Stopped in to show an out of towner this place! The whole neighborhood collectively decorates really nicely for the seasons, so even the walk up feels memorable. Thinking about their experience I noticed a few more things. I love that they have birthday cards and candles, what a perfect birthday gift/ celebration to have a candle in a pie or donut instead of a cupcake! The home made paper roll with the monthly specials always has its own charm to it, and as a creative myself I always appreciate it. Today we tried the banana cream pie, rasberry cream cheese danish, the brown butter cinnamon roll, and the strawberry and pina colada shakes! The shakes were amazing. The strawberry one was really refreshing and sweet, it tasted like it was made with jam. The pina colada one was smooth, and well balanced. It looks like all the mini pies have all collectively gone from $10 to $12 which, meh . I have to say the crust on the pie was probably my favorite part, I thought the banana cream was a little bland, the banana slices inside were a nice touch. The danish was exactly what you'd expect for it to be. The cinnamon roll with brown butter makes me think that brown butter should be the only way to make icing from here on out, though the roll itself was a bit dry, maybe better for dunking in coffee? Seating was limited as the stores preps for Thanksgiving catering and I assume will be for the foreseeable future, we were sitting outside regardless since it was sunny and warm. *Beware* the bees love your sweet maybe even more than you do. The baking kits always catch my eye, as well as the sprinkles. I feel like it all screams *intentional* read more

See all

Service has been way better in the mornings and have not encountered the same person from last time. Key lime pie is fantastic and the garlic and herb croissant over the weekends is great. Nanaimo bars have not been missing a crust lately either. Very impressed read more

The Bake Sale - Half the crust is missing - Bakeries Near Me - West Allis, Wisconsin

We were across the street for lunch (Archie's Flat Top - separate review), and decided to stop over to check out the bakery. What a great treat, literally. This shop both bakery, cafe and coffee shop, all rolled into one. They have several large cases showing off all the different bakery items, breads, donuts, and more. They also carry a large selection of chocolates and confections. Many of the items are made fresh daily there, and the items that they source from other vendors (troubadour, stone creek, simmas, mollys) are clearly marked. They also have gluten free products too (some in a freezer case) Ended up getting a couple of pies to take home, one Door County Cherry and the other Apple. They serve a whole array of coffees and lattes (London Fog please), so I will be stopping back some morning to try one hot beverage and scone. Stay tuned.... read more

See all

Cute little bake shop in the heart of West Allis. Good selection of bakery. Only drawback in my opinion is that it's only street parking Service was okay but employees didn't look to happy to be working Limited seating available inside plus 3 outdoor patio tables for 2 read more

See all

We decided to pick up ham & rolls on 11/2. The ham was so unbelievably salty and fatty I ended up throwing it out the day after. Only 1 sandwich eaten. Normally this would be gone by kickoff. The hard rolls were ok. Extremely disappointing, compared to previous visits. See pic for gelatinous greasy reference. read more

The Bake Sale - Ham stuck to the foil container after I threw it out. Notice the gold gelatinous substance coating the pan. - Bakeries Near Me - West Allis, Wisconsin

What an awesome specialty bakery in West Allis! So much to offer from coffee to sweets and more! Everything is beautifully laid out and fresh and I like that they have small pies so you can't or don't need to commit to a large pie lol read more

See all

I wanted to place a pie order for my birthday and went with the peanut butter and jelly pie. It was absolutely delicious! Tasted just like the real thing. It had peanut butter cream filling and layers of jelly. Also, while I was ordering I got a sausage and gravy pasty for breakfast and it was AMAZING! The croissant was so flaky and delicious! My boyfriend ordered a cinnamon roll and it was one of the best cinnamon rolls I've ever had, and I am usually not a big fan of them. We heated it up in the microwave so the frosting was nice and melted. read more

The Bake Sale - Peanut butter and jelly pie - Bakeries Near Me - West Allis, Wisconsin

See all

Sunday Ham was delicious and so were all the delicious baked goods we took home with us.

