Food was excellent and the bartenders were awesome. Had excellent suggestions for the area. Highly recommend!!!

The server was great and a lot of fun! The food, not so much. Out of 4 meals, only 1 was liked - The Coconut Mahi, which was very tasty. However, the rice was dry and the mixed vegetables were mostly onions. The Key Lime Pie and peanut butter chocolate pie were yummy. The lady who brought the 3 desserts gave us one napkin to share ?? We would not eat there again. read more

I didn't know mozzarella sticks could be THIS GOOD until I came to The Catch. Seriously -- the crunch? Unreal. The cheese? Creamy, melty perfection. And the marinara sauce was so good we dipped our sweet potato fries in it too (highly recommend). We also asked for coconut shrimp tacos -- not even sure if they're officially on the menu -- and they made them for us anyway. They were so fresh, crispy, and a flavor explosion of deliciousness. I'm already planning a trip back just to eat them again. Tried the Godfather Mahi too -- super light and comforting over warm spinach. 10/10 would order again when I want something cozy. A hidden gem! We ordered our food to-go, but the inside looked very cute as well. It is a family-friendly vibe with local charm. read more

The Catch - Godfather Mahi with veggies and sweet potato's and Coconut Shrimp Tacos - Sports Bars Near Me - Key Largo, Florida

See all

Amazing mahi, the Nashville hot chicken sandwich was really good, very spicy but delicious. For dessert key lime pie was amazing and the whole family loved everything. Service was excellent, our server was very friendly! We will be back read more

I loved the local vibe at The Catch and especially the staff and the bartender! They had a great happy hour 3-6 but only 2 food items... hoping they see this review and add the pretzel for 5$, mushrooms for 6$, 2 small fish tacos for 8$ they def need more food items for the normal m-f happy hour food wise (should have 6 to 8 food items ranging from 4-8$ each).... The wed happy hour 6-8:30 has a lot of 5$ food items (and great drinks)! Dinner is also great with tons of specials like pot pie, turkey dinner and nice catch of the day. I liked this place so much I visited 3x during my stay which says a lot as there's tons of restaurants in key largo. read more

The Catch - The daily and wed night happy hour - Sports Bars Near Me - Key Largo, Florida

Food was great.Everyone was so friendly.Definitely a place to go while in key largo. .In fact, we went back for lunch.

Great food and it was entertaining to visit with lots of other folks at the bar. Everyone is very friendly here. The mahi tacos were outstanding. read more

They offer you a price on the menu and then charge you double it. They are cheaters and they also served us fermented coleslaw. read more

The Catch - Sports Bars Near Me - Key Largo, Florida

See all

A great local place with a local comfortable vibe. Coming here I felt like the odd man out given everyone seemed to know each other, but service was friendly enough where that feeling went away quickly. The New England Clam Chowder was one of the top renditions I have had of this soup, which can range from outstanding to awful in other places. The Mile Marker 102 Mahi Sandwich - Blackened Mahi with artichokes, creamed spinach, roasted red peppers on a ciabatta roll was outstanding. That and a couple of cold beers on draft made for a great dinner. read more

See all

Local pub & restaurant secret of Key Largo. This is the kind of place where you feel welcome, comfortable. You'll always find local people here but everyone is welcome and free to join in the conversations. Great atmosphere and friendly attentive staff. So I'm a vegan and it's so difficult to find anyplace in the Keys that will have a vegan option. The Catch has it. A Philly cheese steak ( without the cheese of course) but very delicious. I'm absolutely amazed. I also has "The Catch" beer, brewed at a local brewery. It's the way to go. You'll love it here. read more

I came to this place back in August on a business trip. We picked it based on the high review score and it lived up to the score. There was 4 of us in our group and we all left feeling full, satisfied, and taken care of. I had the Key Lime Chicken with rice and Sweet potato fries. The chicken was very flavorful, and did not have too much lime added.will keep this place in mind if I ever go back. read more

The Catch - Key Lime Chicken with rice and sweet potato fries. - Sports Bars Near Me - Key Largo, Florida

GET. THE. RUM. CAKE! Ok seriously, if you do nothing else... get the rum cake and don't touch the ice cream! This was literally the best rum cake I've ever had in my life. We had appetizers to start. The shrimp bruschetta and the tuna nachos. The tuna nachos aren't nachos they are 4 wonton chips with 4 pieces of tuna. The name definitely gives you unrealistic expectations, though it is delicious. They just need to call or something else. The shrimp bruschetta was ok, but I could live without it. I got the key lime Mahi for my entree and it was stupid good. My salad came out way late and the rice pilaf was disappointing, but the fish was amazing! My husband got the Mediterranean hogfish and it was decent. But mine was better. He got the sweet potato fries. And coleslaw. The fries were delicious. Coleslaw underwhelming. The cocktails are strong! So you'll probably get drunk on one! At least my key lime tea was ridiculously strong. As I said in the beginning, get the rum cake. The end. read more

