I wanted a vegan cake so I called sweet karma ... well they didn't disappoint just so delicious chocolate goodness like velvety creamy I can't tell you must try it for yourself... treat yourself have it made to order thank you Jenn read more

The loveliest little bakery! Such a wide selection and everything looked amazing. When I arrived there was a bit of a line that went out the door but it went very quickly and was totally worth the wait. I ordered a few cupcakes and the staff was very friendly! Definitely coming back, will probably order something custom made too! read more

See all

I've purchased many items from Sweet Karma. Great bakery, and great service every time ! You can't go wrong ! read more

Great little bakery, especially for gluten free items. Was looking for a bakery with fresh gluten free items. The cupcakes were beautiful. They didn't look like the typical sweets that looked "off", because they are "gluten free". They had Oreo cupcakes that looked like the regular gluten bakery item, but it was gluten free with even a "fake" Oreo on top. Great selection of macarons. Our gluten free hosts loved them all. Will revisit read more

Great place for cakes in general. We have tried cakes and cupcakes from this shop and they were perfect both times. Staff is friendly and they have good options. read more

We've ordered plenty of cakes from Sweet Karma and they never disappoint. For my lemon themed bridal shower this weekend, I ordered a two tiered cake to match my theme. This cake was beautiful and delicious! It was honestly my favorite detail at the shower. I cannot thank Sweet Karma enough! read more

Sweet Karma Desserts - a lemon themed cake - Desserts Near Me - Plainview, New York

I don't know where to begin. I have been a customer of this bakery for close to four years. My first order was cupcakes. And then grew to love their Karma cups, cookies, other decadent desserts, and most of all their occasion cakes. What beautiful pieces of art I have ordered and received. True centerpieces of my parties. From a simple home birthday party to a sweet 16, a high school graduation. others... Exquisite. Delicious. Heartfelt. And just unique. No one does it like Brian Fishman. Owner of Sweet Karma. Lifelong customer. So impressed by his work and his staff. read more

See all

Picked up this cake.. the worst I've seen for 180$. I'm so disappointed that I didn't even try it yet. I literally just picked it up. There's a crease.. the thing looks like a hat.. and the cut out looks like my child did it. I make better cakes at work. Maybe they only specialize in structures cause this shit sure ain't it. Never will go here or refer anyone to come get a cake. Manager tried to argue on the phone that it's my fault for not saying something right there and then.. I wasn't there and my mom couldn't say anything. She's not that way. I understand what she means.. but at least have some compassion. For almost $200 you should be a little more helpful. In response to the owner if I cant trust you with a $200 cake I'm not trusting you with a $500 cake. It was to my understanding it was an edible image. If you have to explain that much to me. Your clearly wrong. read more

Sweet Karma Desserts - Desserts Near Me - Plainview, New York

Want to thank Brian Fishman from SweetKarma Desserts-Plainview for all the beautiful cakes that he has made for us in the past . One of the cake's that we requested was such a pleasant surprise.....it was for our son whom graduated to a Suffolk County police officer. All our cakes not only were they beautifully crafted but deliciously tasty. The last one was for our grandson's 1st birthday Lion king theme.....it was such a hit! I highly recommend Sweet Karma for any occasion you may be celebrating. YOU CAN'T GO WRONG! read more

See all

Words can't describe how we absolutely rave about Sweet Karma and Brian. My daughter recently had her wedding. The venue's cake maker neglected to make her 3 tiered wedding cake. The venue was made aware only 1 hour before. Our gracious lady got into action and ended up calling Brian for a favor. And oh boy, did he show up! Not just a cake but a gorgeous and very scrumptious 3 tiered one as well. Little did everyone know at the time that Brian made my daughter's sweet 16, HS graduation, College Graduation and Engagement party cakes. Serendipity...it happened the way it was willed to happen. Our first thought in planning this wedding was for Sweet Karma to make the cake. I wish I have a photo of the cake but I was too busy partying to get one. It was a wedding with 220 people in attendance. read more

definitely the best bakery by far. i'm not a big review person but this place deserves my time. i've been getting custom cakes, pastries and all types of pies and sweets from here for about 4 years now. maybe more. i've never been let down. every detail i've asked for has always been done to perfection, plus some! not to mention, the prices are extremely reasonable also. taste of each cake has always been so good. like very fresh and just perfect. some places make cakes that look great but taste crappy. but these have always looked and tasted even better. brian and the rest of the staff have always been so nice. very friendly and talkative. never once rushed me off the phone or even out of the bakery. i saw a previous review saying they felt rushed, and i think that's complete BS lol. anyway ... here's some photos of my families cakes i had made. perrrfect !!! thanks sweet karma! read more

