Sunset Bagels is a staple in my household! With it being so close by, I find myself running over there whenever I'm too lazy to cook. The variety alone keeps me coming back--I've tried their breakfast sandwiches, smoothies, wings and fries, burgers--but my go-to is always the Philly cheesesteak with fries. So good! The staff is always pleasant, and the establishment is consistently clean, which is something I definitely pay attention to. I remember when it was first built, and honestly, it still looks just as fresh and well-kept as day one. I also love how spacious it is--there's plenty of room to dine in comfortably. It truly added value to the block. My only qualm is the parking situation. With so many people frequenting both here and Frida's, parking has gotten exponentially worse. And since they're open 24 hours, there's often a noisy crowd in the late-night/early-morning hours, which I know can be disruptive for nearby residents. read more

Lasagna was horrible. Served cold non melted cheese just a mess staff at 9:30p were indifferent and rude.

Only in NY can you get bagels 24/7! Hardworking staff. Sent fluffy bagels even if they aren't always fresh. read more

Sunset Bagels Cafe & Grill - Sandwiches Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

See all

This spot continues to amaze me with great food, exceptional service and always a great vibe ! It's my daily stop for food and or coffee. If you are in the area it should be yours too read more

I really enjoy ordering from sunset bagels. They have a wide variety of breakfast and lunch items and there's always something new to try. I specifically enjoy their salads such as the Greek and the Sante Fe. Their food is so fresh and they also deliver without a minimum which is convenient. The only reason I give them 4 stars is because the wait time is always a while, whether you order ahead or order in the store it takes some time for the food. However they do have signs in there acknowledging it and they are busy. I will continue to order here as it's a clean place, delicious food, and a great spot in the neighborhood. read more

As a California girl who is constantly bombarded with trash bagels, bagels are probably my favorite thing about visiting NY. I've never had a bag bagel here, and Sunset Cafe is no different. We're visiting my in-laws for the holidays and this place is walking distance from them. My MIL recommended it and I'm glad she did. I got a sesame bagel egg sandwich with scallion cream cheese & a large Hangover Survivor (apple, beets, lemon, carrot, ginger juice). The bagel was solid and overall the sandwich was satisfying. I was really impressed with the juice, too. More than reasonable at ~$8 for a 24oz. Super refreshing! Check this place out when you're in the area read more

Sunset Bagels Cafe & Grill - Sesame bagel, eggs, scallion cream cheese (we ordered delivery) - Sandwiches Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

See all

Below is a picture of a salad that was given to my neighbor. I warned her about this place. Think she'll listen now and stay away. Giving anyone an old salad is NOT ok especially with their prices. She also requested for the shaved cheese to be placed on the side which didn't happen , instead she received two different salad dressings. The service and ambiance was ok. read more

This is a great bagel place! They have many locations and I have eaten from all of them. Definitely recommend this place!

I been ordering from sunset since they open on Ave L I eat and order from here daily because the food is good and can provide receipts today I placed a order for 60$ and all I wanted was them to use whole grain bread for the French toast instead of the other bread and Carla told me she can't do it because they don't use that kinda bread and I told her I been ordering it that way for months just not with her with the male worker she was not trying to assist me in anyway making me second guessing ordering in future smh read more

the food is amazing the service is perfect everyone who works there is nice and always smiling and it's always clean in there and open 24 hours read more

Good bagels, Nice staff (minus the manager), and place looks really nice. Only downside is the foods quality can be inconsistent. For example a bagel could be nice, flavorful and fresh when you order it but when you order it again it could be the exact opposite. Would recommend. read more

Very good really really love the food so amazing. I recommend this for everybody. I will come here all the time. This is so good thank you. We will be back. read more

Their food and different variety that they have will always keep me going back. Last time I went I created my own salad, and it was slamming, not because I chose it. Because of their fresh ingredients!!! read more

I ordered Philly Cheese Steak Panini but its just mostly onions and peppers!! Sunset Bagels in Ave L increased their prices but quality of food went downhill! I remembered ordering this panini and amount of steak and veggies were just right! Now you dont get the quality of food you paid for! read more

Sunset Bagels Cafe & Grill - Philly cheese steak panini but got mostly onions and peppers!! - Sandwiches Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

Definitely one of the best burgers I've ever had! Highly recommend. The onion rings are also pure perfection.

