First time trying this place, it did not disappoint! Alanna was super helpful, she recommended their Prostitini(ham baked in a black pepper crust) and even gave me a slice to sample, it was delicious. And she recommended the #11 "rogue style" which I will definitely get again. This is my go to sandwich place from now on, and Alanna had some great customer service skills. read more

Employees were amazing !!! We were going to dine it however the temp inside the store felt like it was approx 80 degrees . I would refuse to work in that heat, I feel horrible for those workers.. Boardwalk ....Turn your air on for your employees and customers . Extremely uncomfortable read more

We came in this evening after a long day of traveling and didn't know what to get. The lovely girl behind the counter was super helpful and even let us try a slice of meat we had never heard of. She convinced us to get number 11 and make it a rouge. Super grateful for her suggestions and kind guest service. I wish I was in town longer so I could go back. read more

Tallarico's Boardwalk Subs - Sandwiches Near Me - Wyoming, Michigan

See all

Just want to start off with the food was great and place was clean! Only thing that can be improved is for the employees Grace and Kyle to be more kind to the new kid that was making my subs. He was doing everything just fine fulfilling our order but he was still learning so he was a little slower ( which is COMPLETELY fine since he's learning ). I ordered a #24 minus one if the meats and Kyle came storming up from doing dishes, pushed the new kid out of the way and started cutting the meat I didn't want on my sub trying to micromanage the new kid but just looked like an idiot because he had no idea what I had even asked for. Then Kyle proceeded to yell at the kid and push him out of the way when just my husband and I were in the restaurant. (Also all while Grace was sitting on her phone on the counter in the back). I apologize for this being a long review but it's really sad to see this happen to someone who is willingly trying and who is obviously new and not just being lazy. Moral of the story I understand that new kids can be annoying (trust me I get it, my cousin owns a big franchise) but give the kid some grace, it's not that hard to just be kind! 12-12-25 about 8:15pm read more

I've never eaten here before yesterday. I was so happy with the rouge chicken bacon sub. Everything was fresh and the place was very clean. A few ppl who were in the dining area but it was so quiet. Sign of great food! The guys were so helpful in helping me understand the menu item. Great place! read more

Honestly incredible food and even better customer service. We loved our interactions and were given free samples of their house meat and recommendations out the wazoo. Subs are huge and we ordered full subs - we'll be eating these for several meals. We chose to go rogue and that definitely upped the sandwich to another level. Very sad we don't live around here or we would be regulars! read more

Tallarico's Boardwalk Subs - Number #14. Turkey, Salami and Cheese - Sandwiches Near Me - Wyoming, Michigan

Good subs! Great bread and they slice all the meat and cheese fresh for you when you order. Highly recommend getting your sub "rouge style" which takes it up a notch. I personally love the Italian sub and haven't been disappointed. My only complaint is they don't have a BLT sub or cucumbers. Highly recommend though. Nice friendly vibe. The service has always been good and the sandwiches have always prepared well in my experience. Way better quality than "regular chain" sub shop. I've tried various locations, and the food has been consistently good. Give them a try! read more

alway loved their subs, spent 80 bucks worth for a family gathering,,. no sides in a plastic container,, ok!! Won't ever be back!!

This place is terrible, i don't understand the 4 star review. Terrible doughy bread, and garbage deli meats. Pass and go to Jersey mikes.

I thought the reviews were great and gave the place a shot, holy hell!!!!! The best damm sub I ever ate!!!! Hands down, bar none. I loved it so much I had it for dinner 2 nights in a row! And I recommend going ROUGE version highly I mean stratospherically high! I travel around and love a good sub, but after this one......... nothing will compare and I feel I will have none meet or exceed it's quality or taste. Like the old saying goes "When Alexander saw the breadth of his domain, he wept, for there were no more worlds to conquer." Plutarch. Did you ever feel like Alexander the Great, after you reached a goal in life and saw no new one? And I feel like Alexander for the place is 3 hours away drive time one way. And I can never find that in my area, so as I close out this review with tears forming in my eyes, if your travels takes you to Grand Rapids, Michigan, like Shia LaBeouf stated so eloquently" Just Do It"!!!!!!! The #19 With pickles and tomatoes ,light lettuce and have it made ROUGE!! I guarantee you will love it! read more

