Way too noisy for us. There was a guy playing guitar and singing, but couldn't hear him very well because of all thee people at the bar talking so loud. We had stuffed mahi and mahi sautéed in in a lemon wine sauce. The fish could have used a little more seasoning. Sweet potato fries were really good. The side of mixed vegetables was not cooked and needed seasoning, so I did not eat them. Service was good. read more

On our way back from Marathon we found this casual place via yelp. Very nice and attentive waitresses. It is self seating and the waitress came over right away. They had live music inside which sounded great from what we heard when we went inside to go to bathroom. We sat outside and they had a good amount of seating outdoors. The menu had a lot of options we liked but we wanted fish sandwiches so we got mahi mahi sandwiches (Reuben and baked which came with one side) which we both enjoyed and would get again. We also got the sampler appetizer which came with coconut shrimp, conch fritters, calamari, fish spread with crackers and blackened mahi. Great portion size for all items and reasonably priced. Homemade chips were good. Also my husband enjoyed the old fashioned which is one of his favorite drinks and for $7 which was great. Some things we didn't like but it wouldn't deter us from coming back was that is that outside seating allows smoking and pets. I wouldn't mind the dogs but they were barking and begging for food while I was eating. Lastly One recommendation is to have some stout and Belgian beers. read more

The Catch - Mahi mahi sandwiches - Sports Bars Near Me - Key Largo, Florida

Nope! Not going back. This is the third time the food was bad. I did not complain to the staff because this was my suggestion for lunch and i did not want to call it out in front of my guests. Combo basket - mahi tasted like breaded blood lines (or old fishy fish); shrimp was cooked to death, so it was hard crunchy through and through. Fries were excellent. My granddaughter did not eat her fish because she said it was swimming in butter. Appetizer platter again was so overcooked you could barely chew through the conch fritter. Others said fish portion was very small on the sandwiches. Last two times some people didn't like their food, and the bill was wrong (but didn't notice till we got home-happy hour wine was charged at full price). I debated whether we would return because it used to be so good. After this lunch, sorry but we won't return. read more

The place was fine. The service excellent. The food was lack luster. The sweat potatoes fry's were cold and kind of burnt. The fish size was very small. There are better restaurant in the same area. Sorry, but I have to say it like see it. Try to improve! Word of mouth is so very important. Good luck! read more

This place came highly recommended. Unfortunately it really disappointed. The wings were large and decently priced, but they tasted funky. Not sure if they were nearing their expiration date or were undercooked, but they made me gag a little bit. The staff is super nice and the rest of the food looked good, but ai took my wings to go and just threw them out after ai gave it another attempt when we got home. read more

Busy restaurant with very attentive waiters. Catch of the day red snapper perfectly fried. Steamed veggies, sweet potatoes fries, and rice pilaf sides were good. read more

See all

Horrible experience, and I have never written a negative review, ever. So sad because my husband and I are on vacation and wanted to enjoy some good drinks and food. It took over 30 minutes to get waters, longer for drinks, and they brought out the wrong meals for both of us. The waitress ignored us, wasn't apologetic, didn't check in and didn't offer to compensate for all the errors. We payed over $100 for overcooked food that came out after both the wrong orders were served. Seriously SO disappointed and expected someone to acknowledge the terrible experience. read more

Great service and amazing food!. We would recommend it. We enjoyed the as seared tuna appetizer, buffalo chicken wrap, and blackened mahi tacos and Keylime pie! We will be back. read more

Been in Florida a week and have eaten MANY places..... best food yet.. Heidi the bartender was great. Very friendly atmosphere.

Just picked up an order for calamari and coconut shrimp. Calamari was extremely bland. No flavor. The coconut shrimp was unevenly cooked. Chalky and not flavorful. Ended up eating a few and just throwing the rest away. We are driving up back to the mainland so didn't have time to try to get a Refund. read more

The Catch - Coconut shrimp and calamari - Sports Bars Near Me - Key Largo, Florida

We went to The Catch based on the review. My wife ordered the Key Lime Chicken and asked to have it with out the cheese. I ordered Seafood Platter with Fries. My seafood was fried way too long it was really crispy and very dry inside. The fries were Luke warm at best. The chicken entree came with the cheese. The food came out about the place looked. Not quite right. read more

This place is great! Also reasonably priced! Highly recommend! Hole in the wall with great food and cocktails! read more

See all

We ate at The Catch and was very happy with our experience. I had the coconut curry mahi and many key lime martinis. I live the atmosphere and the desert was a warm homemade rum cake. Would recommend. read more

The Catch - Key lime Martini! - Sports Bars Near Me - Key Largo, Florida

See all

Bartenders with locals attitude. Cooks that only know how to prepare food off the Sysco truck. Stay away! Have been insulted here by the Male night bartender in the past. Then last time not much different. And tonight they ruined a beautiful bag of fresh fish by over cooking it. No more won't come back. A BIG THUMBS DOWN. DONT WAIST YOUR MONEY. And tonight another bartender with a key largo attitude. read more

