Lackluster to say the least. The drinks were really good. The hookah and speakeasy were great!!! The oysters were the best thing I tried. Some of the best oysters I've ever had but everything else leaves something to be desired. The mac and cheese was the same base as the fondue. I didn't care for it and neither did the person I was with. The cheese dip was ok. I've definitely had better. The dang short rib?! Not as tender as it needs to be. The presentation was kind of cool. It tasted like pot roast. I need to try something else, because the ambiance is great and the vibe is amazing. Maybe I can raise my review. read more

See all

First off I've been wanting to oblige this establishment for quite some time. Let me say that the food was great I had NY Strip with Broccolini, seasoned great! The wife had blackened salmon which she says was very tasty. And the shout out to the doorman, very hospitable! Now for the bad news, we had 10pm reservations which was already a late dinner but it was all they had on OpenTable. Arrived at 9:55 only to check in and be told we did not have a table and we could either wait or have dinner in the cigar lounge. Which was disappointing because I don't smoke and much less don't want to eat my dinner in a smoke room. Nevertheless we chose the cigar lounge as they didn't know when a table might be ready. Their answer for this was "we can't help that we are busy!" Uh yeah understood but isn't that point of rsvp? Once getting downstairs to the speakeasy room the waiter was nice. However there was a standing group of guys just hanging out around our table, we eventually had to move our table because who wants to eat a $60 steak with people leering over you? Our original table was ready but the hostess said it was complete chaos upstairs as the party scene had begun. So if you're looking to go to SM44 any time soon I'd say be sure to go no later than 8. Be prepared for rude hostesses, and to wait for your reservation to be acknowledged. For the price point on the dishes, I'd expect better service. Oh and not to mention the 20% auto gratuity on a party of two!? Nice. read more

We had dinner at SM44 before a theatre performance, and while there were a few things I appreciated, the overall experience felt inconsistent and not quite aligned with the upscale image--or the upscale pricing. To start on a positive note, the Christmas decorations were lovely. The space felt festive and welcoming, and that initial impression set a nice tone as we walked in. Our host was all smiles and positive throughout. Things became less smooth during the initial drink service. The host asked if we preferred still or sparkling water--similar to what you might hear in Europe--but both options were bottled Saratoga water and carried a charge. Tap water wasn't offered at all, so our "choice" of still water ended up costing $12 for two bottles. It felt excessive and completely unnecessary, especially since regular tap water would have been perfectly fine. Another unexpected moment was someone taking our photo at the table without explaining why, only to return later trying to sell it to us in a frame. That kind of solicitation felt more like something you'd see at a theme attraction, not an upscale restaurant. My NY strip was cooked well, but it didn't include any sides. When I asked for A1, I was given their house-made steak sauce instead, without being told it carried a $5 charge for a tiny 2 oz portion. The salmon was $35, the strip close to $50, and even the kids' mac and cheese was $20 despite being made with gruyère, which wasn't exactly appealing to our 8‑year‑old. We kept the meal simple and didn't order alcoholic drinks, yet the bill still came to $175--and it automatically included a 20% tip for our small party of three. That's something I'd normally only expect for groups of six or more. There were also a few small but noticeable issues: our table rocked back and forth and wasn't fixed, and some of the flat‑panel TVs on the walls were displaying random computer text instead of anything intentional. It made the space feel a bit unfinished. I know Chef Willie has cooked for celebrities in the past, and there were elements of the meal that were enjoyable, but overall the experience didn't leave the best impression. With more transparency around pricing and some updates to the atmosphere, SM44 could better match the upscale experience it's aiming for. read more

SM44 - Steakhouses Near Me - Atlanta, Georgia

See all

Spectacular spot for special occasions! I visited this restaurant for a friend's birthday, and the presentation of my meal was magnificent--the taste and tenderness of the tomahawk matched perfectly. The classic Mac and cheese was good too. The serving size was so generous that I enjoyed it for three straight days. The seasoning was perfection. Everyone in our party of six enjoyed their meals. Valet parking is available, but I parked directly across the street in a paid lot. I'll definitely return for the speakeasy experience. Be sure to check out this restaurant when you're ready to splurge. read more

See all

The food was excellent was a party of six and we really did enjoy myself. It was my children and grandchildren. The food was absolutely amazing. The jerk lamb chops was delicious!!! compliments to the chefs! Also the collard greens, the brussels sprouts the macaroni and cheese was delicious as well. This is just the name of you because different ones had different dishes, but they were all delicious. I highly recommend this location because of the food. The ambience was nice! My first born, it was her idea for us to come to this location , and it was really a wonderful experience! Thank you keep up the great customer care, with delicious food read more