See all

Stopped for a little dinner on a Sunday. It was very quiet, and we sat at the bar. Our bartender was very friendly and attentive. We ordered some beers and some food. We got the mahi tacos (very good) and the fried fish platter (also good!). The sides were probably the best part though--try the fresh grilled veggies and the yummy potato salad! We didn't make it for happy hour but it is from 3:30-6:30 Monday-Friday. $2 miller lite bottles and some discounted liquor. They also have some apps for $5. read more

The Catch never disappoints!! Just enjoyed Mahi tacos ... simply delicious. The Mahi was fresh and the condiments very tasty! The buffalo chicken wrap was also delicious !! Highly recommend. read more

The Catch - Buffalo wrap - Sports Bars Near Me - Key Largo, Florida

See all

I've been in the keys for 40 years and this has been the best restaurant in my opinion for all the locals and small time towners this is definitely the catch ;) lol read more

Been here before! Too close from camping not to go. Great selections of food.Bartender very nice,Heidi, who recommended and I enjoyed the seafood platter, beautiful presentation and yummy! Honey enjoyed his wings. Nice Happy hour specials we would like to ck out next time... read more

The Catch - Seafood appetizer - Sports Bars Near Me - Key Largo, Florida

See all

This place rocks. Real. Good. Heidi is a terrific bartender. The food-top notch. The Happy Hour Specials - are real. The menu and daily dishes...wish I would have found it all sooner. I will be back. read more

Where should I start? Service? Menu selection? Drinks? Dessert? Live music? All of the above are 5 star ratings! Lala, Heidi, Kathy, Bartendar, and Lala's shadow (forgot her name!) are all fabulous! They make everyone feel like VIPs & family! Their menu selection changes often so we can go 3 days in a row and find amazing selections! Every dish we've had has been amazing!!! Drinks are on point! Save room for dessert! The rum cake is epic. The new banana cake was amazing and we hope it stays on the menu! Last night we stumbled across live music at the bar! The perfect addition to a great local diner! They were so good and enjoyed by all! Love The Catch & so happy we ventured out to try them! We are now proud to say we are "regulars!" read more

The Catch - Shrimp bruschetta yum! - Sports Bars Near Me - Key Largo, Florida

We very much enjoyed our visit to The Catch.  The atmosphere was nice, the service was friendly, and the prices were reasonable. Now let's talk about the food!  The mahi fish tacos were good, but not exceptional.  The tortilla shells were just barely AOK because they were overcooked. The margaritas were decent but I've definitely had better.  On the total upside, the Caesar salad and the burgers were right on the money, as was the slaw. All things considered, I wouldn't hesitate to eat here again :-) read more

See all

After being bummed from not being able to try a nearby Thai restaurant, we did a quick search for alternatives. The Catch was close by, so we headed over. We were quickly seated and had drinks served promptly. The menu had a lot of options. Only complaint is that there were other options available that we didn't know about because we weren't in the bar area. I would've loved to try the wings! The seafood sampler appetizer was good. The lobster/shrimp/crab cakes were ok. The main meal was pretty good. I went with the stuffed mahi. I was kind of disappointed with the "stuffed" description. It was just a crab cake on top of the fish. Tasty, but I had the same cake as an appetizer. For dessert, the rum cake was AWESOME. From the outside, it looked like a dive. But don't let that prevent you from giving it a try. Very good! read more

The Catch - This is the appetizers we had no idea about until after we ordered. - Sports Bars Near Me - Key Largo, Florida

Had the Mahi Ruben Sandwich it was excellent and done to perfection. The restaurant was very clean and had a great vibe. Service was spot on and very friendly. read more

Broiled seafood platter was delicious! Busy but efficient. Personable staff. Homemade desserts.

The food is always on point here. Ms Lala is always a phenomenal server! If I can push my group here every time I will do it! Crowd is always great here. read more

Laid back atmosphere, good food. Was not a fan of the garlic sauce but everything else came out great

We wanted to try out The Catch because that was the closest restaurant to the hotel were we stayed. We set outside. All the other people who were sitting outside were smokers...we are not. Service was polite. The most recognizable person was the bus women.She was running bucket full of dishes and ice buckets none stop. Outstanding employee!!!! Cocktails were mediocre. Food was blah,flavorless. However this restaurant is an authentic Florida Key's old Florida style restaurant,locals seem to enjoy it. Atmosphere was good! So if you want to get a feel of the Keys try it. Price was reasonable. read more

