Cancel

    Open app

    Search

    Swoony's

    4.5 (86 reviews)
    Open 5:00 pm - 10:00 PM

    Order Swoony's Takeout or Delivery

    Swoony's Photos

    Business Info

    SWOONY'S ATMOSPHERE

    What's the vibe?
    Hipster
    Casual
    Trendy
    Good for kids

    You might also consider

    Recommended Reviews - Swoony's

    Your trust is our priority, so businesses can't pay to alter or remove their reviews. Learn more about reviews.
    Yelp app icon
    Browse more easily on the app
    Review Feed Illustration

    Reviews With Photos

    Creamy Lobster Orzo
    Annalise W.

    Great neighborhood dinner spot I recommend checking out. Had a reservation for two people on a Friday and there was a steady stream of people coming and going so would probably try to get a reservation if possible. Ambiance / Service: I sat outside. A few covered (not enclosed) outdoor tables, which could be nice even when it's a bit chillier because there are overhead heaters. Inside is a little dark & moody, but feels intimate and lively and very much a local neighborhood joint. It's a bar, but feels elevated (though still casual in the sense you can show up wearing anything!) Service was amazing. Food: ordered the below and split between two people and it was too much food. -Potato Croquettes: comes with two. Would recommend ordering additional if dining with more people because they're not very big. Nothing crazy here, but exactly what I wanted: crispy and cheesy. -Creamy Lobster Orzo: I feel like this could be a main as well. Subtle taste, but enjoyed. -Greek Salad: fresh and light. Great balance to everything else we ordered. -Crab Toast: good to share with one other person (not very big). -Swoony's Burger: it has the name in it, so it's a must. Really enjoyed and would order again. If nothing else, get the side of fries - literal McDonald's copycat and soooo good. -PEI Mussels: the waitress warned us that it's not everyone's favorite... but honestly the more I ate the more I enjoyed. It has a unique flavor: creamy and not overpowering mustard-y at all. Lots of depth of flavors! -Short Rib Au Poivre: this was good, but I wish there was more seasoning on the meat & sauce. Between the two mains (burger & mussels) this was my least favorite. -French Toast: just get it. I would come back just for this. It's not very big and feel like I could eat my own order lol.

    Bonnie G.

    Loved sitting outside with our dog on a summer evening and feasting on their creamy lobster orzo with big chunks of lobster, their Greek salad with toasted pita which actually is the best Greek salad I've had (our waiter Misha was right), and the decadent two-patty burger, oozing with a little too much thousand-island sauce, but it was still great. I think I like Swoony's more than their sister restaurant Cafe Spaghetti, believe it or not! Every dish is a tad unique. 5 stars!!!

    Potato Croquettes
    Jillian B.

    Finally got to try Swoonys after all the hype around the burger, and it was worth the wait! We opted to share a variety of dishes for dinner.. a few apps and two entrees. The tuna crudo was refreshing, and the potato croquettes were among the best I've had (packed with cheese!). The swoonys burger of course was solid, and I enjoyed the au poivre sauce in the short rib dish. Fries were perfectly crisp and salted! Quick and efficient service. Would recommend!

    Clams casino
    david l.

    What an incredible meal along with top notch service. The hostess was very welcoming and we were seated right away. I suggest to get a few dishes to share to enjoy everything. We had the Brussel sprouts, Tuscan Kale Salad and clams casino to start. All were delicious and it was off to a good start. The entrees were the burger and short ribs. The Burger is among the best being served in NYC and the Short rib was on another level of tenderness. No knife is needed just break it apart with your fork. Finish off with the French toast. You won't be disappointed.

    Clams Casino
    Peter D.

    I really, really love Swoony's. There's not really much to criticize about this joint, except they made the terrible decision of not opening closer to my home. It's the local bar and grill we all wish we had...albeit a little fancier, a little pricier, and much more delicious (but harder to get into as well). It helped that we ordered perfectly. There were simply too many interesting starters, so the four of us decided to split the whipped goat cheese, the tuna crudo, the clams casino, the brussels sprouts with horsey sauce, the iceberg wedge and the spicy crab toast. Too many for sure, but we balanced it out by just getting a couple of burgers for our mains. I can't stress enough how delicious everything was. The iceberg wedge was brilliant in its uniform thickness and utter overload of bleu cheese. It takes the already laughable "salad" designation of a regular wedge, and obliterates it. It's just bacon and bleu cheese and frizzled onions atop a thin cylinder of crunchy water, and I'm here for it. The whipped goat cheese and chili crunch will be replicated in my home for years to come. There wasn't a bad bite in the bunch, but if I had to skip one I'd forego the tuna crudo (nothing wrong, but a little boring comparatively), and if I would get one every single time, it would be the perfection that is that crab toast. If you've ever enjoyed a McDonald's cheeseburger even a little bit, you should know that the Swoony's burger takes those flavors, uses far better ingredients, and places them on a Portuguese muffin. That is to say, makes it perfect. You can wash down all of this excellent fare with tasty cocktails (I loved the Black Manhattan and the [Something] Ember), and again, this is the local I wish I had. I'll be back for more spicy crab toast and that shortrib au poivre, which can't be bad.

