So this is a mixed review. I really enjoyed my grilled lobster. It was delicious! My husband got the surf and turf. He really enjoyed the shrimps but the steak was bland, small, and poor quality, but the price doesn't reflect this. I was ok for the kids but I wouldn't say it was overly kid friendly either. Glad I tried the lobster though. Also, they served warm bread... yum! read more

See all

So good, the bread was soft and fresh. The dill salad dressing was amazing. The entrees of scallops & seafood casserole...out of this world. Highly recommend! read more

Square-Rigger Restaurant - Seafood Near Me - Edgartown, Massachusetts

Definitely not what it used to be. This has been a family favorite for years. Tonight, though, we were charged $80 for a steak that was almost entirely fat and gristle. When we complained, the server spoke with management. They offered 1 free dessert (maybe a $10 value?). When we declined because there wasn't a dessert anyone was interested in having, they simply gave us the bill, charging us the full amount for the steak. We essentially paid $80 for nothing! The restaurant was nearly empty the entire evening. The party next to us left without ordering anything. After our experience tonight, I can't say we will ever be back. read more

Wanted to treat my family to some really good lobster so this was the spot! You can get a whole lobster baked, grilled, on a roll...anyway you want! It's just a few minutes from downtown and walking distance to Bad Martha Brewery so it's a good spot for an afternoon lunch! read more

Square-Rigger Restaurant - Seafood Near Me - Edgartown, Massachusetts

Had a lovely experience there! New decor, new menu, great service and fresh delicious food!! Would highly recommend

Stumbled upon this restaurant and they were thankfully open!!! The lobster roll and clam chowder were AMMMAZZINNNG!!! So good and the staff is so friendly especially Kim!!! read more

One of my favorite places for dinner on MV. Food is great but it can be a bit loud inside during "normal" not COVID times. I highly recommend this restaurant as the food can't be missed. read more

After passing this restaurant's outside stand dozens of times and wondering how good their food is or isn't, I stopped by to sample a pint of their fried clams. ($20+). My assessment is it seemed like they were cooked by a beginner. The whole bellied clams were very small, the strips tough and the crust was thick and looked like something I might find in CT. My advice try someplace else. read more

Excellent soup! Affordable and welcoming. Had takeout and will go back next summer. I hope to eat inside next summer.

We live in Edgartown four to five months out of every year, beginning in July. Compared to Oak Bluffs, Edgartown's restaurant take-out scene is quite limited. There are the few high-end restaurants in downtown Edgartown that are open for the season. For in-restaurant dining, they are first rate. When they close, Edgartown's choices are very narrow. The Square Rigger's menu is substantially seafood oriented. That would be fine if the offerings were more imaginative and tasty. There is no effort to use local produce, herbs or other chef-inspired ingredients to make the menu offerings more flavorful. For example, the salmon is crying out for a tasty marinade--it is so bland that it's boring, even with lemon. There are no fresh vegetables on the menu! Summer on the Vineyard provides a bounty of fresh vegetables and the only things on this menu are mashed potatoes, string beans and sad carrots. No fresh, imaginative types of lettuce are used in their limited salad offerings. The Square Rigger does offer fresh seafood but unimaginatively prepared. Finally, the pricing for this dull menu is exorbitant. It's like being stuck in a hotel with an over-priced menu. Square Rigger should borrow a page from Lookout Tavern and Offshore Ale for taste, imagination and pricing. read more

We arrived about 30 minutes before the restaurant opened, but the owner welcomed us in for an early lunch. We were fortunate to have found this gem of an eatery, as everything from the food to the service, was top notch! The clam chowder was absolutely perfect, as was the pulled pork BBQ sandwich! The owner was a great source of local info, and helped us to plan the rest of our day on the Vineyard. If I could only suggest one place to eat on MV, it would be this one! We will certainly return! read more

Great local spot. Great place to pick up your food or stop while biking from town to town. Lobster roll, chicken salad sandwich were delicious. read more

