Cancel

Open app

Search

Thatcher's Restaurant & Pub

3.6 (10 reviews)
InexpensiveNew American

Thatcher's Restaurant & Pub Photos

You might also consider

More like Thatcher's Restaurant & Pub

Recommended Reviews - Thatcher's Restaurant & Pub

Your trust is our priority, so businesses can't pay to alter or remove their reviews. Learn more about reviews.
Yelp app icon
Browse more easily on the app
Review Feed Illustration

2 years ago

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 2
Oh no 0

1 year ago

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0
Photo of Anna M.
1
75
59

3 years ago

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 1
Oh no 0
Photo of Ben M.
1
38
0

3 years ago

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 1
Oh no 0

8 years ago

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 1
Oh no 0

7 years ago

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 1
Oh no 0

4 years ago

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 1
Oh no 0

14 years ago

Helpful 1
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

7 years ago

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0
Photo of Hannah O.
131
37
11

11 years ago

Helpful 1
Thanks 0
Love this 1
Oh no 1

Ask the Community - Thatcher's Restaurant & Pub

You might also consider

Verify this business for free

People searched for New American 523 times last month within 15 miles of this business.

Verify this business

The Blue Feather - Ahi Poke Bowl

The Blue Feather

4.3(18 reviews)
1.8 mi

Linda M. 020 7 days…read moreago My mom and I went tonight (Tuesday 7/1). She had boneless wings. We both enjoyed our meals. Mom loved her wings. Tender and moist. I loved my salmon especially with that delicious maple bourbon glaze. They put enough to mix with the rice. So good!!!!!!! the broccoli was cooked perfectly, not too hard/not too soft. I really hope this restaurant stays. I have one concern.....the parking, yes, for the customers, but more so for the restaurant staff. Restaurant staff are getting parking tickets. What's the point of working downtown if all restaurant staff tips go to paying parking tickets? I suggest the owners of all the restaurants downtown talk to the city of Lewiston, and ask if restaurant staff could get a free pass to the garage after they show proof of employment. Use a sticker on the window IDing cars exempt from payment to the garage. City of Lewiston, please step up and help hard working people not lose their tips to parking tickets. Don't want to lose good workers due to parking tickets. Lewiston, you have wonderful downtown restaurants. HELP KEEP THE HELP!!!!! Abby was amazing, kind, attentive. Enjoyed her very much. The ambiance was relaxing. The lighting is prefect, not too dark, not too light. There were not many people when we were there, probably due to no available parking, so I don't know the noise level. I could guess, based on the height of the ceiling I would think it would be noisy, echo'ey, if it were packed. But not so loud as to prevent a conversation with your party. Definitely will be going back. I want to try ahi tuna next. Linda Lavoie Mckinney

I'm not sure about this one. The food was good, nothing to…read morewrite home about but not bad. The cheesesteak definitely tasted like steakums, ya know that pre sliced stuff in the frozen section. The bus was too large for the amount of meat given, but the bread was good. The salad was solid for a side, fresh toppings, nothing brown, dressing was good but tasted store bought. The service was slow for how dead it was, the bartender was good for daytime service, nice guy, but I'd hate to see how that panned out on a busy night. Great space, nice decor, lighting, very clean. Lots of potential, several places have failed in this spot, hopefully they work the kinks out. (I didn't eat the other items pictured)

Photos
The Blue Feather - Entrance

Entrance

The Blue Feather - Sweet and sour meatballs

Sweet and sour meatballs

The Blue Feather - Window moniker

See all

Window moniker

Firehouse Grille - Mozzarella Stick appetizer

Firehouse Grille

4.2(69 reviews)
2.4 mi
•$$

Alyssa the waitress was great ! The food came out quickly and was very good quality. The prices are…read moregood too for the portions also. Cool vibes inside and a dope little horseshoe bar. Quesadillas and wings and grilled cheese special and all 3 kinds of fries were good. The sweet potato fries were sooooo yummy ! A must get for the table to share. Would be a good starter ! Would definitely come back!

