On this episode of eating my way through Martha's Vineyard, we stopped at Square Rigger, one of the island's well-known staples. All I wanted that day was some fried shrimp and clam strips -- and for me, the strips are key because they skip the extra parts you get with whole clams. Unfortunately, they were out of clam strips, so we went with fried shrimp, fries, and lobster bisque. Since I had to share with my wife, I asked for extra shrimp -- but heads up, it's $3 per shrimp. Not complaining, just letting you know. The lobster bisque came out hot and creamy, but I was hoping for a bit more depth of flavor and a little more lobster meat and a little less bisque. The shrimp were tasty and fried well, but personally, I prefer mine butterflied for that extra texture and presentation. What stood out most, though, was the service. Friendly, quick, and attentive, which matters a lot when you're trying a local favorite. Overall, Square Rigger delivers a solid experience, but I left wishing for just a little more -- especially when you're at a place with that kind of reputation. Verdict: Good shrimp, great service, but I'll be back hoping for those clam strips next time. read more

My family and I live in Arizona. When we called to make a reservation. We called at 5pm(AZ)/8pm(EST) on Friday several weeks before our visit. A member of the family had requested this location for her birthday dinner. The person who answered the phone "Idk. It's Friday night. I don't have time for this. It's busy." This should have been our first red flag. A separate conversation and call at another time, the GM asked over the phone if we'd like a cake or something special brought in. Very thoughtful. "Yeah we'd love that! Thank you!" When we arrived at our reservation time, the table had to be rearranged while the party waited. Our party was 8 people. When we inquired about the cake, no one present had any idea what we were talking about. They kindly offered to put a sampler dish together which we accepted but all other food and drink took so long, we cancelled it because we just wanted ultimately just wanted to leave. This is a steak house. A few people at the table ordered steaks with a medium center. Plates were brought out and we were advised the steaks had a medium. Every single steak was completely grey inside(well done). There was not a spot of pink inside. We didn't ask for a replacement steak, we just let them know so they would be aware for future steaks and someone else's future steak! We didn't bother asking for the replacement steak because it already took incredibly long for us to get our food and we were hungry. The waitress never apologized. She didn't look like she wanted to be there and was awkwardly hovering between the 2 tables they had filled. Two new steaks were brought out which we thought was nice but it was also suspiciously fast considering our previous long wait. We cut into the new steaks, almost completely raw. There was a man that poured water for us when we sat. He was the only one that looked like he enjoyed working there and showed any real customer service. The menu says 8oz sirloin and instead you get a 10oz New York strip. A larger piece sounds good but it's not what we asked for when we were ordering our food. If you're going to serve a different cut and size, why would you not change your menu? Or at least let customers know when ordering. Drinks were HEAVY. Can't complain about the quality of liquor. The drinks would be put on the table and take almost 10 minutes to get the next drink. The bartender was kind a remixed one of our drinks when we asked to sweeten it. Just wish drinks came out faster. The other food was great! We had pastas, salmon, vegetables, and mashed potatoes. They were very tasty. If the service, and steaks were better, this place would be recommended as it had beautiful flavor. The steak would have been perfect too if they knew how to cook it! read more

Bottom Line: Seafood and American fare served in what feels like an upscale sea shanty. My husband and I enjoyed our last night in MV at Square-Rigger and we had a great experience. Visiting in the shoulder season the restaurant was quiet. We enjoyed the decor that had a sophisticated sea shanty feel and the food was even more sophisticated. We skipped appetizers, although there were plenty of tempting options, and went right for main courses consisting of a filet mignon and seafood pasta. Service was great and we appreciated that this restaurant was not in the thick of the high traffic touristy areas. read more

Everyone was so welcoming and the food was *chefs kiss*. We had dinner there twice in one week and everything was incredible. The chicken croquettes, the meat skewers, the BBQ pork ribs, the prime rib, bacon-wrapped scallops... wishing we had more time to try more of the menu! read more

Square-Rigger Restaurant - Prime Rib - Seafood Near Me - Edgartown, Massachusetts

See all

For years I went to the ToGo window not knowing there was a sit down restaurant on the other side! The ToGo window is amazing but inside it's "Amazing Grace!" The staff was wonderful and the food (lobster roll, scallops, lobster ravioli and cocktails) was great! A hidden charm on the island! read more

We stopped here as my wife remembered the food being really good from a visit last year. Now wondering if the ownership has changed. According to my wife, there were far fewer seafood choices on the menu. Lots of Brazilian choices, however. My son had a hot dog and fries. My wife had the salmon and I chose the seafood scampi. The salmon was simple and cooked fine, nothing to write home about. The scampi had "local" seafood (littlenecks, mussels) plus shrimp and calamari. The sauce was buttery but could have use more garlic. Overall, okay food and fair service. read more

