Great place. Was hesitant after reading they had the "best burgers" in Treasure Valley. So many people overly hype burger places. I was impressed. Very good! Amazing service and played cool music. Loved the roll up doors and "graffiti" paint. Feels old school. Love that. Our food was crazy good. Need to go back and try other items. Burgers are soooo good. Good selection of beers on tap but very limited wine selection. Milkshakes are incredible. Treat yourself. read more

Sid's Garage - Beer Bar Near Me - Boise, Idaho

See all

My wife and I ate here on a spur of the moment occasion. The food was very expensive and so so at best. The one star is indicative of the fact that they, apparently, have zero insect control in effect. We spent the entire time shooing away flies...of which there were many. The wait staff spent the entire time jaw jacking with each other. Overall a definite one star experience. read more

Been open for a few years and I have always said...one of these days I'll go. Didn't know if food was over hyped or not. Had a great burger (French Onion Burger). And parmesan truffle fries. Freaking delish! Fry sauce was great as well. Could go for less heavy metal music on the patio but made it through. Will definitely go back to Sid's! read more

Sid's Garage - Parm truffle fries - Beer Bar Near Me - Boise, Idaho

See all

Sid's Garage downtown Boise is the perfect spot for delicious comfort food and stellar service. I was greeted and seated right away, and my server, Estella, completely elevated the evening. She was fantastic--friendly, prompt, and always smiling with a wonderful, accommodating personality. I started with the 'Setting Sun Sangria' (white wine, seasonal purée, fruit, champagne float), which was the perfect fruity, refreshing drink to kick off the meal. For the main event, I had the BLT Slider Trio. These are beautifully put together with 100% Wagyu beef, jalapeño candied bacon, lettuce, and tomato. The Sriracha bourbon sauce comes on the side. Every single bite was juicy, and you can really taste the flavor of the candied bacon paired with that hint of jalapeño. Dipping it into the bourbon sauce takes the flavor profile to the next level--absolutely amazing! I couldn't leave without dessert, so I had the Southern Belle (peach cobbler)--a heavenly mix of maple, caramel, peach jam, toffee, and rich vanilla ice cream. It was the perfect sweet finish to a perfect meal. A massive thank you to Estella and the team at Sid's Garage. I will definitely be coming back! read more

See all

Sid's Garage is such a fun burger place! It's so great for families or a quick casual dinner. They have a large variety of burgers that you can choose from customizations are available. It is sit down service, which is nice and yeah, I would say the surface is good. It comes out fast. The staff were all really nice and as you can see the burgers are very photogenic, but they also taste great I will definitely be going back. They are famous for very crazy milkshakes that they serve. I just did not order one on this particular visit! Check em out! read more

Sid's Garage - Beer Bar Near Me - Boise, Idaho

The food was great! We loved the burgers here and the service was excellent! The staff were friendly and knowledgeable! The food came out quickly and there was not one complaint from our table of 10! We will be back read more

See all

This is the greases burger I have ever seen. You couldn't even pick the thing up without it falling apart. The waitress was not very good either. Not goi back. read more

Very good, albeit, very rich food. Mouth-watering burgers, great service, and fantastic location. It's tough to find a place that's good AND good for kids, and so we really appreciate the laid back vibe. If I had one note, it'd be that the menu is in desperate need of freshness. A salad, fresh fruit... SOMETHING to relieve all that richness. I love a big, fat burger just as much as the next guy, but a balanced plate is a better plate every time. read more

Inside out: parking can be a bit of a pain, trying to come with my grandma who wanted to try the death by chocolate was a struggle. No handicap or accessible parking nearby do it was unloading a 90+ year old woman on a street and trying to time picking her up in traffic. Not their fault- just something to keep in mind. The inside is a nice set up but the music was a bit loud. Service: friendly and fast! The food: veggie burger and death by chocolate, wonderfully tasty! The fries are made with beef tallow as a heads up to vegetarians! My grandma loved them. Overall, a fun first date spot if you're walking around downtown- split the shake though it's huge! read more

