Best Italian bakery around! Everyone is always so friendly when I visit and their food is always delicious! 1) The wall of cookies is like no where else. They are excellent and I can never leave without getting at least a small container (you know as a snack for the ride home haha). They are always sooo fresh. I've tried most of them and they are all excellent. 2) The hot ham and rolls on Sunday are hard to beat. Their super thin sliced ham is so flavorful and their rolls are so fresh. 3) If you have not had sfincione yet just get some (if it's there- it sells out quick). Sicilian-style pizza and you'll thank me later read more

See all

Great place to stop in for last minute cookie gifts. They have some prepackaged in 1 lb containers or they have a large assortment to build your own. A little on the pricey side though $18.95 lb read more

See all

First of all, they have so many beautiful cookies and other treats. They also have breads! I love getting the rainbow cookie which is a little square three layer cake that tastes like almond with raspberry jam. Soooo good. Then, the tiramisu never misses. It's creamy and so coffee-y. The pumpkin cannoli, a seasonal feature, is sooo good too. The workers are always so kind and understanding. I will continue to come here without a doubt when I need a sweet treat, especially since you made my college graduation much sweeter! read more

Scordato Bakery Inc - Bakeries Near Me - Milwaukee, Wisconsin

The people who work there are always friendly and helpful. They take the time to explain ingredients if you ask. My favorite bakery item there is the Limoncello Cake. I get it every time I go. My husband's favorite item are the Arancini rice balls. Don't hesitate to visit and support a local business! read more

fun experience getting some italian cookies & pazcki. I liked how everything felt like it was made with love. read more

See all

One of the best, if not thee best Italian bakeries in Milwaukee. The bread is remarkable, their Italian cookies are delicious and their Sfincione Siciliano, a Sicilian style pizza, unlike any other you've tried before. Topped with crispy bread crumbs, grated cheese, onions, anchovies and oregano for a satisfying crunch with every bite! The owner is very friendly and always happy to see you! You won't be disappointed going here. A true gem in Milwaukee. read more

I was looking for a place that sells Italian cookies and came across this in a search for "bakery." The cookies I got were all so tasty that we came back for more after two days! A nice variety of flavors and all really well made. The staff was also very nice and helpful! read more

Scordato Bakery Inc - Variety of cookies. Apricot was really tasty. - Bakeries Near Me - Milwaukee, Wisconsin

See all

Solid cannolis and great service. The staff were very inviting and helpful. The sides they offered seemed enticing but I did not try those this time around. read more

WOW! This Italian bakery takes me back to when I was a young girl getting treats from the local bakery. I've been looking for a place to order cookies for my daughter's wedding, so I taste tested all of the fresh delectable handmade cookies. They did not disappoint! Everyone was fresh and flavorful melt in your mouth deliciousness. I am so excited to share these with family and friends! Way to go to Scordato bakery! Love the family business tradition carried on. Milwaukee and SE Wisconsin needs you! Thank you all! read more

See all

Excellent butter cookies terrific staff pastries Italian-yummy Hours are limited:-( Love the Italian atmosphere! read more

I went on Sunday for the ham and rolls. The rolls were really good and the ham was warm. I also got some cookies and they tasted really good. I will be back to try other things at a later time read more

The best. Always very good and the bakery is amazing. You will not be disappointed. Bread, buns and Italian cookies

With Scordato Bakery, every purchase makes the day a holiday! Delicious! They are the "go-to" party making shop.

I tried Scortados for their Paczkis and it was incredibly delicious. They had SO many flavors- Raspberry, lemon, bravarian, Nutella, cannoli cream, prune and many more. They were very good at taking pre orders and they were ready early morning despite the heavy snow blizzard. Very prompt and friendly staff. All covid protocols followed. read more

See all

Our cake turned out beautifully and tasted wonderful . Antonella knows how to decorate a cake all the flowers she placed for us. I'll definitely be coming back in future for events read more

Scordato Bakery Inc - The Lukitsch wedding our cake turned out beautifully thanks to Antonella - Bakeries Near Me - Milwaukee, Wisconsin

Very fast service, fresh, baked goods, and very nice Staff! I come by here all the time for their muffins and assorted cookies! read more

