Visited and had a perch fish fry at this very pleasant restaurant. Sit outside on a beautiful deck overlooking the bay of Green Bay. The perch had a light batter and substituted a garden salad for Cole slaw for $2 upcharge. Very reasonable charge and well worth it. Another diner had the tenderloin and thoroughly enjoyed it as prepared as ordered. The tenderloin did come with unique carrots which seemed a bit over cooked.Service by Dana was very attentive and helpful. I also ordered the margarita flight which had four unique (see the pic) and yummy margaritas. A spicy, a cherry an agave and a mango. Party of 4 and no reservation and sat immediately. Only take reservations for parties of 8 or more. Nice place, great service, good food made for a pleasant dining experience. read more

See all

I called 20 minutes before they closed, hoping I *might* be able to order a fish fry dinner for carryout (I know it was late and was just turned away from another establishment closer to our resort because they were too busy for carryout orders) and the hostess could not have been nicer. I was able to order my two perch dinners, they were ready in no time at all, I went in to pick them up, was treated very kindly and she ensured that I had everything I needed before I left. All was packaged nicely and correctly. The food was absolutely delicious and there was plenty of it. The restaurant looks very nice inside and I hope to be able to experience the ambiance in the future, however after a long day out and about, this was perfect and hit the spot. read more

Just had another wonderful dinner at Carrington. We always try to go there at least once while we're here. No wait and we dined outside with one of the best dinner views in Door County. They have a baked whitefish special that is really out of this world. You should try it. read more

Went for Comedy night dinner show. Wasn't sure what to expect. Buffet style meal - German theme with good selection of authentic dishes. I particularly liked the pot roast with vegetables. Also had chicken, fish and sausage. Sides were just like grandma makes. There was plenty to eat. And, we did. Dessert was German Chocolate cake. The comedians did about a 90 minute show. It was interactive so the closer you sat to the stage then more fun you had. Lots of kibitzing and nothing off color. We had fun. Overall the food was fine. Nothing to rave about. Wished the dinner plates had been warmed. Good hot food on very cold plates didn't sit well with me. The show was mid range. No guy busting laughing but plenty of chuckles and a lot of self depreciation. We would do it again. Learned that they have other theme nights, so check that out before you go. read more

We were staying at the Landmark Resort for a short birthday weekend trip, and reserved a 7:00 table the Friday night we arrived. The staff was friendly, but to say they were understaffed on a beautiful fall weekend would be an understatement. All we could see was one bartender who was barely keeping up, one waitress who was friendly and doing her best, the hostess who was also bussing tables just to get people seated, and one other young man who seemed to be trying to help out where he could. We finally got a table around 7:20, ordered some drinks, and waited. The bar was stacked with dirty glasses they couldn't find time to clear or wash, and the drinks took about 15 minutes to come out. Both were good, and the waitress did keep our waters filled. Sadly, the food was average at best. The whitefish and ribs were both slightly overcooked. The portion sizes were great, but the fries and vegetables on the side were not. The Gouda Mac & Cheese at least, was excellent. Overall, we were hoping for more, but it was far from the worst experience we've had, and the staff was all extremely friendly and trying their best. read more

Amazing service and a view to die for. We so enjoyed our dinner there. They could expand their menu offerings some I think.

Wow this place is BUSY! They are bumpin, probably because of their attachment to the resort. It's wall the wall people, even just waiting for a pick up order. We ordered the shrimp scampi, crab cakes, and the Granny Smith salad. The shrimp scampi was drowned in grease and butter, the crab cakes were good, but mushy and on top of rotted lettuce. The salad was okay. It's fine food for when you are at the resort, but I think the prices are too high for what you get. read more

Carrington - Maryland-Style Crab Cakes - New American Near Me - Egg Harbor, Wisconsin

See all

Should say I loved what I ordered -- my salmon is cooked just right, the sauce was on the sweeter side but it's ok, the veggies were not overcooked and the fingerling potatoes were not overcooked. My hubby didn't really like his because it's not the typical chicken piccata that he was familiar with. He said it tasted like raw garlic and lemon. And the chicken didn't look like a piccata (light colored). He was trying to season it with salt and pepper to his liking but gave up eventually. I combined our order -- my fish and his fettuccine, and ended up liking it. They complement each other. The sweetness of my fish balanced his tangy fettuccine that's why I took a picture of it. Overall experience.. it was fair. Our waiter was attentive on the start when we were about to get our order then got tied up towards the end. read more

