I will start off my saying that you should call to make a reservation even on Tuesday. We got there at 7pm and was told we couldn't be seated inside until 8:30 but they had take out and picnic tables outside of we wanted to eat sooner. We did take them up on this offer and was also able to order drinks from the bar. We sat drinking our cocktails and waiting nearly 30 minutes before my boyfriend asked about our food. We were told it would be ready soon. Another 10 minutes and we looked inside to see two seats at the bar. We took them and were told they would bring our food to us. Another 20 minutes went by before we got our first dish and 5 minutes before we had to ask for the second. When we finally got our food, I can say it was a pleasant surprise that both dishes were hot. I ordered the seafood casserole and my boyfriend the whole belly fried clam plate. My seafood was tender, the creamy sherry sauce was perfectly seasoned (I'm a cream sauce snob). The clams were also tender and the cole slaw delicious. Alison was our bartender. She was a delight. Although it really was so busy in there she kept up with her orders and never looked frazzled. She even put the Red Sox game on during all this. She make me a watermelon martini which I highly recommend. Dana, the head chef and owner came out to us asking about our food and offered us a dessert for our long wait. All in all our visit was positive. I would go back again and recommend you trying it. read more

Great spot when getting on the island Superior service, staff very friendly. Fried shrimp platter, fried clams were outstanding, read more

My son, husband and I had dinner here on a rainy night earlier this week and it was excellent. The broiled seafood sampler was interesting, flavorful and well cooked. My son said the paste in his primavera was fresh and al dente. The atmosphere is friendly and unpretentious, which was perfect for my non-dress-up family. And they seated us near the open kitchen, which was warm on a chill night. My other son and his girlfriend have joined me now and I'm taking them back there this evening. read more

We found this after seeing 4 1/2 stars on yelp. We had the chowder, salmon, and stuffed mushrooms. All the food was ok, but not really good. The chowder was thin, and the salmon over cooked. We feel this restaurant is over rated. The prices are high, just not a good feeling. Also I just don't understand the $12 split plate fee. read more

This place has something for everyone. My scallops were among the best I have ever eaten. My son loved his steak, my daughter delighted in her lightly sauced, garlicky scampi and my hubby loved his baked scrod. Good salads too. The staff was prompt, warm and courteous. We will be back! read more

I had the clams casino and prime ribs. The meal was great and the service was attentive. I'll certainly be going back.

This review is of the takeout window only. The Square Rigger used to be my favorite place for lobster rolls and chowder - but this year's price increase is sheer piracy. They jacked up the price for a lobster roll, and it no longer comes with a cup of chowder. By the time you add in the chowder, it amounts to a 20% PRICE INCREASE IN A SINGLE YEAR. 96 bucks for the same tab that was $79 one year ago. You can stuff it Square Rigger - and I don't mean your quahog. read more

Just like the reviews said. Great clams casino. Excellent prime rib. I asked for an end cut was perfect. A little crispy on the edges cooked just the way I wanted it. I would definitely come back. read more

Can't wait to come back here this summer and celebrate our 10yr wedding anniversary here! We have the best memories here ... the food is amazing the .. the lobster ... wine... service it's the best read more

Have eaten inside and from the window for several years now. Reliably excellent. The lobster roll and clam chowder combo is a favorite, but everything is good. Service is also very good. The inside is comfortable and cozy and bigger than it appears on the outside. Will keep coming back! read more

I love everything about this place, from the food to the ambiance to the service. Every time we go to MV we go and it is consistently very good. The family friendly atmosphere is welcoming and relaxed. I like the nautical theme, it's very "islandy" and even if you're not a local you feel like one at their cozy bar. All the people who work there are warm and cheery. read more

We ate here for our only dinner in Martha's Vineyard. I would say it was just average overall. My mom and grandma both ordered the pasta primavera which came with side salads. The pasta dishes were HUGE. They could have shared the dish and still had some left over. It was jam packed with veggies. Based on the size, I was happy I settled on getting the app portion of pasta and the crab cakes. Both were average - the pasta sauce wasn't anything great. Neither my mom or I were too happy with the wines we drank. The atmosphere was exactly what you'd expect for a 'New England' feel in the restaurant. The server was very friendly and prices normal for what you'd expect in the area. read more

Best lobster rolls! I've had both the hot and cold versions- both are excellent and you can't go wrong with either option. The clam showder was OK, not bad but not amazing. read more

This place is alright. Island prices for sure and a little old school, but good steaks.

