I've been meaning to visit this cigar lounge for quite some time, but securing a table reservation,…read moreparticularly for sinatra saturdays, has proven remarkably difficult. After several months of trying, I finally decided to take my chances as a walk-in. As luck would have it, the evening turned out splendidly. I arrived around 6, and the gentleman at the door kindly suggested returning around 7 to join the walk-in queue for the 8 PM performance. Fortunately, a handful of us were accommodated, and I was delighted to finally experience the place firsthand.
First, a word on attire.. I highly recommend dressing for the occasion. While not necessarily required, a jacket and a little sartorial effort feel entirely appropriate here. This cigar lounge has a dark, intimate, richly appointed, and wonderfully atmospheric feel. There's an old-world, almost fraternal character to the interior, with just the right balance of understated luxury. It's precisely the sort of establishment where dressing well enhances the experience. Upon entering, my coat was checked, and I made my way toward the bar. The cigar selection is available online, so I already knew what I wanted, a davidoff royal, preferably accompanied by a glass of champagne. I've never been much of a whisky guy, even in establishments where whisky seems to be the customary pairing.
Then came the music. Steven Maglio and his band were simply sensational. The intimacy of the room makes the performance feel remarkably personal, and hearing such accomplished musicians in a setting of this scale is a genuine pleasure. It quickly became apparent why reservations are so coveted. There is, however, one important consideration for prospective visitors and that's the view. As a walk-in, I was accommodated in the standing area, where the view of the performers was rather limited. Unless you're fortunate enough to have a favorable position near the mezzanine, you may find yourself watching much of the performance through the live television feed above the bar. Even some of the seated tables toward the rear appeared to have obstructed views. If seeing the musicians directly is important to you, I would strongly recommend securing a well-positioned table.
One observation I found rather curious was how few patrons were actually smoking cigars. Most seemed primarily interested in the performance, which is perfectly understandable given the caliber of the entertainment. Still, as someone who specifically enjoys the ritual and atmosphere of a proper cigar lounge, I found it a little surprising. The majority of fellow cigar smokers appeared to be concentrated around the bar and standing areas. Personally, I think the experience is best appreciated with a fine cigar in hand, though one certainly needn't smoke to enjoy the music.
The service deserves particular recognition. Despite the crowded standing area and my limited access to the bartenders, the staff remained exceptionally accommodating and professional. They assisted with drink orders, cutting and relighting cigars, and generally made certain that even those without reserved tables were well looked after. That level of attentiveness did not go unnoticed. Sinatra Saturdays typically feature three performances, at 5 PM, 8 PM, and 10 PM, making it worth planning your evening accordingly.
Although this lounge is undoubtedly a popular destination, I never felt that it had succumbed entirely to the tourist-trap atmosphere one might expect of such a well-known establishment. The room retains a genuine sense of character, and the musicians, staff, and many of the patrons clearly appreciate what makes the place special. Naturally, there were a few guests seemingly more interested in documenting the evening than enjoying it, but that's hardly unique to this establishment.
If anything, I found myself wishing there were a private members' section for regular patrons who appreciate the cigar lounge experience beyond the Saturday performances. All things considered, I had a thoroughly enjoyable evening. The music was outstanding, the atmosphere memorable, and the hospitality commendable. Despite having to stand for much of the performance, I left understanding precisely why this place is so sought after.
I'll certainly be returning, and hopefully next time with a proper table reservation. A wonderful evening, best enjoyed with good company, a fine cigar, and a glass of your favorite drink.