To Whom It May Concern, Like it or not we are in a current environment of people complaining more than saying thank you, great job, etc. In my dining out experiences over the past sixty plus years, I wanted to let you know what a great job the restaurant and the staff does at your restaurant, Ted's Montana Grill, located at 5910 W. 86th Street, Indianapolis, IN 46278. I've had the luxury over the past 60 plus years of dining where ever I wanted to go and out of all of those restaurants over the years, I still rate "Ted's top of the best". The food selections and quality of the food served are always excellent. The staff always goes out of their way to be sure everything is satisfactory and afterwards they always ask if you want a drink to go when you leave. I highly recommend that anyone looking for quality food, affordable pricing, and high quality service, to visit Ted's Montana Grill in Indianapolis, Indiana Thanks, Paul read more

I'll start by saying this restaurant has the potential to be fantastic. It's nice inside, on the fancier side, with an affordable menu. It's not in the most convenient area of town but worth the drive when the food is on point. There's a great amount of options, including bison, which is rare to see. My favorite item here is the chopped salad, but it's a way better deal to get just the side salad for $11. The entree portion is the same size salad but you'll be charged an extra $9 for one chicken breast. Other things are oddly priced, like $10 for a kids meal which is, for example, a burger (their burgers are usually pretty good), full size side, and a drink for $10, yet a side by itself (such as 4 onion rings) is $8. I've had the chopped salad several times since my first visit here last summer. It's usually good in person but getting this to-go is typically not a great experience, which is why I don't plan to return. The last few times I've had the salad, several ingredients were missing, along with other items missing. It's clear that there is no care or quality check on to go orders. There's a long wait to remake the food so I usually just take a partial refund. If you call and are told 30 minutes, it's usually ready within 10 minutes, so food is cold at pickup. If you are told 10 minutes, you might wait close to an hour because no one remembers to put your order in. It's wild. Yesterday, the to-go order was awful. My chopped salad arrived soaked in water. EIGHT viva paper towels later (yes, the brand matters because this brand absorbs a LOT), my salad was still soaked. It wasn't dressing because the liquid was clear and dressing was on the side. My friend's Caesar salad was also soaked, the lettuce was black and green, and her croutons were like soggy sponges. I called, asked for the manager, and after a 15 minute wait, he said I could pick up a gift card. Even a partial refund for food that had to go in the trash was an option. With rising food costs and thousands of restaurants to choose from in town, this place cannot maintain steady business with such lack of care. Until they hold themselves to consistent standards for dine in AND carry out, save your time and money, go anywhere else so that you can have a quality, edible meal. read more

See all

I originally went to Chili's just to get a burger but they had a 20 min wait so I decided to give this place a try. It looked kinda fancy as I stepped in, they have nice dim lighting and paints all over the walls, very clean setup which I always love! The customer service was excellent from everyone I encountered. I love how they had wikki sticks for the kids instead of the basic paper and crayons, it actually kept them entertained until the food came out. I ordered their Ted's Smash burger with fries (it comes with two patties).They offer it with bison instead of beef if you like that. The burger came out in no time and was really good it was hot and fresh came with adequate pickles/lettuce/tomato and sauce on top. I was very satisfied and glad I have them a try. Would definitely recommend if you want something a little more upscale but also budget friendly. read more

See all

Food was good. Not sure if they were understaffed for Father's Day or kitchen just fell behind but we went an hour into service before we finally got refills on drinks and our food came out. Ambiance was fine. Waitress wasn't around much but was nice. Ultimately comes back to the food. That's what made the visit worthwhile. read more

5 out of 5 stars due to our amazing waiter, Lance. He greeted us with a smile and good conversation. Great knowledge of the menu and specials. He was attentive and never let any of our beverages hit empty. We will be back solely because of his extraordinary service. We had the bison meatloaf with mashed potatoes and carrots, a Kale salad with salmon and the daily special of an open face steak sandwich with Gruyère cheese. Ted's provides free pickles at your table (you'll immediately want another serving). Drinks....they have them all. Draft beers, a variety of wines, unique cocktails, vanilla and cherry coke, kiddie cocktails....the list goes on. Hungry and want to try something new...make sure to check out Ted's soon. read more

