I arrived at Table 23 Tally at approximately 5p.m. to relax after a long week of work. I was having a good time with my family & friends, eating appetizers before ordering entrees. A hostess approaches our table saying they have a reservation & if we can be done by 7:45, that would be great and allow them to accommodate their reservations. We were never told upon being seated that we needed to be up at a certain time. My party was still ordering drinks & had not yet ordered entrees. One person from my party approached the hostess regarding the request and was told that if we did honor their request we would be comped a round of drinks. Her mere assumption that we would be moved to vacate for something for free is problematic in itself. But adding further insult, we were the only party ask to leave, when other tables arrived at the same time as us, but were never approached. The hostesses also ask our waiter to get us to leave. I would never assume a person was racially profiling me, but this would fall into those parameters. When I ask the manager to handle the situation he brushed it over and in attempt to identify with my being black, he asserted his European heritage. While I could've given him a whole history lesson on Europe and Africa, i didn't have the intellectual head to even go there. I am professional in this city who has supported local businesses. We want to see our city thrive and continue to have spaces to relax and unwind, but what I will not be disrespected. The saying still reigns true, support those who support you. Research where you invest your dollar read more

The food was 10/10! The server, Perkins, was amazing and even stopped to talk about football with me. And just the overall vibe was wonderful. If you are visiting Tallahassee definitely recommend. read more

Table 23 has to be my favorite 'Sunday Brunch' spot in Tallahassee. The patio area makes you feel as if you're not even in Tallahassee. The atmosphere is always great. Don't get me started on the menu. They serve everything from Gouda Cheese Grits to Fried Oysters. There is such a variety, a wide range of menu options. My personal favorite is the Chicken && Waffles. They're served with Blueberry Sriracha Syrup. You have the option of getting regular old maple syrup but, who wants that! The Blueberry Sriracha really sets it off. If you haven't been to Table 23 for Sunday Brunch you've been missing out. I can't forget to mention the Bottomless Mimosas for $13!!!!! read more

Table 23 - New American Near Me - Tallahassee, Florida

See all

Very impressed with this restaurant! Friends and I went for brunch on a Sunday. The wait was pretty long but we ended up catching seats at the bar and ordering there. I ordered a Rosè Sangria, the Peach Cobbler French Toast and a side of bacon. Everything I had was amazing and unique to this restaurant, which I appreciated. Great atmosphere for a Sunday brunch! Especially since it's warming up. I'd definitely recommend and will visit again when I'm in town. read more

See all

Love this place, always top notch service and better food. Need more places like Table 23.

The food and the service is great the drinks are great great place to eat at Local and beautiful in Tallahassee

Loved all the food here, but the tuna and fig starter was our fave, just wish there was more of it! We also had the redfish, the trout, and the meatloaf. The cocktails were delish, and the banana pudding dessert was yummy! Great service from a very nice college student named Perkins! Only complaint would be the lighting is too bright, needs to be toned down a bit. Will be back though! read more

See all

What didn't we order???? The shrimp n grits was just as amazing as the redfish. And the bacon wrapped meatloaf with mashed potatoes read more

See all

Found this gem on yelp. We're in town for a business trip and I was looking for something I couldn't get back home. This was a perfect choice! All of the staff were really friendly and welcoming. The vibe is kind of modern farmhouse gastropub, with great lighting and art. We started with the ceviche, the fried oysters and pickles, and cheese curds. We ate them all before I remembered to take pictures. The buffalo sauce with the cheese curds was sooo good. I had the shrimp and grits (no mushrooms) with a side of tots for dinner. Hands down the best grits I've ever had. Tots were crispy and good. My coworker had the burger and added bacon. Nothing was left when we were done. Highly recommend this place. You won't regret it! read more

Table 23 - Shrimp and grits - New American Near Me - Tallahassee, Florida

See all

Three stars because I had a one star experience that was removed from Yelp because I was too "mean". Second time I received five star service. It's all in the matter of attitude. You cannot have a nasty and rude bartender when their number one job is customer service. EXTREMELY rude and I'm pulling the race card here because it was absolutely intentional. My husband is black and I am white and we received completely opposite service from the all-white couple who spoke to her immediately after us with whom she was very polite. Terrible impression for our first time there on our anniversary which was almost ruined had it not been for Midtown Caboose as a second choice. Second time, the manager on duty accommodated a very important work dinner for me and even bumped off a regular high roller who had our desired table. I'll be back but I will steer clear of that bartender. read more

Every time I come back I leave even happier! The boiled peanuts are a must! I love the Grouper, it was so soft and so flavorful! We had awesome service and our big party was well taken care of! Always recommend eating here!! read more