Sid's Garage - Beer Bar Near Me - Boise, Idaho

** (2 Stars)** The burgers were decent, but I was really disappointed by the drink policy. They don't provide straws unless you order a milkshake, and even then, the straws are only for the milkshakes. If you order a soda or any other drink, you're out of luck. I understand trying to reduce waste, but it would be nice to at least offer customers the option to request a straw. It's a small detail that makes a difference in the overall dining experience. Unfortunately, this policy left a bad impression on me. Two stars. read more

Looking for a delicious burger and Sid's came up. Pictures and in person the food looks delicious. Other customers seemed to enjoy their food as well. Service is awesome and attentive. Unfortunately, i'm not sure if it was a matter of cooking properly or seasoning but I did unfortunately get sick. I figured it was something I did however it nothing was wrong until the couple of bites of food that caused me to be sick while still at the restaurant. Super embarassed and hate that it happened. Again, looks great and staff were awesome and I hate I had the experience I did but definitely hope their business success. Seems as though a lot of people love it. read more

Sid's Garage is amazing! The food is delicious and the service is always so friendly.

Food was wonderful but Rhyland made our day. We had just flown in from Atlanta, had our bags with use and she set us up at the perfect table and took EXTRA great care of us. Her friendly smile and wonderful personality made our day!! Thank you Rhyland!!!! read more

Amazing food! Our server Rhylan was great, friendly, and had amazing recommendations. Will be back! read more

Sid's Garage - Beer Bar Near Me - Boise, Idaho

Saw this place on TikTok. It was our last stop on a Sunday before heading to the airport. As a place that was highly recommended, I wasn't very impressed. It wasn't bad either. I am more of an old fashioned burger kind of guy and the combinations that they had just weren't that appealing to me. The fries were good and the beer was cold though. The place is pretty cool, it sits on the corner and has cool vibes! The server was nice and welcoming. read more

Sid's Garage - Beer Bar Near Me - Boise, Idaho

See all

Really cool vibe here. I adore the painting of Joan Jett on the wall. The kids really enjoyed the cookie monster shake. I had the fun Pbb&j burger, served in a fender speaker looking lunchbox. The fries were tasty, a bit peppery for my big fella but he ate them anyway. read more

Sid's Garage - Cookie Monster shake - Beer Bar Near Me - Boise, Idaho

See all

We really enjoyed Sids the location is perfect and hreat to grab a bite! Irie was amazing she was quick and so very nice!!!

We found this spot without knowing it is a spot. If you ever come to town this is a must visit place. The burgers and tots are to die for. Our hostess was so friendly and knowledgeable. I am so full and happy. read more

See all

Excellent burgers, some of the best I've had, topped off great service at the location. Fun environment to eat and socialize in. Love the fact that they use tallow and no seed oils. That should be the standard everywhere. Glad they are setting an example with this. read more

Amazing sweet potatoe fries! Unreal actually and their burgers and epic!! Definitely a go to spot.

Party of 8 "enjoyed" adequate food and service but are all hoarse from screaming to converse over the VERY LOUD music. if that "ambiance" is intended to drive away a certain demographic, it's working. I'll never set foot in the place again! read more

I've always loved Sid's garage, but after last night, I don't think I could ever go there again. I got the hangover burger, and I noticed that the last few bites were almost raw, and I should've listened to my intuition and not eaten the rest of that burger, because boy did I get sick. My partner who had bacon on her burger that seemed to be undercooked also got sick. Yeah, that's the last time I ever go to Sid's. read more

Came in on Halloween for lunch. All of the weight staff was dressed up extremely friendly and happy to be there. I'm from out of state so I've never been here before the waiter was very helpful. Explain the menu provided suggestions and gave us the time we needed as a group of five to figure out our order.under the group, there was a multiple things that were ordered. We had pretzel bites onion rings and green beans from the appetizers we ordered a fig burger French onion burger two other basic burgers I don't remember the specific names of all of the burgers. Everyone shared everyone shared and enjoyed. if you're planning on using the restroom, you have a bit of a walk. read more

See all

We were pleased with our first visit to Sid's Garage. The choices of the Nashville Hot Chicken, Steakhouse Burger, and paired with a side of Parmesan Truffle fries were a hit with the wife and myself. Food was prepared quite well, so big kudos to the kitchen staff. Our server was amazing, friendly, and spot on everything she did for us. We admit we heard mixed reviews, but our visit proved to be a great choice. Love the casual atmosphere of the place. We loved sitting in the high table nearest the windows to enjoy the city life happening outside. read more

Amazing food and great service. Cozy seating area. Crowd was everything from prom goers to kids birthday. Loved it.