See all

Best cake I have ever eaten. Would recommend Brian as the Cake guru for any occasion. Five star bakery. read more

Sweet Karma Desserts - Best cake I have ever eaten. This bakery is amazing. Wood recommend Brian as the Cake guru for any occasion. - Desserts Near Me - Plainview, New York

See all

Just wanted to recognize the amazing work of this bakery in Plainview, Long Island. Not only did they do a spectacular job making the perfect Mets theme cake for my husband's 60th birthday but their customer service is above and beyond. You really feel how important it is to them to get the design right for you. The best part is it tasted just as good as it looked! Thanks to the baker and team for this awesome cake and special thanks to Jen for all her help! 5 Stars all around read more

Cake was exactly how I envisioned it to be & it was delicious. Jen & staff were very accommodating read more

Sweet Karma Desserts - #21 cake, 1 filled with cannoli cream & the other with chocolate mousse - Desserts Near Me - Plainview, New York

Yum! I've been wanting to try this place out for a while and I'm so glad I finally had a reason to come pick up a cake here. I had the rainbow cookie cake which was covered in a thick chocolate coating. The cake itself was so moist and so flavorful. The raspberry filling inbetween each layer was absolutely perfect. The only thing I could do without was the chocolate coating. The chocolate was good, but there was so much of it, it really took away from the rest of the cake. Regardless, it was still one of the best cakes I've ever had. Maybe it's cause we came late in the day, but the girl was a little short with us and didn't really want to help us. There aren't any signs as to what cake was what, so of course we asked and everytime she just got a little ruder. Aside from the service, we'll be back for sure. The cake was $25 and was more than enough for 6 people. Great prices and delicious cake! read more

My sister's birthday cake was amazing, really cute and the taste even better Thank you Teresa and Brian read more

Sweet Karma Desserts - Desserts Near Me - Plainview, New York

See all

Sweet Karma made the best cakes for an 80th bday and 60th wedding anniversary. They were delicious and masterpieces.

My mom had been working with Sweet Karma Desserts since my Sweet 16th (I am 30 years old now). Brian has been making cakes for almost every milestone in my life (16th birthday, HS graduation, college graduation, and graduation cake). My wedding was on 10/8/2022. My venue has a partnership with another local baker to make a cake for our wedding. 2 hours before our reception, the venue director comes to find out that the baker did NOT have my cake or event in her books. Thankfully, because of her connections she was able to get a cake made an HOUR before my reception. A cake made by Brian at Sweet Karma Desserts! What a coincidence! And another milestone with this bakery. I am so thankful for Sweet Karma and for coming to save my wedding! The cake was beautiful, and tasted as amazing as I remembered! Moist, tasty and the frosting was *chef's kiss*. I've always loved working with them and highly recommend using them for any events you have! read more

A little pricey but a great place for baked goods if you have allergies AND if you just like yummy stuff!

How is this place higher than 3 stars? A lot of their friends are reviewing probably. I should have known with their "Best of Long Island" sign, which is a popularity contest and has nothing to do with most establishments. Literally every bakery item we purchased was old, bland, or mediocre at best. There are so many better bakeries around. And for service, the kid working didn't want to be bothered. Extremely disappointing. read more

Had a DELICIOUS custom cake last night that was artistically made. I am totally impressed with Brian's work. He's my go-to guy for cake from now on... read more

Sweet Karma Desserts - Desserts Near Me - Plainview, New York

See all

We ordered a custom cake from Sweet Karma Desserts for our wedding and my only regret was not having more of it! The icing was the perfect combination of thick and sweet while the cake was moist and fresh. I couldn't have asked for a better cake and look forward to ordering my next cake from them! read more

Sweet Karma Desserts - Red Velvet Cake - Desserts Near Me - Plainview, New York

We came here for the gluten free items and they did not disappoint!!! Everything was delicious and soo fresh! The rainbow cookies were my favorite and the mini apple pie was a close second. The rugelach (jelly cookies) were delicious too! Oh my goodness, and can't forget about the cannoli stuffed rainbow cookies!! That filling is to die for. I will be back for the gluten free cider donuts in the fall! read more

