Cancel

    Open app

    Search

    Sophie's Bagels

    4.7 (44 reviews)
    Open 6:30 am - 2:00 pm

    Order Sophie's Bagels Takeout or Delivery

    Sophie's Bagels Photos

    SOPHIE'S BAGELS ATMOSPHERE

    What's the vibe?
    Moderate noise
    Dogs allowed
    Outdoor seating

    You might also consider

    Recommended Reviews - Sophie's Bagels

    Your trust is our priority, so businesses can't pay to alter or remove their reviews. Learn more about reviews.
    Yelp app icon
    Browse more easily on the app
    Review Feed Illustration

    Reviews With Photos

    Lox on everything bagel and the Peach Mango tea with Peach popping boba!
    Desireé H.

    First time visiting Sophie's Bagels today and had a delightful experience! Staff is exceptionally friendly and their menu options are so diverse! Will definitely be coming back :)

    Fair Portion$
    Ralph B.

    Ordered Carryout via website got the Lox on Everything Bagel lightly toasted was good with their selected ingredients. Got 24oz Bubble Tea Pineapple & Coconut with Mango Crystal Boba Simple Syrup light ice, Unfortunately I did not receive light ice but overall drink tasted great. Service was prompt an ready before scheduled pickup time. Love their aesthetics

    Daniel G.

    We love downtown Pendleton. Going to Falls park and walking downtown is one of our favorite things to do. This was our first time at Sophie's bagels. It was a really cute store and I loved how open it was. They had multiple open garage doors letting in a ton of air and a big outdoor patio. They had a large selection of food and coffee items. I will say, we came in later in the day, so I don't think it was fresh, but it wasn't the best bagel I have had but I also think we could have made a better choice on which bagel we chose because they had sold out of some that sounded really good so we will be back again soon to give the bagels another shot.

    Outside
    David C.

    Well, this was an extremely pleasant find! Heard through the grapevine about Sophie's, and so glad I made the trip from the west side of Indy. NY-style bagels to start, but the Sunday special of a sandwich & drink was the seller. An Avocado toast bagel with fresh ingredients paired well with a dark roast. Purchased a 3-pack of day old bagels that I look forward to enjoying this week. Wish I had known earlier, but this won't be a one-off - I shall return to this little gem!

    Best bagels in the state
    Roger L.

    I was born and raised in Staten Island / Hells Kitchen and wholeheartedly believe that Krishna bakes THE BEST bagels in Indiana and that her shop offers THE BEST value when it comes to breakfast in Central Indiana. I live on Mass Ave. and begged Krishna to open up a Sophie's in downtown Indy... until then I'll be going up to Pendleton to get my bagels! For the quality of her bagels and the A+ service, the prices are an absolute bargain. In general, for a breakfast date... 2 Bagels with *homemade* cream cheese & 2 Coffees after tax and tip is 15 bucks. My go to bagel is an asiago + jalapeno cream cheese, but you honestly can't go wrong based on preference. Her key differentiator is importation and attention to detail. Her bagels are boiled in Long Island, frozen, shipped to Pendleton and then baked to order! The venue is absolutely stunning, probably my favorite garage retrofit in the state. Its elaborately decorated in Henna. Krishna's husband owns a badass hotrod shop & you could tell they really took their time in making this place a true gem.

    Sunny!
    Marley W.

    Perfect! Could not ask for more. Wonderful sunny atmosphere (Eastern view!). Sandwiches and real NY bagels.

    Bagels and counter
    Sable S.

    Really fantastic bagels! Huge, dense and full of great flavor! Never skimp on the cream cheese either! We have always enjoyed this fun little local stop and the food is always really good!

    Lauren P.

    I have drove by this place a lot but it has always been later in the afternoon so I've never been able to stop since it's a breakfast/lunch shop. I finally stopped in this past weekend and the wait was worth it! We got a ham egg and cheese on an everything bagel and then a bacon egg and cheese on a cheddar bagel. After we ordered our food came out within a minute and you could tell everything was fresh. There are not many bagel shops up north area of indianapolis so I'm glad this one didn't disappoint. The price was a little high for just a simple sandwich. It was $7.50 for the sandwich and drinks were around $3-$4. We went on a Sunday and they have a Sunday special where you get a bagel sandwich and a drink for $8 so it's a great price. I was a little said I wasn't told that when ordering because we each got a sandwich and a drink and had to have our order deleted and re added because we saw the special sign after ordering everything. Overall a great spot and I will be back!

    Lovely place to enjoy a coffee & bagel before work.