Tallarico's Boardwalk Subs - The best sub in the world!!!! - Sandwiches Near Me - Wyoming, Michigan

*Note: The following review is from a pre-COVID-19 visit; however they are still open during the stay at home order for curbside pickup and delivery via Uber Eats and Grub Hub. I tried a small sample of a Boardwalk sub during the Uptown Shop Hop this winter and loved it! They had coupons out for a buy one sandwich combo, get one sandwich free, so my boyfriend and I went to this location to grab lunch. Walking in, you order at the left of the counter and watch as they build your sandwich with fresh ingredients. We were asked if it was our first time in and the girl making sandwiches gave us some samples of their capicola and prostitini! She was super helpful and polite. I ordered the #8, which is their most popular sandwich and comes with ham, capicola, salami, prostitini, pepperoni & cheese. My boyfriend got the Italian (#4): Ham, capicola, salami & cheese. You can choose white or wheat bread, and then you can get it toasted, untoasted, or Rogue style, which is where they flip the bread inside out, add a special blend of oil and spices to it, and grill it to perfection. We both opted for Rogue style. Once it's toasted you can add veggies, sauces, and spices. They have lots of great mayo options including chipotle mayo, roasted bell pepper mayo, and roasted garlic mayo! I added spinach, tomato, banana pepper, and roasted garlic mayo to mine. The sandwiches are MASSIVE 18" subs - definitely enough to split (and we got TWO because of the coupon). We got our order to go and they cut the sandwiches into halves, wrapped one half in paper and plastic wrap, and then cut the other half into three pieces. This is so genius and wonderful as it made it super convenient to save half for later. Everyone working at Boardwalk Subs was super friendly and polite and it was clear to me how they have won the Celebrated Service award in the past. The sandwich had great flavor and wasn't too messy to eat. All the toppings were as fresh as you can get and really delicious. I would definitely go back and split a sandwich next time. read more

Tallarico's Boardwalk Subs - #8 rogue style (half of the 18") - Sandwiches Near Me - Wyoming, Michigan

Their subs are the best. Fresh. Tasty condiments. The pickles are so good!! Just go. Eat subs. Be happy.

One of the better sandwiches I've had in Grand Rapids area! I would HIGHLY recommend getting the sub 'rogue' style where they turn the buns upside down, season it with spices and Parmesan and toast it, extremely tasty! One thing you should know is that a normal sub is 15 inches so unless you have an non-human like appetite, would suggest getting a half or splitting it with someone. I got the #8 which I was told is by far the most popular sandwich and was not disappointed! It's a little out of the way for me but would definitely recommend if you're in the area! Super friendly workers as well so if you're not sure what to order, then just ask!! read more

Tallarico's Boardwalk Subs - #8 (Rogue style) - Sandwiches Near Me - Wyoming, Michigan

Let me say this... The rogue style warm subs are excellent. If you haven't tried them, pop in and check them out. We picked up 3 subs for dinner recently and the warm, flavorful buns were delicious. The meat, cheese and veggies were solid and make for a great meal. I'll definitely be back. Going to try the "everything" next time. A+ folks. We truly enjoyed your subs. read more

Great sub! Rogue style all the way! I had the #8. The three ladies working offered up several suggestions and sampled a couple meats. The nailed it. This place is going in my phone for the next time I'm in Grand Rapids. Thanks ladies! read more

I often visit this location as it is near my place of work. Lately, I've been disappointed in the quality of turkey they are using. I am almost alway ordering between the #10, #11, and #13. Recently, the turkey on those sandwiches is dry, chewy, and clearly includes artificial coloring. This never used to be the case about 6 months ago. Please fix this! Or talk to your supplier about the quality of turkey they are selling you. read more

Tallarico's Boardwalk Subs - Pieces of turkey I couldn't choke down. - Sandwiches Near Me - Wyoming, Michigan

My favorite sub place ! You can not go wrong. I have ordered party platters for a bunch of my client lunches and they all rave about the subs! Jim johns who? read more

