This was probably my fourth or fifth visit to NY Prime, but it's been quite a few years (at least 5-6) since my last one. I recently returned with my mom to celebrate her birthday, and I'm happy to say it was just as memorable! We made an early reservation for 4 PM on Halloween and were literally the second table in the building. Lol Our server, Ms. Jackee, was an absolute gem! My mom and I were both thoroughly impressed with her level of service, attentiveness, and, most importantly, the genuine kindness she showed us throughout our visit. She truly made the experience that much better! Now, let's talk about the food! Everything was amazing. We started with the garlic butter shrimp appetizer and shared the Tomahawk, paired with broccolini and cheddar mashed potatoes. There was SO much food, and everything was cooked to perfection. Honestly, the best bang for our buck was probably the $10 martinis thanks to their happy hour special. Lol! How I managed to forget to photograph the steak is beyond me! Safe to say, NY Prime is back on my list, and I'll definitely be returning. Oh, and complimentary valet is always a nice touch, especially in ATL! read more

New York Prime - Steakhouses Near Me - Atlanta, Georgia

See all

Food? Excellent. Service? Excellent! Shoutout to Colton and Kyle. Ambience? Everything. We got the crab cakes, ribeye, creamed spinach, broccolini and mashed potatoes. All very seasoned and great portions. BUT I take away a star because my experience with Leslie while trying to book a table was very off putting. We originally had a party size that required us to book a private dining room. We hadn't yet signed any contracts, we were simply inquiring before finalizing details, and during that process, our guest count dropped quite a bit, which eliminated the need for us to book a private room. We let Leslie know that, then booked the reservation via their standard reservation app, and from that point on, it felt like she was doing everything she could to makeup for the profit she would've received if we rented the room. She insisted on us signing a contract to sit in the main dining area, which didn't make sense because would you ask any other group to sign a contract after booking a regular table? In the contract, we received several iterations of it with different auto-gratuity percentages. The first time it said 18% gratuity plus a 3% "event fee", then we asked her about it and she apologized and said that was the wrong version of it, so she sent us another version that said 21%, at this point, our antennas are up, so we asked for clarification, then she said she would remove her 1% from the 21% and have us pay 20%, and finally she landed on the required gratuity being 20%. Keep in mind that prior to this, I called the restaurant prior to this and asked what the auto gratuity for a large party was and they said there was none. The percentage didn't matter because we planned to tip OF COURSE! But it just all felt dishonest after a while and like we were being nickeled and dimed the whole way through. My husband and I wanted to cover the tab for our guests, so we asked if we could bring a printed copy of a fixed version of their menu to keep the dinner within our budget. I printed, designed them and placed them at each seat myself, and with the menu only containing sides that we were ordering family style and a few entrees, that should have definitely made everyone's job easier, but when I asked Leslie about the menu's over the phone, she said yes with an attitude, and then later tried to say that she added the various service fees because of the work that she and her team were doing to accommodate that. What is the accommodation? If my same party came in and ordered all the same things, what would be the difference? Leslie admitted that herself in the email she sent me. You didn't do any extra work. I just wish she would've been upfront and honest from the beginning. Because of her I almost completely canceled the reservation but I'm glad my experience with the servers and the food in general turned my experience around! read more

See all

We had such a great experience at New York Prime! We celebrated my wife's 40th birthday here with family and friends, and it was the perfect place for the occasion. We sat outside for the evening, and the weather was absolutely perfect, which made the atmosphere even better. The food was delicious, the steaks were cooked perfectly, and the drinks were on point! Our server took great care of our group and made sure we had everything we needed. Most importantly, my wife had an amazing time. Great food, great atmosphere, great service, and even better memories. We'll definitely be back! read more

See all

We arrived and were seated promptly, which made for a great first impression. Our server, Moose, was excellent! He explained the menu thoroughly, answered all of our questions, and shared some of his favorite recommendations. I decided on the bone-in ribeye, and it was incredibly flavorful and cooked perfectly. I also experienced the live lobster presentation for the first time, and it was amazing. The presentation itself was a fun experience, and the lobster tasted just as good as it looked. Overall, the food, service, and atmosphere exceeded my expectations. I'll definitely be back! read more

New York Prime - Steakhouses Near Me - Atlanta, Georgia

See all

What's not to like? Excellent steaks and truly delicious sides with great service! I don't know if I prefer New York Prime to other steakhouses in ATL-- as in I'm not sure it'd dethrone my top steakhouse Spot... but I do think it was the best service I've received. The ambiance is fun and eclectic, not a stuffy, formal place nor simply a totally new-age feel. They also have fantastic side rooms for private events, which I filed away for future event-focused reference! A highlight for me-- besides the delicious steak of course-- was the broccolini! We ordered 5 sides and salads (to share) and it was my fav. read more

