After trying another slice of cake from here I don't think I'll ever want to return . I had a raspberry Bundt cake one evening and it tasted as though they used old eggs to make it. The fruitiness , fluffiness and texture were all good except the flavor . All I was reminded of was just eggs . It was disgusting . I also observed a cake they had advertised on a sign infront of their cheesecake and it looked very unappealing but I should have let that deter me from giving this place another chance . read more

Butterly Bakeshop - Eggy raspberry Bundt cake . Major thumbs down . - Custom Cakes Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

See all

Their cupcakes are so wonderful! Seriously no bakery in the neighborhood tastes as good as them. Every time I go the staff is always very friendly and kind. It doesn't matter what time of day I have went, always has been good. read more

My order: Order #DFF59 - Uber Eats. Butterly Bakeshop Order completed * Dec 31, 2025 at 2:55 PM Your order 2 GF Dulce De Leche Cupcake - hard cake, dumped 2 Chocolate Cupcake - good 2 Blackout Cupcake - good 2 Apple Pie Cheesecake - top was hard, didn't try it dump 1 Carrot Loaf Mini - hard icing dumped 1 Turtle Cake Slice - hard cake, dumped 1 Brooklyn Blackout Cake Slice - good Purchased for family members for new year's celebration. Recommendation: icing and decoration can look great but if the cake is has no taste or is hard it's a hard pass. read more

Good cake place that ask have gluten free cupcakes for class parties. The store staff was so helpful when I needed plain gluten free vanilla cupcakes and just whipped up some in a pinch. read more

Butterly Bakeshop - Brooklyn Blackout Cake - Custom Cakes Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

Great little cupcakes ! Very rich and lots of icing on top. The red velvet is pretty good. The vanilla cake is my favorite. The cupcakes come in a cute box. The tiny hearts and stars sprinkles are adorable too. Happy to find a high quality bakeshop - and they delivery locally too. Butterly Bakeshop offers a Brooklyn location - there's also a store in Manhattan. read more

Butterly Bakeshop - a box of butterly bakeshop - Custom Cakes Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

See all

Wow! An amazing and delicious cake - you don't find those often! They worked with me to create an adorable 1st birthday and smash cake for my daughter. Not cheap, but well worth the price. I extra loved the strawberry milkshake flavor! read more

Butterly Bakeshop - Custom Cakes Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

As a vegan it can be difficult to find good cakes! The place I normally go to was unavailable so I searched around and came across this place. They don't have vegan cakes off the shelf but with a little notice (I called two days ahead, not sure if one day would suffice?) they will make one. Let me tell you, it came out amazing. It was absolutely gorgeous and tasted incredible too. (Get the vanilla strawberry!) Everything was very smooth, on time, no problems. They did a great job with the writing and even added beautiful sprinkles. Thank you Butterly Bakeshop! read more

Butterly Bakeshop - Custom Cakes Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

Came in and bought two cakes for a dinner party: a chocolate one and lemon blueberry. Both were loved by all the guests. I look forward to trying more from here! read more

The chocolate frosting was rich and creamy, and the colorful sprinkles added a fun crunch. The cupcake itself was moist, though a bit dense for my taste. read more

Warm, friendly service. Cute little shop. DELICIOUS, beautifully decorated cake!!! Got a small lemon cake with blueberry compote. Lemon flavor was so bright, cake and frosting were light. Can't recommend enough! Used to get my cakes from the other place on the same block, but now I'm a Butterly Bakeshop convert. Thank you! read more

I saw this place post the cutest hot chocolate drink with a mini gingerbread house painted pink and white on their Instagram page during the holidays. However, when a fellow Yelp Elite and I finally went to visit, they no longer had that beverage available. I was quite disappointed, but enjoyed the exterior cute and colorful décor and impressive looking treats, from cupcakes, to cookies, to cakes, and more. My friend and I were trying to decide between the S'mores cookie and the Nutella cookie, so I suggested we just get both and share them. Both cookies were absolutely delicious and very generously sized. They were both warmed up and delightfully melty and moist. The S'mores cookie had plenty of marshmallow in the center, with a dusting of graham crackers on top a chewy, rich chocolate cookie. The Nutella cookie had soft, smooth and sweet Nutella in the middle and the flavor from it was nicely strong. Just perfect ooey gooey mouthwatering yumminess! I would certainly return if in the area to try other desserts. read more