The best homemade cookies at a good price. Fresh and delicious. Great variety too. The eclairs are large and filled to both ends. And the cannolis are the Best! Great Italian sausage and bread too. read more

If you're looking for amazing themed cakes or just tasty treats like Italian cookies, this is the place to go. Alex and Antonella are very good at what they do and are there to talk with you if you need help selecting the right items for your next party or just want to try something new! Antonella recently made me a small Penguin cake for my daughters 1st birthday and she loved it. read more

Scordato Bakery Inc - 1st Birthday cake created by Scordato Bakery. (I added the candle..lol) - Bakeries Near Me - Milwaukee, Wisconsin

I have been meaning to get over here for a while and today I finally made it but even though I have traveled the area many times I still couldn't remember ever seeing it, well I drove right past it and still didn't see it so I did a U turn and pulled into the strip mall because it has to be in here somewhere. Sure enough it's in a sliver of the strip mall with 0% street presence when you drive by. The place is small but what it has is just right with limited hot food, take and bake foods, fresh breads, deli meats, cheeses, pastas, salads, olives, cookies, and numerous sweet things. I wanted a little cross section of the place so I had the cooked sausage sandwich, take and bake calzone and one raspberry sweet treat thing from the fresh baked cooling rack, all under $10 mind you. The sausage sandwich was a mild Italian sausage on a seeded roll with green peppers and onions. My first bite was, a nice tasty/seasoned sausage on a chewy seeded roll which I liked. My second was, hot/spicy is creeping in now that the onions and green peppers were in that bite but I didn't ask for any hot topping and I don't know where it came from but I liked the kick that it had. The sweet treat raspberry something, turn over ? was good with a super flakey pastry like body with a sweet glaze on it, crap I only bought one and if I knew how good it was I would have grabbed at least 2. The take n bake fresh calzone was probably the best take n bake item that I have had from anywhere. It's ham, pepperoni and herbed ricotta cheese basically in a sealed crust. It bakes up nice and golden with a crispy and slightly chewy crust that is tastier than pizza crust with a little sweetness. There is a nice little crunch when you bite in it and then the herbed ricotta hits you and it's like man this is fresh and tasty with the ham and pepperoni that is not piled high but just right. This place is definitely a hidden gem with some good items and I'm glad that I finally got over to check them out, I can't wait to try some of the other sweet goodies. read more

See all

Decided to stop to see what type of deli they had available. The deli case was small and I didn't see much of a selection of deli meats. To my surprise the lady said we have hot Italian sausages today. I decided to give one a try and then of coarse couldn't say no to the cannoli. They did have a nice selection of cold salads in the case so I also grabbed some antipasto. The bread used for the sausage was perfect and the peepers and onions were so full of great flavor. I could have eaten two of them. The cannoli was stuffed full with filling and the pistachio flavor seemed to stand out. Antipasto was full of ham, pepperoni, cheese, olives, and peppers. I will be back for Italian sausage sandwiches which they only serve every other Saturday. I didn't try any of the Italian cookies but they did have a nice selection available along with some Italian breads. Great little place to stop by if you're in the area. read more

See all

Not your typical Italian bakery. While the breads are terrific, their cookies are the reason to go. If you're looking for quality Christmas cookies, like your nana made, this is the place to go. Mister Cookie himself passed away a few years ago but the kids have taken over and maintained his quality standards, he would be so very proud of them. You can order them on line, but then you can't taste them.... I can't recommend them high enough. read more

Just a of fashioned bakery. Everything is so good. My favorite is their homemade banana chocolate chip bread at the moment. Their Italian Bread is wonderful. Deli is nicely supplied with the essentials. Free 1/2 dozen rolls with hot ham on Sundays. Let us not forget the people who work there. Always very helpful and pleasant. Can't say that about a lot of places. I would recommend you stop in and see for yourself. read more

The service was amazing and I absolutely love their bakery cookies bread everything taste fresh had a great experience

Great bakery. Ran upon it while looking for something else in the neighborhood. I have never been known to pass up a bakery. Glad I stopped. read more

Largest and best selection of cookies in Milwaukee. Offbeat neighborhood location so you need to know about it. Also some deli items, fresh pizza dough and ham and rolls. read more

The photos and close to me looking for a place that looked like a great place to order from