    Alex M.

    Great neighborhood joint! Came here for dinner with a friend and we both had a wonderful experience. We ended up splitting the clams casino (some of the best I've ever had) and the croquettes (also some of the best I've ever had) and each got our own cheeseburger. The cheeseburger was divine and reminded me of a highly elevated big Mac (minus the shredded lettuce) with perfectly crisp fries. Service was quick and friendly - even while the place was packed and bustling. Luckily we had a reservation or else we would've had to wait a while for a table. Ambiance was chic and cozy. Looking forward to coming back and trying the rest of the menu - that short rib looked delicious!

    Blue Cheese Stuffed Olives
    Cyrus A.

    Swoony's is a gem -- steakhouse vibes, without quite as high of a price tag! The restaurant has a classic American vibe, with a nice bar that stretches from near the entrance all the way toward the back of the restaurant. Plenty of smaller tables for groups of 2-4, they really don't waste floor space packing folks in. The food was excellent. They have a smaller menu and some specials, focusing on quality over quantity with the selection. The burger lived up to the hype, though it was more of a "smash" style patty than some of the pictures seemed to imply. It came with fries, which were crispy and nicely salted. The PEI mussels dish was delicious, it featured a unique mustard sauce that made the pasta much more interesting. Service was wonderful, very friendly and welcoming! I would definitely come back here, people in the area are lucky to have Swoony's nearby.

    Crab Louie toast
    Jason M.

    Swoony's fell onto my radar through Instagram - one of the food accounts I follow highlighted this spot and it looked like a cool place to check out. Since my brother works in Brooklyn and I was off from work, we thought it would be a good idea to meet up for an early dinner, so off we went. Swoony's is located on the Waterfront close to Carroll Gardens; parking can be a challenge but I managed to snatch a spot a block away from the restaurant. The restaurant itself is very charming - it gives of a very cozy aesthetic with warm lighting, earth tones, and touches of decor; the entire space was very hygge. The menu is mostly American fare with touches of seafood. We decided to start with three apps: the spicy crab toast (also called the Crab Louie Toast), lobster orzo, and the whipped goat cheese. These were all delicious - everything had great flavor and I was especially impressed by the goat cheese as it came topped with a sauce and paired with cucumbers and bread. The lobster orzo was also a standout - creamy without being heavy. Swoony's is known for their burger, and I couldn't leave without trying it so I ordered it as my main. This was a double-patty smash burger topped with American cheese, Thousand Island dressing, and pickles. In lieu of a bun, it was served on an English muffin and came with a side of shoestring fries. The burger itself was great - it's everything a smash burger should be and all the flavors worked really well; the fries were the icing on the cake. My only critique is that the English muffin was a smidge too soft which made the burger slightly messy. We shared a side of creamed spinach - this was good, though definitely more cream than spinach. For dessert I had the cheesecake mousse which was tasty - not too heavy with a smooth consistency and creamy flavor. Service was great, everyone was friendly and food came out at a good pace. Overall, Swoony's is a yes - the atmosphere was warm and inviting, the food was delicious, and the vibes were on. I wouldn't hesitate returning to explore more of their menu.

    Clams Casino
    John K.

    They went to McDon's and stole the french fry formula, I swear. They were bang on similar. Flavor, thirst quenching beverages, great vibes (awesome tunes) and friendly and attentive service. Burger lived up to the hype, excited to go back for the blue cheese olives, croquettes, and more good food and drink.

    Whipped Goat Cheese | Creamy Lobster Orzo - June 2025
    Kay C.

