Cancel

Open app

Search

Stone Lodge Tavern

5.0 (1 review)

Stone Lodge Tavern Photos

You might also consider

Recommended Reviews - Stone Lodge Tavern

Your trust is our priority, so businesses can't pay to alter or remove their reviews. Learn more about reviews.
Yelp app icon
Browse more easily on the app
Review Feed Illustration
Photo of Maggie L.
439
72
47

9 years ago

Helpful 2
Thanks 0
Love this 2
Oh no 0

Ask the Community - Stone Lodge Tavern

One13 Social - Tallow fries and short ribs

One13 Social

4.4(129 reviews)
5.4 mi

Absolutely a gem! This locally-owned place elevates the quiet downtown of Carlisle. Everything we…read morehave tried is delicious with complex flavors that complement each bite. The service is consistently great and very attentive to allergy concerns! This is our go-to date night and always our first recommendation for hosting and visitors.

Is this "fine dining" or just another Olive Garden clone? From reviews and business website the…read moreintent is fine dining but they failed completely in my experience. It started off well enough. The maitre d' was friendly and I was made to feel welcome and escorted to my table. A lively, modern dining room that did give off the "relaxed fine dining" vibes. I liked my seat where I could watch the busy bar and the brightly lit open kitchen. I studied the menu. Pretty extensive and, while not crazy-innovative, seemed somewhat above the average in creativity. I decided on the swordfish special. No free bread though. Lack of free bread is almost automatic loss of star for me; this alarming practice must stop. But for some reason I really wanted bread that day. I did find "Smoked Goat Bread" on the menu, the only bread listed, for $14. Hoping for some good focaccia or similar. Far from it. Room temperature, hardly any toasting, soggy, small. For Fourteen Dollars! Tastewise, the chèvre was excessive and the balsamic wasn't enough to balance its tangy, assertive flavor. Not sure what was meant by "smoked," as there was no smoke flavor in it. The swordfish was perfectly cooked and absolutely fresh. And also, unacceptably tiny. The lemongrass sauce may have been great but it was hard to tell, the 9 drops artfully splayed across the plate were woefully insufficient for anything but decoration. The risotto portion also was small with a weird consistency that was both watery and creamy. The carrots, thin and in rainbow colors, were delicious. At least I they were for the 15 seconds it took me to consume the 3 dwarf vegetables, leaving me wanting more. Just like I wanted more swordfish and more risotto. On the way to the rest room I passed the kitchen and saw somebody's salmon plate, with a piece of fish almost 3 times as big as mine. Hey, if swordfish's too expensive, either raise the price and let the customer decide or remove it from the menu. My portion was just insulting. I wasn't drinking alcohol that evening but ordered a mocktail, an alcohol-free margarita. Big mistake! Awful. I've had some great mocktails before and know alcohol isn't always essential but this thing was almost undrinkable, so unbalanced, too sweet, thick, no fresh fruit tang. I didn't order any dessert. I didn't want to risk another disappointment.

Photos
One13 Social
One13 Social - Dishes that had multiple staff pass by on a very small table right near the server station.

Dishes that had multiple staff pass by on a very small table right near the server station.

One13 Social - Mint Julip's aren't just for the Derby!

See all

Mint Julip's aren't just for the Derby!

1794 The Whiskey Rebellion - Beef stroganoff, crab fries, old fashion, and the best ever warm bread and butter.

1794 The Whiskey Rebellion

4.0(224 reviews)
5.2 mi
•$$

My wife and I had dinner at 1794 The Whiskey Rebellion while we were in Carlisle for Corvettes at…read moreCarlisle. We had a 6:30 reservation and were seated right away. I started with a 1794 Old Fashioned, which was good enough that I had a second one with dinner. My wife had a Pinot Noir. I had originally planned on ordering the 14 oz. bone-in ribeye, but after seeing that prime rib was offered as a Friday and Saturday special, I decided to try the Molly Pitcher English-cut prime rib prepared 1794 style with the extra grilling. Unfortunately, about five minutes after ordering, I was told they had sold out. I went back to my original choice of the ribeye, ordered medium rare, with Yukon Smash and the seasonal vegetable, which that evening was corn on the cob. The ribeye was tender and flavorful and cooked the way I wanted it. My wife had the chicken pot pie and enjoyed it, although she thought it could have used a little more butter. Desserts are presented verbally rather than on a printed menu. I had the bourbon apple blondie while my wife chose the skillet cookie, which was topped with ice cream and chocolate drizzle. Both were very good. The restaurant is located inside the Comfort Inn and literally occupies the same space where the hotel's breakfast is served each morning. From our table I could even see the small refrigerator used for the breakfast yogurts, so the setting doesn't provide quite the same atmosphere as a standalone restaurant. Overall, we enjoyed our dinner and I would consider returning when we're back for Corvettes at Carlisle next year. I'd probably make an earlier reservation next time so I could finally try the prime rib.

In downtown Carlisle, 1794 The Whiskey Rebellion captivates you with a unique atmosphere. With a…read moredecent number of sitting options, you feel comfortable with the company at your table. The menu has great options to pick from, and our service was nice and attentive. Most of the table had some of the steak options, from the filets to the medallions and then to the pot pie variation. The mashed potatoes were delicious - great flavor and taste. I'm not even a gravy fan but I wanted more. The steaks were cooked to our liking and flavored well. Would return for a nice dinner again!

Photos
1794 The Whiskey Rebellion - Entrance from hotel lobby

Entrance from hotel lobby

1794 The Whiskey Rebellion - Queen cut prime rib only on Friday and Saturday nights

Queen cut prime rib only on Friday and Saturday nights

1794 The Whiskey Rebellion

See all

Stone Lodge Tavern - cocktailbars - Updated October 2026

Loading...
Loading...
Loading...