We are out of towners driving up to celebrate our daughter's OB-GYN graduation tomorrow. We read the restaurant's reviews and stopped by for a late lunch at 3 p.m. They lock the doors at 4 p.m. We were impressed. There were two people who came before us, and then a group of 14, and then my husband and me, followed by another bunch of people into a restaurant that was already packed. The waitresses did not even bat an eyelid. They were very polite and were busy doing their work. They were helping seat people as well as checking out people who had just eaten. We only waited about 15 - 20 mins. In the meantime, we chatted with the locals, who told us how often they came here just to eat the pies. When we got seated, the first thing we ordered and got started on were the AMAZING pies (chocolate PB for me and custard for my husband). Oh my God, they were out of the world yummy! We got to watch the ladies on the grill as they made the food. My husband ordered he Swiss steak and I had the double hamburger with all the fixings. The food is great but so are the people who work here --they are just so friendly, have worked here for years and truly care. You don't see this anymore. If I lived here, I would come here once a week to chitchat with them and eat PIE!! Make sure you come here. This place is a gem and has been here since 1948. read more

It takes a lot of work to be that miserable, cranky and grumpy Waitress hated us, hated life? Hated the job?? Just nasty And Apple crumble was BAD Bad experience.. when someone treats you that poorly, you never go back read more

See all

Tried the pies: vanilla peanut butter pie had pronounced vanilla flavor but not overwhelming, nice rich peanut butter flavor you'd expect and the crème topping was a nice light taste that was balanced - the crust however was surprisingly bland and tasteless. Not sure if I expected a honey taste or a typical flaky crust taste what I didn't expect was a complete void of any taste at all. The chocolate peanut butter pie was a bit different had a basic chocolate pudding taste but lacking a huge chocolate flavor like the deep flavor in the vanilla version, shockingly it was lacking was an overall peanut butter flavor while eating the pie unlike its vanilla counterpart where every bite had the PB flavor prevalent in every bite the chocolate version the PB was glaringly absent a big disappointment, the crème topping was balanced and pleasant but thick dominating the flavor of this pie - again the crust however was surprisingly bland and tasteless. Researching menus and the pie history I believe the way it used to be done and now has changed in the past the crème topping was 1/2 the thickness and the PB combo pies had a distinct PB layer between the flavored bottoms and the crème toppings that are lacking in current versions. Past crusts were distinct thickness approx twice the thickness as current versions and a whole different color much browner which would indicate it would have the "flaky" texture you'd expect from their style of pies which currently completely lack any real texture and:or flavor...perhaps it's my batch perhaps I'm being too picky I'm not a pie eater per say but I do know my crusts and what to expect out of a beloved establishment with a rich history in pie making - remember your roots and what made you famous to begin with all the good service in the world won't win you new customers with these pies unfortunately - sadly I cannot recommend these pies for dessert it pains me to write this because I was so happy to see them rebound after the fire - was my first visit as well adding to my disappointment my mum raved about them so expectations were high but alas they failed every level this particular visit - added the picture from your own menu of what I was expecting for visual representation - bring back the past flavors and flaky crust PLEASE!!! PS: Doug & Betty thank you for your reach out and responding to my review it's nice to know owners read reviews - wish more did - I certainly look forward to coming back and giving it all another try - I generally hate leaving bad reviews but also believe in honesty and sharing good and bad, you can't improve what you don't know is wrong - Blessings read more

See all

The pies are still sublime, but unfortunately, after a fire in the past year and the subsequent rebuild and reopening, they are only open for breakfast and lunch--check the hours. So if you want a Wimpy Burger and a slice of pie for dinner, you're out of luck. read more

This is everything a diner should be. Waitresses are on point. The speed of the food was on point. The prices were more than fair. If I lived in the area, I would be at this place constantly. Puts 98% of other diners to shame. read more