    I discovered Swoony's through @eatsbynyc on Instagram and knew I had to try it for myself. We wanted to get a good sense of the menu and decided to share a couple of starters and a main. First up was the Whipped Goat Cheese served with chili crunch, cucumbers, and grilled sourdough. This was a delightful combo - creamy, spicy, cool, and crunchy all in one bite. Next came the Creamy Lobster Orzo, which had tender chunks of lobster that were definitely a win. "Creamy" felt like a stretch and the dish leaned more toward a soup. It was tasty, just not what I expected texture-wise. For the main, we split Swoony's signature burger that comes with a double patty and topped with Thousand Island dressing and American cheese on a soft Portuguese bun. The burger reminded me of an elevated 7th Street Burger, except the bun, and the freshly cut, crispy and golden fries had a nostalgic nod to McDonald's. Service was friendly and attentive. Our water glasses were never empty and the food came out fast, which is always appreciated. The vibe was relaxed and everything ran smoothly. Overall, Swoony's is a solid spot and worth a visit if you're nearby.

    Iqrah C.

    Visited Swoony's on my birthday eve and had the absolute best time ever! The restaurant is located in Cobble hill which is one of my favorite neighborhoods, and it's actually quite spacious and large inside ideal for a big party or a casual dinner date. The staff is so friendly and attentive and they knew it was my birthday so flooded me with lots of love and wishes. Ordered the burger which is one of their popular dishes, lobster orzo, potato croquettes, whipped goat cheese toast, and French toast and vanilla ice cream for dessert. The drinks were great as well I had a margarita and a cocktail. The food was all flavored wonderfully and fresh, the burger was a double patty smashburger served with fries! Overall my favorite dish of the night. The food is heavy and portions are good so I recommend coming hungry. For my birthday celebration, they brought out a green colored cake and sang to me and then brought out dessert which was so lovely. The French toast was immaculate and the soft serve complemented it very well. Lobster orzo was also cooked wonderfully and paired amazing with everything else. I loved it here and can't wait to come back! Highly recommend

    Menu Nov 2024
    Jenny E.

    I had a great experience at Swoony's. I love the interior and the cozy lighting. Waitstaff and hosts were friendly. The Swoony's burger was delicious! Fries were the exact kind that I enjoy -- not too thick, with a good amount of salt. Very easy to make a reservation. My only complaint would be how close together some of the tables are.

    French toast
    Kimmy U.

    Check out Swoony's during the holidays! Their decor is so festive and cute We were able to snag a last minute reservation for an early dinner We mostly came for the burger, but also got the clams casino and kale caesar salad. We all loved the kale salad! It was so cheesy but not too overpowering My friends also raved about the cocktails (especially the mezcal one), so I can't wait to come back and try it after our little bebe comes. The burger is more of a smash patty style and is quite simple with thousand island dressing and cheese. The bread is very unique! I read online that it was a portuguese style bread? It looks very similar to an english muffin, but definitely doesn't taste like one. It's pillowy and soft and I do wish they maybe toasted it for a slight crunch, but it didn't take away from the overall burger and was still delicious. I love that they serve it with real fries and not just potato chips or something else, like other gourmet burger restaurants. The fries actually reminded us of mcdonald's fries! We ended with the French toast for dessert, and while it was good, I don't think it was necessary. We went down a few streets to Brooklyn Pharmacy for ice cream, which I think is a better move for dessert

    Creamy Lobster Orzo

    See all

    2 years ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    2 years ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 1
    Oh no 0
    Photo of B C.
    3
    10
    0

    3 years ago

    Helpful 1
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    3 years ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    3 years ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    2 years ago

    Helpful 1
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 1

    Page 3 of 3

    Ask the Community - Swoony's

    You might also consider

    Verify this business for free

    People searched for New American 148,788 times last month within 15 miles of this business.

    Verify this business

    Charm Bar & Restaurant

    Charm Bar & Restaurant

    3.8
    (509 reviews)
    1.4 mi
    $$$

    Charm BK was a nice night out in Brooklyn. The atmosphere was a vibe and the service was great. Our…read morewaiter Demmoy made sure we were good the whole time and checked in on us throughout the meal. We started with the crab cakes and calamari, which were both tasty and came out fresh. The drinks were also good about an 8/10 for me. For the mains we tried the Steak Rasta Pasta and the Oxtail with rice. Both dishes had good flavor and the portions were satisfying. If you're looking for a Caribbean spot in Brooklyn with good food and a nice vibe, Charm BK is definitely worth trying.