Ted's Montana Grill - Espresso martini - American Near Me - Indianapolis, Indiana

See all

The atmosphere in this restaurant is warm and so relaxing! And the staff made us feel welcome and comfortable ... especially our waitress "Nicole"! Her service skills were top notch as she found so many ways to make our lunch amazing! They serve fresh dill pickle slices instead of bread and oh my they were crisp and delish! (And Nicole sent some home with us!) The hamburgers were so flavorful and seasoned to perfection. I had the Avalon which had Gruyère cheese, bacon jam, blue cheese crumbles and arugula . It was delicious! Make a plan to eat at this restaurant and ask for Nicole to be your server! read more

Ted's Montana Grill - The Avalon Burger! - American Near Me - Indianapolis, Indiana

See all

Best onion rings bar none, in Tally. Great cocktails, great service. BYW The steaks are amazing, always cooked to order..

Came in for a date night on a Friday and it was just blaise. Pros -Server was extremely friendly - Food was ready and delivered in a timely manner - Restaurantcwas very clean Cons - Flavor was blah, meat didnt have a lot of flavor, and the pickles didn't have much flavor either - Burger was supposed to be medium, but was rare, MAYBE medium rare at best. Overall, an okay experience but won't be rushing back. There are other great spots in the area worth checking out. read more

Ted's Montana Grill - Pickles - American Near Me - Indianapolis, Indiana

See all

I want to start by saying that my service here has always been amazing. My boyfriend introduced me to this spot and we first tried their burgers. The bison burger to be exact. This restaurant is 2 hours from us so when we are close by we stop in and order. We ordered the bison brisket and bison short rib. Both were not as expected. The brisket tasted more like pot roast, tasty just not what I think of when I think of a brisket. The short rib meal was good as well but the portion of short rib for what is priced Is what was disappointing. I was given 3 small short ribs. Amazing flavor just not what I expected I will definitely be back and stick to the burgers because they never let me down. Amazing service and clean establishment. read more

See all

We went at an odd time so the restaurant was empty! Made for a nice quiet experience. Had the canyon creek bison burger which was very tasty! I wasn't sure about the raspberry jam but it had a lot of flavor which was great on my burger. The broccoli wasn't steamed enough for me but some people like it crunchier. Not a lot of seasoning so it was kind of bland, but that's broccoli. My friends got a side chopped salad, kids burger, and knife and fork chili cheese burger. Overall everything was great! Next time I'm in the area I'll be back. Nice that they offer 50/50 onion rings and fries for those who can't decide! One person got this and there were 3 nice sized onion rings plus fries. read more

See all

I ordered the Cedar Plank Salmon and a dirty martini. The food was delicious and my drink was just right! The service was great. My server, Marieta was so nice and the GM Zane (sorry if I mispelled your name) was very welcoming! I will definitely be coming back to visit when I am in town! The restaurant was very clean, calm and just an overall nice place to enjoy my lunch. Thank you, Ted's Indianapolis Staff! read more

Ted's Montana Grill - Cedar Plank Salmon with Parmesan Roasted Broccoli Parmesan and Buttered Carrots - American Near Me - Indianapolis, Indiana

See all

Very nice restaurant kinda hidden in traders point area! I've come here twice e and each time the food is delicious. The servers are always well informed and accommodating. Gotta love the pickle starters!!! read more

See all

Great for our group of 24. We had 2 tables and a great time. Our servers, Tez and Scott, were wonderful and very accommodating. We had a holiday gift exchange. The food was delicious as always. The bison chili was a big hit! There was meat in every bite. read more

See all

The food was great. Service was great. Enjoy the evening. It's close to home and convenient read more

I have to shout out our server from last night. SHELBY was amazing. I was out for a girls night and she took such great care of us. She never made us feel like we need to rush or hurry as we were there for 3 hours. Food is always on point and if.you have a love of steaks I would check it out. read more

Great service and food! The cook did an excellent job preparing our food, we had the Red Rock Bison and Bison sliders...both were delicious! The strawberry shortcake was different but good. I personally loved the pickle cucumbers...my husband not so much. I would definitely come back to this place. read more