See all

This is definitely a nice quiet place to get some fresh and well seasoned local food. I will definitely be back! Service was great! They will treat you like a local when you visit! Don't forget to try the key lime pie. read more

The Best seafood platter I have had in a while. Nice fresh mahi. Excellent service. Friendly people read more

The Catch - Menu - Sports Bars Near Me - Key Largo, Florida

The catch really caught our hearts and tastebuds! The place was great very clean. The staff was seriously amazing our waitress Lala was the sweetest! Everything was so good there wasn't anything I didn't like! Also notable mention to Felix who was playing some great music all night. We will definitely be coming back again and again! read more

See all

Stopped by for dinner during a trip to the keys and hit the jackpot! The wait staff was friendly and welcoming. It was obvious it was a favorite or locals with many repeat customers as many customers were greeted warmly and with hugs. The bar area was quite full with a local musician playing for the crowd. Our waitress was very helpful as we debated several food options. We had the fish dip which was devoured before we could take a photo. For entrees we had the whole fried snapper and mahi tacos. Both were excellent. The fish was fresh and flavorful. Tacos were also excellent with a spicy crème sauce. Although we were stuffed, the waitress talked us in to a slice of house made key lime pie and chocolate peanut butter pie. Both were flavorful but the peanut butter pie = amazing! Would definitely return during a future visit to the keys! read more

The Catch - Whole fried snapper - Sports Bars Near Me - Key Largo, Florida

See all

Love the food here and the locals vibe/ the female bartender is always friendly and makes infused waters that are great

We both had the seafood fradiablo. It was great. We live in Florida, and went to the keys for a mini vacation. Not a fancy place, but the food and service was great. Coldest draft beer that we have in the keys! read more

The Catch - I could not finish it. - Sports Bars Near Me - Key Largo, Florida

Great bartender and good food. Fresh fish! Transient pilot staying across street at The Hampton. Excellent place for sports and brewskis. I read some of the other negative reviews about food. I would personally disagree. You are coming to a sports bar in the Keys! Food was above expectations. read more

Excellent food at a fair price. Kinda low key. It's inside with AC which is rare in the keys. read more

Stopped in here based on reviews. Place was cleanly kept staff was friendly. Took a look at the menu on the wall and decided on fried hog sandwich with fries and a small cucumber salad. After a short wait another server returned with fries hog snapper and my two sides. No sandwich though . Just the fried hog. I asked if it came in a sandwich and she said yes if you ask. I Guess my subtle hint wasn't enough . Food was good not great salad and fries were the best two things . Snapper was dry and lacking flavor. Maybe next time I stop in I'll try something else. Also there is an up charge for the snapper . 9$ upcharge‍. That is absolutely absurd. Oh well live laugh and laugh it off. read more

See all

My daughter and I found this "locals" dive on Yelp (of course) and decided to give it a go. We were not disappointed. It was a Monday night so plenty of socially distanced seating and it Truely was a locals hang-out. Our meal selection: Appetizer Sample Platter - fried calamari, fish dip, coconut shrimp, blackened mahi, 4 sauces/dips - amazing! This could have been our meal! Fried Mahi sandwich w/ cucumber salad - excellent! Buffalo chicken tenders with sweet potato fries - can't mess these up so not worth rating. The service was excellent and very hospitable. I will be back! read more

Mahi key Lime was good. Cucumber salad was drenched in balsamic vinegarette. The key Lime martini was all coconut, but the Rum Punch was to die for. The fried seafood plate was excellent, but the fish was dry. We will definitely be back, but just had our opinions. read more

The Catch - Key Lime Martini and Rum punch. - Sports Bars Near Me - Key Largo, Florida

See all

A great return to this cozy place, The Catch. Jessica was our waitress this time. WoW what a service, decent, kind young lady, she suggested the Conch fritters, a great grilled Mahi that we enjoyed with a nice cocktail. Great food, music and the ambience extraordinary. A Key Largo favorite. read more

What an excellent place to relax, drink and eat. My friend and I had an enjoyable time drinking Rum Runners and eating several starters. The service was always attentive and the food was super! The atmosphere is relaxed; so, never felt rushed. read more

So we were headed home for the keys looking for a little dive bar with a happy hour and we found it. Beers were like $3-$4 I believe. We also got an app of their loaded fries. Very good they had cheese ' bacon served with sour cream. They had daily specials listed and they sounded great but we weren't that hungry so just the app and beers. The place is a nice size inside . read more

Found this restaurant on a road trip through Florida. There were four of us and we ate four different sandwiches. All of them were delicious. The prices for food and drinks were reasonable. The staff were very nice and service was prompt. Overall, we enjoyed the place. read more