The Bake Sale should be on your places to check out if you're ever in West Allis. They had an overwhelming amount of choices!! I truly wanted to try about 25 different things. Sounds like I gotta go back, right? Mine and David's favorite was the French silk pie. That was fantastic and I loved the crust. My second favorite was the cinnamon roll. It was a little dry but the amount of frosting they put on made up for it! I look forward to heating it up tomorrow then I bet it will be awesome. A little disappointed in the peanut butter cup brownie. There was no peanut butter flavor besides the few pieces of chopped up peanut butter cups. I see potential in the brownie but probably wouldn't get that flavor again. The raspberry and Nutella filled croissant dipped in chocolate was good, but also a little dry. Although that may be common with croissants? I'm no expert when it comes to croissants so maybe that's suppose to be. Overall we had a fun time trying The Bake Sale out. The worker there was soooo friendly and helpful as well! read more

The Bake Sale - Chocolate peanut butter cup brownie, frosted cinnamon roll, raspberry and Nutella filled croissant dipped in chocolate - Bakeries Near Me - West Allis, Wisconsin

See all

Yikes this place is cute but I just had the worst customer service experience ever! I stopped in to pick up an order I had placed online and no one was at the front desk - I waited a minute or so but had to get going, so poked my head in a door off to the side and saw someone said "hi" and was greeted honestly with the most irritated look. I said I was there to pick up an order, she muttered "name?" and then grabbed my bag for me. Never gave any kind of greeting or apology for having me have to wait and seek out service. Maybe she was just having a bad day, but I will definitely second guess coming back. read more

I entered having no idea what to expect. I craved sweet and savory. Upon perusing the bakery case, I reduced my choices to two pastries: a Cheese Pocket and/or a Cheese Danish. I asked the employee which she would recommend. She said, "the Cheese Pocket." It was absolutely anazing! The sweetness of the vanilla frosting, the flakiness of the pastry, and the rich, slightly savory cream made for a symphony of flavors. I highly recommend The Bake Sale!‍ read more

Stopped by The Bake Sale in West Allis - such a fun concept! They have a wide variety of treats baked in-house and sourced from local vendors, including a nice selection of gluten-free and allergy-friendly goodies. We grabbed a latte and a few items to go but they have plentiful seating inside. read more

See all

Horrible customer service. Manager is extremely rude and needs to learn how to speak to humans. Unfortunately it was my first time visiting, I won't be back. read more

When I moved to West Alis, I was pleased to see there was a bakery just around the corner from where I live. The first time I visited I was unaware of their hours and went in around 45 minutes before closing. The woman who served me and my fiancé wasn't rude, but not exactly happy we were in there. We both ordered coffee and a cheese pocket, which were both incredible and delicious. The second occasion we had a lovely woman working behind the counter who made small talk with us and offered us ideas on things to order. And just recently we went in again today and to my dismay the woman working behind the counter was not friendly at all. We ordered coffee and a pastry. And upon receiving my coffee, I decided I wanted another pastry that was quick to grab. I mentioned it, and she rudely told me the total and tossed my pastry up on top of the showing case. This place is so cute. It is a shame that the employees do not feel the same sense of happiness that the shop brings everybody else. I will keep going her just for the quality of goods...NOT the quality of service. read more

Great little place for sweats, scones, coffee and bread. We also tried their pasties which are delicious and they will heat them up there for eating in or to go. read more

Have been there 2x before, bakery ok, went there on a wednesday morning . Clerk was doing something on her ipad. Seemed like she was giving me a BREAK to wait on me . Wanted rolls or a bread They dont have that every day I would of gotten some bakery, but I have the feeling i was interrupting the employee from the ipad. I walked. Went to Grebe's. Service excellent, bakery very good Next trip to bake shop, WONT be one. I refuse to give my business where customer service sucks. When i read some of the other reviews i see a pattern Not a good one read more

Was looking for a simple but good chocolate croissant, not here. Baker said they don't make them. I did try their coconut chocolate hay stacks which were great but they were out on my next visit . Unfortunately the sarcasm from the female baker wasn't very tasty. Poor customer service skills left a bad taste in my mouth . Probably won't return for that reason alone. read more

Nice little place for some coffee and pastries. I loved the selection they have for vegan and gluten free. Just had a latte today, but will definitely come back to try something else. read more

