I had high hopes for a new bbq place near Boston. Ive struggled to find great BBQ anywhere near the city since I moved here from Florida about a decade ago. Secret sauce does a decent job with some things, and completely drops the ball on others.
The good: Ribs were actually smokey, decently well cooked but could have been more tender. You get 3 ribs in a 1 meat or 2 meat and two sides meal, so not a very generous portion, but not awful. They seemed a bit under seasoned and relied too much on the sauce...I like a good dry rub with a small amount of sauce..If you like heavier sauces then these should be quite good. I'd say they could have spent another hour in the smoker to get to fall off the bone goodness, but the flavor was nice. The pulled pork was a little chewy, but again, good flavor. They threw in a few triangles of toast and some spicy pickles, made for a decent pulled pork sandwich. One of the sides we got was good (see below).
The bad: we ordered 2 meals. One was 2 meat two side, the other was 1 meat two side. The 1 meat meal had ribs and undercooked (slightly raw) unseasoned "grilled" corn that had 5 kernels with a black mark on them. Smelled off as well, didn't eat it after the first bite. This meal was supposed to come with fries, but they weren't with the delivery. Other meal also came with grilled corn, still a bit under seasoned (came with melted butter on the side, but needed a bit of salt while cooking), but nicely grilled, juicy, and generally good. Big grill marks, nice char, not burnt. Cole slaw was the worst I've ever had. Dry raw cabbage and huge slices of raw red onion. You can see a tiny bit of watered down mayo on some of it, but very little. No flavor other than strong raw onion.
I'd say the ribs and pulled pork could earn a solid 3-4 stars in this area, and if you just want some BBQ it will scratch that itch. Won't win any competitions, but it's a lot better than most of the other bbq places I've tried in the city. Lost a star for terrible sides, and lost a star for bad quality control and missing an item in the delivery. Grilled corn and Cole slaw are some of the easiest sides you'll ever make, and they proved that they know how with one of the ears of corn, but the other was inedible and the Cole slaw was awful. I'll let a lot of small mistakes slide when eating southern food up north, but this was too much.
Might give another chance in a few months if they are still around. If they get their act together and fix up their sides they could be a good local BBQ place. As is I'd say only order if you're really craving BBQ and don't want to drive out of the city to get something better. read more