Table 23 probably has one of the best Happy Hour specials in Tallahassee because 1) it's all the time! And 2) great wines/cocktails are discounted. For the most part I visit for their drinks and sometimes have appetizers. The complimentary bread rolls they give you are delicious if fresh and warm (only once has the butter been basically frozen so unusable). Otherwise the pimento cheese and guacamole, fried green tomatoes, fried pickles, Gorgonzola chips and the egg rolls with chicken have all been great appetizers to go with my drinks. Service is also usually very good, but they do get busy and it's understandable wait times may be longer on those days. I'll definitely be back. read more

Table 23 - Pimento cheese & Guac with Tortilla chips - New American Near Me - Tallahassee, Florida

See all

This place is good and bad at the same time. Like something on your plate will be good, and something else on your plate is gonna taste like garbage. Brunch is okay, but I will say the charcuterie is pretty decent. But as far as dinner goes, I wouldn't suggest anything other than appetizers for the price point. The ribeye here is fatty and not worth the price to me, and I actually like fat. But this place will have you leaving like, okay that was decent, but you will ask yourself "but was it worth it?" read more

This was the first stop we made when my family arrived in Tallahassee, and it DID NOT DISAPPOINT!!! Everything we ordered was fantastic! Don't pass up the chance to go here! The staff was friendly and had great recommendations! I'll be back to try more things on the menu! read more

Came to this place on my 30th birthday because it looked really nice. The atmosphere was great sitting outside with the lights and the heaters. The food and service left much to be desired though. I'm a big fan of grouper, so I was excited to see they had a grouper entrée. The grouper was not good at all (not sure how you can screw up grouper with crab on top, but they did), and the squash was completely undercooked. I let the waiter know, and he was like "well that is very disappointing to hear. Can I get you a desert?" The guy had the skill of a chili's waiter. BTW no free dessert on your Bday also. While the place looks nice, it's very expensive for the quality of food and service you receive. They also have no free parking. They have a parking lot but it valet only. If you are looking for a good nice place to eat, I would recommend Harrys'. They are $10 cheaper per entrée and the food and service are much better. Also Harry's only costs like $1 to park vs expensive valet here. I prefer places that focus on the food and customer experience, rather than places that try to nickle and dime you. read more

Great food and super bar area. Don't go here if you're looking for a "clean and healthy" meal - this is the place to use your fat grams but worth it. read more

Even though it was graduation weekend we were able to walk in around 4:30 Saturday and be seated within 15 minutes. Menu was limited and they were out of several items. The coffee rubbed steak was tender and flavorful. The appetizers came out fairly quickly but our main course took a little longer than expected. Everyone in our party was pleased with their food. The large windows make it feel like you are dining al fresco and there is a lovely patio area with spots to take pictures. My daughter was graduating so it's unlikely I'll return however would definitely go back again if we're in the area. read more

So excited to try this place, since 23 is my favorite number! Fun atmosphere, great food options, and perfect for the birthday event I attended! My only grievance is the tables were too close, and patrons were back to back, making social distancing impossible! Looking forward to trying something else from the menu soon! read more

Table 23 - Hashtags Peach Cobbler French Toast Brunch - New American Near Me - Tallahassee, Florida

We were kindly greeted by the valets upon arriving and found our way inside. We made reservations and were seated as soon as we arrived. The dining area we sat in was nice and with the windows you could see outside to the porch area. The meatloaf was very delicious, as was the 23 Burger. read more

I'm literally drooling thinking about this place. Everything here is DELICIOUS. I've been a few times and I always get the gulf grouper which is absolutely unreal. The shrimp and grits is also great! The drinks are really yummy too, I love the pomegranate martini. You seriously can't go wrong ordering anything here. A little more expensive than other restaurants in Tallahassee, but it's definitely worth it! read more

I tried lunch. I had the salmon with truffled tots, my two dates both had the fried catfish, cheese grits and truffled tots. We started with an appetizer of fries green tomatoes with a remoulade, the tomato was ripe and firm with a great seasoned breading. The remoulade, thankfully! was not overly mayo, it tasted really good with the fresh tomato. Our lunch entrees, my salmon was perfectly cooked, I enjoyed the verde sauce (forgot the true name) and overly cooked truffled tots. I would have preferred an in-house ketchup, and of course not overly fried tots. My partners enjoyed the catfish and their sides, no complaints. The "Mason Punch," was good, fresh peaches would have made it truly punch, but it was a good drink. Service was exceptional as well. read more

Consistently good. Recently went with a group of out of town guests for Sunday brunch. Was a little disappointed we couldn't sit outside on a lovely cool day - but nice clean booth and everyone loved the food and service! I have dined here many times over the years - love taking out of town guests because I trust the service and food and cleanliness! read more