See all

i highly recommend this place. They did my birthday cake and it came out exactly as I wanted it. the taste was absolutely delicious and the presentation was perfect read more

As a fellow baker, I wanted to love this place so much, especially with how gorgeous the products are and how awesome the portion sizes are. However, there was almost nothing I really enjoyed about anything I got. Nutella cookie: Texture was great and had nice crisp edges but something tasted slightly off about the flavor of the cookie that didn't have Nutella on it. Butter Pecan cookie: Again nice texture with a crisp edge, not many pecans at all unless they were very finely chopped and I just didn't notice. Had a buttery taste that was a touch more done than a brown butter taste. Chocolate cupcake: This was where I kind of knew nothing else was going to be great. The butter cream frosting tasted like old freezer burn butter and left the more disgusting greasy coating in my mouth. I scraped all of the frosting off and took a bite of the cupcake that way and was happy to get a moist cupcake but there was almost no flavor and was reminiscent of spruced up boxed cake mix. Red velvet cake: Again, frosting had a greasy texture in the mouth that was really unpleasant. True red velvet cake should be simple with cream cheese frosting and I will give them points for that part because the cream cheese frosting part was pretty good but then gets ruined by the addition of buttercream frosting being on the same cake. I really feel like this cake would be top notch if they did it with ONLY cream cheese frosting and completely left out the buttercream. The cake part itself was not bad either. Brooklyn blackout cake: The frosting on this had a better texture than the cupcake and the buttercream part of the red velvet so that was kind of nice. The cake part was not too bad and had a good chocolate flavor. However, the pudding filling was underwhelming. Brooklyn blackout cake is hands down my favorite cake on earth and this is one of the 1st ones I tried that I really wasn't too happy with. Mini carrot loaf: The cake part of this was moist and flavorful but still missing something I can't put my finger on. The frosting also had that weird greasy in the mouth quality to it but wasn't as bad as the cupcake. read more

I felt very confused by the slice of cake we ordered. We ordered a slice for my birthday. The slice itself was beautiful and looked like it was going to be delicious. I was so excited to eat it. But then when we bit into it it was bland. It didn't taste bad or good, it tasted like nothing. It was very strange. The frosting didn't taste like anything either. It was a very strange experience but, Im open to going back and trying again. read more

Butterly Bakeshop - Custom Cakes Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

Absolutely fast and amazing service. Prices are awesome as well. But most of all their cakes are delicious and peanut free.. Placed an order for a cake for my daughters birthday brunch Friday evening and it was ready by 10am on Saturday.. straight out of the oven..I had also purchased cupcakes from them earlier in the week for my daughters school party (which is what made me go back for the cake) I do believe this is a black owned establishment which is a plus for me. read more

Butterly Bakeshop - Custom Cakes Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

I found this bakery on Yelp and decided to give them a try when I was ordering my man's birthday cake. Ordering was super easy and they were able to make changes in a short amount of time, which I appreciated. When I went to pick up the cake, the women packaged it up for me and put it in a paper bag. As soon as I got outside, the cake ripped through the bag and fell on the floor. I was super nervous and stressed out but luckily they were able to fix it in the less than 20 minutes. The cake itself looked really pretty. The taste wasn't my favorite. It was really dense, extremely dry and not sweet at all. The frosting was also really hard and not sweet. The cake tasted sugar free. My mother, who hates sugar, would really appreciate this cake so if I were to order again from here, it would only be for a small cake for her. read more

Wow!! Felt like having a sweet treat and happened to find this shop on Yelp. I love carrot cake and this was really amazing!! Tasted homemade. Wish I lived closer, so I could get a cake for my birthday. read more

Butterly Bakeshop - Carrot mini loaf - Custom Cakes Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

The owner was friendly. I bought a cupcake and chocolate chunk cookie. Both items were delicious! I loved the icing on the cupcake, smooth with just the right amount of sweetness. I'd love to try a cake. . The display was very appealing. read more

Ordered a cake for a baby shower and it was a massive hit! The guests could not stop raving about it. Kristen was awesome and helped me land on a design and flavor. This flowery lemon blueberry cake was reasonably priced and exceeded all my expectations. read more

Butterly Bakeshop - Lemon blueberry custom flower cake for baby shower - Custom Cakes Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

Amazing amazing! Highly recommend you get your cake from this bakery. Ordered my a custom cake from them for a birthday party and now a second one for a baptism. Very accessible and easy to talk to staff makes ordering even easier. Support a small local business and shop here. You'll be very happy. read more