The Firehouse grill lives up to its reputation!!…read more The food was all in large portions and delicious. We started strong with mozzarella cheese sticks and the pretzel and cheese appetizer. Fresh and hot defined these apps perfectly! The sticks were warm and stringy, the pretzels were warm, soft, and salty. The cheese dip was actually delicious and tasted nothing like a can mix. For the main courses we had the home made mac and cheese that was topped with pulled pork which was sauced in Sweet Baby Rays and the Loaded Nachos topped with the Firehouse's award winning chili. The food all came out sized for a table of 8 with savory and sweet hints of deliciousness! The waitress was welcoming, outgoing, and offered sound advice on food choices. The cook staff was timely and efficient, and the bar tender was busy busy slinging cups full of the nectar of God (BEER!!)! The Firehouse House ambience lived up to the name with firefighter equipment, first responder memorabilia, and crafty decor. The only downside to this establishment is that is dark and throws a dive bar vibe. 9/10... we will be coming back here for sure (and ordering less food)!!

Photos
Firehouse Grille - Back to the basic in New Auburn, at the FIREHOUSE GRILL!!

Back to the basic in New Auburn, at the FIREHOUSE GRILL!!

Firehouse Grille - Pretzel and Cheese Appetizer

Pretzel and Cheese Appetizer

Firehouse Grille - Specials board changes daily

See all

Specials board changes daily

Gritty McDuff's Brew Pub - Blackened Chicken Sandwich with sweet potato fries

Gritty McDuff's Brew Pub

3.3(139 reviews)
1.8 mi
•$$

Gritty McDuff's in Auburn is an excellent choice for dinner and drinks!…read more I walked to Grittys from my hotel and sat inside the bar while they made our food to-go. The bar is spacious and on Thursday night they had someone playing life music. We ordered a pizza, burger, and pickle chips and all of the food was tasty. The service is also excellent! Only reason for 4 stars is I didn't care for their beers. I tried their blueberry ale and hazy IPA. I'm a bit of an IPA snob so don't let this ruin your opportunity to have an amazing experience. Grittys has an amazing outside dining area and a large menu! Check them out if you're in Auburn!

Having the option of sitting outside is fantastic! Loved that…read more Varied menu options - for beer, drinks, and food. Mac & Cheese with kielbasa was good. We were surprised to see a pile of jalapeños included - maybe it's on the menu and we missed it. Corn bread was moist. I opted for a build your own burger which was great. No bun, lettuce and tomato. The waitress told me to just tell her what I wanted on it and she'd get it for me. Cool. She didn't tell me I would be charged an extra $1 for a tiny bit of spinach, and 75 cents each for grilled onions and mushrooms. Not cool. I definitely would have just selected an "already made" option. I asked for sautéed mushrooms and onions so was a little surprised to get deep fried shrooms. There were good - I would probably order, and even be willing to pay extra, for them again. My issue was not being told. The seasoned fries were really good. The iced tea and Hazy IPA were (of course) good. Our waitress was a bit too attentive. It seemed almost like every time we took a bite, she was asking if everything was okay. Maybe just check in a couple times over the course of the meal? Please do remember that 3 is not bad. For me, it's a solid average.

Photos
Gritty McDuff's Brew Pub
Gritty McDuff's Brew Pub - Pretzel Pub Sticks

Pretzel Pub Sticks

Gritty McDuff's Brew Pub - Not just a mimosa, white wine sangria

See all

Not just a mimosa, white wine sangria

The Sedgley Place - Surf and turf

The Sedgley Place

3.9(73 reviews)
5.8 mi
•$$$

Excellent food anchors this wonderful find. The wait staff - especially Rachel and Jacob- proved…read morefun, kind and generously welcoming. Had the pork tenderloin with a fig jam surprise. My co-eater uncovered tenderly prepared ragu with a flair for highlighting the actual tomatoes. The stuffed mushroom appetizer proved fun and yummy. Both of us remain amazed at the generous portions, unhurried service and delicious mashed potatoes. The desserts were a treat. We highly recommend this lovely historical space with a chef and staff that really care about food and the joy it brings