This was my first time at this place and I am extremely underwhelmed. Let's start with the positives; the decor is very nice. I always say that a good indicator of the quality of an establishment is the quality of their bathrooms, and I'm pleased to report that Table 23 does have very nice bathrooms. Clean, spacious, and very nicely decorated. The lights and color palette are calming enough to give you a moment of peace away from the hustle and bustle of the eating area, but not so dark that you aren't even able to accurately assess whether your own decor looks as good as when you left the house. Now the cons-- the food left a lot to be desired, extremely disappointing considering I did come to actually enjoy nice food, not just to get out of the house. I started off my night with the "Sparkling Rosé Peach Sangria" and this should've been the first sign that this night wasn't what I was expecting. I don't know if I'm used to my sangrias being made by generous bartenders or if 23 was being stingy with the wine, but this cocktail had WAY too much peach schnapps in it. All I tasted was a sugary, artificial peach flavor, not at all ideal for a cocktail or the beginning to an evening, but the Avissi I ordered afterwards was actually tasty so I still had hope. I love coconut shrimp so I of course got excited when I saw it on the appetizer menu. Again, left underwhelmed. If I wanted mediocre coconut shrimp I'd just buy some at the grocery store. The coconut coating was nicely crunchy and actually tasted like coconut, but the shrimp was not a spectacular quality and again: what is the point of going out to eat if I can have better food at home? For my first entrée I ordered the panko crusted rainbow trout and was severely disappointed. One bite and it was way too dry, and even worse absolutely no discernible flavor. It might've been better with a sauce and seasonings but I shouldn't have to figure out how to make the dish taste good when I go out to eat. I'm guessing the cooks had the same opinion because I can no longer find it on the menu. I ordered the pickled beet and blue cheese salad on the side, and it definitely needed a touch of salt and pepper but it was a nice salad overall. The sweet potato fries were lukewarm when I got them but they still had crunch, and thankfully perfectly seasoned; since I was hungry I ate them while I waited for my new entree. I ordered the ribeye to replace the trout and was again disappointed because it wasn't tender enough. I've grilled ribeyes rare/medium rare and they were perfectly tender and juicy. Maybe grilling renders the fat differently? Either way it wasn't enough to satisfy me, and I wasn't about to wait even longer for a new entree. The potatoes were really creamy and delicious so at least I didn't leave starving. I am bewildered as to why this place was as crowded as it was; maybe people are just stir crazy and are just happy to feel some type of normalcy again-- of course, obligatory mask requirements aside. I didn't even think to take pictures of everything, but just think of the food like a trophy wife: it looks good, but that's about it. All in all, it's not the worst experience I've had but it was far from the best. Probably won't come back but if I do then I'll of course post another review with pictures. read more

If you like pub atmosphere , food, at 4 star prices, Enjoy ! From the moment we arrived to find construction left overs at front door, I said lets not do this. Bad experience, unfortunate for my husband , It was his 71 birthday ! Never again, gumbo room temp, baby wedge drowned in thousand island, burger dry, fries over seasoned, ribeye ( strange texture ), m/r yet no steak juices.! Asparagus was soggy, tasteless. Disappointed is not the word ! read more

Table 23 - This was on way out, someone attempting to cover the rotted wood. Why not just remove it ? - New American Near Me - Tallahassee, Florida

Excellent food. Friendly, knowledgeable and efficient service. The only drawback is parking can be a challenge.

Grouper fried fish appetizer is always good. Hushpuppies were good. Have ordered before. Service was good. Meatloaf was not good, way too dense & not particularity tasty. Huge serving. Looked like a piece of cake. Took remainder home, but did not eat it. Need to rethink and revise this menu item. read more

Table 23 has always looked so beautiful from the outside, so when it came to a date night, I insisted this was where I wanted to go! We made reservations for a Monday night, and I'm glad that we did! The porch was beautiful, a bit loud, but beautiful. Our waitress was very kind and attentive! Don't remember her name very well, I want to say it was either Jessica or Jennifer? (I'm sorry I forgot ) I ordered the filet cooked medium rare (subbed the brussel sprouts with asparagus). It was delightful!!! The fingerling potatoes were also so flavorful and delicious. My husband ordered the NY strip (medium) and had brussel sprouts instead of the chef vegetables. He scarfed it down. We both actually cleaned our plates. So so yummy! Attached are photos of our yummy meals! Also, both steaks were cooked perfectly to order. Maybe the only criticism I could find would be food presentation. $30+ for each dish would usually have a more "pretty" factor, but that's not a big deal and this isn't some cooking show lol. It didn't look bad at all though. I'm thankful this restaurant exists in Tallahassee and I hope it continues to thrive! read more