    If for no other reason Sophie's gets a 5 star from me for ambiance. What a lovely place to sit in the morning to enjoy a cup of coffee snd a bagel. I stopped while passing through town on my way to work. It was most pleasant to sit on the little deck to dine early morning. Lovely flowers adorned the deck with clean picnic style tables. My everything bagel with cream cheese chive onion spread was good. My plain black coffee a smooth taste. Plus, I took a bag of 6 assorted bagels and spreads to go for my work mates. I will stop again no doubt to try a muffin or sandwich egg bagel sandwich next.

    Bagel counter
    Chris G.

    Yet another outstanding addition to the Pendleton area, wow! New construction that occupies the former location of King Hun Chinese, just off State Street downtown. They serve a large variety of bagels, all made onsite. We picked up a half dozen and made sandwiches for lunch with some Boar's Head teriyaki chicken. They have a very good menu full or organic items, bubble teas, custom sandwiches, even lox! I really would have liked to try the London Broil but I was already planning for home. Delicious smells inside, mellow music, and a well designed patio seating outside with garage doors opening when seasonally able. At 11am Saturday the line was out the door and not moving terribly fast. But that is OK, nice place to not be in a hurry at. I had known about Sophie's for a bit and just never made over here, glad I finally did. Great place, stop by.

    Buffalo chicken
    Kyle C.

    Say hello to Pendleton's newest small business, Sophie's Bagels! There is a wide variety of fresh bagels you can order up plain or as a sandwich. We had the Turkey Club and the Buffalo Chicken on Everything bagel and they were both delicious! The buffalo was not over spicy if you don't care for the heat. The sandwich was served with a side of chips from the Broad Ripple chip company. So cool to see one small business support another!

    Avocado toast on asagio cheese bagel
    Jennifer B.

    My new favorite place. Food is excellent, environment is and just adorable. Boba teas in all flavors you could imagine. Yummy desserts.

    Veg out on cheddar bagel
    Brooke H.

    Super tasty, everything tastes fresh. Good variety and able to customize. Bagels of course are the gourmet kind that are chewy, not soft. Will be back!

    Lemonade bubble tea

    See all

    4 years ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    4 years ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    5 years ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    6 years ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    Page 2 of 2

    Ask the Community - Sophie's Bagels

    You might also consider

    Verify this business for free

    Get access to customer & competitor insights.

    Verify this business

    Michael's Bistro - salmon

    Michael's Bistro

    4.9(15 reviews)
    0.0 mi

    Awesome nee Gem.in Pendleton. Great food. large portions. friendly staff. Chef attention to all…read moredetails. Great atmosphere

    Amazing! We are so glad we found this place! Service was 10/10, from the hostess to the incredible…read morewaitress to the chef who made a trip to our table to make sure we were good. We joked we didn't know who owned the place because every person there treated it as if it were their own. Super cute bistro vibe- our food was incredible! The shrimp cocktail, is a must! Massive shrimp! The beef Wellington bites, absolutely next level!! So glad we ordered those- they were the best! The tomato bisque soup came with a little grilled cheese sandwich - such a great touch! It was also one of the best tomato bisque soups we've had. Nailed it! The french onion soup was unlike anything we've ever had before, and incredible! The croissant toast with the cheese was such a treat! We were in town for a babyshower and wanted to grab a quick lunch- or a couple apps, and a glass of wine before as the shower was more snacks. The suggestions for us were wonderful. I'm sure it's great for dinner too! This place was above and beyond across the board and we can't wait to come back when we meet the new baby! We aren't from Pendleton, but raved to all at the shower that if they were local, they must check it out! Amazing spot! Thank you for the wonderful time!

    Photos
    Michael's Bistro - Cool bar back. Go check it out.

    Cool bar back. Go check it out.

    Michael's Bistro - French onion soup

    French onion soup

    Michael's Bistro

    See all

    The Grill A - Big, thick, juicy, and crunchy the tenderloin was absolutely delicious

    The Grill A

    4.9(23 reviews)
    7.1 mi

    They have the best tenderloin in the state, hands down. The fries are amazing too. Everyone I know…read moresays the same thing about this place. It's a gem and worth the roadtrip. Seating is somewhat limited but they are exapnding. They are also known for their pizza and burgers although I've heard everything is great. I have had the tenderloin twice now and it's consistently perfect.