Great seafood restaurant located in the upper Keys. I've dined here twice and can say that both of my experiences have been extremely satisfactory. It's kinda hard to pick what to eat because everything is so good you just want to order everything. I love the lobster crab cakes because they taste so fresh every time. The coconut crusted fish with the raisin curry sauce is by far my favorite entree on the menu. I choose Hogfish because of its juicy and tender profile and I ate every bite. Make sure you read the board before with the specials because they often have an enticing list. Their beer list isn't the craftiest but at least you can guarantee yourself a cold one. In the Keys, life is simpler, the food is fresher, and it's always casual behavior. read more

See all

What a great addition to Key Largo's restaurant scene! The Catch has a great, wide variety of offerings from various appetizers to full meals. I have had the baked camabert cheese plate and it is yummy and filling! The fish "sticks" are great as are the wings and conch fritters. The happy hour raw oysters are cold and tasty. Lots of locals here for happy hour. There is a small patio in the back with several tables that have umbrellas. If you have your four legged furry friend with you, you can sit here! The servers will even bring some water for them. Great, relaxed Keys restaurant. Looking forward to returning again and again. read more

Looks like a local dive from outside and yes it is a "locals" kinda place which are my favorite. We were there in a Monday night arriving at 9:15 and they closed at 10 and we got excellent service and food just the same. They also have very good chicken wings read more

See all

Food was very good and service was excellent. Would highly recommend this restaurant when in Key Largo. read more

The Catch - Yellowtail Snapper Whole excellent! - Sports Bars Near Me - Key Largo, Florida

Friendly place with good food. The smoked fish dip appetizer is excellent. My family all ate the fried seafood baskets. They were good. There were several sides to choose from. The cucumber salad was ok, but I probably wouldn't choose it again. They had an extensive seafood menu. It deserves another trip to try some more choices. read more

Our server was very good, their Scampi is excellent, the beer selection is OK, not much of a view, but the food is why we go. Definitely recommended. read more

Like wow. The menu is small and WOW, so freaking good. Best mahi tacos I've ever had. The tuna poke tower was DELICIOUS!! And Paige made my Pina colada WITH LOVE. Our Chi-town waitress was super nice. I do not understand why it was empty on a Sunday afternoonhe place feels really homey, everyone had real positive energy. I might just become a local! Thank you guys read more

The Catch - Tuna poke tower, we ate half of it already. So delicious - Sports Bars Near Me - Key Largo, Florida

See all

Excellent lunch! Jerk yellowtail with mango salsa. Blackened chicken sandwich with cheese and cherry peppers. The best sweet potato fries and great coleslaw. Yummy Will be going again for sure! read more

We are local Key Largo residents, and this is one of our go to hangouts. It's very casual with good food and great service. The owners are very involved in the business and one of them is nearly always present. They recently updated their menu and have some nice new features. The shrimp bruschetta is delicious! Great appetizer for 2-3 or lunch for one. Soups are always good and they have a delicious prime rib on Friday night. Check it out! read more

We have a vacation home here in Key Largo and have been here a few times. It seems to be hit or miss, but tonight was a one star and I thought it was time for a review. First off, the staff is fantastic. They're friendly and inviting, always super, but the food is in need of help. They did move from a chalk board only menu to an actual menu, nice.. but ordered a $15 cheese steak which was about 5 inches long? Really? The fries were seriously previously cooked and arrived shriveled up, hard and crunchy, just horrible. My wife is gluten free and the first plate arrived wrong and the waitress realized when she arrived at the table and turned around and went back to the kitchen. Ugh... we got a little nervous at that and my wife decided not to eat the cucumber with the dressing. Going to take it out of book of recommended places I think. read more

I've stopped in the Catch over a dozen times on the way out of the keys for late lunch and never been disappointed. I will admit I tend to get the mahi sandwich often but fresh fish and homemade meals like a real chicken pot pie how can you go wrong. Staff is insanely friendly and has a CHEERS BAR vibe as well like they all know each others name. I will continue stopping in here on the way out of the keys at least once a week. Delicious read more

One of our favorites places to dine! Great specials, fun atmosphere, full bar and great service. We have never been disappointed. Super local hangout with live music! read more

People All Over The World - are you looking for a place the locals love? This is it! This is the most amazing restaurant/bar in the Key Largo area! Stumbled upon it in YELP (right here) so I wanted to voice my opinion also! My husband and I compete to "out order" each everywhere we go and he succeeded again by asking the bartender his opinion which was "The Godfather". Food was delicious, service was outstanding and the OWNER, Kathy makes all the desserts! Don't miss her RUM CAKE! Ask the bartender to pour a little rum on top! Total Bliss! read more

Everything was just good./average. The server, Diana, was excellent. The place was very small kind of a local feel. They have an outside patio but not much ambience out there, not really much ambience inside either. they have one vegetarian entrée which is a pasta Primavera with a garlic cream sauce. I ordered the fraDiavlo sauce instead which was very tasty and spicy except that my broccoli had gone bad apparently and ruined the whole meal. Nice side salad and the spinach artichoke dip was especially good, heavy on the spinach and not a big bowl of mushy cheese! Gator bite appetizer was good-average. Nothing special.m read more