Schmucker's is a Toledo institution and you can feel the history when you walk inside. I'm not from Toledo, but I work in town and Schmucker's was one of the first restaurants recommended to me by my coworkers. I recently took my dad and he loved it. The food is simple but good, prices are very reasonable, the service was great, and I appreciate that a cup of coffee comes with the purchase of a meal. I took a slice of peanut butter chocolate pie to go and it was very good even though it was more of a chocolate pie with light peanut butter flavor. read more

Long time serving up pies and eats since 1948. Diner has the old school vibes with a counter which are the best place to sit allowing you to to be in the midst of it all. The dining area is quaint with some booth seating and tables. Service is friendly and each person had a personality that made for the best experience in this old piece of history still doing things well. Nothing screams healthy, my egg salad even had extra mayonnaise slathered on both pieces of bread. The chicken noodle soup had thick egg noodles, the small size is a very generous serving. Pies, yes they make plenty of pies and the earlier you get there your odds go up drastically for getting your choice, I don't know a pie I don't like so just bring a couple slices and call it the end of the day or diet. Awesome spot. read more

See all

Vintage classic all American diner! Super homey, feels like you're in a small town here where locals come to eat and enjoy talking to each other. Service was great! Food was good! The pies were phenomenal! No complaints here. Enjoyed everything about this diner! Would love to come back again! read more

See all

Great homemade pies, including my favorite:rhubarb! Went for lunch two days ago and the place was packed (as it usually is, which tells you people love the good!}. You can get breakfast anytime and I usually do; the servings are huge and always served quickly and hot. But i decided on a cod sandwich and hand-cut fries, which were plentiful, tasty and golden. I love diners, especially ones with counters and stools and Schmucker's has 2 with 6 stools each. People usually talk to the strangers on each side of them and watch the kitchen and waitstaff action. There also 3 or 4 booths and a couple 4 top tables. These are real servers, handling 6 customers at once, calling you "sweetie," and regulars by their first name. My food was hot and delicious and got my pie to go. The crust was flaky and the rhubarb filling tart, which i love. Customers will find specials like hot toast beef or turkey with mashed potatoes, meatloaf, and other comfort meals. The restaurant and women's restroom were clean and eating areas wiped clean immediately. If you're tired of fast food and impersonal eateries, check out this place. read more

See all

Thought I reviewed this place. It's all about the home fries. They are that homemade crispy type with just the right amount of seasoning. I usually get the sausage biscuits with gravy with home fries and eggs. If you get it to go make sure and ask for the biscuits and gravy in a separate container or you'll have gravy all over everything and ruin those wonderful home fries. It's a family-owned restaurant It's been here forever. No online ordering or grubhub. Old school spot. Very small so I very rarely eat in here because it is packed no matter what time of day. The staff is friendly and the food is homemade. Just missing some good grits. All of the breakfast food is very tasty with the biscuits n gravy being my favorite. Can't comment on the lunch items I've never eaten here at lunch time or dinner. No mimosas so it's not quite perfect for me but good for a carryout order. Im not a pie girl but most folks swear by them. Come on by n see if you can get a seat read more

I'm from Michigan. Ive been here many times when I go to Maumee. The food here is so delicious from the breakfast to the dinner items. The pies are out of the world good, some of the best ive ever had. read more

If you're looking for a great local spot, with down home cookin fare and some great staff, this is the spot! We came here for dinner and couldn't wait to come back for breakfast! We ordered the chocolate shake (absolutely amazing), the special (it was a Turkey mashed potato platter), a burger and a big salad and all of us were happy with our choice. My burger was perfectly cooked and had fantastic flavor. The shake was so delicious and rich I was glad I ordered a burger with salty fries - it was the perfect combination. Absolute must visit spot!!! read more

Schmucker's - Inside - Diners Near Me - Toledo, Ohio

We absolutely love this place for breakfast, however on our last visit we had breakfast in the afternoon and the difference was like night and day.. instead of the quality we had just two days before, we ordered our usual one egg over medium homefries with onions toast and bacon. In short bacon was black on one side, potatoes were undercooked and toast was cold. We will return, but only order breakfast in the morning!!! read more