See all

New York Prime is an incredible spot in/near Buckhead that has delicious food, friendly staff, and a welcoming atmosphere. Come for the steak, stay for the hospitality! While in town I had dinner here solo. Sitting at the bar I had the pleasure of two very attentive bartenders who were happy to serve. The menu doesn't make it easy to choose as it is packed with an assortment of apps and entrees that are guaranteed to please. And they delivered! The oysters were perfect and my steak was incredible! Thank you, NYP, for teaching me that the way I like a steak, with a HEAVY char, has a name: "Pittsburgh-style". My life has been changed. They cooked it to perfection that left me wanting to lick the plate! (we'll look past the name and steak-style that conflict, okay?!) And all of this while soaking in a dining room/bar that feels very NYC and is just the right level of lively. What I really liked was the manager glad-handing the regulars. Delightful! This experience ranks among my top of steakhouse experiences - not something I thought I'd say about a spot in Atlanta. Take my advice and make a reservation, you'll be glad you did! read more

New York Prime is a longstanding steakhouse in the Atlanta area and continues to hold its own. We visited Valentine's Day weekend, and as expected, it was packed. We did have to wait about 30-40 minutes past our reservation time to be seated, but given the holiday rush, that was pretty much par for the course. To start, we ordered red wine and a Hugo spritz, along with the Caesar salad, shrimp fettuccine Alfredo, and crab cakes. The standout for me was definitely the crab cakes, mostly lump crab meat, just as they should be. For dessert, I received a birthday treat: a warm cookie with a scoop of ice cream, plus chocolate-covered strawberries in honor of Valentine's Day. A very nice touch. Despite the holiday crowds and slight seating delay, New York Prime remains a solid choice in the Buckhead area for a classic steakhouse experience. read more

See all

Spent our wedding anniversary here. First off, I wish they had a New York Prime in Houston. Food was 10/10 and very filling. The crab cakes weren't too soft , the creamed spinach was flavorful , and the fettuccine paired well with our entrees. Waiter was kind and friendly and the restaurant was clean. I would say they didn't have bread options for a peanut allergy person , but the food made up for that. Overall, a good experience read more

New York Prime - Steakhouses Near Me - Atlanta, Georgia

See all

I'm really sad I didn't take more pictures because this restaurant deserved them. This was easily a top 5 steakhouse that I have ever experienced. Now I will note the ambience will not "blow you away," but the food and service is every bit and more what you expect from a fine dining restaurant. I went with the 8oz filet which was perfectly cooked medium well. Our sides included creamed spinach and fettuccine Alfredo, the layer of which we were amazed and glad we could get that as a side it fulfilled our desire to have steak and pasta. They also have a good caesar salad and a variety of tasty house bread for the table. I hope they expand to Texas and open up a location in Houston or Dallas. I can't wait to come back again. read more

New York Prime - Petite Filet - 8 Oz. Barrel Cut - Steakhouses Near Me - Atlanta, Georgia

Spectacular! Right away, the service was incomparable to anything else I've ever seen. The entire staff made us feel welcome from the minute we walked in the door. We have been wanting to go here for quite some time, and I can promise you it was worth the wait. Collectively, we had an aged ribeye, the Sea bass, the garlic chicken, and sides of spinach, mushrooms, shrimp cocktail, crabcakes, and butter cake. Everything was absolutely delicious. Inside the restaurant, it's very dark with candlelight and low lights. Very cozy and relaxing atmosphere. We were celebrating some big things, and they gave us a complementary giant cookie and a huge scoop of ice cream as well. That was much appreciated. read more

See all

I don't know who the chef was last night but this has been the best dinner we've had in a while. We alwayssss have to start off with the seafood bisque whoever invented this bisque is a genius. It soooooo good that I just want to eat it all in one sitting. It's creamy thick and full of seafood so if can be very filling. I have tried this sea bass sooo many times but last night something was different it was so buttery flaky and the crunchy garlic on top was the cherry on top. I got a side of broccolini which is always great full of garlic but it does have a little spice kick to it for me it was great. Hubby got the ribeye which was very flavorful and tender. Defiantly was a great dinner. read more