Butterly Bakeshop - Custom Dinosaur Cakes! - Custom Cakes Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

Butterly bakeshop baked the most delicious and gorgeous wedding cake we ever could have. It's part vegan wedding cake too so we gave them an additional challenge but they manage to deliver! We are so happy that we chose Butterly Bakeshop to make our wedding cake. :) read more

Butterly Bakeshop - Custom Cakes Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

I'm not a big dessert guy but DAMN this place is so good. This is the place you go to get that special dessert that will have your family/friends saying dang who brought this? Don't get some boring pre-packaged desert from Whole Foods or Trader Joes. Get something with some love behind it! It's also great for your own little pick me ups. They have an assortment of cookies, brownies, and other small treats. I had a Chocolate Chip Cookie and Brownie. Man this shit melts in your mouth. God. Thinking about it right now is making me drool. It looks like they're starting to offer other items besides sweets. The owner suggested the Cheese Pizza Croissant to me which was heavenly. The main thing I came in for was a cake for my newly engaged friends at my Superbowl Party. It was seriously the hit dessert. I think I got the Caramel Cake which the owner told me is a favorite by her customers. I can tell this team is so passionate about her craft! It really shows in all the baking goods she offers. There is a true taste of passion. Thank you Kanu and team for your suggestions and kindness! read more

See all

Exceptional customer service. The chocolate chip cookie is one of the best I had in years ! The lemonade is dress hot made and so worth it. I will be back again. read more

This may have been the worst cake I have ever had. My birthday was a few days ago and I didn't have any birthday cake, so I thought hey, let me treat myself. So I came to Yelp to find a bakery nearby that I could order from. After seeing the reviews of Butterly and how good everything looked, I decided to order the birthday cake. Where to start... The frosting was absolutely disgusting. Terrible. It almost had a sour taste to it. The cake itself was actually edible, but it was burnt on the outside. The inside of the cake was dense and the flavor was meh. The ONLY reason I am even giving this two stars is because I also got the s'mores cookie which was absolutely bomb. If only the cake was as good as the cookie. I wish I had gotten to try the banana pudding just to know if it was good, but they had run out. Based on this experience though, I'd recommend anything but the cake. read more

Had theses cookies on a whip after hanging out with friends and we all got a little sweet tooth. The cookies we ordered ended up being amazing! Better than ice has in a really long time! Definitely bookmarking this place and ordering from them in the future! read more

Kanupriya and the Butterly team made us THE perfect cake for our daughter's first birthday. I was new to commissioning a cake and she helped me through every step beautifully. She had me think through the setting and its limitations for a big cake (temperature, etc.), brainstorm flavors and fillings, and of course, the decor. I sent her my mood board and she really made our vision come to life. It was such a smooth, easy and fun process - so responsive, creative and supportive. We had spoken to 9 other cake/cupcake vendors, and when I spoke with Kanupriya, it was a no-brainer. She gets it and she can do anything. There are so many cake, filling and frosting selections to choose from. The cake was also DELICIOUS - not just GORGEOUS. The compliments were NON-STOP. I can't wait for more occasions with Butterly! read more

See all

I bought a small birthday cake for my daughter yesterday. I picked the small one in the front of the display. It was a lemon and blueberry birthday cake. I found this 4 1/2 star bakery from Yelp. The service was good, the sales were nice. I was so happy to find this small shop with yummy cakes until we ate the birthday cake after dinner. First of all the salesperson gave me a slightly different color cake from her outer side of the display instead of the one that I pointed to. The cake didn't taste fresh and I wonder if she gave me an older cake. Besides the butter milk layer cake and sprinkles, there was no other flavors whatsoever. Extremely disappointed. read more

Butterly Bakeshop - Custom Cakes Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

See all

Came to this bakery and was pleased to find out that they have nut free and gluten free options, which I was looking for. I decided to try two of their small cupcakes, which were priced at $4.50 for each one. I bought the Dulce De Leche and a chocolate cupcake with chocolate frosting. I have to say there was absolutely nothing special with either cupcake. I found the Dulce De Leche to be so little in size of cake to frosting ratio. For less money I bought 3 large cupcakes that were delicious from Ladybird, which is diagonally across the street from them. I will purchase cupcakes from there in the future. read more