See all

Visiting family and found this place using Yelp. Cute place with an abundance of items made in house and locally. The cinnamon roll and cookies were delicious. My only complaint was apparently interrupting the person at the counter who was involved in figuring out an order that needed to be placed. read more

Cool little bakery and local goods shop. There's a case with pies, cakes, and all kinds of other bakery. I chose a slice of carrot cake, as I was still full from a burger across the street. My carrot cake was really good! They had shelves of local snacks and a couple coolers with other items. Everything appeared to be from local vendors. My wife ordered an ice coffee, which was made while we looked around. Kids got puppy chow and gummy worms. This place is mixed into a 2-3 block section of cool little businesses in West Allis. Definately worth the visit and easily supplemented by several other stops. read more

I had the most amazing almond cookie of my life here yesterday. The inside was perfectly gooey and sweet. A lot of places miss the mark on the sweet almond flavor, but not this bakery! My fiancé and I also got a brown butter oatmeal cream pie and snickerdoodle cookie, and both were incredible! Oh, and they have treats for doggies too! Get something for yourself, and something for your heckin' good boy/girl. HIGHLY RECOMMEND! read more

Traveled through Milwaukee and wanted to stop here. Service was fine. I ordered a few things, carrot cake, blueberry lemon scone, and a cream cheese danish. It was $15 for all three things... and they all missed the mark. The carrot cake was extremely dry and didn't have cream cheese frosting, just normal frosting. The scone was terrible, it just tasted like butter and salt. No blueberry or lemon flavor at all. The danish was super dry. I definitely wouldn't be back again. read more

Wet your taste buds to the smell of fresh bread, pastries, and desserts as you walk into this cute little bakery on Becher Street in West Allis. Gluten? Vegan? Chocolate addict? You'll find a variety of yumminess that caters to everyone. Browse favorites like bear claws (donuts), cookies, hand pies, cakes, brownies, and new ideas (vegan pop tarts). This baker is hip and cool, always eager for feedback and excited to share other worldly inventions. Her team gets the job done leaving you wonder, what's next? This business also partners with local eateries around Milwaukee building community and bringing people together over delicious delicacies. Inside, outside, you pick! Both are cozy and out of the way of the hustle and bustle of life. Enjoy a nice cup of steaming coffee or tea with a homemade baked good that brings a smile to your face. read more

See all

GREAT PLACE TO STUDY OR WORK!!! The costumer service was delightful and this is a super DAIRY-FREE, GLUTEN-FREE, and VEGAN friendly place to go (treats and drinks for all three)!! Definitely coming back!! read more

The Bake Sale - Bakeries Near Me - West Allis, Wisconsin

Super cute bakery featuring homemade goods made in house and from other local shops around town. Staff was super friendly and answered all my questions. There is plenty of space to enjoy the baked goods inside or outside the shop. They offer baked goods, breads, popcorn, candy, honey, jams and mixes to bake your own delicious treats. Definitely check them out if you are looking fir a sweat treat or putting together a cute gift bag of goodies for a gift. read more

See all

Everything here is just perfect. They have so many things I want to try. So far I've had the oatmeal cream sandwich & cherry pie, both are to die for. I also spotted some popcorn seasoning I would love to try out. read more

This is such a fun place to go. They sell baked goods from various places as well as their own. It is like a bake sale! It is fun because you can drive to one place but try several kinds of bakery styles/items. They have a little bit of everything without driving all over the county. read more

Super rude and condescending employee at the counter. No greeting coming in, she kept staring at us while browsing. When we were ready to make our 2 picks from the glass she was rude saying "are you gonna want anything else from here?" We also got 3 trays for take and bake cinnamon rolls and she says "oh you're clearing me out, the lady that makes these is gonna be upset because she will have to make more." Like who says that? I guess I shouldn't buy any? Never again. read more

I picked up the most amazing smoked ham at the BakeSale and I highly recommend it. Much to my surprise they ran out of biscuits. But guess what, when I bit into the 'cookies' belonging to this six cookie 'cookie platter', I found those missing biscuits alright. These Packer cookies are literally baking soda biscuits. With frosting. Just wrong. read more

The Bake Sale - Frosted Biscuits?? - Bakeries Near Me - West Allis, Wisconsin

Great pie and other treats! Lots of fun stuff to look at and choose from. Coffee and donuts, cakes, pies, and other delicious snacks.