This is hands down the worst place to get a sub. While they are normally good subs, the first two times we tried Boardwalk, there was ONE person in front of us. We each ordered two things the first time, 2.5 the 2nd. It took THIRTY MINUTES each time, & both times the staff was SO confused. If you ask for something different than what's on the menu (I wanted Turkey instead of ham) it turns into an impossible job for the staff...we decided to give it one more shot since the subs are good, so this time we ordered over the phone for pick up. My husband made sure to tell them multiple times I wanted TURKEY instead of HAM...guess what I got on my sub. Yup! HAM....we have given this place THREE tries and every time have been disappointed. We are done with Boardwalk Subs-at least this location. Get employees that can actually take an order...and make a sub in less than 30 minutes...ridiculous. read more

Tallarico's Boardwalk Subs - Asked for Turkey instead of ham...got ham... - Sandwiches Near Me - Wyoming, Michigan

Excellent subs! So good, wide variety. Affordable, high quality, great value. Staff is friendly and fast. Was there during a lunch rush and they have an efficient process for getting all the orders completed. read more

I'm going to give them the benefit of the doubt that it was because we showed up 20 minutes before closing. My sub, #15, usually comes loaded with my choice of veggie toppings. I ordered lettuce, spinach, onion, black olives & jalapeno. I usually get tomato too, but they were out. Get home to find basically a cheese & lettuce sub (see picture). My husband's #4 was also very skimpy on the toppings, besides the meat. Very disappointed in the 45min. round trip we took to get these subs. read more

Tallarico's Boardwalk Subs - #14 with little to no toppings. Ordered 5 different veggies, can you spot anything but lettuce & spinach? - Sandwiches Near Me - Wyoming, Michigan

Always the best! You can not go wrong with the subs & even the soups! When ever we go to my husbands hometown we stop here to get some yummy sandwich's! I recommend the all! Pizza sub, Turkey Sub! White chili soup! All of it!!!!!! Get your sub on! read more

Since the owner never called me, in which could be because he never got the message, guess I gotta put it on here! Few months back had a run in with the long blonde haired kid /ass hat that's works at this location! Long story short I called for a pick up at about 20min before close one night said punk answered the phone and tells me they are closing I said you got 20minutes and I'm 5 minutes away not even he proceeds to tell me it's 10 to in which I replied no it's 20 to then he says "what do you want" in an extremely pissy manner I reply a chicken sub and click....... nowI'm pissed, I call back he answers I say you hung up on me "yeah you told me what you wanted" he says..... I respond well don't I get to add toppings!?!?!? Again pissy he says "ok" complete the order hang up at this point I'm in the parking lot walking in I walk in and ask was that you on the phone he said "yup" I tell him he shouldn't act like an asshole to his guests and he then proceeds to argue with me and blame the whole situation on me !!!! So that's the quick version of that when I left I said I'd never go back next day called left message for owner to call me never receive a call from manager or owner not a soul..... Fast forward to today I thought ok I'll give them a chance again........ boy was I wrong!!!! Walk in after ordering on phone and bam same ass hat there no issue or argument though someone else cashed me out he was making subs and that is the issue when I get home....... look at pictures !! This ass hat didn't look my way or nothing but now I know why he thinks he's slick ..... Hope your reading this management that kid is an complete ass I hope he reads it to if your employees can't handle making a sandwich maybe you need new employees it's not exactly rocket science!!!!!!!!!! read more

Tallarico's Boardwalk Subs - Butt ends of tomato !?!? So now we are an asshat and a little punk and a coward!!!!!! - Sandwiches Near Me - Wyoming, Michigan

Stopped by for a quick/late lunch on our way through town with my daughter. This is a small place in a non-descript strip mall and a very bland/plain interior, definitely nothing special to look at. However, the service and food were excellent! We were offered samples of their various meats and even told about how they were made (I definitely recommend the capicola, it had just the right spice/kick). The subs were very large (15"), fresh, with really good bread and the meat/cheese were great! Positives: Really good meat, cheese and bread. Excellent service and value. Negatives: Nothing really. (decor if anything) read more

Tallarico's Boardwalk Subs - Enjoying our lunch. - Sandwiches Near Me - Wyoming, Michigan

By far one of the top 3 subs I have ever had. I went with a #7 rogue style and I will be back to grab another soon! Be aware this place is very busy during lunch, but very worth the wait if you have time! read more

Great sandwich. They have a new way of toasting sandwiches panini style which is awesome. They call it rogue style or something like that. The outside was toasty and delicious. read more

Tallarico's Boardwalk Subs - French dip rogue style - Sandwiches Near Me - Wyoming, Michigan