Great burger! We had the whiskey bacon. Go in ask for Evan he will tell you why their food is so amazing. Then get a shake we got the one that has peach in it, I wasn't really crazy about how it sounded BUT Evan told me all about it and I'm so glad I did. Take a friend the portions a big. The inside is fun or you can sit outside also! So glad we stop here. Thanks Evan! read more

Okay, about the nastiest burger I have ever had. The meat was severly undercooked and all the slop they put on the burger basically made it inedible. The owner/manager was a total douche when I complained. Would not recommend this to anyone!! read more

First off, fun vibe. Great service. The fries are by far the most memorable in a long time. Fried in beef tallow. It makes a difference! Tossed in a local salt-pepper-cayenne seasoning. Single order definitely enough to share, maybe even with three. Whisky Bacon burger was huge. Very good. I'll come back next time I'm in Boise! read more

See all

Love the vibe!! We found this place on Yelp and had to try it out while visiting Idaho. Our waiter was friendly and was so welcoming! He asked if if we had visited before and when we shared that it was our first time he gave us some recommendations. We started with some beers and an appetizer. We ordered the Blood orange Hefenweizen and the Tempura Green Beans. We definitely came for the vibe and the crazy menu options, they are very unique. I ordered the Not So Wimpy burger and my hubby ordered the Hangover burger WOW!!! We also ordered the Parmesan fries- delicious!! read more

See all

I visited Boise and decided to go to Sid' Garage for my first meal there and everything about the place was amazing. The servers were great and we shared a laugh on how I was from California but they were so cool. The food was amazing. I had the Mimosa Flight and it was super. I am not a mimosa drinker but that was amazing. I also had the Classy Redneck Boozy Shake and it was perfect. Finally, the Boss Hogg Burger was super cool and with a side of tater tots (That were seasoned perfectly). I loved the vibe of the place. A little bit of the underground, punk rock feel. Hopefully, I can get to Boise again and the first place I will head is to Sid's Garage. read more

See all

Traveled through Boise on tour a few days ago and popped into Sid's by chance. We came in about 20 minutes before close and were expecting attitude and eye rolls, but all the staff was super kind and the guys in the kitchen ended up absolutely crushing it. I got the PB&J burger and the loco fries. Some of the best food I've ever had. Absolutely delicious, cooked and seasoned wonderfully. The service was incredible as well. My band mates got wings and the trailer trash burger and they were both really stoked on their food. Our server was super prompt, had great energy, and just genuinely seemed to enjoy her job. Bonus, my burger came out in a little fender amp lunchbox. Great overall time, well lit and fun decor, and will definitely be back next time we go through Boise read more

Waitress did not bring waters to the table. Took a long time to come back and get our orders. When we got our orders in the food took forever. The food itself was repulsive and sad. We were looking forward to the downtown location as the Meridian location is on point and really good. However I would not recommend the DT Boise location. Also, the music was really loud and the worst version of early 2000's rock I've ever heard. read more

Update time. See my earlier review for a more detailed run down but wanted to adjust this accordingly. Sids is still great if you are in the mood for an over the top culinary pub/restaurant style burger. Unique flavor profiles stand out at Sid's. So if that's what you're looking for it's the place for you. If you are looking for the juiciest tastiest burger in town....well this isn't it, but you won't be disappointed or shun for choosing it either. read more

Sid's Garage - Jekyll & Hyde - Beer Bar Near Me - Boise, Idaho

See all

Such a fun idea! Great burgers and appetizers, AMAZING milkshakes. We went to the Village Meridian location and had an absolute blast. Service was quick, our waitress gave amazing recommendations (el jefe burger and the truffle fries). Ambiance is very fun, very casual. Loud music and chatter but not too loud that you can't have a conversation. Pricing is pretty reasonable! I believe we spent around $50 for everything. The death by chocolate milk is literally to die for, I highly recommend ending your meal with this. read more