So many delicious treats! They make some of their own pastries and have tons of other local bakeries/coffee shops. You can also get some foodie items or a coffee drink. On this stop I got an iced coffee, $8 mini French silk pie, a Cranky Al's doughnut, and a delicious breakfast pasty filled with hash browns, cheese, peppers, a s sausage. read more

The Bake Sale - Inside - Bakeries Near Me - West Allis, Wisconsin

Just tried it today for the first but definitely not the last time. Such a cozy little shop. Employees were friendly and helpful. Omg the Ham is the best I've ever had. It's shredded with great smoke flavor but not overdone and came with 6 tasty rolls. Got a couple of pastries and enjoyed them too. read more

Love the pulled ham but hard rolls are very crumbly. Cheese pocket too much frosting but good otherwise. Like cherry pie

Currently, easily the best and most innovative bakery in Milwaukee County precisely because they're not responding to the siren calls of cheap edible oils like soybean, canola, palm, coconut or cottonseed. This comes at a price I am willing to pay. They are not perfect, but they're trying much harder than their competitors. Milwaukee generically has a good bread scene and they remain competitive with a simple selection of breads and rolls. Dutch crust anyone? The pulled hot ham on Sunday is an inspired idea which needs to be moister; a little brown sugar, butter and water worked perfectly to rehydrate the meat. And who offers house-made peach mustard? Which works better as a ketchup replacement than as mustard. Pasties, a Cornish miners filled meat pastry which have mostly disappeared from the American diet, are available here. Cinnamon rolls could use more cinnamon. Their version of the Hostess fruit pie is the best I've ever had; especially the Door County cherry. As mentioned by others, the filled almond cookie is epic. The brown sugar buttercream oatmeal cream pie, a variant of the whoopee pie, is prize winning. They do mini-pie's, cookies, donuts, croissants, et al. To their very strong credit, they're offering different bakery items to a customer base who has been conditioned over decades to expect a limited menu of very dull offerings. This is what Milwaukee used to be like for your grandparents. A disaster for those on a diet. As it should be. Fancy coffee and a robust selection of other local food purveyors round out this unassuming storefront in an unassuming neighborhood. I'd kill to have access to something this good in Los Angeles. Unlike nearby Grebe's (AKA Grubby's), they're not allergic to butter and eggs or cleaning their equipment. Pretty much the antithesis of the modern industrial or foodstore bakery. A wonderful addition to what has become a mini food makers district. I'd like later hours, but I can cope for bakery this good. My cardiologist would be horrified. What happens in 'Stallica stays in 'Stallica. You want to be a foodie? This is a fine place to start. I'm a very seasoned food traveler and this place is globally competitive for what they do right. The much lower overhead of this unhip 'hood is likely what makes this possible. Indulge in this joint as much as possible before the spreadsheet jockeys ruin it and let your tastebuds explore. Best option other than doing it at home. read more

The Bake Sale - Brandy almond peach mini-pie. - Bakeries Near Me - West Allis, Wisconsin

Ambience and service is great. The cherry hand pies are my favorite. What a great hidden gem.

Be sure to have a steak knife! We bought two small pies - a Door County Cherry and a Caramel Apple -- quite pricey. They tasted very good, BUT the crusts on both pies were so hard that the pies were almost impossible to cut. The bottom crusts were (hope I'm not exaggerating) tough as leather. NOT worth the price! read more

This cozy shop is yet another treasure in West Allis. The bakery is outstanding and the coffee is as well. Hubby tried a savory hand pie and I had a scone. Both were greet. The shop has giant Rice Krispie treats made by Carrie's, Urbal tea, Purple Door ice cream, and other locally-produced items. There are vegetarian and gluten-free options as well. read more

I ordered a pie and it was fresh and fantastic. I had some questions and when I called the woman was polite and accommodating. The place is cute and clean. I would definitely recommend to anyone looking for a good bakery. read more

Friendly service and excellent baked goods at the Bake Sale. Highly recommend the hand pies.

Got special cake & it was excellent. Service excellent. Nice homey type job place. Nice location.