Absolutely great experience! As I walked up, I was greeted and the door was opened by a gentleman in a black suit. I was sat immediately. There was no wait for my other party and we added an extra plus one at arrival. Very accommodating. The waitress was very friendly. She introduced herself, asked questions and answered any questions we had. There were three of us. We ordered the tomahawk, Chilean sea bass, Brussels sprouts, broccolini, bread pudding, fondue dip, fried mushrooms, blueberry Mai tai, and agave old fashion. Everything was amazing! The steak was brought out and cut in front of us. There were displays happening at several tables as well. After dinner we went downstairs to the speakeasy. We enjoyed shots that came out on a tray with lights and smoke! Great presentation. I believe there is valet but the lot across the street does not play with the fees be prepared to not park there or pay up front to not have overpricing. The food and experience was so good I didn't get many pics. read more

SM44 - Tomahawk - Steakhouses Near Me - Atlanta, Georgia

See all

This was nothing less than a great evening. The had outdoor, bar, main, and upstairs seating. We sat upstairs with a party of 7 so it was more private. Our waiter was great as well as the bartender as I arrived early and started there for happy hour. The drinks did not disappoint and nor did the food. From the appetizers to dessert everything was well plated and delicious. I had the branzino and it didn't stand a chance. Started with the ponchatarian oysters they had a lil spice but were great. The valet is $25 which isn't posted anywhere and 20% gratuity is included on all checks, but service was still up to par so no complaints. read more

See all

The restaurant is very cute! It's perfect for any occasion, date night, girls or guys night out, or business meeting. The staff was friendly and helpful and the service was quick without making you feel rushed. So to get into the food, everything was perfect! I didn't take pics of the seafood fondue but that was stellar, much like the Brussels. The Mac and cheese needed a little more pepper and it would've been perfect! The lamb chops have a nice kick so be ready for that. My cousin has the fried fish and she said that wasn't seasoned well but the collards and cornbread that came with it was amazing! The price point is what you'd expect but it's well worth it! read more

See all

Celebrated birthdays at SM44. The ambiance and decor are very grown and sexy. Perfect for a date night or adults only dinner. Everyone enjoyed their drinks and the food. Coincidentally we all ordered seafood. No one ordered the steak. But the sea bass was the clear favorite. Someone next to us ordered the prime rib. Plan to go back and order that next time. Definitely worth a try. It's not just a pretty face, there's (food) substance behind the glitz and glamour. read more

See all

Food, service and ambience was all delightful. The oysters were a highlight, as were the steak and the crab fondue dip. I also loved the guava vodka old fashioned and my girlfriend really enjoyed the hibiscus yuzu marg. They played some great tunes during the meal and i thought it was actually very reasonably priced for such an upscale and delicious meal. One of the best steaks Ive had in a while, great chimichurri as well. I want to go back and try the desserts read more

See all

Came here for cocktails in the speakeasy. The drinks were great and the staff was really nice. I look forward to coming back for dinner.

I went here to celebrate my friend new job and my other friend moving to Atlanta and I'm glad I picked this restaurant out now I will say a little bit pricey, but if that's how you roll definitely do what you do best let's start off with the service, which was amazing our waitress did a lot for recommendations and I trusted everything that she stated, and we tried everything pretty much on the menu. I will say there was nothing that I did not like I even liked the lobster mac & cheese and I feel like a lot of people in Atlanta can't can't make mac & cheese, but this was amazing and I will get it again. I think overall it was a beautiful environment very cute. I love the fact that they take photos and let you purchase them. The speakeasy was pretty small and smoky so did not stay in there at all. We pretty much walked in and walked right back out but overall, I will do it again if I wasn't paying. read more

See all

Don't believe everything you read on social media. I saw a great video on social about this place so I decided to try it, even after reviewing the menu, pricing and location. I really try to support black owned restaurants. Unfortunately, this isn't it. The food was subpar. Service below average. The only thing I'd come back for is the drinks. This is definitely not high end or fine dining. This is 1/2 a step above a club for 21-25 year olds. A definite NO for me in the future. By the way, this IS NOT a black owned establishment! They lied. Sorry. read more

SM44 - Over cooked salmon. - Steakhouses Near Me - Atlanta, Georgia

The bread tasted like it had cake straight out the microwave. Worst bread. Lobster Mac Is disgusting. Doesn't even look or taste like macaroni needs to be called something else. Steak and fries were good! Overall wouldn't return, read more