See all

First, the service, food and ambience at NY Prime was INCREDIBLE. Being from Dean Martin's Hometown I was really feeling the vibe there. EXCEPT. Last Saturday there was a Lounge singer doing something, but not singing. (If it was Karaoke, I apologize.) I swear it looked like Dean Martin's expression on the large picture on the wall did this when the entertainment was happening. Love the place! read more

Haven't been here in years and decided to come for date night with my husband. Making reservations was easy and being seated was fast. Service was personable and our night went smooth with helpful recommendations. We started with seafood bisque that was to die for and had the porterhouse for two and omg it was cooked to perfection. New York Prime was the perfect setting for date night read more

New York Prime - Steakhouses Near Me - Atlanta, Georgia

See all

As always, we had a wonderful time and there was impeccable service! It was my birthday and they welcomed us with open arms. The Bacon appetizer never misses nor does the crabcakes. Steak should not go without mention. Again, thank you for an excellent birthday celebration. I appreciate everything you offered. read more

Beautiful and classy restaurant. Impeccable service. Delicious food from the appetizers to the dessert. Superb wine and drink selections. Wonderful way to celebrate or anniversary. The attention to detail made dining here well worth the visit. We will return! read more

See all

Stopped by for dinner and a cocktail. Cliff is an excellent bartender and provided great food reccomendations. I had the grilled oysters, grilled shrimp and alfredo. It was all really good but they oysters were my favorite. Looking forward to coming back and trying more items. read more

New York Prime - Steakhouses Near Me - Atlanta, Georgia

The ambience was decent dim lighting with candles and several TVs throughout the space. The hostess did an excellent job confirming my reservation and accommodating an additional seat when we arrived with an extra guest. When our entrées arrived, we realized there were no forks on the table, and our server had already stepped away. As we attempted to get another waiter's attention, he deliberately ignored us multiple times, presumably because we were not his table. After several attempts, he finally came over and provided the utensils so we could eat our food before it became cold. The interaction was uncomfortable; while I understand we were not his assigned guests, ignoring a customer for that reason is unacceptable especially when the request was as simple as providing utensils. The food itself wasn't as hot as expected, but it was still enjoyable. Our tomahawk ribeye was cooked to the perfect temperature, and the drinks and desserts were delicious. Our server overall did a good job read more

See all

My hubby and I were in town for a Hawks game. He loves a good steakhouse and this was within walking distance of our hotel. We didn't have a reservation but we were seated immediately. Our server was a young man who was a college student and he was extremely helpful with questions about the menu. The restaurant was very intimate and great for couples. Our food arrived and it looked amazing. And fortunately, it tasted even better than it looked. We started with the crab cakes and OMG....the mustard sauce made the dish! I had the sea bass which was delicious and the best I've had! My hubby had the bone in filet and he loved it. We're definitely going to add this to our list of go-to spots! read more

New York Prime - Bread made in house! - Steakhouses Near Me - Atlanta, Georgia

See all

I came once for a private party and it was awesome, the dirty martini was delicious, the steak was tasty and the service was great. This past time, I don't think they could've cared less. The server was immediately trying to rush us and we were there to celebrate (we probably would've spent way more had things gone right) but we got apps and they split but kept half and took it back with a napkin over it? Then our steak was so salty, the Martini was fine but not as good as that first experience and we were paying within 45min of sitting down for a CELEBRATION dinner. I will be taking my celebrations elsewhere, I was embarrassed to have recommended read more

I enjoyed a romantic birthday meal here and the service and ambiance was wonderful. Pros: the crab cake was good- no filler. I am originally from DC so it's hard for me to find good seafood in GA. The steaks were good. I had the center cut filet and my partner had the NY strip. Con's: I do think their style of preparation is probably best for steaks with more fat. I ordered the filet and it was a little dry and unevenly cooked. As you can see in the picture one side of it is well done and I ordered it medium. The garlic spinach side was also ok. A little underwhelming. Overall, Its a good choice and enjoyable meal. read more

See all

Very disappointing and total let down! We've been to so many steak houses and this one missed the mark shockingly! Two of our dishes looked and tasted burnt. Seems like it was rushed prepared based off the presentation. Service was also a little disappointing because the server was nicely charging and assuming things we didn't order. I so hate that! I'm obviously there to spend a decent amount of money but don't try to get over on me! Too many options here to settle for quality and service like here! read more