Schmucker's - Panfried steak breakfast - Diners Near Me - Toledo, Ohio

See all

I love the atmosphere and the staff. They are fast and friendly. They also helped provide fresh home made pies for a reasonable price for my father's funeral service. They are always busy but we'll worth the wait. read more

the fruit pies we ordered were disappointing, the crust was soggy, the filling tasteless. Granted fruit is out of season. Not worth the price and asked if I wanted to tip the bakers? No, why? For doing their jobs? read more

I am invisible tonight. Nine minutes. Told four times that "someone will take your order." Nope. I am the only person sitting at the counter. Two open 4-tops. I moved to a table ... server arrived promptly. Loved the meatloaf sandwich and got a slice of pie carry-out. read more

See all

Stopped at Schmucker's for lunch and was blown away! We loved this place. Everything for the old-time diner feel to the phone booth ringing with to go orders. People were lined out the door waiting to get their pies to go and booths to open up. The hot roast beef sandwich would melt in your mouth. The pies we got to go were amazing. I will definitely be back here someday. Highly recommend this place! A must see and do. read more

See all

Diner food at its best--this is a must-stop in Toledo if you like this kind of food & feel! Meatloaf was fluffy and mouthwateringly savory. Breakfast burrito has the fluffiest eggs ever--quite a feat when the eggs are stuffed & rolled inside a tortilla! Best thing we ate, though, was the chocolate peanut butter pie. Again, crazy fluffy and was exactly the right flavor profile. We also had a chocolate peanut butter shake to which we asked to add bananas. Also fluffy and yummy! read more

See all

I order pie first! Great food and plenty of it. Can hardly wait until it opens again. read more

I ordered take out from this restaurant and I wished I hadn't when I received my food at home. I'm a pregnant lady who was starving and had a specific craving, I asked for the rise and shine, with toast and a slice of apple pie al a mode. I asked for my eggs over hard because I cannot eat any yoke because my body is sensitive to bacterial infections from under cooked foods that can kill my unborn child if I'm not careful. Well the yoke was there and running all over my pancakes. on top of that I got loads of butter and jelly in hopes of getting the toast I paid for, didn't happen, I got no toast with my order and my Apple Pie was DRENCHED in ice cream. The pie was genuinely not even good, and I would know because my taste buds are super heightened at the moment. I understand y'all were really busy when I walked in but restaurant business is no joke, please ask back of house to pay closer attention to order specifications, and maybe al a mode could come in the same container as the syrup does to prevent sogging the apple pie just out of courtesy for out of house costumers. read more

OH MY GOODNESS WHAT A WONDERFUL DINER!! We stopped in while visiting Toledo and had just the best service! Our waitress was patient, helpful, and had a pleasant demeanor. The diner has that old school no frills vibe, and even has an old phone both in the back. My travel companion got a burger and fries that they enjoyed, while I got the hot roast beef sandwich served dinner style. So that means my meal came with a huge side salad, homemade chicken noodle soup with delicious thick noodles, a giant roast beef sandwich covered in brown gravy, AND I was hooked up with the potato trifecta! So mashed with gravy, fresh cut fries, and homefries! Seriously I was in a heavenly food coma with this meal and gobbled it down. (Well, there was a ton of food so I had to get to-go boxes and have a second dinner later that night in my hotel bed haha). Before we came in we looked at their website to see what pies were on special and their snickers pie was one we wanted in our bellies! However, when we arrived it was about an hour before closing and we were told that popular pie was sold out for the day. So instead we ordered slices of cherry and PB & chocolate pie. BUT, our server must be a foodie angel because she casually dropped a whole dang snickers pie on our table for us to take home and enjoy! When we got back home we split the pie and shared it with friends and family. Oh lordy, that thing was the best! I had to put my loved ones piece in the freezer to stop me from being tempted to eat it before I gave it to them. I wish I could remember our servers name, because she made our stop at Schmucker's a highlight during our first time exploring Toledo. I 100% recommend this place and highly encourage leaving big tips here. read more