Brian you did it again!! WOW. The Encanto cake you and your team fabricated for Olivia's 4th birthday stole the show. From the detail to the taste it was perfection. Words can not describe the beautiful job you did. The cake was the talk of the party and stole the show. Thank you for always coming through with quality work and craftsmanship as well as more than reasonable pricing. If you get your custom cakes and desserts anywhere else you are doing yourself and your guests a huge disservice. Sweet Karma you rock!!! read more

Sweet Karma Desserts - Custom Encanto Cake - Desserts Near Me - Plainview, New York

Got a 6 inch cake for my girlfriends birthday. Had Red velvet cake with cannoli cream. The cake was beautifully decorated and definitely exemplified what I had asked for. There was lots of fondant on the cake which added a nice touch and also tasted great. read more

Sweet Karma Desserts - Desserts Near Me - Plainview, New York

I guess I just had a bad luck coz bought an almond square cake at $2.50 as a treat for my son since he behaved so well at Doctor s office. It was so sad he only had a couple of bites then turned it away and said:"Mommy, no more I don't like it." To my surprise that he loves sweets, how could that be? It turned out the square almond top had spoiled oil smell and tasted funny too. What a shame! read more

Sweet Karma Desserts - Smells bad spoiled oil used in the mixture May be just this once? - Desserts Near Me - Plainview, New York

I worked exclusively with Teresa the cake designer on my wedding cake and was so happy to have her feedback and ideas. I not only ordered the wedding cake but also a grooms cake from SKD as well. Our guests loved not only the whimsy of the design but also the Carrot Cake/Cream Cheese combo and the Chocolate/Peanut butter mousse of the grooms cake. My husband and I are beyond happy with all the great service and and experiences we had with Sweet Karma Desserts I would highly recommend you going there for any occasion. I've also posted photos above, our cakes were the White Rabbit and Gameboy. read more

Sweet Karma Desserts - This was out amazing wedding cake by Sweet Karma! Many thanks to Theresa for making my vision come to life! - Desserts Near Me - Plainview, New York

See all

Had multiple gluten-free items. I always pick up way too many things when I come here. Had the chocolate chocolate cake. Chocolate mousse on top and fudge on bottom. This cake is a lot more enjoyable if it's chilled. Trust me. Try it. Tiramisu was amazing. Chocolate mousse dome also thoroughly enjoyable Macaroons are not really my thing. But the wifey loves it. Excellent sweets without the yucky feeling afterwards. May this place always be blessed with sweet karma! read more

See all

We got a cake for our wedding (5/8/21) from this place because my wife is gluten free. I can say not only was it one of the worst gluten free cakes I have ever eaten, but they completely lost our cake topper, which was given to them over a week in advance. They did not say 1 word to us about it and just brought the cake thinking we were stupid and wouldn't notice. Obviously my wife was devistated on our big day (thanks so much for that one). When I called I was basically given the run around and told that a manager would give me a call back. I'm still waiting to hear from someone. Bad cake and bad customer service means bad business. Needless to say I'll never order from them again and will not be recommending them either. read more

I have been going to Sweet Karma for over 15 years, since they were in East Meadow. Any birthday, anniversary, special occasion, or just a Sunday Family Dinner, we have been enjoying cakes, pastries & treats. Not only is Brian & his wife Jenn the nicest people on the planet, but the desserts are always fresh, always delicious, and everyone always asks "Where did you get this?". I recommend Sweet Karma Bakery to everyone & everyone that I cross paths with, if they are looking for amazing desserts. So many places can make nice looking cakes and/or desserts, but do not deliver in flavor, either are too sweet or are just terrible. Sweet Karma's desserts & cakes are not only beautiful, but taste good and make you want to come back over & over again. read more

I've been buying from Sweet Karma since they were in East Meadow. I thought they had closed, until one day I saw them in Plainview. Super happy I did. Everything is always super fresh and tasty. My wife loves the chocolate indulgence, personally, I'm a fan of the peanut butter and jelly pyramids. They have delicious mini cakes, cup cakes and cookies. They also have speciality cakes, which I can't comment on as I haven't had them. Highly recommend trying them out. read more