Excellent from beginning to end. From the moment I arrived to grab a drink at the bar, Cliff took great care of me and my guests. As we transitioned to dinner, Lucas took great care of us thru dinner. We were there to celebrate my brother's birthday as it was his first time patronizing NY prime. He's a steak guy and loved the Pittsburgh style tomahawk and bone in ribeye that we ordered. Top of his list now of favorite steaks in Atlanta now. The steak was cooked to perfect temperature and the sides, mushrooms and Brussel sprouts were spot on as well. We also ordered several desserts to cap the evening. From the cheese cake to the key lime pie, all tasted great. One last thing...their playlist of 80's-90's music was excellent! Will continue to come back for great food, service, and ambiance. Keep up the great customer service NY Prime. See you soon read more

See all

As I walk in the aesthetic of the place is very dim but it fits very nicely. The waiter was very nice and kind and served us with some sparkling water. The menu looks very nice but the letters are very small so for the people with bas vision you might nit be able to read the menu. The look again was very nice looking, the tree was especially pleasing. Next, the music choices were good nothing too much to talk about there. The chairs were very comfortable as-well. The place was very quiet compared to other places. The food I got was the petit filet, and the loaded baked potato. The bread I received was spicy and normal, the bread was good, but I was hoping it would be warm, just a personal preference (not a big deal. Now, the waiter is coming out with the food and the baked potato looks especially delicious. I get the food and first thing I taste is the Filet and it's perfect. It's nice and buttery which I love. Next up is the baked potato, it's incredibly fluffy and delicious and it was so much good food I couldn't even finish it all. All in all, I give New York Prime a 9.27/10 the place looks nice, tastes good, and the service was amazing. read more

Came here for a dinner with a party of 5 during a trip to Buckhead. I went with the chateauneuf du pape, and it was excellent. Started with a salad that included candied pecans, cheese, and raisins. I thought this was solid. I went with the petit filet (8oz), Philly style (charred outside and rare inside). I thought it was quite charred on the outside. It was too bitter for my preference. However, the inside was very tender and flavorful. Ambiance is standard upscale steakhouse. Service was friendly and on point. read more

Everything was top notch. From the moment we arrived until the time when we departed. We started our evening off with free Prosecco while we were waiting to be seated. Once we were seared, our server was prompt with his arrival and gave a thorough explanation of the menu as well as recommended a few items. For our entree, we ordered the sizzling bacon. f you want it precut you must arise the server at the rime you place the order. We forget but he was quick to get us a steak knife so that we could cut it without any issues. Flavor was fantastic and not overly salty. We both ordered drinks, but I can't remember the name of them but they were refreshing and helped prepare us for the bread service and our entrees. For entrees, we ordered the garlic chicken and the Delmonico steak which were both cooked to perfection. Normally, I go for a steak but the garlic chicken was definitely a palette pleaser. Juicy, flavorful and cooked to perfection. It was actually the highlight of the evening. For sides, we opted for the broccolini and the praline sweet potatoes which were topped with marshmallows. I should have mentioned this earlier in the review, our server was Jake and I would recommend him as a young man who has customer service down and serves as if he has been in the business forever. I will request him on my next visit. When service is that great, you definitely have to tip him well and recognize him in your review. Again, his name Jake. read more

New York Prime - Garlic Chicken - Steakhouses Near Me - Atlanta, Georgia

See all

Such an unforgettable experience that 5months later we came back! Still a 10 out of 10! Food was absolutely delicious. Service was amazing. Ambiance is always we had a booth this time, loved that! read more

See all

I love everything here! It's def one of my favorite restaurants yet it's not as much of a scene. Best crab cakes you'll find in atl. Great sides... better than other nearby steakhouses! Amazing filet also. They do under estimate temp so round up! Get the famous chocolate cake or butter cake for dessert. read more

See all

Hubby and I went on our date night, and completely enjoyed our dining experience. We got the absolute best service from Colton. He was so delightful and accommodating, and just a joyful presence. The food, oh my word. We are on a journey to find the best steakhouse in ATL, and oh my, the running is tight! We've had some phenomenal steaks & NY Prime did not disappoint!! All things considered, it was reasonably priced too...!!! read more

See all

This is truly my go to spot for steakhouse. When I want to feel like I've been teleported back to New York after watching a wonderful Broadway show this is where I come from the staff to the friendly service. It's always amazing. This is my fifth time coming here and I will definitely come back again. The food is amazing. Well flavored oh my God the best steak the best ribeye I think it's a little too salty the Rockefeller, however, I will definitely come back again always a hit. read more

