I have been to this restaurant twice. I ordered a solid tagliatelle with chicken both times, as I am an excessively picky eater. Despite the slightly odd looks I got from the waiter for not ordering the sauce that was supposed to go with it, the pasta was inarguably delicious and easily sufficed as a magnificent comfort food. The part of the evening that lacked magnificence was the drink situation. As aforementioned, I am pickier than the average picky eater, and would consider myself difficult to please at restaurants. But what I do not believe that I deserved was the refusal to give me water without lemon. I often overreact - I have succumbed to the diva lifestyle - but this story is far short of an exaggeration. I have been undoubtedly gravely wronged. After we were brought a bottle of water with lemon, I felt bad to send it back after my difficult food order. So we asked a different waiter as kindly as possible to get us a bottle of water without lemon. When he returned, there was no visible lemon in the water and we thanked him gratuitously and with a smile. I poured myself a glass in a sorry attempt to quench my accumulating thirst. When I raised my glass to my lips to try to take a small sip, I almost did a spit take. I have had lemon chicken, lemonade, and even smelled actual lemons. And yet, I have never taken a whiff of anything with such a large, strong lemon smell in my long 17 years of life. My two friends still had cups of water from the original bottle of water with a visible lemon, and yet these cups smelled suspiciously significantly less like lemons. I could not tell you why this supposed lemon-lacking water has even more lemon than the water with a legitimate lemon in it, but what I can tell you with ease is that I was not pleased to not be able to drink any water throughout my whole meal. I know I am picky, but I am still the customer. If I had been allergic and had drank that high of a concentration of lemon, who knows what could have happened? I trusted the waiter to cleanse my water of lemon, and that is just despairingly not what played out. Nonetheless, The Shack Restaurant has excellent food. But please, take it from me, and do not order water without lemon. You will regret it. read more