See all

We loved our meals. Their coconut shrimp was so good and they had a vegan option for our vegan! Yellow curry that was delicious. My husband LOVED the ribs with cherry bbq sauce. The service was excellent. And we met some new people. And we got to see a gorgeous sunset! read more

A great aspect of the Landmark Resort! Our family always enjoys having dinner here when we stay at the resort. The service, food, and ambiance are all very good. read more

If your looking for mediocre food and terrible service then you've hit the jackpot. I hope you want French fries because that's about the only thing coming out of the kitchen that's fairly edible. FYI our Waiter didn't know what a dirty martini was! Never refilled our waters and My sister ordered a quesadilla and they didn't give her the sour cream and salsa it was supposed to come with! Taco Bell does better. On top of that the manager was rude straight to our face. He said he would get the check, we told him we need two checks and he said why don't you make it more complicated!!! Customer is not always right I guess... read more

Carrington - The Smorgasbord - New American Near Me - Egg Harbor, Wisconsin

So, up front, let me say this. We just came in for coffee and dessert after a fantastic meal at The Fireside...coming here was a disastrous choice, but comical as you will soon learn. My wife and I decided to "spread the wealth," and try another local establishment for dessert and coffee. We quickly realized that Door County coffee shops close early...like 3 pm early. Also, on a cool, rainy day, the ice cream shops are kind of "outdoorsy." So that was a no-go. We headed back to our resort and figured, "Hey, let's give the on-site restaurant a shot." Immediately upon meeting the host we regretted it. When we explained that we were just there for dessert and coffee, he rolled his eyes and said [actual quote], "Well, then I WON'T sit you by a window." Had clearer heads prevailed, we would have turned right around and left. But, knowing that a dumpster-fire experience like this only comes around once in a great while, we decided to roll with it to see if the rest of the experience could salvage this opening gaffe. Oh brother, keep reading if you want a laugh. After being relegated to "coach seating" for the temerity of just wanting dessert, we met our pleasantly earnest, if not quizzically confused server. Please understand, this person was nice, but clearly a member of the wait staff's "B team." Understandably, a couple coming in for dessert is not the kind of table that promises a huge tip, but remember, we had run out of options and we always tip a better if we aren't eating a full meal. When we ordered our dessert, we split a S'mores Brownie Sundae, which was really quite good. My wife asked if the restaurant has any specialty coffees, taking a flyer that maybe they'd have a capachino or something. Our server, innocently answered, "we have decaf." We went with the full on caffeinated. The coffee was not great. Our server seemed very concerned about delivering the coffee and handled them as one might handle a German bier stein... if it contained plutonium. We seriously held back laughter as our server brought out the coffee in a way that one might handle a potential biohazard. My wife, who always surprises me, actually went for a refill, which I think she did as kind of an experiment to see what would happen. Also, because her coffee was getting cold by the time the brownie arrived. Yep, they charged us another $2.50 for the second cup. In total, $7.50 for 3 cups of subpar coffee. Awesome! As we exited the now understandably sparsely populated establishment, we knew that would not be back. We offer this post as fair warning. read more