See all

I visited New York Prime with my large family. We had an unforgettable experience of great flavored food and service on a weeknight. Service: We were met by a flexible staff who accommodated our large party for a late night dinner. Initially, they were going to seat us at two different tables. We explained that this would not be ideal and we were hoping to sit all together and they made it happen without difficulty. Food and drinks were brought to our table timely and our waiter very enthusiastically checked on us regularly and showed great personality! The music was a lot of fun-80s rock and pop. Food: The Crab cakes, Steak, and Lamb were all cooked to perfection and juicy with a traditional grilled flavor. I did not have to add salt. All sides are family style, served hot. We ordered the creamed spinach (very rich and creamy- too rich for my liking), fries (colossal fried potato wedges), fettuccine Alfredo, seafood bisque, broccolini, and salad. Great wine list and cocktails to complement. I left very full and would gladly come back! read more

New York Prime - Prime Bone-In Ribeye - 22 Oz. - Steakhouses Near Me - Atlanta, Georgia

We came here in August for my boyfriend's birthday. Our car was left with valet and we went in to a pretty full restaurant for a Thursday night. The servers were great and very attentive. No problems with service at all. They placed a complimentary assortment of bread on the table and they were all pretty great. There was one in particular that reminded me of a cinnamon stick or something. It was really great and I love cinnamon. The charred Brussel sprouts were a little bit too charred for me. I like my Brussel sprouts a little less burnt. The cheese mashed potatoes were really good and tasty. The 8oz petite filet was cooked to a perfect medium, until I realized it was too pink and I asked them to give me medium well. They helped me realize I'm a medium well girl. My boyfriend had the bone-in 22oz ribeye medium rare. Despite it being medium rare, I did take a bite and thoroughly enjoyed the burst of flavor as it filled my mouth. Everything was flavored well and was so filling. Be prepared to spend a pretty penny here, but it's so worth it. read more

See all

This place has some of the best food I've ever had. When I travel to Atlanta this is on the list for sure, maybe even a few times. Service is always great, the crowd depends on time and day but I've never had a bad experience here. read more

See all

Customer service and ambiance were great! The Crab Cake was delicious with no fillers. The Baked Shrimp, while a fan favorite I wasn't necessarily a fan. The lamb was seasoned and cooked to perfection. The baked potato was probably the best I've had in quite a while. The Cesar Salad was okay. The Alfredo was okay. The Amaretto Sour was perfection in a cup. Last but not least that Butter Cake was Amazing! I'll be back to try a few more items. Updated Visit Reviw: So as promised I did visit again to try some additional menu items.... Again ambiance and customer service were exceptional For starters I had the Oyster Rockefeller they were decent but I've had better. The 3.5 pound lobster with table-side service was delicious. The baked potatoes this time was no prepared the way that first potato was prepared during my initial visit and this time around was just okay. The cheesy potato I wasn't a fan of and the broccolini was okay. This time around my amaretto sours weren't perfection in a cup and I stopped at one instead of 3... with every sip I could smell the rawness of the egg white which was a bit nauseating. Despite just the okay experiences NY Prime is definitely consistent on service and I love that. Everything always served hot and with a pleasant attitude. read more

See all

Shout out to the bartender who was an absolute girls girl ! Got a glass of Champagne on the house since it was my bday, I will def be back !! read more

Some of the best Brussels I've had. Not too sauced up. And the Ribeye cooked medium was great too. The service is spectacular. I loved it. I came early for a birthday celebration. I will be back. I enjoyed my meal and my time here. Definitely worth it for me. The selection of bread they bring to your table is very nice as well. read more

See all

We had a reservation on a Sunday evening to celebrate a birthday. The restaurant was about 75% full, so no delays being seated. Service was excellent, we were greeted promptly, our server was very present and there if we needed her, but not in your face. We all had steaks, 2 strips and 2 filets, steak fries, asparagus and split a wedge salad. Steaks were temped as ordered and well seasoned, the baked potato was perfectly fluffy. Complimentary dessert for the birthday boy - will return for more special occasions. read more

Food was terrible. Nothing had flavor. I was expecting butter and garlic and it tastes like they forgot it. The quality is good but no flavor. The waiter didn't pay attention us. He would be talking and looking other places. They forgot my drink. The environment is loud. Just bad read more

Went here for dinner and the express martinis with mezcal were to die for. The bartender makes them with fresh expresso

Great service and steak was excellent. Great experience. Definitely will return and recommend this place.

The service is excellent. The wait staff was very attentive. Dining was wonderful. I tend to like steak with sweet potato casserole. They make a Praline Sweet Potato casserole. By far, the best casserole I have ever tasted. I would highly recommend it with any steak or lamb selection. The ambience was too dark, and music too loud, hence 4 out of 5 stars. read more

See all