on the chairs Cons: -you're still in Idaho -waaaay too crowded most of the time -sometimes almost impossible to actually get drinks from the bar -after ordering the same drink multiple times for four days in a row, one douchey bartender will insist that it costs more and be a total tool about it -people are easily offended Overall, the best place if you're staying in sun valley and want a bar to go to, although I would probably shoot myself in the face if I lived in ketchum and had to go here year round. read more

Been here twice, once in December and once last week and it is such a fun spot! Even on a dead night in the Ketchum bar scene this place is getting going! Inside is super cool with bar games and an almost divey feel. The outside makes you feel like you're sitting on a stoop in NYC or Boston, complete with brick. Great and strong cocktails. I hear the food is good too. read more

Its pub food and I thought it was damn good. Our waiter was a lively chap with a unique voice...I liked his level of service. Our food was good...but it was bar food and the wifes stew was damn good. Nice job. We played some shuffleboard and that was a blast. Bar games. I have one complaint...and its more me than them. I dont like that vinegar smell of this place. I know it comes from fish and chips and its in the wood, not the air. but still...its the first thing that hits you and i'm sure it freaks some back out the door. Oh well. Dont come into a bar if you dont like what a bar smells like...right? Thanks for a nice cheap dinner. We had a fun time. read more

The cellar was absolutely fantastic except for one female employee behind the main bar. I've been with a big group of people and there were multiple people that that went to the cellar pub throughout the day and had an awful experience with JUST her. If she was fired it wouldn't be five stars... it would be 10 stars. She really brought down the vibe for multiple groups being extremely rude. Other than that bartender... highly recommend! read more

Local bar with awesome food! Not only do they have daily specials for various drinks, they are extremely nice here. I'm new to town and Kitten made me feel like a local already! The food is surprisingly good, and although I haven't tried the corn dog yet, those hand-battered doggies look deeeelish! Fish and chips was great, and their drinks are always awesome! Super bonus points for having shuffleboard, I LOVE me some shufflin'! read more

Best town in pub! If you want to hang with the locals and feel welcomed like you are family this is the place. Thanks for making me feel at home! read more

Cool little place to have drinks and enjoy the weather! Indoor and outdoor seating, great cocktails and a cool vibe. Serves dinner and drinks definitely come here before, during or after dinner! read more

The Cellar Pub - Pubs Near Me - Ketchum, Idaho

I went here a few times while in Sun Valley and each time it got better and better and better. Good drinks, good happy hour, free shuffleboard... But the waitress we had the last two times we were there was the absolute best!! I don't want to put names in a review because that's weird, but let's just say that after an upsetting experience at a different restaurant in town we went back to The Cellar and this gal not only made sure the kitchen stayed open a few extra minutes so we could order food, but she also brought us Jell-O shots left over from Super Bowl Sunday and I'm pretty sure she asked the bartender to make the drinks a little stronger for us. Not just that, but she seemed to genuinely enjoy us being there and cared about our group (even the grouchy ones). She was hellbent on making our final night in Sun Valley a good one and she did! Thank you so much!!!! read more

Always my first stop when I arrive to town. Paige and Kitten are the badassest. The food is great, the drinks are strong, and the prices are fair. Not your typical bar food - their chef clearly takes pride in his/her menu and cooking! I love the corn dog with Guinness mustard. Seriously so good...and I love the fact that the bar stocks Blanton's. read more

Ate and drank there (and will likely go back again for another round of cocktails or $2 Rainer). Food was very good. Note: buffalo burger isn't a bison burger but a "buffalo seasoned beef burger" still quite delicious. Portions are very generous. Drinks are very good and atmosphere is very pubby-relax here and enjoy the ambiance! read more

Nice place for a quick meal. We had the fish and chips and a burger. Fries were really good. Service quick and efficient. The only improvement would be if you didn't have drink dudes in the same room as a bunch of families with kids swearing and shouting obscenities. read more

Great atmosphere with awesome staff! We went here 3 times in our weekend stay. I left a personal belonging there after a late night and Jason even mailed it back to me! If you need a beer or tasty food- don't miss this fun little spot! read more

We just got off the Middle Fork of the Salmon River and were looking for a cozy, relaxed place for dinner. We found a corner table in the bar and plopped down. The service was excellent and the food was delicious. We had roasted red pepper hummus and pita to start. The pasta special was penne with a cream pesto sauce with shrimp. Delicious! White wine was excellent and served perfectly chilled. We will definitely go back! read more

We enjoyed our whole experience at the cellar Pub. The atmosphere is relaxed and comfortable, the jovial place! It's very cozy it makes you feel like you're welcome. We were told to choose any seat and we picked a little booth out of the way. Our server was very very quick to bring us water and offer us drinks. I chose to order bangers and mash. He chose the fish and chips. Both meals were superb! I got two different kinds of sausages and a pile of yummy garlic mashed potatoes with gravy. I ordered some coleslaw on the side and it was also tasty. His fish was beer battered and so very light and flaky! The fries were yummy and hot. They made what seems like a homemade tartar sauce; it was just the perfect amount of tangy. We received prompt and friendly service the entire time we were there with lots of smiles and attentiveness. If we were staying longer we would certainly come back here again! read more

The Cellar Pub - Our meals - Pubs Near Me - Ketchum, Idaho

$7 Bullet on the rocks. Bar tender fills the cup full, best deal in town. New favorite bar period.

Best bar in Ketchum and best service of any restaurant in town. Really good food and such a warm vibe.

This place is great. I love the laid back feel creative drinks and the food here is pretty good. The atmosphere there is cozy and relaxed. It's almost like being in a pub in England. The owner was bar tending and the rest of the staff was very friendly. If you are looking for a place to grab a drink and take a break from your day this is it. read more

See all

Fun, local atmosphere, good drinks, okay food. Tried the lamb sliders and poor man's surf and turf. The sausage on my husband's surf and turf was good, but I didn't try the fish. Slider were okay, hit the spot after a day of winter fun. Good option for a casual night. read more

Great food, great vibe! We had the wings, tomato bisque and Fish & Chips and it was all fantastic! Service very good as well. Highly recommend for a casual dining experience! read more

The Cellar Pub - Tomato bisque, chicken wings, and Fish & Chips! - Pubs Near Me - Ketchum, Idaho

See all