Good chow and service. We ate at the bar and were happy campers. Not your normal chain bar food. We would definitely return. read more

We've been coming to the island for years and I never knew until this year that this was a fully functioning restaurant and not just a take out spot. We ordered dinner from there and I got two stuffed lobsters. They were absolutely amazing! The stuffing seemed to be made out of Ritz crackers and lobster meat. In fact, I was finding full lobster claw meat in the mix. I'm looking forward to trying some of the other tasty looking items on this menu. This may turn into one of my favorites. read more

Do you have an affectionate relationship with cholesterol and calories? Do you reminisce about the beautifully cooked roast beef and Yorkshire Pudding of yesteryear? Do you appreciate lots of butter? Cream? Traditional Olde New England Yankee Fare? This place is for you. Big time. When my sweet folks are in town, they want to go here. And so we do. It's traditional, comfortable and predictable. Lobster (any way you want it), steak, fish and chips,clams - basic New England goodness. It is NOT a unique, gourmet fine dining experience. It IS an inviting, old fashioned comfort zone with very easy parking (excellent news in August) and a familiar, traditional environment. Sometimes you just need a place like this to warm you up and fill you to the brim with basic comfort food. It's here waiting for you. All the time. We like that very, very much, read more

If I have only one dinner on MV, this is where I go - the best lobster presentation on the island (grilled with extra lobster meat) in an unpretentious atmosphere. They also offer salmon, prime rib, and other grilling specialties. The Square Rigger is one of the oldest restaurants on MV tracing its history back to the early 1800s. In the winter of 1966, I had a dinner here when it was only one of three restaurants, as I recall, that was open in the winter months. About 30 years later it was purchased by Doreen and Tony Rezendes who own and operate the restaurant today. Located at Edgartown's "Triangle", the Square Rigger has parking for patrons which, in Edgartown in the summer, is worth something! For more, read Dorothy W's excellent review here on Yelp. read more

Geez. I must have driven by this place for years and only recently stopped in this December for dinner. Well I missed out on many evenings of great dinners at this place. Since it was my first visit I kept in simple ordering their sirloin steak which was flavorful and cooked perfect. I was taken back by the size of the baked potato. It was very small but was also good. The dinner came with a side salad and a loaf of warm bread. My server was very friendly. We laughed and had a great conversation during my visit and I was happy to leave her a generous tip. All and all a fine dinner at the Square Rigger. I will return very soon. read more

I service an account that's close by the Rigger and I'm glad for that. Always an enjoyable experience. AWESOME lobster roll that comes with a large bowl of very good chowder. Fried items are tasty and never greasy. Very cute atmosphere if a bit dark due to the dark woods in the decor. Nice service staff--I've never had an issue with any service there. That's why I always go back. Free parking and a take-out window as well keeps you moving. read more

Best meal I had on the Vineyard, BY FAR. Crazy fun fact, they have a lot of odd and DELICIOUS salad dressings, give those a try! Also the serve a little mini loaf of bread at the beginning that is delicious and fresh out of the oven! I have a gluten allergy and the chef and server were not only very knowledgable and cautious about it, but they had an immediate solution whenever I came across something with gluten. My husband and his friend had the filet mignon and there's only one way to describe it... WOW. One ordered medium and one medium rare and they were both cooked to perfection. They came with a bearnaise sauce (which I usually don't like) that was KILLER! I'm not a big fan of sauces with steaks (I feel if it's a good steak, it doesn't need sauce) but it was served on the side and was absolutely delicious. My friend and I both had the Bouillabaisse, but we had two different versions which was fun. Because I had told the server that I had a gluten allergy, she let me know that the chef makes that dish in the same way but with some different ingredients for the sauce. The regular version is a tomato based broth, which was delicious. Mine was a garlic and oregano based broth and it was EVEN BETTER! This should definitely be on the menu!!!! That dish was one of the best meals I have ever eaten! Our server was Brittney and she was amazing. So helpful, SO attentive, SO sweet, and super funny! She made our whole experience even better! read more