Boardwalk Subs has been my go-to sub shop for years now. Their quality of freshly cut meat is top notch. The owner works often with the crew and his energy is contagious amongst the other workers. I have driven far out of my way to get a sub from there. Ask to have your sub "toasted rogue". You won't be disappointed! read more

Great food for a great price. They have top notch customer service!! Even with the Pandemic we are all dealing with, they bring your order right to your car. read more

Great subs great price. Some of the best subs in GR. Great ingredients and they slice everything, meats and cheeses, right there in front of you deli style which strangely makes the sandwiches taste better. read more

OMG best sub I've ever had! Toasted chicken fajita, mmmmm. First time ever the white chicken chili was as good as mine. Well organized menu. Very busy, but line moves fast. Great customer service, everyone was very friendly. I wish this was near my house I'd eat here all the time. read more

I had heard about this place for years, and recently started going there for dinner pretty frequently, their cold-cut subs hit the spot when it's hot out and don't want something heavy. They slice the meat and cheese right in front of you onto the sub, then top it with whatever veggies and sauces you'd like. I personally recommend the Turkey and Prostitini sub with cheese(provolone) it's huge, roughly 1/4 wider and longer than a subway sub. With a large drink it's about 10 bucks, but it's completely worth it. Sure you can get cheaper foot long subs, but well, they're cheaper for a reason. read more

Tallarico's Boardwalk Subs - Sandwiches Near Me - Wyoming, Michigan

Great freshly made sandwiches. Interesting fresh ingredients. Great service too. They have some kind of Italian Hamthat makes a great topping and adds lots of flavor. I would definitely recommend this over subway or other chains. read more

Great service! Perfect sandwich!! The proportions were absolutely perfect and delicious! read more

Tallarico's Boardwalk Subs - Toasted roast beef yumm - Sandwiches Near Me - Wyoming, Michigan

See all

A great sub, there so big 3 feeds five with left overs. There are not cheap no 5 dollar footling here , but you get what you pay for. Sweet staff that goes the extra mile. If I had one compliant I have thought it was a little dirty for time to time and I did pull my hand in something sticky on the counter once. Still the subs are out of this world. read more

They slice your meat in front of you (but it's not gross like Blimpie Sub meat). Slice your cheese, fresh bread. The toppings are not many, but they have all my favorites and can be generous with them. My favorite is turkey and salami with extra pickles, olives, lettuce and onion. Then it's a toss up between mayo and honey mustard or mayo with vinegar and oil. Both very delicious. Like all sub places they offer soups, which are nothing special; chips and cookies which are something special!! They also offer a punch card which is a nice reward for being a loyal customer. Try it! You won't be sorry!! read more

What used to be the best subs in town is now mediocre. Longest wait ever and two people in front of us--and they were together. Literally in the place half an hour. Meat is scarce, extra means nothing even if you pay. Wish it was good again. read more

After a few hours of shopping at the new outlet mall we came here for some grubbing. This is a great place for sandwiches. I like how they cut them up in thirds and sometimes in sixths if you get the whole damn 15 inch sandwich like my father and I did each. Yep, to top it off we got the everything sandwich. He got his with the Italian dressing and I got mine dressed with the chipotle mayo, but it wasn't as spicy as I would have liked it to be. My dad and I did do a pretty good job of finishing 4 out of the 6 parts of the sandwich, and then I had the rest for breakfast and it was still good! I was pretty impressed with the white chili my mom had too. I noticed she finished the whole cup. The service was pretty friendly and the prices were reasonable. read more

Been here a couple times now and had great service and quality food. Bread was fresh and soft, veggies were good, sauces flavorful. The inside is dated and not welcoming and I feel like it's a little overpriced. But all in all a good subplace since jersey giant isn't in Gr yet. read more

Always happy with a great sub! Lots of different combinations available. It would be nice if there was more than one cheese. The location can be difficult to navigate, especially during the lunch rush, and typical rush hour. Staff does an excellent job of managing the lunch lines. It was crowded, but totally worth the wait. read more

Great subs, freshly made. Owner gave us some samples of the sliced meats while we made up our mind on what to order. Come hungry, these are huge. Friendly staff. Will definitely hit this place again. read more

First time here, ladies behind the counter were super helpful. All the cheese and meats sliced fresh with each sandwich. Not your cheap subway sandwiches, and worth the few extra coins. read more