Went lobster roll and quahog chowder to lunch after we hit the brewery across the street. The chowder was AMAZING. Probably the best I had all week around the cape. Lobster roll was served with potato chips, which I don't like but wife does. I asked to sub fries and still got the chips with the fries on the side. The lobster roll was pretty good... looked like mostly leg and claw meat, no tail... but not a ton of filler mayo or celery. Wife ordered the hot lobster roll, which is a nice option. The lobster meat was cut up, I would prefer it whole, but tasted very good. Overall, a great lunch. read more

Absolutely incredible experience with Chelsea as our waitress. This establishment is authentic, welcoming, mellow, and has phenomenal food. We ordered multiple items including the baked cod, seafood casserole, double-stuffed lobster, clam chowder, and sides and left full and happy. Chelsea was one of the best servers I've ever had and she made the evening priceless. I highly recommend this restaurant for your MV trip, what a time! read more

We had the best service from Laura! The restaurant was very comfortable and the entire staff was very friendly. The food portions and the meals were good. read more

The BEST lobster roll I have ever had!! We asked our hotel concierge where she would go for the best roll on the island and she sent us there. Perfect spot! The owner Tony was absolutely wonderful. There was almost two lbs of lobster in the roll and it came with a delicious cup of chowder. I couldn't even speak as I ate. It was that fantastic. If you are in search of the best lobster roll around... GO to The Square Rigger! Thank you Tony!! read more

Really great food!! We had the bouillabaisse, grilled lobster and prime rib. I think the best was the bouillabaisse. All the sides were delicious as well - especially the rice. Rhonda, our waiter, was really patient with us! read more

The lobster is wonderful. Good variety of drinks. Could improve beer list. Too full for dessert so we got it to go. Staff was top notch.

This restaurant was recommended to us by a number of locals for its farm to table approach to classic American food with a focus on seafood. The food was quite good... I had the clam chowder which, as a chowder snob, was my least favorite thing.... it was a bit too runny and the meat was really chewy to the point of not being edible. (Our waitress, however, was kind enough to take it off of the bill as a result). As for my filet mignon, it was perfect. But the real star was the produce... the side salad (often a "throwaway" at restaurants) was made with incredible local greens and the side veg of a puréed squash was *out of this world* good. My boyfriend had fried clams which were wonderful... perfect breading so as to not overwhelm the wonderful clams. He then got the special... a lobster casserole with a strip steak. The lobster was great and, again, the beef was really nice. All portions were very generous, which led us is to guiltily leave a lot on the table, but apparently they participate in a local composting program, which assuaged most of our guilt. But we both felt, more than anything else, the service was fantastic. Our waitress Laura was a complete doll as well as being highly knowledgeable about the menu... plus, since we were one of the last tables of the evening, she brought over extra au jus and popovers... a real treat! We will most definitely be coming back on our next visit... and I'll just skip the chowder and bask in a massive dish of whatever is in season! read more

ordered scallops. wow! cooked perfectly. baked potatoes were fantastic! tried another guest's steak. again delicious! everyone at our table enjoyed the service and food. will come back! read more

All year long the Square Rigger is our "must go to place" Everything on the menu is terrific. Great specials daily. Give it a try....You will become a regular just like us! read more

Sorry Rigger, but that was the worst "lobster" roll experience I have ever had. Bland, dry, probably not lobster, and absolutely 100% not fresh. This would be the best way to describe what I was served. Disappointing considering there are many options around for actual fresh seafood. read more

This place was very good during our trip to Oaks Bluff Martha's Vineyard! We stoped as this place before heading to the beach. The turkey wrap was great, however the Chicken Salad was amazing! You should definitely stop here on your way to the beach. Just noticed that this is a restaurant and I should have gone there . We will return the next time our family travels to MV. read more

i've been going here all my life and while it is a staple for an older generation of islanders i have never been blown away by the food. it's good, odds are pretty good you'll have a good meal, i'm a big fan of the prime rib with their butternut squash and rice pilaf sides (very tasty) but if you have a seafood allergy you can cut the menu in half, from what i hear all the lobster dishes are amazing, unfortunately i can't partake. the staff here is always very friendly and very helpful, they really know their menu and you will walk away full. read more