Carrington Pub & Grill in Door County, WI. CHEESE CURDS-I mean, come on. When in Wisconsin...gooey, piping hot fried cheese? Does it get better?? Only negative IMO? Bottled ranch dressing is gross; get a better product or make your own! The generic Sysco ranch should be illegal in "fine" dining establishments. #ranchsnob FRIDAY FISH FRY-lightly battered cod, creamy slaw, homecut steak fries (think steak fry meets curly fry) and a side of tartar sauce. Freshly fried and hot, great flavor. TILAPIA-lightly battered tilapia with a baked potato. Batter is different than the cod, more flavor and lighter, but delicious. Two awesome sized fillets piping hot. PULLED PORK SAMMICH-this one is unique. The pulled pork is a combination of tart cherries and pulled bbq pork (when cherry pie meets the oinker)! It was uniquely satisfying to the taste buds, and I don't love cherry pie nor bbq but this was a different and exciting twist. Last, but not least, LIMONCELLO PASTA-Scallops and mussels pasta in a lemon butter sauce. I am glad I didn't order this, though I had planned to, as the first thing I noticed were that they were bay scallops and that's a turnoff for me in most pasta recipes. It's like ordering "crab" in my pasta and getting pollock imitation crab NO! But my friend said his was great, buttery and tasty, and a hint of lemon. Black mussels were plentiful. Cherry tart and chocolate lava cake to top the evening off. Tart was so hot it bubbled at the table, and chocolate lava cake I wouldn't call a lava cake but it definitely was chocolatey. When I think lava I think flowing chocolate, this was just chocolate cake (though very good). Outdoor seating required a reservation, unfortunately. I don't love outdoor seating but in this instance I was excited, then disappointed after finding out there were no tables open. Inside was a cool 50° requiring me to borrow my friend's jean jacket to keep from breathing ice . Staff all wore masks, server was kind and from Bulgaria, food and drinks were VERY PROMPT (no waiting around long for food here!)!!! read more

See all

My sister picked this place after a small family funeral. We were early, and they were very accommodating! We sat at the perfect table by the fireplace. The view is spectacular, but we knew that because we hail from Door County. Very pleasant service, the food outstanding. Saw my favorite Au poirve on the menu, and it was delicious. Everyone enjoyed everything from the drinks to dessert. Thank you, Carrington, for a great "early" evening! We will be back! read more

Please do yourself a favor and dine somewhere else. We got our food to go, as the weather was chilly and we originally wanted to eat on their beautiful patio. We got our food home, and my boyfriends Ribeye was GRAY! a $38 "steak frites" was disgustingly salty fries, a gray steak, and old wilted greens on top of it! I am livid we paid this much for such inedible food. He even tried putting ketchup on the steak to tolerate it... so gross. I ordered "the award winning" cherry BBQ ribs, they weren't bad. Not anything to write home about, though. Skip this place and go to Chop like we should have. read more

Carrington - New American Near Me - Egg Harbor, Wisconsin

Since we were staying at the Landmark we decided to visit the Carrington for a late dinner. Our server Jolena was a joy. Food was good. Shrimp scampi was delish and husband has the daily soup of loaded potato and then a bolanase was ok. Looking forward to warmer weather to dine on the outside deck with beautiful views overlooking Green Bay. read more

The walleye and ribs are highly recommended. They were prepared perfectly. The fish was crispy and the ribs with bourbon cherry sauce were moist and chewy. The manager came by our table to be sure we were satisfied with our experience - such a nice touch. Thanks to all of the staff for a great evening! read more

Carrington - Ribs and Line-Caught Walleye - New American Near Me - Egg Harbor, Wisconsin

nice view! Food is ok. Nothing special. Female bartender with pink hair won't let you eat at the bar but the male bartenders will let you eat at the bar. I don't get it read more

We arrived on a Tues night where the wait time was 2 hours-ish so placed reservations for Thursday. The day came and I'm sad to say we were disappointed. Food did not meet expectations of quality (for the price we paid). The bar was in (roughly) the same space as the dining area inside, which seemed to negatively contrast the "high quality" environment we were expecting. We are very understanding people and considering covid and labor issues, we know everyone is hurting so it further pains us to leave a review like this. The staff were all very nice and service was reasonable. Overall, the hype we saw Tuesday night raised our expectations quite high, and the food wasn't bad, just pricey for the quality. I hope this is taken as more constructive criticism than a disgruntled customer trying to mischaracterize the dining experience of this establishment. We ended up leaving unsatisfied and went somewhere else for a desert and appetizer. If we come back to door county, we may give this place another chance, but the competition will change the likely hood of that. If you are looking for a good view and good time with some appetizers, sitting outside, this place might be a nice start. read more