A coworker of mine had brought in a slice of Pizza bread from this Bakery/Deli for me. it was absolutely DELICIOUS! My Husband and I visited this Awesome Family Bakery/Deli on 4/13. The staff was super friendly! we purchased some of their Italian Sausage and added it to out Homeade meatball and sauce for out Sunday Family Dinner. The flavor of the Sausage was amazing so delicious we have never had better Italian Sausage, also we purchased Cannoli for desert that I have to say is the best we have had also!!! included in our purchase was some of the fresh pizza dough they make. We like to make homemade pizza and are so excited to try their pizza dough!! The selection of cookies and assorted bakery and bread looked amazing too! We definitely will be telling Family and Freinds about this wonderful Business and will cannot wait to go back to purchase their homeade Lasagna and breads and bakery. read more

Amazing service and baked goods. I ordered a custom birthday cake for my fiancé's golden 30th birthday, it turned out incredible! It looked so beautiful and tasted even better. 10/10 would buy again, and I HIGHLY recommend! read more

Scordato Bakery Inc - Cake - Bakeries Near Me - Milwaukee, Wisconsin

Love the hot ham and rolls great bakery too always have to get the turn overs always a line but they move fast super friendly staff little hidden gem read more

Good things come in small packages, and this Italian bakery/deli is a prime example of that. This is one of those amazing hidden gems on the south side. While it doesn't have the variety of a lot of others bakeries or delis in the area, anything it does everything extremely well. I discovered this bakery years ago and I always visit often, even when I lived all the way across town. One of the big reasons is the chocolate covered cannoli's. I don't think I've ever tasted anything as good as a chocolate covered cannoli here. They also offer a variety of pastries, eclairs, creme horns and even slices of cheesecake. While the cheesecake isn't the best in the city, it's still great and extremely cheap, running you only a buck and some change for a regular slice. They also offer a large variety of Italian cookies which are fantastic. These are great to bring to a function or even to give as a gift to really set you apart from the crowd. They have a chewy almond cookie that's heavenly. The breads are awesome, today I left with a loaf of Italian bread and a loaf of French bread. Well worth the money. Sometimes I walk in here feeling like Tony Soprano, then I order some Gabagoo. The worker then looks at me weird and I go back to being awkward Polish guy. I don't hit the deli part all too much, but once in a while I come in on Sunday morning for the hot ham and rolls. Like most delis on the south side, they give you six free rolls with a pound of ham on Sunday's. Pair that up with some of their potato salad and it makes for an awesome lunch during the Packer's game. Come in for a visit, you won't regret it. read more

See all

AMAZING! That's the one word that comes to mind. They made an ADORABLE delicious cake for my son's birthday just the way he requested. Antonella was a pleasure to do business with. Answered all of my questions and was an A+ with communication. Very reasonable price. I will be ordering all of my cakes from here from now on. read more

Scordato Bakery Inc - Birthday Cake - Bakeries Near Me - Milwaukee, Wisconsin

This bakery has the best rolls a breads. It is the closest you will ever get to the old fashioned hard roll. Nice and fresh and extra crispy. I should probably tell you to stay away from the hot turnovers on Sundays. If I tell you how delicious they are there won't be any left for me! All kidding aside they are fabulous. The only problem is I can never decide which filling I like the best. I just tell them to surprise me. I was soooo sad to hear the owner passed away. He was the sweetest kindest and cutest man. I miss his smiling face extend to his family my deepest sympathies. read more