See all

For a quality diner you cannot go wrong. The fries, the pies and the service Toledo is lucky to support a gem like this that has been a staple in Toledo for decades. Delicious meals like your mom wish she would have made. Never had a bad meal, breakfast or sandwich. And even if you're full; GET SOME PIE! read more

See all

Hey! If it's a great breakfast or brunch you're yearning for,then it's gotta be Schmuckers to put the peddle down for,and if you're thinking of a knock out chunk of the most Lucious pie,then think no more because that's what you're in for if you have any room left down there.. I've taken a whole pie once and no matter how hungry you get later,well,mine lasted us two days..yes! Yes!! They are that good..don't stall any longer and get your kickers on and get kicken' for Schmuckrs. read more

If you're looking for good pie in the city of Toledo, this is your place. It can get busy at peak times, but the workers do their best on getting you served quickly. It's small inside, but has an assortment of tables, booths, and counter service. Today I enjoyed the pie of the week "snickers". It was amazing. They have some amazing diner food like burgers, Swiss steak, salads. Something for everyone! read more

Schmucker's - Snickers pie - Diners Near Me - Toledo, Ohio

If you don't know about Schmuckers it Toledo, you have to have been under a rock forever.. the place is an INSTITUTION of Tradition! Door is great home cooked comfort food! They are Famous for their Pies, make sure you have a Slice or take a WHOLE PIE HOME! read more

This diner is amazing! Summer was my server and she was top notch and 5 star worthy. I had the lunch portion fried chicken and it was the best i've had in along time! To top it off I had the BEST Chocolate Peanut Butter Pie I've ever had!! I even have leftovers for tonight's dinner. I was by myself so I sat at the counter and enjoyed the experience of watching the servers and cooks hustle and do great work. Great atmosphere. I came here based on other positive reviews. I will be back! read more

Not sure what the big to-do is about this restaurant. On August 17, 2024, my order was wrong, and I got blamed for it being wrong in front of my dinner guest. I was embarrassed. And my dinner guest is the one that can corroborate what I ordered in the first place. Nothing special here and it was expensive. Go down the street to Reynolds Garden Cafe for some friendly faces. read more

Excellent food and service. Very busy establishment. Great prices. Definitely will go back. read more

Old-timey greatness! We loved everything about Schmuckers! The original building, fixtures, and decor were just as awesome as the tasty food and wonderful service. There's something for everyone here as they have a big menu with lots of variety! This spot will transport you back in time and make you nostalgic for the old days! read more

See all

We went off the beaten path on our road trip from Pittsburgh, PA to our home in the Chicago suburbs to eat at this place. We were hoping to find a "Triple D" recommended diner along the way. But apparently Guy Fieri hasn't made Toledo, OH a destination for his show, yet. So we depended on Google searching & reviews, and settled on Schmucker's. Just like reviewers have said it would be, the place was packed. We got two seats at the bar. Service was friendly and lightning quick. Usually diners' entrees can be greasy, too salty and too sweet. None of that here. Fries were fresh cut, but not crispy. A big pile comes with the burger order. Too big. Burger was tasty and juicy. Breaded veal cutlets were crisp and not salty. Perfect! Side salad )instead of potato choice) was generous. They're known for their homemade pies. My hubby's was the Caramel Apple Walnut which was good. I shouldn't have tried their Key Lime pie since my standard (Mike's Key Lime, Bradenton, FL) is hard to match. I didn't finish my slice. Restrooms could use updating, but it's just a local diner. I don't think the customers would care one way or another. read more

Quick and tasty. The food is always good no matter what you order. Here is a pic of meat lovers omelet and a side of bacon and white toast. Bacon could have been crispier but I forgot to ask. Had over a dozen pies in stock too. We took home five slices. Delicious, friendly, quick, and affordable. Just a single family restaurant. read more

Schmucker's - Meat lovers omelet with toast and side of bacon. One bite missing--couldn't wait to get picture. - Diners Near Me - Toledo, Ohio