    First and foremost, I am absolutely flabbergasted and disappointed by the experience I had today…read more Three friends and I stopped by to enjoy a few cocktails and maybe grab a bite to eat. When I walked in, I noticed two available seats at the bar. A Caucasian woman took one of the seats, and I sat in the other. Moments later, an employee asked me to move because the woman's friend was supposedly on the way. Now, I've always understood bar seating to be first come, first served. What made the situation even more frustrating was that I wasn't even given the opportunity to order a drink or remain seated until the friend actually arrived. Instead, I was immediately asked to give up my seat for someone who wasn't even present. As a Black man, on Juneteenth of all days, the optics of the situation did not sit well with me. The music was Black. The atmosphere was Black. The culture being celebrated was Black. Yet it felt like preference was being given to someone who wasn't even there over a paying customer who was. Maybe that wasn't the intent, but perception matters, and the experience left a very bad taste in my mouth. Unfortunately, based on this experience, I cannot recommend this establishment. Avoid it at all cost! Zero STARS

    Photos
    Art on the wall. Biggie
    Art on the wall. Biggie
    Signature Mac & Cheese with Oxtail.
    Signature Mac & Cheese with Oxtail.
    Spinach Salad

    See all

    Spinach Salad
    Flamingobaby Kitchen

    Flamingobaby Kitchen

    4.3
    (279 reviews)
    1.4 mi
    $$

    I am still thinking about this food. It was so good, flavorful and fresh. We cleared those plates…read more We were full, but not sluggish at all..just completely satisfied. This is an intimate and cozy space, great to sit and talk without the noise of a loud space. Music was played, but not obnoxious and there is a tv. Service was great, food was tasty, no complaints at all! Quick heads up, this is a cash only spot, but so worth it. Will definitely be back!

    I scoured the internet and my old photos trying to find this restaurant again. It had been about a…read moreyear since our first visit, so it took some digging but we eventually found Flamingobaby Kitchen and off we went! For the table, we ordered the oxtail stew, fried chicken, yams, collard greens, and mac & cheese. I also had a Peach Bellini for a little bubbly. Everything was exactly as I remembered -perfectly cooked and well seasoned, large portions with more than enough to take home. The chef stopped by our table which was a nice touch. Service overall was great. They also make great use of such a small space. It is indeed well worth the visit. Side note, we ordered the same exact items off the menu as we did a year ago...only one thing was missing which was the biscuits with the flavored butter jam. We were told the biscuits were replaced with cornbread. I didn't order the cornbread this time around but would like to see the biscuits return at some point.

    Photos
    Southern Fried Chicken + Waffles
    Southern Fried Chicken + Waffles
    Sweet & Spicy Chicken Tenders + Fries
    Sweet & Spicy Chicken Tenders + Fries
    Menu

    See all

    Menu
    Emily

    Emily

    4.0
    (996 reviews)
    1.9 mi
    $$

    We loved the food…read more Came here on a saturday for lunch before the world cup. We arrived just when it opened I think. The place was pretty quiet. Friendly waitress greeted us and sat us immediately. Menu's came out and they recommended a pizza and burger. We agreed and ordered. Place started to pick up and get busy immediately after we ordered. Food came out pretty quickly. We each had a burger. Not a lot of options on the menu but we all tried the emily burger. It was worth it. Think, juicy and with an amazingly unique taste. The ingredients were high quality, the burger cooked to perfection. The table also split the modern pizza (I think). Not sure what to expect from this one but turns out it was perfect, unique and delicious. The cheese taste really shined through. Overall, we were super happy with the food here. Stop by if you have a chance.

    Greetings all, it's been a while but here I am. Let's talk about Emily a quant pizza restaurant…read morethat you could easily walk pass and not know what they sold. Today however it wasn't pizza that brought me here, it was the famous Emmy Burger. To begin with the atmosphere of the restaurant is dim lighting a few tables with a reasonable sized bar in the middle of the room. They also have an open kitchen concept where just past the bar you can see the cooks working. My server Inda was polite and knowledgeable about the menu. My burger was excellent, normally I don't eat my burger with a knife and folk, but in this case with all the cheese and sauce oozing down the sides, not to mention the caramelized onions, it was necessary. (If I were home I wouldn't mind having burger juices running down my arm, but other people were eating in the restaurant also). The tiny pickles which I can't remember the name of were an added treat to the burger. I decided to order mine with the loaded fries. Just imagine the ground burger with all the toppings covering french fries and add melted white cheese. Since I was alone I didn't order a pizza because how would I eat it all, but next time I will try the pizza. I don't mind paying extra for a burger when it's aged beef and the taste is great. I definitely recommend this location. There is a fast food burger restaurant next door to Emily's but I can't imagine there burgers compare. I will try them another time and let you know. That's all for now, see you on my next review.

    Photos
    Emily
    Emmy Burger
    Emmy Burger
    Karaage

    See all

    Karaage

    Swoony's - newamerican - Updated August 2026

    Loading...
    Loading...
    Loading...