Old time comfort food at its best! Gotta love the "Rigga! Prime rib was very tender and flavorful...my friends had the grilled lobster and bragged about it all weekend! The setting is rustic an classic. A visit to the Vineyard is never complete without a stop here! read more

One of the best cuts of prime rib I've ever had. Service was phenomenal, and the food was even better. My favorite place on the Vineyard.

Does exactly wat it says on the tin. Good seafood, friendly service, and fair prices. Difficult to be disappointed when you go to a place like this read more

one of my favorites on the island! awesome food. awesome people. if you don't get a lobster roll here , you're a stupid idiot. best on MV

This a good old fashioned restaurant. You order the entre and get a salad with the meal. We both had the Prime Rib. It was delicious as was the Yorkshire Pudding. read more

Good restaurant... Nice experience... Pretty pricey (36 bucks for a lobster) but overall goof

Best lobster roll Ive ever had. Not quite the views of Menemsha but tasted great.

I had been passing the Square Rigger for years but never stopped in because of its awkward location. So glad I did. It is an old school restaurant with quality food. The Clams Casino are awesome (even if they don't have a piece of bacon on top) The drinks were perfect too. We had the grilled lobster, steak tips with shrimp scampi and steak tips with shrimp alfredo. There wasn't a drop left on our plates, the lobster was fresh and flavorful and the steak tips were cooked to perfection (didn't even use the salt) and the shrimp dishes were a very nice complement. I even enjoyed the salad prior to the meal. We will go back the next time we are on the island. read more

Great place! Decently priced for the vineyard. Love there lunch options and staff is very friendly.

My favorite restaurant on the Vineyard. The broiled lobster stuffed with lobster meat is well worth the price. Owner Tony and his gang deliver great food at a fair price and in a home like setting. The wait staff is efficient, friendly and unobtrusive. Great place to take a date or your family. read more

We had a great dinner. We have overlooked the place so often due to the location but worth a visit. This past week went for lunch & dinner. Preferred lunch dye to cost & service. It's not too expensive but your server makes the meal. It appeared our waitress on Tuesday night was new read more

I have been every where for baked stuffed shrimp and by far this is the best I ever had. The service is superb and the food is amazing. The cozy atmosphere says it all. Salad with all meals is a plus. This is my husbands favorite for Prime Rib.. You will not be disappointed.. read more

This is the second time we have had take out at this restaurant. I can honestly say this is the worst customer service experience imaginable. We were told food would be ready in 10 minutes. We arrived on time and waited at least 40 minutes. By the way we ordered 2 lobster rolls and a shrimp cocktail. The girl at the window never smiled, was nasty when everyone placed their order and thought texting was more important than answering a simple question. "Do you have any idea how much longer? "The reason she gave me for the wait... The burner on the stove wasn't working. Really?? I told her I overheard the cook in the back say he never got an order for lobster rolls. Save your money, there are plenty of other restaurants in Edgartown that REQUIRE their staff to treat everyone with respect. This is a non negotiable lesson in life that this restaurant does not practice read more

We went here on Saturday, August 12, for dinner. There were 4 of us, myself, my husband, my sister and her husband. We received a warm welcome upon arriving. Our waitress, Laura, was amazing! She has a great personality and extremely knowledgeable of the menu and the cooking styles. We had the fried clam appetizer special which was the best fried clams I've ever had and I'll admit I'm quite the aficionado! It was lightly battered, large portion and delicious. I had the baked stuffed lobster which was moist and the stuffing made me keep eating even after I was full because I couldn't get enough of it! My husband had the sautéed lobster, he wanted all the deliciousness of the lobster but not have to work for it, ha! My sister and her husband both had the seafood special of sea bass with Cajun spices. My brother in law also got his with shrimp on top. We are still talking about our food, waitress and service three days later. We will definitely go back and bring our kids next time. They have a great kids menu too! Please run, don't walk to this hidden gem! read more