We simply got takeout, so there were no servers, or an ambiance really. Besides this, we ended up with delicious food! The lobster bisque was extremely rich and creamy. I could feel it boiling in my stomach and sizzling on my taste buds. Though, The clam chowder was good, but average in my opinion. We also ordered some fish tacos which were so wonderful. The fish was soft inside, had a nice outer crisp/crunch, and wasn't overly oily like most fired fish. The slaw and diced were a fresh nice touch. Additionally, the avocado was creamy and a nice temp. Oh, we also got orange juice which was freshly squeezed and I could taste the youthful freshness of it. Overall, delicious food :) read more

Square-Rigger Restaurant - Orange juice - Seafood Near Me - Edgartown, Massachusetts

See all

We've stopped here for a Lobster Roll lunch at the outside window but never made it inside. Came for dinner and it was very cute. Maybe 10-12 tables, small bar, open kitchen with the grill up front. Quick service for seating and drinks, yummy bread with oil to start. We had the Wagyu burger and the seared scallops with the Lobster Lollipop for a starter - and that was a great appetizer. Considering that it was pretty quiet - it took a while to get our food. I could not tell the difference between prime beef and Wagyu, so that was lost on me, good burger though. The scallops were excellent. Overall it was really a nice place for any kind of occasion, or no occasion other than dinner time. read more

Square-Rigger Restaurant - Seared Scallops - Seafood Near Me - Edgartown, Massachusetts

Takeout Window Only My takeout was absolutely delicious as always. very pleasant young lady taking my order thanks for the great food as I drove home. read more

Used to be fun. Poorly run nowadays. They randomly close early for lunch "because someone new is in the kitchen." What?! Clams are still pretty good. Avoid the milky chowder. read more

Stopped in for lunch - limited menu, slow service, bland food. Very overpriced. The music was unnecessarily loud at 1pm with only two tables in the entire restaurant (should've been a red flag). read more

Not worth the effort. Hoping to rediscover an old favorite but will not be returning. Food was decent, however the service was inattentive, sporadic and seemed uninformed. We saw people leaving because they weren't attended to in a timely manner. Entrées came out one at a time with large gaps of time in between. Also felt like it was overpriced for what we got. Awkward and disappointing. Food was okay and the place has potential if they make significant improvements to their service. read more

Sometimes you just want very fresh food, simply prepared, friendly service and -- a rarity in Edgartown--easy parking. And did I mention, very generous and delicious cocktails? If so, the Square Rigger may fit the bill. At the waiter's suggestion, I had the crispy salmon, well prepared, nearly enough for two. My husband had the seafood scampi which was again very fresh and tasty. And my caipirinha was huge (at least a double) and excellent. Pair it with genuinely friendly service, and you've had an enjoyable, tummy-satisfying night out. read more

Swardfish needed a steak knife to cut so over cooked again price is high it's not worth it

Outstanding. 5 star all the way. Cute ambiance. The bar area and the restaurant section both have a bit of character. Even though it's was 9:45 and close to closing, we had Excellent service and the food was absolutely AMAZING! The scallops we delish and the lobster ravioli made my night! Last year I had food from the carry out and didn't even know the sit down portion was an option. This was by far on of my favorite meals on the island this week. A must try on the island!! And for me a must visit again when I'm back! read more

See all

Food was beyond exceptional. Cuisine is modern and authentic. Drinks were great. Fun staff- gave us complimentary shot which is always good. Modern atmosphere. read more

Square-Rigger Restaurant - Coconut Shrimp - Seafood Near Me - Edgartown, Massachusetts

See all

Upon approaching the counter and disclosing my son's food allergies, the woman behind the counter had no interest in helping us. It was startling to encounter such apathy read more

Not The Square Rigger I remember... I got the prime rib which came with no veggies or any sides at all. When I asked for a baked potato they were out. The person who took my order was nice but agreed that the kitchen was slacking.. Definitely an expensive disappointed. read more

wonderul servers, food is amazing and the atmosphere is energetic! Made sure we were always taken care of and kept our water topped off.

Such a cute restaurant that has a great place to eat, drink, and cool off. Service was wonderful and attentive. Clam Chowder 10/10 best Clam Chowder since traveling Boston New England area. read more

Square-Rigger Restaurant - Cod fish sandwich, pain killer, berry margarita. - Seafood Near Me - Edgartown, Massachusetts

See all

Square-Rigger Restaurant's lobster roll to go or stay is not to be missed for a great casual dining. We each had the lobster roll, me cold with mayo and my wife had the warm lobster roll with butter. The lobster rolls were chock full of lobster. French fries and salad are ala cart. You get lobster roll. Good quick service as we were first when the take out window opened. Less than 2 minutes from Stop & Shop in Edgartown. read more

This was supposed to be a 3lb lobster. Unfortunately it was not. The explanation from the chef did not meet with my dining party's satisfaction. Neither did the 45 minute wait to be seated past our scheduled dinner reservation. Another group walked in without reservations and delayed our seating because of Their slow departure. Meanwhile, we had to stand in the bar area looking crazy because we were a party of 8 and due to the rain, there was nowhere else to wait. We were not offered any complimentary food or beverages for our Inconvenience. And the apology given was not heartfelt or satisfying. The food was good but the service was poor, hurried and disappointing. This used to be my annual stop on my visit to Martha's Vineyard. After 6 years I am sure this is the last time. read more