Ted's Montana Grill - Strawberry shortcake - American Near Me - Indianapolis, Indiana

See all

Food was delicious! Always is! Server Shelby is spot on from the beginning to the end! Great place for a great dinner, service, and atmosphere! read more

Good burger, but it was pretty expensive. It was really greasy and they only give you a cloth napkin. I could use have used extra napkins. I sat at the bar and it was dirty. Nobody was working behind the bar. It was a busy night and overall, the staff had a hard time keeping up. My server did a good job checking on me though. She was nice. read more

We stopped in for lunch! Food was amazing!! I had the meatloaf, it was delicious and very flavorful. Zane the GM was very polite. Our waitress was Andersyn, she was very attentive to our needs. We will definitely be back! read more

I have been only once but it was money well worth spending. I got a bison burger but it is much healthier for you.

Always a good time here. Good and service are excellent. Mr. Smith seems to run a really great staff here.

I love finding places that serve things out of the ordinary! And this place goes above and beyond for everything!!! Ambiance is like no other and Scott, my server, was nothing short of top notch! Will be sure to be back! read more

The food, service, and ambiance are amazing ! The server set this restaurant apart from any other. The waiter's attention to detail was superb. Scott ( the waiter) made dining more than just going to get dinner, it was truly an experience you must go try. We definitely we will be making this a regular dining experience. read more

Lance took great care of us, no complaints about the food - everyone's plate was pretty clean and even though it was noon - it wasn't very busy which was a bit surprising! read more

See all

Our experience at Ted's was top notch! The service was incredible (ask for Andersyn's section, she's literally the best & was so helpful/knowledgable!), food was delicious and cooked to perfection, the ambiance was romantic mixed with an at-home feeling, and the restaurant was super clean! Everyone was so friendly; being greeted by the GM (Zane) at the front door was super comforting, and we'll definitely be back! Don't think twice, make the reservation and check this place out! read more

Good customer service. Waitress had a good personality but forgot the to say no tomato on a salad. Food was rather bland. Also asked for no tomato on one of the salads (not pictured) which they remade and we still found a tomato on it. The excuse was it was mixed in the same bowl. Salad was inedible. The drinks were tasty but not strong. The burger was bland and dry. Had to season everything. They give you pickles when you arrive read more

See all

Went to Ted's on Saturday had the ribeye cook to perfection. Service was spot on. Five stars.

Visited twice and enjoyed the meal both times. Husband and our 6 guests also enjoyed their meals. The Avalon burger is amazing; I also enjoy the chunky mashed potatoes and gravy. The service is great. Their cherry lemonade is very good. The crab dip app was great as well; the fresh made tortilla chips are read more

Have eaten hear many times, (both this location in Indy & across the country) typically either before or after events at Pike High School on Indy's NW-side. Right off of I-465 on West 82nd street in the Trader's Point Center and right in front of the National FFA Offices and a couple blocks from Corteva Offices & Park100, so a great place for business lunches or drinks as well. Food is really good, the menu is diverse and the service is efficient. Lots of dark wood and an old fashioned saloon is the vibe. But the main attraction is the American-raised bison from one of many of Ted Turners vast ranches & land-preservation efforts. One of the first (and most prolific) farm to table efforts of which I am aware. Good fish as well. And don't miss the pickles to start or the desserts. Well-stocked bar, but we never did get Suavecito tequila in place, though. So stick to the bourbons & whiskeys! read more

Used to love it here. Food quality has dropped. Left recently due to a terrible sewage smell. Traders point used to be better!