See all

In town for the holidays and heard this place was good. Damn, it did not disappoint. I got the 208 burger. The brie, fig jam, and Granny Smith apple on a thick patty was killer! We also got the loco fries and they were also really tasty! The service was always asking if we wanted another drink or water filled. They're all awesome. The ambiance is decent. Environment is nothing to write home about, but I don't think that really affects how good the food tasted. It's clean, well lit, and the music is solid rock. read more

See all

Average burger joint. I actually came in for the Elote Hot Dog that was on their menu, but is now no longer being served. So I got the Trailer Trash burger because it sounded good. Although it fulfilled my hunger, the taste wasn't there for me. Our server was one of the best that we have had. She was very attentive. read more

See all

Omg best milkshakes and burgers ever!!! They are giant so great to share! Inside it's so cool too and has a great atmosphere! And the service is always great! 100/10 I would definitely recommend! read more

I was in town visiting. I got the chicken sandwich and it was delicious. If I'm in Boise again I definitely will return.

Very disappointed. They once had the best burger I have ever had. They removed it from the menu. They removed both the candied pork belly burger and the full throttle fries. Our Exchange student from Germany was visiting for Christmas and asked to eat there again. There were 5 of us and it ran $125ish dollars for mediocre burgers at best. I didn't even finish 1/2 of mine. We shared 1 basket of plain fries and had 2 drinks and 3 waters. Our exchange student finished his burger but said, "It wasn't as good good as the other burger." He was being kind. Honestly, 5 guys or Smash burgers its all the same as Sid's and at least you get fries and a drink with your meal at the other two, and know ALWAYS know what's on the menu. The music (classic rock) was okay but I was disappointed to the point I ate less than half of a burger, and I left the rest on the plate. You had something great, I recommended you guys to everyone looking for a great burger. Now I don't know how you manage to keep the doors open. I had to get on Facebook an offer my friends an apology for wasting their money. Worse part is, several friends replied they went and tried your food and wondered what I was talking about when I recommended you guys! The server was okay he could tell I wasn't happy. He did get our order wrong, and was very apologetic, but it was par for course of the experience. He brought us 5 pieces of bacon hanging from stupid wire thing, instead of the full throttle fries. He explained he was confused because they no longer serve the fries. Later he asked if I didn't like my burger, I told him honestly, "It was no better or worse than any other burger anywhere else, just more expensive. Very disappointing". To his credit he did asked if there was anything he could do to make our meal better. So there is that, and that at least you hired intuitive staff. Had I not been with family I would have simply walked out as soon as I discovered the menu changes. As for your response the reviews are all from the same account they didn't seem to be posting. I really don't post much on yelp, in fact I only have 1 other post so it should tell you how disappointed I was with your food. To be fair I removed one of the extras reviews. I will check again tomorrow to see if the other pops up and remove it too, so there is only one review from me. The fact you responded in 25 minutes tells me I hit a nerve.... I take it things are already not going well. Too bad, at one point you guys were great. Good luck. Oh just checked, you are mad my wife posted as well? lol! What, a woman's opinion doesn't matter? I didn't even know she posted. Your response to her was over the top tough guy, sure the people in the in valley will be impressed. Hopes it helps your business. Ahhhh so you again edited your response to take out all BS you were talking and instead say I treated your staff disrespectful. I don't believe anyone will believe you, since I specifically complimented your staff in the above review. It was the only bright spot of the visit. I also notice in the other poor reviews, you accuse several dissatisfied customers of being disrespectful to your staff. Seems to me you are to childish to take responsibility for knowingly advertising menu items such as the Boss Hog and full throttle fries on your site when you know they have been removed from your menu. As for your business is doing well, I hope so, but I suspect you wouldn't be on Yelp so obviously lying, and denying any wrong doing in your negative reviews if that were true. Another edit and more lies huh? Not like people can't check my Yelp account to see exactly what I posted.... I have two posts one regarding your business, the other an airline. However on a positive note, almost 900 views so far, and roughly twenty private messages, people laughing at you, and swearing off you business. Katzu thank you for messages especially, they made me laugh!! read more

Very disappointed in the new menu. Took off what was the best and unique part of going to Sid's. Sadly won't be back, with this response from you, sad I am only posting once as my husband posted otherwise read more