Great food, great selection, great staff. 24/7 operation! Nothing else in the area like it! I highly recommend read more

Sunset Bagels on Ave L never disappoints! The food is always fresh and delicious, and the staff is consistently pleasant and welcoming. Even the delivery guys are friendly and prompt. Definitely a neighborhood favorite! read more

I'm giving these guys 1 star because this place is too pricey and still mess orders up I specifically asked for a grilled chicken Ceasar salad with onions What was given to me was an avocado salad On top of that, they wanted an extra $3 for the chicken and I give the avocado salad back Me and my coworkers are repeat customers, so to try and squeeze an extra $3 and you guys messed up is crazy to me You guys lost the whole office We will not be ordering from this place anymore Mind you this is NOT the 1st time an order was wrong...and we simply let it slide read more

These past few weeks I have ordered my blt on a bagel, I looked forward to every encounter as it was sooo heavenly....until tonight. I received a bagel so thin,stale and hard...I was so disappointedbut it does not stop there...I also received old lettuce with overcooked bacon CRUMBLES...like did the chef get his heartbroken tonight or something??? Que Pasa??? Big lesson well learnedI will not waste another dime for a disaster as I have had tonight read more

This is likely my last review of this place. I really can't stand it anymore. I keep trying to look at the glass half full and give them the benefit of the doubt, but I think I'm done. The food is OK. Nothing to write home about, but OK. But the service has possibly gotten worse, which I didn't think was possible. No less than five people behind the counter, me and one of the customer, and it still takes 15 minutes to get one bagel with butter and one cup of coffee. I don't even know how that's possible. I could make five of those orders in that amount of time. Yapping, joking with each other, I don't know. Then I had to ask one of them to turn the music down, after he had to ask me three times what I was saying. Maybe if you turn down the crappy rap music, you will be able to hear me. It's like a Saturday Night Live skit in there. Highly unlikely that I will ever be back. It's really a shame. All of those workers are very lucky that I don't own that place because they would have been on the unemployment line a long time ago. And now the kicker, just got in the car, and my order is wrong, as is usually the case. One bagel with butter, not toasted, and surprise, surprise, they toasted it anyway. Scotty, beam me up. No intelligent life at this place. read more

Diverse menu is amazing and the drink options are great. The interior is clean and comfortable to sit and dine.

My go to breakfast burrito, every morning would definitely recommend it and also their croissants were actually pretty good buttery & fluffy

Not only do they make the best shrimp salad on earth But the employees are so nice,understanding and patient!!

Continuously paying high prices for orders and they NEVER get the order right. I know prices have gone up and don't mind paying if I get what I'm I ordering. They started out as a great place but now I will not return to this establishment as I am tired of getting ripped off. read more

Great customer service and food. It was very calm and quiet not too much people but still a nice vibe.

Slow service not enough staff to keep up with walk-ins, phone and internet orders. If you want expedited service all in a half an hour to an hour in advance. read more

Ordered from here several times and only one time my order was correct. The delivery guy was extremely rude and disrespectful, definitely won't be ordering from here anymore. read more

First, my order said it was ready so I walked all the way over there for them to tell me they never turn on the machine to receive my order, which is obviously a lie if I had a notification saying it was ready! So I was told to wait, I went to sit down and wait, and they canceled my order I saw the cash app notification pop up and then she come to me saying because the machine wasn't on it automatically canceled my order. Another lie because I saw the girl say she canceled it, and then came over to and told me it has been canceled. I've been going here since I moved back to New York, the bagels isn't even that good I just go because they are somewhat close to my house but they just played in my face and waisted my time, so I most likely won't be returning read more

I must say since moving to the area and grabbing breakfast, lunch, and dinner on occasion from this spot- I havent been disappointed yet. The place is always clean, organized, and extremely friendly. The food is tasty (order a BACONEGGNCHEESE) and so are the hot drinks. Im a latte snob and Karla makes it JUST PERFECT. Truly such a gem in Mill Basin, I hope they stick around and become a neighborhood staple. Keep up the excellent service! read more

Never coming back. My last order, never received an item-was told I would get a refund, never got it. Called back and asked to speak to manager, none available and non wanted to take the call because it was "busy". allegedly took my number from diff shits and never got a follow up for days... my order before that, literally got the WRONG order delivered, had to call about it - this time the manager says their "personal" delivery driver will send my correct order and guess what?? I got the WRONG ORDER AGAIN!! at 2am, my order before that? who forgets the bacon on an bacon egg and cheese? the only pro was it's 24hrs but at this point I've lost so much money that's not even worth it read more

Food always taste good. Service is always available love that its 24 hours . The place is well kept and clean.

Decent bagels, attentive staff but wait times are very long for a typical NYC bagel shop. I waited 20 minutes for a egg and cheese sandwich.