Sedgley Place was quite a disappointment. If I go to a restaurant that is charging $81 for salmon,…read moreover $100 for fillet of beef, and $79 for meatloaf (!) I expect the food and the service to be impeccable, and that is not the case. The best item served all night was the bread and butter, which was very nice. The meatloaf lacked seasoning except for the strong taste of the charred top. It was drowned in a brown gravy made with canned mushrooms. On top were the worst string beans I have ever had, they were undercooked and bitter. The vegetarian squash dish was a Delicata squash filled with mashed sweet potato that completely overpowered the squash taste, and covered with a low quality mozzarella cheese. The 'dip' served with crackers when you arrive at the table tasted like Velveeta and pimentos mixed with gelatin to give it a weird thick consistency. The desserts were ok but nothing special. The servers were friendly and pleasant, but the level of service did not match the price point. Utensils were not picked with and then replaced with the removal of completed plates. New dishes were served before the completed dishes had been removed. The experience seemed rushed as they took the entire order at the beginning and then pushed the courses without a break. Finally the wine list was far overpriced for the quality of wines being offered. For example: El Jefe Tempranillo costs $10.99 retail and the price at Sedgley was $64. They were charging $17 for one glass. That is simply an unreasonable mark up for a pretty poor quality wine. The Mark David Lodi Zinfandel retails at $13, Sedgley charges $58, and it was also not a great tasting wine. While I know there are not a lot a classy restaurants in this area, but it is worth the drive to Bistro Milliard or Slates in Hallowell, or Fishbones in Lewiston to get a much better meal at a more reasonable price.

Photos
The Sedgley Place - Dining room

Dining room

The Sedgley Place - Scallop stuffed mushroom

Scallop stuffed mushroom

The Sedgley Place - Decor

See all

Decor

Chick-a-dee of Lewiston - Boston Lobster Pie, Baked Beans, and Coleslaw

Chick-a-dee of Lewiston

3.5(142 reviews)
4.3 mi
•$$

Used to love this place was my go to for local food when in the Lewiston area. Quality has gone…read moredown some and I hear they are closing. Shame. Had many great dinners there will miss them

The Chick-a-Dee is the kind of of spot in Lewiston where, if you blink, you'll miss it. It's an…read moreunassuming building on outer Lisbon St before you come really hit town, and honestly? I never really considered checking it out until my in-laws suggested we go for lunch one day. I always just saw the sign and kept on driving. Now, it is good... and as a bariatric patient, I am usually pretty hesitant to try new places simply because of my restrictions; however, I was pleased to find that there were options that worked for my post-op food plan. Yes, there's a lot of fried options, and there's a lot of pasta, but the stir-fry is what got me saying, "yeah I'll give it a go," and later, "yeah, I'd come back." The food has been consistent, and with a young child (who is a fantastic eater and not that picky... but still), that's huge for us. The service has always been great. They are accommodating, punctual, and friendly. Our most recent visit was extra impressive, because our server happily made sure to spend a little extra time and had so much patience with my five year old who is learning how to order for himself. Give it a go, friends. It's a pretty solid spot.

Photos
Chick-a-dee of Lewiston - General dinning

General dinning

Chick-a-dee of Lewiston - Baked beans and Boston Lobster Pie

Baked beans and Boston Lobster Pie

Chick-a-dee of Lewiston - Chicken tender appetizers mmmm was so good

See all

Chicken tender appetizers mmmm was so good

Fish Bones Grill - Lobster Rangoons (2)

Fish Bones Grill

4.3(227 reviews)
1.9 mi
•$$

Why do I always forget about this place? I've never had a meal that I didn't sit in my brain for…read moreweeks afterwards and it's pretty close to my house. I just never think Lewiston for a nice meal. But obviously I should. We went there for a couple drinks and some oysters, but then I saw a cheeseburger go by and I knew I needed in my life. It had to be done, my life wouldn't be complete unless I had it. It was cooked, perfectly, medium rare, towering over the french fries. This thing was colossal. Smoked Gouda, jalapeño and crispy onion rings piled on top. A single bite containing most of my favorite things. I have no regrets. We saw a gorgeous dessert come out towards the end of our meal so naturally, I asked the bartender about it. She said it was meant to be an evening special, I would ask if it was available for sale. After having it photograph, the chef came and delivered it personally. Much like his vision of a cheeseburger this dessert was flawless. Strawberry mousse with dark chocolate, ganache, and Oreo cookie crumble. I would've eaten it out of a shoe, a dirty one, a damn fishing boot.

Stopped by this restaurant with hubby on the way home from Maine. The food was tasty, portions were…read morenice and the drinks were good. Sara was our server and she was on point. The ambiance was fine.

Photos
Fish Bones Grill - View of the bar

View of the bar

Fish Bones Grill - Local Oysters

Local Oysters

Fish Bones Grill - The view from the end of the bar. Manhattan very dry & up on the right. Tall non-alcoholic seltzer and lime on the left.

See all

The view from the end of the bar. Manhattan very dry & up on the right. Tall non-alcoholic seltzer and lime on the left.

Thatcher's Restaurant & Pub - newamerican - Updated October 2026

Loading...
Loading...
Loading...