Appetizers free ones, pickles, where different but good. Fresh cucumbers soaked in like a brine. Really refreshing on a hot day before you eat! Great steaks .. we got the beef ones ... (wish I would have gone for the Buffalo instead after eating the beef ones) cause the beef ones where cooked perfectly, salads too where fresh had the carrots with my steak had fries with other. All real good , had to be patient as they where busy, but staff was friendly and great !! We will be back !! Not overly pricey either ! read more

See all

Eh...evidently all Teds are not equal. Poor Bison Delmonico..almost half tuff or fat. Two less than stellar salads. Server was good...but this place won't last much longer with these prices and this quality. read more

Overall pretty good food and service. Wasn't blown away by anything but it's a good place for a quick meal. read more

Ted's Montana Grill - Cadillac Burger - American Near Me - Indianapolis, Indiana

See all

1 St time in a long time we decided to try this steak house. Greeted at door and given a table. ( My Choice ). Server was at table within minutes. No appetizers ordered just drinks. I requested an Old Fashion drink. They had a different name. It arrived quickly and was very tasty. Had a baseball size rounded ice cube. My wife had a Amaretto and Coke said it was tasty also. My friend had a drink he liked also did not get the name of it. My wife and I ordered the Beef Filet and onion rings. The Filets were cooked to order and tasty. The onion rings were excellent. Hand made seasoned well. My friend had a Hamburger with an egg he said it was cooked to order and tasty. Recommended by server. Seating was comfortable Place was clean and comfortable. read more

So, I'm struggling between a 3 star and a 4 star. Being the nice guy that I am, I'll give a 4 star with an explanation. The interior of the restaurant is definitely dated. We were seated promptly, they host was very welcoming. Our waitress was very nice, but very forgetful. Food came out wrong. Had to ask multiple times for water. There was about 20 minutes where she was just gone. The redeeming value of the meal was the bison filet, and the reason for the 4th star. Absolutely amazing steak. Cooked perfectly, very tender, tons of flavor. Bottom line: when you factor in the dated interior, the subpar service, and then add in the great steak, they're charging too much for their meals. read more

Always outstanding service, fresh ingredients for their hearty menu. The restaurant is located in a strip mall that is partially filled. Ted seems to be able to draw in a study group of regulars. The Montana themed brain child of Ted Turner features bison with a side of beef. The decor is upscale lodge with warm wood paneling. Tables are covered with brown paper maps of sky country and cloth red checkered napkins. Very boys club vibe. Today, we celebrated a retirement with a small group. Our server was excellent, attentive, and anticipated our needs. Signature pickled cucumbers greeted us at the table. Yum. So good. I ordered the Big Sky Salad with grilled chicken. As always, the salad was fresh, hearty and delicious with lots of thick cut bacon, avocado, boiled egg cheese and greens. The chicken was freshly grilled..so good. I cleaned my plate. Our sever took our photo to celebrate. He even moved us to a better lit location so we would have a good picture. That was 5 star service! Most lunch entrees run $13-15. They have a full service bar which I have not tried. They have some nice outdoor seating but I like the cozy inside. read more

Ted's Montana Grill - Big sky salad - American Near Me - Indianapolis, Indiana

I had never been to one of these before. I was pleasantly surprised. I was expecting some cheesy corporate steakhouse, but it didn't feel like that at all. It was more Ruth's Chris than Texas Roadhouse. Except for the prices. Very reasonable. I ordered the bison, as it is their specialty. It was very moist and tender which is a testament to the quality of the meat and the skill of the cook as it is so easy to overcook bison making it tough and dry. read more

Ted's Montana Grill - Complimentary pickles - American Near Me - Indianapolis, Indiana

Pretty disappointed in our return visit to Ted's. Moved away from the area in 2017, and just returned. Met for a family dinner at Ted's in the overall experience was less than satisfying. Two burgers, Caesar salad, and a steak, and one appetizer. Under 50 bucks with tip. The steak and the two burgers were barely warm. We were short on time so did not have time to ask for a new meal. When the best things at your table are the pickles and the chips and dip, somethings wrong. We had great experiences in the past, but this one will have us looking for other options. Update: I was asked to contact the manager, which I did, no response. Probably more disappointing, but not surprising read more

Poorly prepared food and cold Fries are a problem, No one checking to correct it makes it abysmal. My Dinner guest also complained on yelp and contacted Ted's and surprise surprise they did not reach back. read more

Their food is nothing short of amazing! Our waiter was excellent....funny, informative, professional! The atmosphere was relaxing! Highly recommend! read more

See all