Table 23 - New American Near Me - Tallahassee, Florida

See all

One of the best restaurants in Tallahassee period. I have been here on multiple occasions and the food is always amazing. I usually start with one of their Caesar salads. It can be a little light on dressing at times, but it is always fresh and tasty. You can also ask for bread to be brought to the table (free of charge). The bread is delicious as is the butter served with it! My favorite entree so far has been the Lucky Goat Coffee-Rubbed Ribeye. The ribeye gushes with flavor and has a great texture with the coffee rub around it. The cooks consistently prepare my steak to perfection as well. The house-made steak sauce is probably my favorite steak sauce I have ever had. I would suggest getting an extra serving on the side (it's that good)! The fingerling potatoes are also excellent. I can't speak on the asparagus that comes with the meal because I usually sub it for fries, tots, or some other side. Any of the sides I have had are very good. If you are looking for a great dinner in a great atmosphere, Table 23 is definitely the place! They serve the best steaks in town (in my opinion) and all of the entrees I've tried are incredible. I couldn't recommend this restaurant enough! read more

Table 23 - Lucky Goat Coffee-Rubbed Ribeye, fingerling potatoes, fries, and an extra side of house-made steak sauce - New American Near Me - Tallahassee, Florida

Small place unique decor I would call it modern country good food they are big portions. read more

Table 23 - New American Near Me - Tallahassee, Florida

See all

The service and the food was great. When I am back in the area I will visit again. 1/2 price wine was a added bonus read more

Table 23 - My favorite person - New American Near Me - Tallahassee, Florida

See all

Great, friendly restaurant. The food was amazing. Service was warm. Make reservations well-ahead, though. It is very popular.

After living in Tallahassee for a year we finally gave Table 23 a shot and it was well worth it! For dinner, we decided to try the coffee-rubbed ribeye, mac and cheese, fingerling potatoes, and tater tots. I'm very particular about how my steak is cooked and it was perfect. The coffee-rub gave the steak an excellent taste and texture. Paired with the homemade steak sauce it was delicious. We even had to ask for more of the sauce! The mac and cheese is my favorite from any restaurant, I would go just for that! Overall, our experience was great and I would recommend it! I also really loved the atmosphere. read more

See all

Went to Table 23 last weekend for brunch and it was fantastic. This was my second time going and I must warn you they will be packed and you will wait a while. However to me the food is worth the wait. I was lucky that me and my friend were able to secure a seat at the bar so we cancelled the wait for a table. Me and my other guest got the unlimited mimosas and the bartender kept our glasses filled. For brunch we had the fried green tomatoes which were just okay, cause I have had better. For our meals I had the omolette which I loved and my guest had the chicken and waffles which were very good. I enjoyed the environment and the nice bar setup outside. I even met some other great people while eating and they gave me more insight on this place and how great it was. Plan on coming for dinner real soon. read more

See all

Good food, good drinks and great vibe. I'd visit this place again next time I'm in Tallahassee.

Sunday brunch was not good...our service was great! We were on the covered porch so good ambience.. Eggs from a carton for omelet, toast too hard too eat and everything bagel with salmon was in some kind of melted cream cheese on top of hard store bought bagel... read more

I LOVE coming here for brunch!! The food is amazing and the bottomless mimosas you can switch up the flavors. I've had the sweet potato pancakes, bacon and grits. The key lime pie was pretty good as well and friends loved the Creme Brulee. The ambiance is really well thought out. As a former server, I do feel bad for the employees I wish they could come up with a more streamlined way to make and distribute the mimosas. Definitely recommend for brunch! read more

One of the best places for breakfast/brunch in Tally!! Chicken and waffles are delicious and the mimosas are a 12/10!! Service is great as well!! Can't wait to go back. read more

Per my 12 year old daughter: Food's a 9, the service is maybe a 6. Our server had tables in multiple completely different locations in the restaurant. We sat on the deck and for 8 tables and each table seemed to have a different server. So thats a management/planning issue. I enjoyed my trout and my husband enjoyed the grouper. In retrospect we would have waited to not sit on the deck due to the heat/sun. The hostess did mention that the seating was in bright light before seating us. The food was good, but not sure that we will go back. read more

Nice outdoor seating and view. I like their atmosphere over there and the food are above average :) like going there with friends. read more

Table 23 - New American Near Me - Tallahassee, Florida

See all

Don't waste your time. Food is just average and over priced Waited in a long line when finally reached the door the head waitress told us we were in the wrong line?!?!? They now require valet parking, bad experience read more