See all

On a recent vacation my wife and 2 friends stopped in for dinner. I ordered the seafood platter. The serving size for the price was not proportionate. The food was dreadful. The scallops could not be cut with a knife. They had the consistency of rubber. I spoke with the server 2x and she was reluctant to do anything about it. When I pushed the issue, I felt to be embarrassed by her avoidance of handling the situation. Needles to say we will never go back there. Our food was not good, the service was terrible. My friend could not go shopping afterward if you know what I mean. The only thing your going to catch here is a bad meal. read more

The only reason I'm not going with 5 stars is because the atmosphere was just mediocre. But the people are super friendly and accommodating and the food is fantastic. If we had discovered this place sooner we'd have eaten here ever day, especially considering they are so much cheaper than many of the seafood places we tried in Key Largo. My daughters absolutely loved the lobster mac & cheese as well as the mahi tacos. read more

See all

I lived in Florida for 20 years and just came back on vacation to Key Largo. I stopped at "The Catch" for the first time and I have to say, I'm extremely impressed for 2 reasons. The first, our server, Lala was AMAZING! She was so accommodating, on point with what we needed and super friendly in that " real way "! She makes me want to come back! 2nd Reason: Lala recommended the wings and warned us that they are huge! We ordered 20 anyway and... ATE THEM ALL! Cooked to perfection with crunchiness on the outside and juicy inside! my fiancés doesn't eat mozzarella sticks but inhaled theirs! if you're looking for a comfortable and friendly atmosphere with great food, you MUST go go to The Catch!!! read more

I was dead tired after afternoon dives in stormy sea (we had 4-5' waves on the reef), so I wanted to get a quick bite and crash to bed. Catch was just across the road from my hotel and it turned out to be a nice surprise. The food was really tasty (I had ahi tuna poke and lobster/crab cakes appetizers plus house salad), the service was very friendly, and the portions are huge - I ended up packing half of my meal for next-day lunch. As an added bonus they had a band that plays there in Thursday nights. They play country music and the singer is really good. My father is from Luisiana and he plays country all the time, so I have a thing for country music :) The only thing is that the crowd there may be a bit weird, some drunk guy twice my age came to my table and asked whether I am a tourist from China and suggested to come with him, so he will show me around... Anyway, other than that, the place is a great value for money and I highly recommend it. read more

See all

First thing you'll notice about this place is their friendly service! Everyone is in a great mood and thats what I like to see. The lunch menu is rather small with a few specials that they'll inform you on. The prices seem fair, of course it's Key Largo so they're slightly higher than the norm. I had the Hog Fish Platter w/fries $14.95 which I must admit was a bit fishy and I hate the aftertaste of fish. She had the Blackened Swordfish Tacos $14.95 very generous portion consisting of 3 tacos. Very good! Overall it wasn't bad, but I've had much better. The service was excellent!! My hogfish just didn't taste fresh and the fishy aftertaste was disappointing. read more

See all

First place we tried in the Keys I thought $13.99/dz raw oysters... let's give it a try! Not very appetizing. Lots of bits of shell in the meat from shucking. Almost all of them were sandy and they were all very small. There were 4 patrons in the whole place and we waited about 15 mins at the bar for our order. Not super slow but for as slow as they were it felt like forever. We were very hungry so take that with a grain of salt or two lol. Everybody else's food look very good and they were all complimenting the bartender on How good there food was. A lady next to me order wings. They looked and smelled amazing! I seriously wanted to order some but we were on a quest for fresh amazing seafood and were not going to compromise, so down the road we went I really wanted to give this place a better review but I couldn't. Had to be honest. In their defense I don't think raw oysters is their thing, even though they were available if you asked... read: weren't on the menu. If we had ordered something I had a feeling we would have much been happier. Unfortunately we didn't. I would give this place another try to be fair if I could read more

Awesome place! Ignore any negative reviews. Cold beer. Yummy food. Great live music. You can't go wrong!

just picked up a take out. Asked for tartar sauce also one extra, received cocktail for clam strips. Also ordered onion strings which came in a big blob of uncooked batter and tasted horrible. wish I took a picture before I threw them out. stuffed mushrooms were hard fried balls. I'm not one to complain, but go Catch yourself another restaurant to eat at. This place has gone downhill. read more

Best fish meal ever! We had the Yellowtail Snapper Godfather style. Delicious fish over creamy spinach artichoke stuffing with wonderful lemon butter sauce. Also had a fried shrimp basket and cole slaw. Everything was excellent! read more

The Catch - Outdoor patio. - Sports Bars Near Me - Key Largo, Florida

Good food, good service, good bartender. What more can you ask from a smaller restaurant during the times of no help. I'll stop back by.

Great neighbor place. Paige is awesome bartender. Had the cayenne shrimp very good but too spicy for me. Yellow tail snapper sandwich perfect and very cold draft beer read more

The Catch is the typical cafeteria full of seafood, the Seafood platter is a good a stater and the stuffed shrimp is heavenly good! Good deals and the service is outstanding, super nice people read more