We generally ordered Stromboli from this restaurant, but decided to try dinner. We ordered 2…read morelasagna dinners and an antipasto (total cost was $42.82, though we did have a $30 purchased coupon to redeem.) The lasagna portions were pretty small, weighing overall about 11 oz, which included the metal tray and sauce. The salad had lots of unappetizing brown lettuce, and one half of a thin slice of tomato. When we arrived home and looked at the food, we packed it up and returned to the restaurant. The counter person indicated that all the portions were like that, and remaking the food would result in duplicating what we already had. We said no, thanks, and asked to switch to something else - we were told it has to be the same thing ordered (they have a blurb in the restaurant, which says if you are not happy with your meal, bring back at least X% and get a redo), but apparently it has to be the same food. If you are going to give me exactly the same thing I was unhappy with, what sense does that make? The antipasto, which was $12.50 had brown lettuce on top/bottom, and had what amounts to maybe 1 slice of tomato. The only part of this salad that was correct was the "Anti". Customer service was interesting, too. The counter person, who was obviously not the one in charge, had to go speak to the 'manager' in back, at least a couple times. That person (not sure who it was) did not come out to speak to me. As a manager, you would expect the manager to address you directly. A refund was also not possible because the coupon itself could not be refunded, so our only option was the take the food. I asked for the owners' name, and was told they did not know who the owner was, but was given the Office # 570-970-0000. I called the next day and had to leave a message, gently explaining that I would like a call back to discuss a situation I experienced at the location I visited. I never received a call back. Had a received a call back and a resolution, perhaps this review would not have been necessary.

ordered 3pm told would arrive by 4pm. it actually arrived at 4:37. I live 2 miles away. almost 40…read moremin late for a cold greasy meatless dough thing with unmelted shredded cheese. see photos. $27 for this "cold mess"!

Pizza was amazing. I definitely recommend coming. Service was good and it was a nice environmentread more

The Stromboli is the best I've ever had. Joe is friendly and very personable. Can't beat his…read morespecials for taste and price.

Marty's seems to have been a firm family favorite and suggestion to others for....well, since I can…read moreremember. Seems like they've been open since the mid-80's, circa my start date as well. I can't really say it's a 'hidden gem' because it's notoriously mentioned in many circles as the "have you ever been to THIS place??" place, but people usually answer YES, with wide eyes and a few memorable dish notes. We went for a mid-week date night, and there was a constant flow of seemingly satisfied diners. The ambiance was warm and cozy, not too dimly lit but very deliberately paced with the huge portions they offer; the service was top-notch, friendly and knowledgeable, always checking back at the right times and knowing what we would need as guests. We ordered several of their suggestions with no reservations, and they delivered. My fiance still talks about that apple cider margarita and it's firmly on the list of not-too-hard-to-make restaurant favorites we roll out for our guests at home. The stuffed mushrooms had a ton of crab meat and far less breading than most, without being saturated or too heavy to start the meal. The salads are certainly slept on; neatly arranged but never the star when pitted up against their hearty steak or cajun offerings, their house salads are hard to beat, unless you're paying up for a meal-type salad. As good as those two items were, the scallops I had with their cracker-encrusted light breading were the epitome of simple, sauteed, buttery-by-nature seafood; they were the best version of scallops like that I've ever had. And the dessert...just perfect for so many reasons; crispy and gooey caramelized bananas, a good amount of vanilla ice cream and the best cinnamony syrup sauce that I couldn't stop lapping up. Really, a fantastic experience, we'll be back!

Fantastic great steaks and great chicken wings and salads ,pizza too…read more Service is good but they only allow a certain time per party

It's a nice addition to Nanticoke as a much needed restaurant. I hope it stays…read more The menu is a nice size with lots of options and some nice specials too. Meatball app was good Parm was good Marsala was good Shrimp were ok. A bit pricey for what you got. I was hoping for more lump crab in the stuffing and less deviled taste

GREAT DRINKS! GREAT FOOD! GREAT SERVICE!…read more Friendly staff and very accommodating! Has Bar Menu, Private Dining Room, Booths and High Tops. Also has a nice outdoor seating area!

Pickles are outta this world amazing!!! Salads, hoagies and more are delicious as well!!read more

Great food and service!! Hoagie trays and chili dogs, pierogi and haluski, salads are hugeread more

Amazing food and service. My regular orders are Veggie Quesadilla with a side of Arroz (Rice) and…read morebeans and I can never get bored of ordering it. Everything is freshly made, including the tortillas which amazes me. Folks are very courteous and always serve you with a smile. They get the food ready in less than 20 minutes. Free delivery in and around Nanticoke. Only thing is it's difficult to spot this place the first time. Parking spots could be improved. Price breakdown: $8 for quesadilla $5 for Arroz + Beans

They serve great food, they have nice variety of options on the menu and they provide friendly…read moreservice

My first time here and I doubt I'll be returning. I played it safe with a tuna salad sandwich and…read morefries. How can you screw that up, right? Well, I found out--there is a way. Everything was so over-the-top salty, there was no way I could enjoy it.

Small hometown atmosphere with amazing gyros, original and chicken. Tasty burger and crispy fries…read more Serves breakfast too.Never ever disappointed. Hidden gem in the Square in Nanticoke.

Fantastic wings and pizza. We've never had to wait for service . It's like a neighborhood party.read more

Food was mediocre at best and they also charge a 3% service charge if you use a card. instead of…read morebaking it in to their prices or sucking it up as a cost of doing business they tell you to bring cash. Chickenshit move on their part and it reflected on my tip. 3% surcharge means 5% less tip.

I and others in my family have patronized this restaurant for most of the 30 years that I lived…read morehere through the ownership changes. I hadn't been there in a while. I ended up spontaneously taking a few family members for dinner . It wasnt at all busy, 2 other couples besides us. The food was okay- meh, but the service definitely wasn't . Our server, an older woman with blonde hair was not just unfriendly, but clearly rude and irritable. It was unmistakable and noticed by everyone at our table . It was my grandson's first visit and he was reluctant to even ask for a drink refill. Normally I'd say "oh well, she's having a bad day" , except that she was quite jovial and super friendly to the people a few booths down whom she obviously knew. Curiously, close to the end of the meal- right before handing me the check- she suddenly warmed up quite a bit, offering to top off my hot drink etc. My family never says anything negative about servers but they wondered aloud if she was thinking about her tip. $70 I could have spent somewhere else for a more enjoyable experience. I wont go there again if she's working. Sorry not sorry.

Great homecooked food, and reasonable prices. Love their lobster tail dinner also liver and onions.read more

Small little place with a small/simple menu and nice people behind the counter and in the kitchen…read more Decent sized hoagie filled with steak and veggies. Good overall taste but the seeded bun takes over a bit. $12 for a cheesesteak, a small bag of chips, and a bottle of sprite. Just can't beat that these days.

OMG this place was amazing. The two ladies who were working were super nice and made two amazing…read moresandwiches. The bread was so soft and fresh. The Italian cold cut had delicious good quality meat and the cheesesteak sandwich hit the spot and one of the best I've had in awhile. All sandwiches came with chips and a drink, so great price and amazing sandwiches. It's kind of hard to find. I think it's in an old social hall and behind a bank that the now a cafe, so keep your eyes out so you don't miss it on the side of an old brick building.