I'm so surprised I'm the first to offer a review of this awesome bakery! I've been going to Scordato's with my family since I was a kid. I have many fond memories of this bakery and it still is as delicious and awesome as it was when I was younger. I'm assuming that as a result of it's location on the South side it doesn't pick up the foot traffic of say Sciortino's or Groppi, but it certainly matches them both in quality. If you don't live nearby, I can say that this place is worth the drive. The shop isn't as big as other Italian bakeries and they don't offer an enormously huge selection of Italian delicacies, but what they have is tried and true and oh so tasty. If you had to order only one thing at Scordato's, this is it: SFINGIUNI They seriously have some of the best sfingiuni I've ever had in my life. If you're not familiar with it, it's basically like a delicious equivalent of cold pizza but with so much more flavor. Growing up our family would order sheets of it for our parties--it's perfect for eating while walking around with a drink in hand. One word of caution--this stuff is delicious and they can sell out of it so be sure to come earlier in the day if you want a taste. Another important thing: ITALIAN COOKIES Now, you might be thinking "Yeah, yeah, I've had cookies before." Not like these. Sadly, a lot of bakeries lately have been buying pre-made or par-baked pastries and cookies from big companies and selling them in their stores as their own. I've watched a handful of bakeries in Milwaukee succumb to this fate as the cost of food and time increases. The cookies you'll get here at Scordato's are all made, on site, by hand. THAT ALONE IS REASON TO GIVE THEM A TRY. The process of making a few of the cookie varietals they sell can be quite time/labor intensive so to be able to get the homemade versions in person really makes this place special. Also, for various Christian holidays they have amazing seasonal Italian treats that are a great addition to any gathering. Like other Italian bakeries, they have various styles of bread, olive salads, canolis, tiramisu, pizza dough, and so forth. They do have a few Italian-style cakes like a limoncello cake I've been meaning to try that you might not find elsewhere. Please stop by and give them a try. You'll be so glad you did. Also, have a fig cookie for me--they're amazing! read more

Picked up four dozen rolls at 7:30 am when they open. What, I got there 10 mins early, and already open. Great!!! Mix hard rolls ready to go, I brought them to work with my home made bbq pulled chicken. Everyone loved it and the roll made it awesome. Scordato's has the best bakery! It's a waste of money to go anywhere else. read more

It has been about one month since I visited Scordato's bakery after church on Sunday. It was ALWAYS packed, you took a number and waited for service but it was worth the wait for hot ham, rolls, Italian bread and bakery plus many items in their display case. But today when I went there after church, there were only a few people in the store which caused me to wonder. I thought initially it was closed because there were so many empty parking spaces. I have frequented this place for many years and NEVER has this occurred. I started to reflect and recalled in the recent past that the owner had passed away. I am sorry for his family and express my condolences. A wonderful, hard working person who will be missed by his customers also. Naturally this has a huge impact on the store, and I am wondering after dealing with the death to his family, will they continue to operate the bakery? read more

Try the slices of Key Lime Pie-the best ever! They also make awesome Gluten Free Brownies.

I love the macaroons, they're chewy and beautifully flavored. And I'm so excited that they have arancini (rice balls); love them! I wasn't a fan of some of the cookies that were dry to me; guess you're supposed to drink them with coffee? The person that waited on me was sweet as pie and the prices were very reasonable. read more

My Italian bakery closed in February of this past year and have been looking for a replacement for my Sunday hot ham and rolls. Tried Scordato's for the first time and was it delicious. I love the ham, it is seasoned very well and the rolls are wonderful. I will get the longer rolls next time and will try some of their cookies. Only down side is that their shaved ham is not hot, just have to warm it up when you get home. Very impressed. read more

The owner licks his fingers to pull off and open plastic bags! Very nice people. Good prices but they don't always get your order right and are often out of rolls. read more

Scordato Bakery is one of the best in the city. The bakery offers a wide variety of traditional Italian cookies that are beautiful to look at and so tasty. I often bring them to gatherings and an Italian friend commented that they were the best she had ever had and asked me a lot of questions about the bakery (she had never been, but now it is the only bakery she frequents). I actually learned about it from my sister who lives in Brookfield. There have been many stories about this bakery and their expertise and absolute joy in making the cookies. They sell them in a nice presentation box for a gift with each cookie described as well as by the pound. My sister purchased one of the presentation boxes of cookies at Sendiks and served it over the holidays and knew a lot about the bakery as she worked at the Milwaukee Journal and they wrote about it several times as one of those places that is a hidden gem in Milwaukee and well worth traveling too. We live pretty close, and often pick up their bread (very tasty), ham and rolls, and something fabulous is their pizza. It has a doughy bread crust and an awesome tomato/cheese topping and they sell it by the piece. Of course the sweets are out of this world. I am told by those of the Italian community that this bakery sells some specialities that are hard to find. Well worth traveling to this bakery from any part of the city - very fresh, authentic, tasty and reasonably priced. Also, nice people who own/run the bakery. read more