See all

Hats off to Brian (and my apologies for this long over-due review). I was in a bit of a bind. My neighbor had committed to baking a cake for my father's 90th b-day and then backed out a week before the party. My wife went to school with Brian, and since Sweet Karma was near where we had to be I gave them a call. And I'm glad I did! Being from NJ, I emailed some cake designs to Brian, who was very responsive and provided a variety of different options that could be done, given my price range and available time. When I went to pick up the cake, Brian told me that he made some changes to the design. At first I was like 'Uh, oh...' until he explained that the design elements that I truly wanted -- the icons depicting some of the major events in my father's life -- would have been lost with my original design. Then he revealed the cake, and I was thrilled. He was absolutely right, and I loved the changes he made. His interpretation of my vision was spot-on. The decorations were very realistic looking and the cake was delicious. Even better than that was the reaction from my father and family, who couldn't help but crowd around and take pictures. The cake was the centerpiece of the party and everyone thought it was outstanding. Kudos to Brian for saving the day and for delivering a great product. I know that some people might question his decision to change my design - indeed, that's unusual. But it really showed that Brian is an artist (whose medium is cake), and not just a baker. If I have the opportunity I would absolutely patronize Sweet Karma again, and I'm not afraid to recommend it to my LI-based friends. read more

Sweet Karma Desserts - My original design was a car-shaped cake with the steamer trunk sticking out the back. Brian's re-design was MUCH better. - Desserts Near Me - Plainview, New York

I have gotten various desserts here, from an opening to a business to my birthday cake that I received today on May 21, 2022. They are the most talented people I've ever met and I've known them a very long time. I 1000% recommend anyone who needs a cake for whatever reason to chew Sweet Karma Desserts in Plainview New York. It will be the best money that you've ever spent. read more

Sweet Karma Desserts - My birthday cake. - Desserts Near Me - Plainview, New York

Thank you so much Teresa and Brian for making my daughter's Sweet 16 cake and push up favors. The ombré purple was beautiful and the 2 cakes were delicious . We had red velvet with a cannoli cream and vanilla with a vanilla/chocolate pastry cream. Every single guest ate cake and raved about it! Working with Sweet Karma from making my order, cake tasting to delivery, everything was perfect! The staff is so nice and treat customers like family. I cannot say enough great things about Sweet Karma, if you need a cake, I whole heartedly recommend Sweet Karma, you will not be disappointed!! read more

Sweet Karma Desserts - My daughter's Sweet 16 cake was perfect! - Desserts Near Me - Plainview, New York

If I could give this 0 stars I would. Horrible experinece with the manager/owner. They dont know how to talk to customers. The cake was horrible and overpriced. Ordered a custom cake, went back to let owner know that I did not like the cake. She brought the cake to the back and said "we all tried it and it tastes fine." I asked for credit of my $75 and was only offered a $20 credit. Do yourself a favor a don't go to sweet karma. STAY AWAY!!!! There are other MUCH better bakeries that would habe treated a customer much better & the cake would taste much better read more

I was completely blown away by the custom cake they made me for my wife's surprise 50th birthday party. Not only was it visually stunning, a genuine work of art, but it was delicious too. The people are also wonderful and genuinely care. My expectations were exceeded in every way. Sweet Karma will be my go to place from now on. read more

Sweet Karma Desserts - Desserts Near Me - Plainview, New York

See all

This was the second cake we bought from Sweet Karma. YUM! Great canes and great service.

If you're looking for a PHENOMENAL cake artist who can turn your concept into exquisite reality -- look no further. If you're looking for a traditional Long Island bakery that has all the comfort baked goods you grew up enjoying -- look no further. If you're looking for the place for all your celebratory baked goods needs -- LOOK NO FURTHER. The owners and staff of this AHHHHMAZING bakery are second to none. A++++++!!!! read more

This is our third custom cake ordered at Sweet Karma and we couldn't be more thrilled with the results. Each time we have been blown away with the creations! Today's cake was for my sister's baby shower. We ordered the cake with Brian and showed him a few inspiration photos of what we were looking for. He went above and beyond! Whenever we are in Plainview we always stop in for pastries and macaroons. Their GF selection is delicious- you can't taste the difference. If you're looking for a special cake- this is where you should go!!!! read more

Sweet Karma Desserts - Baby Shower "little pumpkin" cake for my sister's shower - Desserts Near Me - Plainview, New York

Amazing bakery for Celiac's. Incredible selection. Very helpful staff. Worth the trip read more

See all