4 of us from Sturgeon Bay went looking for a fish fry. The ribs here with cherry sauce are divine, so we thought we'd try their fish. 2 of use had the fish fry, with both cod and walleye. It was OUTSTANDING! Perfectly cooked and nice-sized portions. Two of us had just the regular walleye dinners, and they also did not disappoint! The cole slaw was very tasty with just enough dressing and no strong unpleasant flavor. The potatoes were very tasty; two of us had broccoli and it was cooked well - not too mushy, but not raw. Great wait-staff , and the chef even came out in person to see how we liked everything! We will be back! read more

If I could give 0 stars, I would. $30 steak tenderloin, basically beef jerky. It took over 30 minutes to even order our entree's and then waited another 45 for it. It wasn't busy, we were patient but this was hands down one worst dining experience ever. Food is mediocre and the service is even worse. If you love your server to constantly roll her eyes while you order or forget any refill requests, then come on down. Absolutely horrendous. read more

Oh dear Carrington. I was hoping this resort restaurant would mirror the tv show Dynasty. Hmm not so much. The waiter was very nice and helpful. The food, well I'm at a loss. I can't believe fried appetizers can be ruined, but there you have it. We should have figured something was off when RC cola was on the menu. Granted, RC was my favorite in 1980. I can't even remember what we all ordered for entrees, but everyone in our party agreed they were bland. read more

Ordered the beef tenderloin for $30. This was the most disgusting piece of meat I have seen in my life. It smelled rotten and it was over-seasoned to hide that it was very expired. The texture was slimy and rubbery. I was throwing up all night (and I only took 2 bites). read more

Great deck overlooking the water. A little off the beaten path, but worth the drive out of Egg Harbor. Friendly staff. Great charcuterie board appetizer and solid entrees. read more

I went on New Years Eve. What a disappointment. I should have know when I saw the place almost empty. The service was terrible. Wait staff just standing around. Paid $220 for 6 meals that was almost to the point of gross. Our waitress made the comment that it wasn't her fault that their chef was stingy when we asked for dressing for the salads. I ordered chicken Caesar salad and it came with 3 small bites of chicken that I think were from the refrigerator in a week? Not freshly cooked and insane for the price. I would never go back. Could be a beautiful setting if someone would hire a decorator and hang something nice on the wall. read more

Good new menu. Wife had Chili Colorado and me Hot Brown. Both unique and tasty dinners reasonably priced. Good service. Nice time.

Great food. Excellent service. Best view in Door County! This is our "go to" restaurant.

All around experience was wonderful!! First time visit. My son is now a fish lover! My steak was cooked to medium as I asked. My wife's chicken piccata was amazing! Our waiter, Prem Lama was excellent! We went with his recommendation on the Cherry Crisp with ice cream. It was a knock out! Nice Job Prem! If you're in Egg Harbor please check it out. One more thing, Please call ahead for a reservation. Covid-19 has screwed everything up. I recommend a visit. read more

Carrington - Carrington Pub & Grill, Door County - New American Near Me - Egg Harbor, Wisconsin

Great view. Good service. Consistently good food. One of our favorites. Love sitting on the patio

I understand restaurants may be short staffed due to COVID Gov incentives not to work, and it was a little early in their tourist season, but neither is an excuse for rude behavior. The food was great, so obviously the kitchen staff are doing their part, but the rest of the service was a complete joke. The wait staff actually appeared put out and offended that we actually come in. There were several tables on the deck this night and our fellow diners were having the same experience as we did. This was my first time eating here, so I will probably give them another shot because the food was good, and maybe it was just an off night. But I will be checking other yelper's post first to see if the pattern is continuing. If so, I won't waste my time. There are plenty of good restaurants that appreciate those of us customers that still support them during COVID and off season. read more

This was our first visit. We were a bit wary after reading some negative reviews here. We had an excellent experience. We were seated on arrival. Someone immediately brought water. Our waitress, Katie, was friendly, efficient, and attentive throughout the meal. Our food was delicious and served in a timely fashion. We will return. read more

Who changes the big screen that guests are watching during the Bucks playoff game 7, tied in the 4th for karaoke...which is really just the karaoke worker singing. But I can watch it on the tiny one on an angle. read more