I have been coming here for lobster rolls and chowder - to go for 3 years. THE BEST LOBSTER ROLLS EVER. Only a tiny bit of mayo, a buttered roll, perfect never fishy fresh lump meat. TO DIE. Chowder is good but not neccessary but I think it's a good deal for 19 bucks - fills you up and is DEVINE! Fast service too and easy parking. read more

This is my favorite restaurant on the island, the service is AMAZING, especially if you get a girl named Laura. I love the ambiance of the place and the food is perfect. read more

Very disappointing dinner at first time after they reopened for the season. I'm hoping it's because they need time to get in the groove. The drinks were great, well prepared. The clams casino were delicious. The prices are outrageous for what they offer. The Captain's Cut Prime Rib was $98.00!!!. Fine but it only comes with a limited selection of either a Caesar Salad(bottled dressing, boxed croutons, not an anchovy offered) and pasty mashed potatoes or bland white rice. The baked stuffed lobster was $78.00. It was a small (maybe 1.5 lb.) with very little stuffing. It was over cooked and very dry. Very disappointing. The chef came over to ask why I didn't eat it and volunteered to me that it looked so dry. He then offered to give us half off the price. We will see if that comes true. I am sad this old standard restaurant is so off balance. With the abundance of great produce on this island, it would be nice if they incorporated some in the menu. The wait staff was lovely and was apologetic that the food came out so quickly . Definitely pre-made. read more

the takeout window for this restaurant is outrageous!!! they put out the wrong menu and then made us wait almost an hour twice!!! im am never going to this place again they take far too long for a small order of a sandwich and chowder! please heed my warnings and do not support theire takeout area!!!! read more

For a beach-side, no frills-type of joint, TSR serves up FLAWLESS lobster. LOBSTER ROLLS and CHOWDA. Holy Jesus. Lobster roll was just under $15- and not huge but enough; lobster is rich! TSR blesses with fresh, delectable, tender in that stringy way, juicy and sweet lobster. With just a bit of mayo and black pepper, in a simple white bread bun; perfection. The roll actually came with a half pint of chowder, which left nothing to be desired. read more

(3.5 stars). Dorothy W says it well- this place is classically New England circa 1970 (think: a better version of Ye Old Oyster House in Boston), from its somewhat bland decor to its extensive seafood menu where everything can be cooked either in butter or cream (I do think there are a few "cajun spice" options if you're feeling adventurous). The meal starts with a warm loaf of bread served on a cutting board, and a plate of simple salad (very large greens, shredded carrots, and a few croutons). Everything we sampled was tasty- the scallops (cooked in butter) were delicious, the salmon (served with a creamy sauce), the very creamy clam chowder, and so on. And all the dishes were served with the veggie of the day -- yesterday: corn on the cob. Nothing was surprising, inventive, or interesting - this is solid, very New England sea food fare, at Martha's VIneyard prices. read more

First and foremost, you can order via delivery on www.mvtakeout.com. This makes it super easy for visitors without a vehicle. Keep in mind there's a $16 delivery charge. However from west tisbury it's worth the cost. Try getting a taxi for less. Uber might be a possibility. I ordered a burger, mushroom, onion and cheese, fries and a pint of quahog chowder. The burger was perfectly cooked with a proper amount of condiments. It was rather large! Fries were fries. The drive to me might have taken away some of their crispness. I would highly recommend the burger. I wouldn't call myself a chowder pro my any means. So keep in mind this is just my opinion. From a thickness standpoint it was just right, not thin just certainly not corn starch thick. The potatoes were bitesized and tender. The flavor was spot on. Perfect creaminess with a touch of tang. The quahogs were tender and flavorful. However, I wish there was just a bit more clam in the soup. That would by my only complaint. Otherwise, I would have given 5 stars. This place isn't cheap but I certainly think it's better than some of the other options on the island. Having the option for delivery really makes it a no brainier. read more

I've yet to eat there but I get take away every year. The food is good, the out door take away window is convenient and the prices are reasonable. The fish and chips, the fish isn't breaded, that was odd but it was still good. read more