Square-Rigger Restaurant - Seafood Near Me - Edgartown, Massachusetts

A local sent me here Totally loved this place but it's small so get your reservations in early!!! We sat at the bar. Great bartender!! Allison The manager hostess was great she made us feel at home and knew almost everyone by name that came in the door!!! I had the garden salad with grilled shrimp. The shrimp were nice size and the salad delicious The fried shrimp platter came with a ton of tasty French fries and the shrimp lightly breaded and fried to perfection Comes with a salad and home baked bread We split the mud pie for dessert it was great and a huge portion Drinks reasonably priced with a good pour You will not be disappointed!!!! read more

Great dinner with friendly attentive service. We have been coming here for years but with a change in ownership were apprehensive as to what we would find this year. The dining room has been updated and is bright and inviting. Staff was excellent and service was brisk but not pushy. Prime rib was delicious, perfectly cooked and clam chowder on par with island fare. Also ordered the seafood carbonara which was filled with delicious clams, shrimp, and other delights. Highly recommend for an evening out. read more

Great service, amazing cocktails as well as well as mocktails. Our party of five had amazing food !!! New and fresh atmosphere compared to the original Square Rigger. Would highly recommend giving it a try. Another plus is that there is ample parking. read more

Ordered takeout when we were on the vineyard because there weren't a ton of options. The food was decent but pretty expensive for what we got. Good clam chowder. Also got fried clams and two lobster rolls and believe it was over $90 read more

Excellent traditional lobster roll. Finally! Someone who actually knows how to make a real lobster roll. Here's the breakdown, you butter the outside of a new england style bun. You grill it so it's golden brown and just slightly crunchy. You take nice fresh lobster meat (celery is optional) toss it cold with mayo and pile it high on that bun. The lobster is cold, the bun is warm, the food is fresh and light. That's the most perfect thing in the world and Square Rigger totally nails it! We had rolls all over the vineyard and Square Rigger was the best by far. Although I haven't tried everywhere, I'm ready to bet the they have the best roll on the island. read more

Square-Rigger Restaurant - Seafood Near Me - Edgartown, Massachusetts

See all

We sampled 6 different lobster rolls in our week's stay and this one is the best. My wife likes the cold(traditional) but I preferred the hot. Either way, avoid the clam chowder. By far the worst we tried out of 4 restaurants because it was watery/thin and lacked much flavor. read more

Phenomenal meal and service. The lobster bisque is light and not too creamy, with big chunks of delicious lobster in it. We split the lobster roll (hot) and the steak sandwich - both are phenomenal. The chimmichuri on the steak sandwich makes it a perfect lunch or dinner. read more

Delicious. Everything was great including the service. Clams casino and stuffed shrimp were wonderful.

I've never been in the place. Heard it's outdated. But takeout is quick, easy and affordable

Red Lobster quality. Martha's Vineyard prices. Clam chowder and lobster was below average at best. I've honestly purchased larger and higher quality shrimp and scallops at Kroger in the Midwest. On the positive side, our server could not have been nicer, it wasn't her fault that the food quality was so poor. read more

Pricey but excellent food. All three of us enjoyed our food. I think my wife had some form of bouillabase. The kid had a lobster dish with a creamy sherry sauce. She actually found it too rich, but it was good. I had scallops which were large and fresh and zero grit. Andies Candies a nice touch for after dinner mints. read more

Recommended by one of my besties this summer and food was delicious! A must go to spot while in MV!

Terrific servers and friendly staff serving outstanding lobster dishes. I loved their lobster roll. High proportion of locals to tourists is always a good sign. My bride says Square Rigger has the best fish & chips in Massachusetts. We will definitely return. read more

We arrived when there were maybe five people in the restaurant. We waited ten minutes for water. We ordered and the apps arrived pretty promptly but the mains arrived 40 minutes later, 2 at a time, 5 minutes apart. We all ate at different times and the food was not good. Never again read more

We really loved this restaurant! The food is great as is the service. The decor is super homey and the staff is very warm and friendly. We had: Swordfish - totally delicious Grilled Lobster extra stuffed - very good! Grilling a lobster in its shell gives it a delicious smokey flavor and it wasn't dry at all Hamburger - my daughter loved it Crab cakes with corn on the cob - my other daughter loved it Mudslide Cake with ice cream and fudge - very good All the entrees came with salad and rice or baked potato. This is a super kid friendly restaurant. read more

Nothing fancy. It's convenient. They have cold beer and good sandwiches. It's an 'order at the counter' and sit outside on picnic tables kind of place. Definitely hits the spot! read more

Has gone downhill. Nowhere near as good as it was years ago. the fried clams were severely over fried and much much to crunchy. honestly they were the worst I can remember having anywhere. read more

I'm sad to say that things have changed for the worse. I've gotten the chowder in past years and it was always wonderful. I got chowder this season, I was so l disappointed. It's so thick with no stock. It tasted like flour.. I couldn't eat it..So sad.. Miss the old Rigger read more