Carrington - New American Near Me - Egg Harbor, Wisconsin

See all

Food was delicious! I was dining with a big group, and they were able to accommodate well. There was a decent view of the lake from our table and a cute fire place outside. read more

This is a great grill stopping point out in the woods. We found that the ribs were actually really good as well as the cheese curds. All of our other food, burger, club sandwich, and Caesar salad were all very good and I'd highly recommend. read more

Very friendly staff, tasty food. Went for brunch and was very pleased. A little bland (needed salt) but I don't mind that as it can always be added. All meats were cooked very near perfection. Quality selection of fruit and healthy options. Omelette station was great and tasted magnificent. The view is beyond compare. Indoor or outdoor shaded seating. Would highly recommend. Oh, and a bottomless mimosa glass. read more

Carrington - The view from our random seating at the Carrington. Doesn't get much better than this in Door County. - New American Near Me - Egg Harbor, Wisconsin

Wonderful views and beautiful patio setting! Great cheese curds and artichoke dip. Enjoyed the rosé as well while watching the sunset. However, most of our party ordered the Caesar salad which clearly states in the menu description "crispy or grilled chicken" as part of the salad. When we got our bill we were charged an additional $6 per salad to add chicken. When we brought this to attention we were told it would be removed from the bill. We were then charged the original amount, told our bill couldn't be voided but we could have a drink on the house instead. 21 dollars for a Caesar salad....almost more than anything else on the menu? Perhaps make the menu more clear and not include items in the description and then charge more for them. It was a lovely evening until the hour long end that resulted in drinks we didn't need or want and 40 dollars on chicken we already paid for. read more

Carrington - Caesar Salad description from Carrington's own website which says it includes chicken, but we were up-charged an additional $6 for chicken! - New American Near Me - Egg Harbor, Wisconsin

I visited with my family a week ago. We had an unusual experience where almost everything went wrong with the service, but I personally enjoyed the food. I sized up the menu and decided to go with the salmon, which ended up being good. Not everybody in my party liked their meal as much as I did. Actually I think I was the only one who had a decent experience here of the eight of us. I hear that people really did not like the buffalo chicken wrap and my wife didn't care for her sandwich. We had a very odd waiter who couldn't get anything right and said some bizarre things. We sat outside and had a lovely view of the water. That was probably my favorite thing about the meal. For me it was a decent experience, but the service was ridiculous. The manager did come by to apologize though, so they are professional here. read more

Carrington - New American Near Me - Egg Harbor, Wisconsin

Tried this place twice now in the past year. Neither experience was good and I think we won't try again. Service is less than expected and food was not appetizing. Both visits we asked if we could sit at the bar and told very rudely that no food is served at the bar, they can't have their bartender spend time getting food for patrons. It's unfortunate for Carrington because we then went into town to a crowded dinner venue and were gladly welcomed up to their rooftop to eat and drink. The Carrington should be so much more and it just is not. read more

We just had a great meal, and a great server! Greg was the bomb. He knew the menu so well and really helped us enjoy the whole experience there. We come to stay at the landmark every winter and it's fun to walk over and have a great dinner at the Carrington too. read more

We should have minded the bad reviews and so many previous complaints, all realized on our past visit. 1) We immediately felt like we were intruding, and heard countless complaints about the working conditions/ hours from the staff. They close at 8 pm every night and 9pm on the weekends, are you kidding me"? 2) loud bartender with pink hair, just killed the resort vibe. She was yelling across the restaurant at one of her bus boys "You always steal my cherry. There was a bunch of us sitting at a table and we all just looked at each other? 3) Considering the price, the wait and the quality of food, we wouldn't go back. We did feel bad for the man bringing food to the tables, he had a thankless job and good demeanor. 4) The service is slowwwwwww. As a side note , There's an older woman bartending at Mojo Rosa's down the road and she was juggling dinner and drinks for a dozen people with just one person helping her and about as pleasant as it gets(If I managed the Carrington, I'd track her down).We had no other issues dinning at the other establishments in town most of them as busy or busier than the Carrington, Which is quite fortunate to be sitting next to a resort. read more