Lump crab cake is NOT that. It's the shredded type that tastes cheap. My drink was decent. Good staff. Be aware water is a charge so you're not surprised ($6 per bottle). Automatic gratuity. Valet parking $20.. Parking garage close by though. Kale salad is delicious. Salmon and mashed potatoes were pretty good, but nothing spectacular. Ambience is nice. I would not recommend to my out of town company (like my other faves) and it didn't make to my MUST return list. read more

On September 19th, I had an AMAZING experience at SM44. The ambiance was incredible, setting the stage for a time I won't forget. The crab cake was pure perfection, firm, flavorful, and without a hint of mushiness. I'm not ashamed to say I completely cleaned my plate, wishing I had a biscuit to soak up every last drop of that amazing sauce ‍ The mac & cheese was equally comforting, with that perfectly well-done top layer just like my granny used to make. My friend declared the NY Strip the "Absolute best" steak they'd ever had, and the greens were fantastic and full of flavor. The food there will have you looking for Chef Willie in the daytime with a flashlight A huge shout-out to the manager, Ashley! She was the Absolute BEST, walking around and checking on patrons. Her warm, attentive service truly elevated the entire night I'm definitely returning to SM44. It's an experience, not just a meal read more

This is a great place to eat if you want to break up with your lover. I ordered salmon and requested it to be cooked well. When the food came, it was cold and drastically unseasoned. I lost my appetite after the first bite. The salmon had a very questionable sauce that didn't balance well with the dish. I was immediately disgusted with the taste and disappointed with the presentation. The ambiance was similar to that of a sports bar with just enough intimacy for a good quiet conversation. The service was not great nor memorable as the waitress did not hold a smile the whole evening and did not inform us of all the pairing's to the entree's. Our tab was roughly $300, and to be frank we didn't even want to box it. As someone who enjoys fine dining and is no stranger to luxury experiences, this establishment has proven to be subpar at best. Don't you dare bring an empty stomach to this establishment and expect to be fed delicious food. You would be robbed of a fine dining experience. I wouldn't even feed these leftovers to my dog. Straight to the bin, I say! read more

SM44 - Red snapper - Steakhouses Near Me - Atlanta, Georgia

See all

Food, amazing!! Server Ms. Veronica was very nice and a bundle of joy. She made our experience for my mom's birthday wonderful! Also, the ambiance was a vibe! read more

Most of you may think this is up your taste bud palette, but it's not. Trust, give it five more months before you decide to dine here. Everything was bland, and if you work at this establishment, please change the cooking oil; it tastes old. Salt and black pepper work wonderssign an Aquarius woman read more

My girls and I saw this spot on TikTok and just had to check it out! Overall, the vibe was super cute--definitely not your typical steakhouse. The drinks were on point, and the food was pretty solid too! Just a heads-up: valet parking is $20. But honestly, I didn't mind--it is ATL after all. The valet team was so sweet and professional. They assured me my car would be well taken care of, and they definitely delivered! I loved that I could just text them when I was finishing my meal, and my car was ready and waiting by the time I walked out. That level of service was definetly worth it! read more

The food and the service could improve greatly for the price. The food is not up to par. This place is only good to take a Instagram picture and smoke hookah. read more

I came to SM44 for a birthday dinner. I had an amazing experience. The food and drinks were great! My fav is the Guava drink. The customer service was top tier. The managers were welcoming. I will definitely be back. read more

Food was excellent. Atmosphere was dope. Prices was good! The service was wonderful. Will definitely go back!

Heard about this restaurant from social media so went to try it out. Needless to say I found out the restaurant was black owned and they also had a celebrity black chef. I had reservations on the weekend which was very busy i recommend to make them early or during the week for the best experience. From the moment we pulled up, the valet set the tone for an exceptional evening. Very Friendly, and professional, I was skeptical because the valet was backed up, but I tried to park across the street, but public machine parking was 30$, so I went back to the valet and they handled our vehicle very quickly. It was cheaper and also had the option to pay before or after which helped because I don't carry cash. All we had to do is notify the valet via text message when we were ready to leave and they had the car ready the second we stepped out. The restaurant itself was incredible--delicious food, warm ambiance, and service could be better--but I have to give special praise to the valet taking care of my car. It's rare to find a place in the city of Atlanta who don't over charge for parking and also make sure the car is safe. I'll definitely be returning, the food, the good vibes, and the valet service is a huge part of why. read more