Absolutely perfect bar food. The buffets they have are always amazing. I just wish they had a…read morewebsite or something that posted the weekly food schedule, rather than you having to make the drive to look at the sign on the door. Bonus - the waitresses are exceedingly cute.

Amazing food! The fries are amazing, the chicken is a MUST HAVE item if you go there. The day we…read morewent, there was only one person running the entire place! Bar, cook and waitress. She was very nice. We had chicken, walleye and amazing fries! Will come back again.

Was here years ago and I'm so happy it's still around. Was driving past Green Bay to Milwaukee and…read moreI wanted to see if I could find the restaurant so that maybe one day I'd go back and get the amazing steak sandwich, and it is

Cool bar vibe, chock full of taxidermy, with excellent salmon burgers to die for. Your favorite…read moreplace to day drink.

Learned of this restaurant (more of a bar) when I saw them cook on a morning talk show a while…read moreback. Decided to give it a try and was highly disappointed. First flag, Saturday afternoon lunch (a little of a late lunch) but no one in the place. Waitress was nice, and the menu had all day breakfast along with lunch and dinner offerings. The specials on the wall added a number of choices too. We ordered a bowl of Chicken noodle soup to share, I had the Country Fried Steak (special on the board) and my wife had a cheeseburger and onion rings. First the good, the onions rings were great and the soup was better than average. Burger was okay, with a very good bun. What was disappointing? We ordered and our waitress disappeared until the food was done. We wanted our soup first (which is the way it should be served) but we couldn't find anyone to ask for it. Of course our food came out, and then we got the soup! My meal sucked! Everything was greasy....the hash browns, the eggs and the steak. I tried, but I couldn't eat it. Even the eggs that were supposed to be "over easy" were hard. The hash browns were a gray color and for some reason buried underneath the gravy covered County Fried Steak. Only thing good about my meal was the sourdough toast! Adding to the bad meal, which was actually funny, was that the wet naps they handed out with the meal were dry as a bone! How old do wet nap packages have to be to be dried out?! Prices were reasonable, but because I left most of my meal on my plate it wasn't too great of a value. Not a place I'd go back to.

Very unexpected to have such a great restaurant in Abrams! The food quality is multiple levels…read moreabove food served in other bar/restaurants and truck stops. And the server Emma is exceptional. Great personality, hard worker, and very attentive. Highly recommended!

Always great delicious food, great drinks and the best service!! Highly recommended!! Everything is…read morevery reasonably priced!!

Very clean little food and bar.. service was above excellent.. a little wait for our food, but was…read moreworth the wait.. we got the opportunity to try the walleye cheeks, I will call them scallops of the river,so delicious .. we will definitely be back..

Not very special. Not many cars in the parking lot, went in and was only taking people that had…read morereservations.

6:15 arrival on a Wednesday without a reservation. Sat fairly promptly. Ordered apps and drinks…read more Calamari was over done. Very chewy. Drinks arrived after the calamari. Nothing fancy just a neat bourbon. Had one of the month of June specials. Grouper. Overdone as well. Wife had a bone in ribeye. Cooked properly and tender. Not much flavor. All in all a definite do not recommend. .

Something just seems different here? New owners? I am not sure. This is my usual go to when I am in…read moreSturgeon Bay. The olive tapenade & goat cheese was ok. It could have used some olive oil. We asked for gluten free bread and multigrain crostini's. We only got the GF bread. The chicken risotto was ok. The sauce was really good but the dish was lacking in veggies and chicken. Our server was nice but I think new and kind of clueless. I may go back and give them another try.

I sat at the bar and had a great experience. The bartender recommended her must-see stops in town…read moreand the surrounding areas, and I took notes. She recommended the Green Goddess salad and a few other favorites. I chose the Green Goddess and Salmon. My salad was fresh! Most of the time, we eat lettuce shipped in on a truck across the state. This salad tasted as if it came straight out of someone's garden in town. Now I'm spoiled and won't look at lettuce the same again. The salmon was slightly overcooked, but it was still good. The homemade green goddess was amazing. I do wish the bread crumb pieces were a little bigger so I could have a crunch element. (just me being picky) I didn't notice they were there, and I love the crunch of croutons on a salad. I didn't drink or have dessert, but the dessert selection sounded amazing!

This restaurant is right on the beach and directly connected to our hotel, making it incredibly…read moreconvenient. They have weekly specials. We dropped by for a late lunch /afternoon snack and ordered the cheese curds and tacos. Both were fresh and flavorful! We spent the afternoon by the water and came back for dinner and ordered the grilled salmon with fries, clam chowder soup and the cherry pie. The salmon was perfectly cooked, and the flavors were excellent. One of the coolest parts about this place (and Door County in general) is that most of the servers are international seasonal workers. They brought such a great, energetic, and friendly vibe to our dining experience! The restaurant offers both indoor and outdoor seating right by the water. Giving it 4 stars because there is definitely room for improvement regarding service pacing and menu clarity: Time your dessert order: The restaurant was busy, so I placed my dessert order along with my dinner. Unfortunately, the hot cherry pie was brought out before we finished our main course, so the ice cream had melted significantly by the time we were ready for it. Taco Fixings: Just a heads-up that the tacos come with meat only by default. It was tasty, but I really wish it had come with some standard toppings or fixings. The Fish Boil sells out fast: They host a fish boil right by the lake, but you absolutely need to reserve well in advance. We tried to book it on Tuesday afternoon right after checking into our hotel, and it was already completely sold out for the night.

Sorry but this was the worst experience I've had traveling. Food was disgusting and the bugs on the…read morepatio harassed us the whole meal. Had fish n chips (chef special ). I really think it was made the night before. Dry and greasy. Left such a bad taste we went to Kitty O'Reilly's Irish pub and had the best Fish n Chips so I know Sturgeon Bay has good fish. I won't be back to Waterfront Mary's.

Visited and had a perch fish fry at this very pleasant restaurant. Sit outside on a beautiful deck…read moreoverlooking the bay of Green Bay. The perch had a light batter and substituted a garden salad for Cole slaw for $2 upcharge. Very reasonable charge and well worth it. Another diner had the tenderloin and thoroughly enjoyed it as prepared as ordered. The tenderloin did come with unique carrots which seemed a bit over cooked.Service by Dana was very attentive and helpful. I also ordered the margarita flight which had four unique (see the pic) and yummy margaritas. A spicy, a cherry an agave and a mango. Party of 4 and no reservation and sat immediately. Only take reservations for parties of 8 or more. Nice place, great service, good food made for a pleasant dining experience.

I called 20 minutes before they closed, hoping I *might* be able to order a fish fry dinner for…read morecarryout (I know it was late and was just turned away from another establishment closer to our resort because they were too busy for carryout orders) and the hostess could not have been nicer. I was able to order my two perch dinners, they were ready in no time at all, I went in to pick them up, was treated very kindly and she ensured that I had everything I needed before I left. All was packaged nicely and correctly. The food was absolutely delicious and there was plenty of it. The restaurant looks very nice inside and I hope to be able to experience the ambiance in the future, however after a long day out and about, this was perfect and hit the spot.