Had some cupcakes and cake delivered for my sister's birthday. Tropical cupcake is AMAZING, the tart and sweet flavors are so unique and pair perfectly. Beautifully crafted cupcakes, and it was a smooth delivery process. It is not always easy to find places specializing in cupcakes in South Brooklyn, but this is a great place! read more

Cute bakery. I'm always down for checking out a new mom and pop baked goods shop. A friend and I had noticed some kind of cocoa gingerbread house concoction on instagram and she really wanted to go here and I can't say no, especially if it's kind of close to my neighborhood. We walked over after brunch and oggled their goods. Tons of cupcakes, cookies, cakes, whoopie pies. I guess the hot chocolate picture she had seen online was only a temporary thing. So we ended up getting two giant cookies and splitting them. The nutella and the smores. Both gooey and decadent. Pricing is pretty fair for a cookie that dense and huge - it was a little over $3 a pop. Cupcakes were priced about the same. Still need to come back to try one of those! Only thing I noticed is that if you come here for a specialty cake or birthday cake theyre a little bit expensive. But it's a fun spot and will definitely see myself coming back. read more

See all

I love this place. It's just what the neighborhood needed. Their mini cakes are just perfect for an Instagrammable birthday celebration, especially when you're having a small party and don't have enough people to eat a huge cake. Their croissants and cookies are delicious. Always a treat to get something here. read more

Butterly Bakeshop - The perfect cake for a Covid first birthday - Custom Cakes Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

I walked into this store completely unplanned because I was in the neighborhood. The staff was amazing and everything looked delicious!!! Loved everything I managed to try in one sitting :) Will definitely come back for more. read more

Found this gem of a place to order customised cakes. I wanted a one month birthday cake for my newborn and did not have the time to select a design as a new mom. I contacted the owner of this women operated business. With few basic questions, she was able to pull of this beautiful cake which had the most perfect details and perfect taste. Highly recommend this place for cakes and the owner is very easy to talk to and can be trusted with design for customisation. read more

Butterly Bakeshop - Custom Cakes Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

What a great new addition to our neighborhood. Everything is made on the premises and absolutely delicious. Can't wait to try some of their cakes! read more

Butterly Bakeshop - Custom Cakes Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

See all

I have been a fan of this bakery since they opened up in the neighborhood. My wife knows I am a notorious hater of birthday cakes so she stopped by and got me an assortment of their baked goods. I just stopped back into replenish supplies. Friendly wait staff and cookies that always put a smile on my kids face. You can't ask for much more in a great local bakery. read more

Butterly Bakeshop - Dulce de leche cupcakes, coffee cake and carrot cake - Custom Cakes Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

The icing on the cake was really bad and extremely disappointing. The icing didn't taste homemade and tasted like supermarket icing. it's not even comparable to some of the other cake shops in Brooklyn. I do not recommend! The icing SUCKS! I'm not happy I ordered from here. I left my whole cake and cupcake uneaten. that's how bad the icing was. ALSO the cake itself was dense and didn't taste fresh. tasted a day old. we got a slice of funfetti cake. read more

They didn't have measurements on the website and the cake was so tiny! It cost $5.44 extra just for writing and we weren't aware. Kinda sad the cake costed over $30 and it's so tiny :( the design wasn't as elegant as I thought it would be as well. The cake was also very sweet and tasted like cookie dough. read more

Butterly Bakeshop - Custom Cakes Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

I took a trip out to butterfly bake shop out in brooklyn and I must honestly say this place is one of a kind. I was completely blown away by the warm welcoming I received from the time I opened the door from the staff and after having some of their pastries, that s'mores cookies with melted marshmallow stole my heart. Now I'm not even gonna talk about the fudge brownies. I am a massive lover of brownies and this happened to be one of my best I've had in quite a while. You guys got to check it out for yourself. It's worth the trip. I give them a 9.0 from a 10. read more

Butterly Bakeshop - Fudge brownie - Custom Cakes Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

See all

Clean shop, had the most incredible butter pecan cookie. crunchy outside, gooey center, not too sweet, and a little bit of salt to round it out. perfect cookie. come get one! they deliver also read more

Visited Butterfly for the first time today. I was greeted warmly, I asked about their cake selection, and I was blown away by the selection I chose The Birthday Cake The cake was amazing and tasty the sample I was given was delicious, and PERFECT sugar level. Thank you, Butterfly crew for making my baking dreams come true. Earl read more