We heard about Schoolhouse and we were in the area trying to find something to eat. We drove by, found a parking spot close by and popped on in to a pretty much empty restaurant on a Friday around 4pm. The employees noticed we looked confused, and we explained it was our first time here. We were told to grab a menu and any seat in the restaurant. You order at the cash and prepay and they bring it to you when ready.
We went with a half cheese half pepperoni. (We have kids, we had to keep it simple, flash forward, it was still "too cheesy" for them) We also ordered a side ceaser salad, which hubby and I both agreed it was ho hum and we'd skip it next time. The side of hot honey and garlic dipping sauce was scrumptious and a great addition to the pizza.
It did take a while to receive the food and we grew a tad impatient. We did notice a lot of people arriving afterwards for pizza that they had called in for. We even ran into a neighbor who had called in for a pizza and she did explain from past orders wait times can run about and hour or more. So call ahead if you are in a rush.
The pizza was airy, thin, and NY style slices. BIG, and comparable to Di Fara Pizza in Brooklyn, which I have also reviewed. Although I could have easily eaten about 3 slices. The slices were not heavy.
They also serve suzy Q donuts, which we grabbed one for the kid, and gelato which we might go back for in the future. You can grab some premade slices if you are in a rush. They have a self serve water station, and a television in the restaurant. Street parking.
The pizza is a pretty penny, but well worth it. I recommend, and I'd probably be back to take out and bring home. read more