Family owned and operated Schmucker's Restaurant has been a Toledo tradition since 1948, and although most go for the Homemade Pie the diner style Entrees are also delicious and plentiful at a fair price. Originally opened by Harvey and Nola Schmucker, and currently run by their third generation, the homey Diner opens at 6:30am Monday through Saturday and remains busy continuously until nine o'clock at night. Unchanged in the last two decades, a vintage register and yellow brick inside with signs advertising "Good Home Cooking," guests choose from classics prepared by skilled line cooks including signatures such as the towering Club offered by itself or as a meal. Scratch made for nearly 75 years, staff as friendly as ever, those seeking something hearty are tempted by springy Meatloaf or Fried Chicken over Biscuits - each overloaded with Gravy alongside choice of Potatoes. Never forgetting Dessert, over twenty Pies changing with the season, Chocolate Peanut Butter was passed on this occasion in favor of Coconut Cream, Pecan and "Scutterbotch," the best a toss up but all justifying the slogan "Its a family treat to eat at Schmucker's!" read more

See all

Great food, large variety for breakfast, lunch or dinner. Service is A+ always. They always smile and accomodate their customers with such friendliness. Love this place. read more

We love finding iconic restaurants and dining at them when we are driving near unfamiliar cities. This was the case when we were coming back to Indianapolis from London, Ontario. We looked online and found Schmucker's in Toledo. When we drove up and saw the old-fashioned original sign and the small freestanding building we were really excited. Once we walked inside and saw the counter with stools, the case full of homemade pies, and the woman expertly flipping burgers on the griddle we couldn't wait to order! We both had delicious smash burgers and shared two pieces of pie, chocolate cream and apple crumble. Everything was great! A well-oiled institution! read more

See all

Feels like a small town diner that takes you back to the past in the best ways possible. Fantastic food, if you want a home cooked style breakfast good luck finding better food, service, and prices than this place!! 10 out of 10 and the pie is amazing too. read more

Schmucker's - Sunrise Special Plus* ** - Diners Near Me - Toledo, Ohio

MarkM found this and we thought were going to a 'Smuckers'. Hohum about that. Searching for Chicken Fried Steak. Not on the printed menu but was on their website. Mark called and confirmed. So this has so special foods not found in chain places. So I'm doing Pecan Pie to start. Then Hamburger Steak. Mark, the Meatloaf Sandwich. Pecan pie appears all handmade and is excellent. Very close to what my own Mom made. So those are foods most all us cherish all our life. All good here. read more

See all

Very very disappointed. This was my third whole pie purchase and I was excited to continue the tradition for big family events. This. Pie.was. Terrible. Blueberry crumb, dry filling no flavor. I truly believe they forgot sugar and salt. read more

Good home cooking in an old school diner. This place is small, so be prepared to wait if you go at a busy time. We stopped in on the way home from Michigan. This is not far from the freeway, which made it a convenient stop. The food is old fashioned with big portion sizes. I ordered meatloaf and mashed potatoes. I also tried my husband's order of perch with home fries. Also at our table was a meatloaf sandwich, cheeseburger and fries, and kids' PB & J sandwich with applesauce. Every item I tasted was delicious! One of us ordered grilled chicken at first, and the waitress kindly informed us it would take 25 minutes, so the order was changed. We didn't want a stop that long while on the road, so I appreciated that she told us. We finished off with a slice of caramel apple walnut pie. Wow! The pie was so decadent. I highly recommend this small diner for great home style foods. read more

See all

I'm assuming this place has just gone downhill. We got the cod plate, chicken nuggets and ff for the kids, and the Dagwood (club sandwich). We were actually planning on getting breakfast for dinner but evidently you can't after 4 (though it doesn't say that anywhere and the menu includes it) and we were about 10 minutes too late. The Dagwood was good but nothing else. The chicken nuggets were just off, the fries were not fresh and had no seasoning, the cod were triangular shaped patties you'd expect to find in the freezer section at the grocery. Even the Dutch apple pie and rhubarb (very tart!) pies were just ok at best. This place gets great reviews and is a recommended stop in Toledo, but we were really disappointed. read more

The 1st time I ate at Schnmuckers was about 5o years ago, and I have enjoyed it from time to time since then. