We very much enjoyed their "indecision" multi course meal which was fabulous. Service was very friendly and prompt. Ambiance was comfortable and casual. We have also been there for breakfast on the patio which was great wake-up food. Happy tummies. read more

Located in the downtown area of Rapid City, this is a great spot to check out breakfast or lunch. I have been to this restaurant a couple of times and I have had the opportunity to enjoy both. This is definitely a hopping place during peak hours so be prepared to wait. I love the communal table which allows you to sit down and chat with neighbors. While the breakfast is very good, my last visit I had a bison curry soup that was off the charts one of the best soups I've ever had. I begged the Kitchen for the recipe, but they wouldn't budge! Services is great and pricing is good for an excellent meal. Highly recommend stopping into this downtown favorite. read more

See all

A superb restaurant right in the heart of downtown. Tally's Silver Spoon is an upper scale restaurant that not not shy away from a hearty menu. The setting was a little more formal than casual. There were parties where everyone was dressed nicely but we were a little more business casual and were fine. My wife and I were in town on a visit and decided to grab a late night dinner. We arrived when the restaurant was winding down so seating was not an issue (we were one of the last tables to leave). Our meal started with Cureiosity as an appetizer. This is a cornucopia of flavors with a hearty portion of pork belly. Layered with flavors of miso, ginger and candy this dish shocks the taste buds awake to prepare for the main dish. A good portion size to start but with the pork belly it can be a quick filler. For my main I chose the vegetarian option of parm to table. The name was what caught my eye but the description of mushrooms with feta cheese and parmesan mousse reeled me in and I was glad I made that choice. The dish was excellent with so much flavor and perfectly cooked mushrooms. This dish did not disappoint. My wife chose the Bison Maytag Marsala Mushroom which paired nicely with a cabernet sauvignon the waiter recommended. Again, no disappointment here. The dish was amazing and the bison was so tender it fell apart with a fork. Unfortunately, I do not get to this area often but when I return, Tally's will be my first stop. PS - reservations are highly recommended. read more

Tally's is a cute spot in Rapid City with yummy breakfast. I ordered the build your own omelet with Gouda, cheddar, onion, arugula & peppers. It came with a choice of toast and hash browns. The omelet was fluffy and full of the ingredients. The hash browns were nice and crispy and not greasy, which I appreciate. The sourdough toast was really good, just needed a little extra butter (IMHO). Our server was very attentive and nice. I'd go back for sure! read more

See all

Stopped in for late breakfast and the food is incredible! Had the veggie omelette and Miga breakfast bowl and was very good. The pancakes are great! The service was very good as well. Plenty of street parking and outside seating available. read more

Tally's Silver Spoon - Bar area - Desserts Near Me - Rapid City, South Dakota

Nice bar restaurant. Pub food but very good. Was a little hard to find. There's no sign outside. There were only seats at the bar. Everything was reserved. It was ok though. read more

In town on a Sunday and yelped for a place for lunch. 30 minute wait so we sat outside patiently. Noticed a couple walk in and get seated immediately and was confused. Asked the hostess why they were seated before us, she stated they wanted to eat outside. Of course that option was never given to us. We did mention to her that my husband needed to eat right away due to medical issue. We were finally seated and waiter took our order. My husband had a few questions and the waiter stated " are you from the north east". Don't think it was a compliment. Ordered ice tea never arrived had to request again. Waiter said sorry I forgot about it. I ordered the Cuban sandwich which was pretty good and tasty. My side was a fresh salad. My husband ordered a hamburger which was spot on. Served with seasoned fries well cooked. read more

See all

My review is based on lunch/brunch only, as I've never eaten here for dinner. 1. Wait times: They can get long, so I recommend arriving early and putting your name on the waitlist before you're actually ready to eat. We showed up very hungry once, and the 40-minute wait was a little painful. 2. Location/Parking: Downtown parking can be hit or miss. You might get lucky and find a spot right outside, but it's best to be prepared to park and walk. 3. Service: Service has always been great--no issues at all. 4. Drinks: We've ordered the mimosas several times and they've always been yummy. 5. Food (the most important part!): The food has consistently been excellent. I've tried both breakfast and lunch items--my favorite is the breakfast burrito--but the more traditional lunch sandwiches are also great. Everything has always been cooked well, and I've never had a bad experience. I will say Tally's is on the spendier side for a lunch spot, which is why I don't come here too often. That said, it's perfect for a nice brunch date or meeting up with the girls read more

Excellent Restaurant! Three of us had breakfast last Friday. My wife had the gluten free blueberry pancake, egg and bacon and loved it! I had the chicken fried steak and eggs and it was wonderful! Crunchy steak covered with a delicious milk gravy! So yummy! Our daughter had the duck confit breakfast and absolutely loved it until she tried the duck liver. To say the least, she was not a fan of the duck liver. Some people may love it, but next time she would ask the restaurant to save the liver for someone else who might appreciate it more than she would. She would gladly swap the liver for more duck meat though any day of the week! Wonderful atmosphere to spend the day eating and drinking in! Great place!! read more

See all

We stopped here for breakfast, and were not disappointed. The breakfast BLT was served open faced on fresh sourdough bread with Gouda cheese, crisp bacon, tomatoes, arugula and an egg cooked to order, drizzled with balsamic. The flavors and textures combine to create the perfect bite. If you're on your way through, stop and enjoy the downtown atmosphere and delicious food that is off the beaten track. read more

Tally's Silver Spoon - Breakfast BLT - Desserts Near Me - Rapid City, South Dakota

Tally's is my favorite breakfast place when I'm able to go out. They have the best eggs benedict and of course I don't go without getting a mimosa. My husband and I don't get away much especially for breakfast or brunch, but when we do, This is our top choice. read more

Tally's Silver Spoon - Desserts Near Me - Rapid City, South Dakota

See all

Food was very good. Service excellent and we liked the atmosphere. I had a chicken sandwich with a few add ons and fries. Liked the lemonade. Friend had breakfast. Place got busy but we got a table quickly. Not too hard to get parking nearby on a Sunday afternoon. read more

If you only have 1 meal in Rapid City, you must come here. We were here for dinner, lucky for us, there was one that just opened us. The menu looked fantastic, we couldn't decide what to have but then we saw "indecision menu". That peaked our interest and asked about it. We were told we get what the kitchen sends out. We love the idea of being surprised by the chefs. We tell our server our restrictions e.g. nuts, cheese etc and they take it from there. Some items the kitchen creates won't be in the menu or other dishes with some improv. I love this idea! It gives the chefs in the kitchen room to play and create. For us, it's a surprise - like Christmas morning! We chose the 4-course menu and my husband chose the wine pairing service. Our first course was a pulled pork bun - describing my meal does not do it justice. Second course was a salad with fried brie, fig, grapefruit wedge, tomatoes - not to be found on the menu. Third course was duck l'orange, the sear on the skin, the meat - so much flavor and so tender. Fourth course was a biscon steak with difference sauces but the star was the marrow butter! All the wines that were brought with each course complimented each dish perfectly. I have pictures of our meal, feast your eyes. read more

See all

We stopped for lunch and had the gf hot beef sandwich, gf alfredo, gf pancake special, and the chicken fried steak. Everything was delicious. The alfredo was especially good, you can taste the fresh garlic and the gf noodles were so good they were hard to tell the difference from conventional noodles. The sandwich was probably the best hot sandwich I have had in years. The gf pancake had good flavor but was a bit flat and chewy. Partner said the chicken fried steak was delicious. read more

See all

We stopped by for dinner and it was so good!! I wish I could go back! We walked in with 3 of us at 5pm but they were a lot of tables already reserved so I recommend making a reservation if you can. People working here are dressed up, but not to worry, there is no dress code. Most of people are tourists, just walking in with T-shirts and shorts. I had their burger and it was delicious. I highly recommend their sweet potato fries. The service was amazing and their breakfast menu looked good as well. The only thing was they serve juice from dispenser like continental breakfast....The food was very high quality, they should serve quality non-alcoholic drinks as well. read more

Food is average and pricey. When we came in no one greeted us. The hostess was not there. The waiters just look at us standing there but no acknowledgement whatsoever. The place is cramped. We were seated very close to the door, we felt the cold draft everytime people come in. read more

Tally's Silver Spoon - Buffalo Hanger Steak and eggs for $26. I ordered medium rare. My first time, will not order it again. - Desserts Near Me - Rapid City, South Dakota

We wanted a special dinner for our last night in South Dakota, but unfortunately, the experience fell flat. I ordered the $56 Trailblazer steak, which arrived cold after a long wait. There was no first-bite check from our server and in fact, I had to go inside and find the manager myself once my wife was halfway done with her meal. The manager did give a halfhearted apology and reluctantly offered to remake the dish, but at that point, the timing of our evening was already off. My wife had to leave with our kids before I finished eating, which made what was supposed to be a special dinner end with me eating alone while the waitress tried to hurry me out the door. The steak was reheated instead of remade, and nothing was comped or offered to make up for the poor pacing or cold food. The reheated steak ended up being medium instead of medium rare and the manager just kind of shrugged it off saying I thought that might happen. We still tipped and left a polite note, but for a high-end restaurant with a strong reputation, the lack of real service recovery was really surprising. The food itself was good, but sitting outside, we felt completely overlooked. Almost as if out-of-towners don't get the same level of service. If you're visiting Rapid City and hoping for a memorable dinner, you might be better off choosing a place that values all guests equally. read more

Our server Dawn was so sweet and attentive, we never had an empty water and she checked on us after tasting each course. Every bite was flavorful and fresh. Not too loud for a small dining room, we will definitely be back. Best meal we've had in rapid city in the two months we've lived here. read more

See all

This is a very clean restaurant. The hostess was friendly and let us know there would be a 15-minute wait, but we were seated in just 5 minutes. It's a busy place with plenty of seating. We were served by the bartender, Rich, who was professional, attentive, and remembered our orders without writing anything down. He definitely deserves a raise! He managed tables and the bar with ease. The only downside was that the restaurant seemed understaffed. It took about 10 minutes to get someone's attention for the check and to go boxes. Other than that, we had a great experience and would definitely come back. read more

See all

First thing - Note that they charge a bogus 3.5% "Living Wage" surcharge. My normal tip was lowered by 3.5% due to this. These charges should be disclosed verbally by the host/hostess instead of being buried in a size 2 font on the menu. Now on to the review Note that it is a relatively small restaurant, so expect there to be a wait during high traffic times. We were lucky and were seated with no wait on a Saturday for breakfast. Service was excellent and our waiter was very attentive. The food was excellent and serving sizes were slightly more than I expected. The Special Breakfast (aka Tally's Original) is a great deal for breakfast, coming in at under $10. I opted for the Omelette and was not disappointed. 5 "toppings", hash browns, and a muffin/toast for $20. Not too bad. I was pleasantly surprised that the muffin was split, buttered and grilled. It was awesome! Highly suggest you give them a try. I would give them 5 stars if they didn't try to slam you with the bogus living wage surcharge. read more

Tally's Silver Spoon - Special Breakfast (aka Tally's Original) - Desserts Near Me - Rapid City, South Dakota

See all

I was looking forward to dining here I have passed on my way to speed goat coffee (the best). I stopped in at 4:45 and the place was empty. But between the 6 outside and all the tables inside with nobody sitting at them and they couldn't find one for me. I've traveled the world and I know when I am being snubbed, it's simple, the don't want to sit one person at he able. My only option was to sit at the bar but I don't drink and I don't want a bunch of spit in my food while every is getting drunk. So FU silver spoon, not about the food all about me he money, you suck read more

We had dinner here this time and we were not disappointed. I had a cup of potato leek soup and a Sprig salad. Both were excellent and the salad tasted even better than I expected from the description. My husband enjoyed his Grandpa Dick burger very much, it was a generous beef patty and well prepared. read more

This place is amazing! Was here in 2022 and so impressed that Rapid City could have a chef's restaurant that rivals a big city. And it does, so I returned. This trip was a solo outing to try Tallys again, and I was more impressed than before. My server was very knowledgeable about both the food and wines for the "indecisive menu," also known as the chef's choice -- even her pick for a Pinot Noir as the first wine was successful. The foods were amazing. I am not much for dishes with many strong or dominating flavors all at once (like a pizza with pepperoni, sausage, ham, hamburger, pineapple, olives, peppers, etc.... how can you taste this???), but the chef used them well to make this work (cayenne with ricotta and fennel on a salad). These flavors did not overpower each other and created a balanced experience. The only item I was not satisfied with was the bread with butter, orange, and rhubarb dipper. Rhubarb was missing. The multiple dinner courses were excellent. I only wish I could have eaten them all - the portions were quite generous for a five-course meal. I chose the wine pairing - which was worth it. My server, Palina, knew her stuff and could explain each one. Love this. I recommend all to go. Many may not think of Rapid City, South Dakota, as a foodie destination. And I might agree. But Tally's is a contender. Go! read more

After so many wonderful meals, I chose to bring an out-of-town guest and both of us concluded it was the worst meal we had had in months. Waiting over 45 minutes for breakfast, only to receive utterly cold and inedible food is not a good way to start your day. It didn't help that the server, rather than apologizing or being somewhat empathetic, threw the kitchen staff under the bus and blamed it on a shift change. The one good thing that happened was the bearded gentleman that is regularly there, who in the end was able to partially make it right. He is an excellent example of how all employees should be. read more

Food was fine, pancakes were really good but disappointed that I couldn't exchange the meat in my dish for hash browns without there being a surcharge. Mimosas were pre mixed so no ability to control the amount of orange juice. Only had almond milk for alternative milks. read more

Good place for a Sunday brunch. We ordered the avocado toast with poached eggs, the berry filled crepes, and the meat lovers (sausage, bacon, eggs, and hashbrowns). Everything was pretty good standard breakfast fare, except for the hashbrowns. The hashbrowns were really bad. They had the texture of a stale cracker and no salt. Pretty much inedible. Everyone else at the table liked what they ordered though. The service was great; our waiter was super nice and very good at his job. read more

We're from out of state and picked Tally's for breakfast. The meal was fantastic! And it was even better because of our server (Noah) at the bar. I'd highly recommend giving it a try, and if Noah is working requested him. It was a great experience. read more

I came here for lunch and ordered Bison Maytag Marsala Mushroom. It was delicious. The portion was big and tasty. The meat was tender. I also ordered a side salad since I love to eat noodles with salad. The restaurant was clean and wasn't too noisy. Service was quick and attentive. The waitress was very kind, friendly, and has sense of humour. I stayed in the hotel next to it so I didn't pay for parking. But if you drive, you will need to pay to park. No surprised since it's downtown. I would love to come back. read more

See all

I like Tallys, although last visit was not good. I had the smoked salmon Benedict. Not Good. English muffin was bland starchy and dry like a biscuit. Hash browns were lifeless, dry, and cold. $24 bucks not well spent plus $5 coffee and 3.5% wage surcharge. hmmmm Service was good. Nice ambiance. I hope mgmt. reviews and takes corrective action. read more

Quality food. They have great pancakes and a fantastic lox plate. Hashbrowns are solid.

The food was fantastic and so was the service!!! I sat on the outside patio with my small dog. Very dog friendly here. I was visiting from out of state and was only here for one night and I'm so pleased that I picked this amazing restaurant for early pre-dinner tapas/beer and then I hung around and had dinner afterwards. read more

See all

We needed a hearty breakfast for a long day exploring the area and Tally's solved the problem. Our waiter was nice and attentive. The food was very good and the portions were large - I think I had hash browns for 3 but I ate them all! read more

See all

Food was amazing! Friendly staff - Gage was supper cool, knowledgeable about everything on the menu and more! Best dessert ever! read more

Tally's Silver Spoon - Dessert at Talley's! - Desserts Near Me - Rapid City, South Dakota

Was very obnoxious person talking on phone asked waiter to have them stop ruined breakfast and fo5 was awful not a place to eat over priced for amount of food as well not recommended read more

We are in town for a few days on a cross country trip. Tally's was recommended to us by a friend and we stopped in for a Monday night dinner. We were served by our waitress Sam, who gave us one of the best dining experiences we've had all year. We got the pork belly with the "condensed pear" appetizer...incredible. I got the Bison Marsala which was probably one of the most unique pasta dishes I have ever gotten in a restaurant. If you're in the mood for a hearty plate of pasta, don't pass it up. The restaurant was super homey and had a great vibe despite a slower Monday. If you're in Rapid City make sure you stop in, this is an awesome spot. Thanks Sam for being such a great server and having such great recs! read more

Tally's Silver Spoon - Farm to Table Vegitarian Dish and Buffalo Marsala Pasta Dish - Desserts Near Me - Rapid City, South Dakota

See all

I wish I had pictures, but we ate so quick I didn't get any. Visiting from out of town And it was so good that we came back the next day for breakfast. I had the salmon plate and the eggs Benedict. Our table also love the pancakes. Only negative feedback I got from our crowd was not enough gravy on the biscuits, but we're from Georgia. read more

Ate at the bar during the last day of Sturgis bike week in 2024! This place is my kind of place. It was a refreshing change from all the other places. I had the eggs Benedict breakfast, phenomenal. We sat at the bas as they were very busy but had great service. read more

I love coffee and I was blown away by their coffee. I have lived and traveled all over the world and I would recommend going to Tally's just for the coffee. Their eggs Benedict is pretty wonderful too. read more

Their pancakes are the best, but got the migas breakfast. I was severely disappointed. Had no flavor at all. How do you have chorizo in it and not have flavor??? read more

Tally's has really set a standard for the downtown. Although a few years ago, the consistency seamed to be amiss for a period of time, the past several visits have been outstanding. Your customer service and attention to detail with quality food, makes Tally's a frequent favorite! read more