I have eaten at the Rigger before, generally have swordfish or Prime Rib - always very good Tonight I was all set for Prime Rib - sold out :( Laura behind the bar recommended a Stripe Bass caught earlier today by the owners son Best Fish I have had all year Choice was butter and lemon or Cajun - I choose butter / lemon best $38.00 I have spent all summer Not including a excellent house Cabernet -CK Mondavi - I choose the wine before they told me sold out Prime Rib Laura & Jen we're Great read more

The staff was great and the bartender was funny. Even though the place was packed, they managed to keep up. The food was very tasty and fresh. read more

Consistently this place pleases me. Fantastic Prime Rib, spectacular Fresh Catch specials and seafood that I always enjoy. Service this past time was friendly and helpful although inexperienced. Bar beverages are excellent. Food is pricey and ambiance is rustic. One of my favorite local places to eat. read more

I was told by locals to come here for the best calm Chowder, and boy were they right. Without a doubt the best clam chowder I've ever had. The lobster was pretty good but I was also blown away by their prime rib. Did not except to get such a fine piece of beef on the island. read more

Square-Rigger Restaurant - Seafood Near Me - Edgartown, Massachusetts

See all

My friend and I came here to try out their lobster rolls. We ordered one of each-- hot and cold-- to try them both. Each were good-- with well toasted rolls and a decent amount of lobster. The lobster roll with warm butter was our favorite. The location of this spot is great-- you can swing by here while you are out riding your bike or on the way to (or from) the beach. If you are a fan of lobster rolls, you should stop here. read more

Best grilled lobster!! Wonderful seafood selection. Love the chowder. Take out window is convenient. Family owned and operated- great people. read more

See all

Great place for a solid old school casual dinner with family. Prime rib is huge. Popovers. Friendly staff. Nothing fancy but you feel good when you leave and you still have some money left in your wallet! read more

I've been to MV for years. My bride and I honeymooned there 25 years ago. We return every year for our anniversary. As it was a special occassion we dined at the Rigger. We were warmly greeted and felt very welcome. Service was perfection as was the French campagne. A hot freshly baked loaf of bread was delivered. It was great. Now on to the food. It was good but not great. I had their speciality dish that is a split grilled extra stuffed lobster. I looked beautiful. However it was overcooked and the generous portion of lobster meat tasted old. The bride had a special that was a ribeye with lobster casserole. We assumed it would be grilled but it was a thin slice of prime rib. It was basically raw and served at room temperature. The lobster casserole looked great but the lobster tasted day old at least. I will confess that I ate here raw rib and I was in heaven. I love raw meat. I know, that's weird. Two stars for the food and one for the great service. Prehaps the many large takeout volume distracted the two cooks in the open kitchen. I wish this Vineyard staple was better. read more

Dining area very very hot Been going here for years but they need new air conditioners badly --- Food and service excellent Never fails to be 5 star read more

Delightful evening with my family. Baked stuffed and boiled lobsters received great reviews from my sons. Really strong mussel app big enough for entree. Great chowder and clams casino. We have been several times over the years and will be back. read more

I love the Square Rigger! All of their food is delicious! Good, home style meals all starting with fresh made bread, soup or salad. My favorite dish is the Lobster Newberg - complete creamy/lobstery/flaky goodness! Another top seller is the prime rib. Always tender and the best part is that they give you choice of the center piece, captains cut or and end cut. I definitely recommend the rigger for a night out for any occasion! read more

My husband and I dined here for dinner. They take reservations but none were required for the evening we visited. The food was good but not exceptional. All entrees come with salad, vegetable, and choice of potato or rice, so quite a bit of food! Reasonably priced for the island. Again, the food was good, but not great. The service was friendly and accommodating. read more

Food just ok. Ambience meh. Salmon overcooked. Jukebox a little loud. Overpriced. When we asked to split an entree we were told there is a $12 splitting charge, but hey you get extra rice or potatoes. read more