Love these cupcakes! A friend brought some for my birthday & it was a big hit. This was my first…read moretime visiting the location. Cupcakes are so moist but don't fall apart. And the flavors are amazing! Wish I had gotten more! Staff was very helpful. There is a big step to get inside.

Cupcakes are delicious!!! Definitely recommend!! They have a Knicks inspired cupcake in a jar!!!…read more Small place but a very nice staff!!

Ughh so disappointed. Found this place off of Yelp and…read morewalked in to pick up a birthday cake. Went with the raspberry vanilla. It looks great and was excited to try buttermilk from all the great reviews, but was so disappointed when we tasted the cake. Icing was hard and extremely sweet, even the kiddos said it was too sweet. The inside cake was dense. I'm thinking the cake was old and was sitting in the fridge for a while. But for $47.50 I am disappointed.

Let me tell you, Buttermilk Bakeshop has been in my rotation for years, and it's only gotten…read morebetter. From the old tiny window setup to the new roomier location you can actually step into, it finally matches the charm of what they bake. Cases full of sweets, that warm bakery smell, and creations that feel like someone bottled joy and added sugar. note: I am not a pumpkin spice person. That cookie turned me into a believer for at least five minutes, then it vanished because we inhaled it. Staff is consistently sweet and on it. Past wins include cupcakes, tiramisu in a cup, and a parade of cookies that make decision-making a sport. Great for birthdays, thank-yous, or those just-because moments that make a week better. 5/5. Trust me, I'm a pro.

loved the cupcakes we picked out! I got the vanilla confetti cupcake & a smore's bar for the road…read more I wish the cupcakes had filling! Service was helpful and nice, recommended choices; and the shop itself was cute and welcoming! I would have gotten a cake, but I was just visiting for the weekend!

We got a couple of items. Two Iced Chai Lattes, a vanilla cupcake and the strawberry shortcake…read moreslice. The lattes and slice were extremely sweet I have a sweet toothe so didn't mind but if you are not into sweets it may be too much. The cupcake was a good balance as the cake was semi sweet and the frosting brought the flavor

Fantastic service, great desserts! We don't live in Brooklyn…read morebut we make a point to stop by here and splurge. They make delicious in-store ice cream. The carrot cake and cookies and cream are worth all the pain I suffer with lactose intolerance. The cookies, pastries, cakes change day-to-day but never disappoint. Flavors I'd never bother eating anywhere else I enjoy here. A kimchi croissant, the carrot cake, and cheesecake. Just so delicious. We also had them do a custom birthday cake which they nailed! My party guests RAVED about it for weeks.

The cupcakes here a delicious and my family ordered a birthday cake here a it was amazing. When you…read morewalk in you feel appreciated and welcome by customer support staff. It's needed in the community.

My order: Order…read more#DFF59 - Uber Eats. Butterly Bakeshop Order completed * Dec 31, 2025 at 2:55 PM Your order 2 GF Dulce De Leche Cupcake - hard cake, dumped 2 Chocolate Cupcake - good 2 Blackout Cupcake - good 2 Apple Pie Cheesecake - top was hard, didn't try it dump 1 Carrot Loaf Mini - hard icing dumped 1 Turtle Cake Slice - hard cake, dumped 1 Brooklyn Blackout Cake Slice - good Purchased for family members for new year's celebration. Recommendation: icing and decoration can look great but if the cake is has no taste or is hard it's a hard pass.

After trying another slice of cake from here I don't think I'll ever want to return . I had a…read moreraspberry Bundt cake one evening and it tasted as though they used old eggs to make it. The fruitiness , fluffiness and texture were all good except the flavor . All I was reminded of was just eggs . It was disgusting . I also observed a cake they had advertised on a sign infront of their cheesecake and it looked very unappealing but I should have let that deter me from giving this place another chance .

The customer service was great and the desserts were amazing moist buttery and not too sweet. My…read morefavorite though was that amazing banana pudding. Including the Biscoff banana pudding. Would make you park your car outside and wait form them to open in the morning. That Good!

The cupcakes are delicious and the store is very clean. The customer service is lacking though…read more When you go into a business it is the job of the owner to sell to customers what's in their store. When I arrived at this shop with my granddaughter and the person behind the counter was chilling in a chair engaging with her phone and didn't ask if she could help us or anything. At one point, after being there about two minutes just viewing the products in the case the person said, without looking up from her phone, let me know when you're ready. I said, I'm ready!!! I bought five cupcakes and called it a day. I hope their customer service changes or I won't be supporting them.

I only gave her 24 hours to customized the cake and she execute it perfectly. The only downside for…read moreme was the outside cream was hard and not a soft cream. I know she needs to do that to stabilize the cake. $95

E's made our wedding cake and it was the best decision. We sent a picture of what we wanted and…read morewent with the fresh mango cream flavor. Not only was the price quote the best we found out of 5 places we inquired with, but the cake turned out exactly like we wanted and our guests couldn't stop raving about how delicious it was. Most wedding cakes are only there for appearances and usually taste dry and boring, but the mango cream and fresh mangoes were so unique! I want to go back to get a cake every year for our anniversary!

The vegan red velvet cupcake is so good! The cake is moist and the frosting tastes like marshmallow…read morefluff. Love that they have a vegan option.

I've been coming here since I was younger, so I was excited to try it again! I love the decor and…read moredesign of the shop--it's absolutely adorable. I usually go for the banana pudding, but this time I decided to mix it up and try cupcakes. I ordered the vanilla cupcake with chocolate frosting and the it was with gluten-free or vegan banana chocolate chip cupcake with frosting. The cupcakes looked beautiful! The vanilla cupcake was okay--the cake was a bit dry and slightly overbaked on top, so overall it was just average, especially for the price. The banana chocolate chip cupcake was much better, and I really enjoyed it. The frosting was good, though personally I didn't think it paired perfectly with the cupcake. One small thing: they put the cupcakes in a bag instead of a box, which I prefer. Overall, this place is worth a visit! I'd recommend trying a cupcake (maybe a different flavor next time) and the banana pudding.