    Grill-A Grill only opened in 2024 and is one of the top contenders for best hand-breaded…read moretenderloins in Indiana. Indeed, the tiny restaurant on Main Street in Markleville (population 484) is filled most evenings and weekend lunch with guests anxious for the hand breaded sandwiches, hand cut fries, burgers, wings and more. The owner, Doug, began restoring the historic building in 2019. Now he is working to add dining space upstairs for another 15 tables to help accommodate the demand. I was steered to the restaurant by a fellow Yelper from Virginia. I did not hesitate to make the 90 mile round trip drive for lunch. The dining room is small with a couple cloth covered tables and a bar seating. Soft country music fills the room and a gorilla hangs from the ceiling. The tenderloin is incredibly tender, fresh, juicy and hot with a perfectly seasoned breading. I ordered the regular size tenderloin, Doug also serves a larger version that is about a pound of meat. And don't skip the fries - hand cut and crisp. The fries are 5 star too. The service is impeccable, the kind of small town service that makes you feel special. We loved hearing Doug's story. There is street parking on the side of the building. They do a robust carry-out business, as well. They are not currently serving alcohol. They are not opened mid week for lunch- check the hours. It's worth the drive, even from out of state. So good!

    Photos
    The Grill A - Ordering at the bar

    Ordering at the bar

    The Grill A - Grill-A Wings

    Grill-A Wings

    The Grill A

    See all

    Catello's Italian Art Cuisine - Pasta

    Catello's Italian Art Cuisine

    4.5(190 reviews)
    0.0 mi
    $$

    As I was coming home from Ft Wayne I was detoured through Pendleton…read more I remembered I had an Italian place marked on my bucket list on Yelp- WOW- honestly this was the best Italian meal I have had in Indy! It is worth the drive!!! All pastas are made fresh. The staff was so friendly and accommodating! They have a piano player as well...what a treat! I sat in the back corner and took it all in! The food was outstanding, I ordered Linguine Frutti di Mare- homemade linguine ( delicious) served with clams, mussels, scallops? Shrimp, cherry tomatoes, evoo, garluc, parsley cooked in a white wine sauce!!! As you can see I absolutely hated it... lol! I has an expression and lava cake for dessert. The lava cake was a little overcooked- that is the only complaint.... Other than the lady sitting across the table from me that talked loud enough for the whole restaurant to hear her conversation. I wish people would be more observant and realize they don't have to talk so loud when they're sitting at their table it made it difficult to hear the piano player and it went from a relaxing stress free feeling to an annoyance. I was so happy when her food arrived. This place is very special. It's very small. I got in because it was very early in the evening. I believe their doors open at 5 o'clock. I would highly recommend reservations, but if you have a special occasion that you're celebrating, and it appeared that several people did this is worth the drive!

    Ambience and service superb. Food not so much…read more Not a lot of choices and all very rich.

    Photos
    Catello's Italian Art Cuisine
    Catello's Italian Art Cuisine - Rita's Ragu

    Rita's Ragu

    Catello's Italian Art Cuisine

    See all

    Jimmie's Dairy Bar - Iconic

    Jimmie's Dairy Bar

    3.4(76 reviews)
    0.7 mi
    $

    Hard to believe but Jimmy's has been serving up diner food and ice cream since 1954. We couldn't…read morepass up a chance to check out what was beneath that orange roof. The orange booths inside reminded me of the 1970s, but seemed newer. The walls are decorated with kitschy country decor. The sign outside claimed the best Bar-B-Q in Indiana, so I decided to give their BBQ sandwich a try with fries and coleslaw. The sandwich was large with lots of saucy sweet pork. The was a slight tang to the sauce, which was good. The fries were crispy and hot. The side of coleslaw was small but creamy and tasty. In response to peer pressure and my lack of self control, I finished my meal off with a tangerine soft serve cone. A small cone was $4. The ice cream was perfectly refreshing and delicious (and the best part of the stop). The staff seemed tired and frustrated, and didn't waste time with pleasantries. Maybe they were understaffed as they worked both a walk up window and inside patrons. Tables needed to be wiped clean, but cleaning didn't happen during our visit. Despite the service, the place had great small town, local charm. I'd return to try the Coney Dog, which looked good. There's plenty of parking in their private lot.

    We decided to drive to Jimmie's Dairy Bar the other day. A tangerine cone dipped in chocolate was…read morecalling my name! It was a pretty day for a drive from Greenfield. Walked up and got our cones, which are very generous servings! Then we drove around back to take pictures. Of the tables I had mentioned in a previous review. There is inside eating, some outdoor eating and of course order at the walk up window and eat in your vehicle. The outdoor area is shady and a chance to get out and stretch your legs. Inside is retro and interesting.

    Photos
    Jimmie's Dairy Bar - Indoor menu

    Indoor menu

    Jimmie's Dairy Bar - Indoor menu

    Indoor menu

    Jimmie's Dairy Bar

    See all

    Sophie's Bagels - bagels - Updated May 2026

    Loading...
    Loading...
    Loading...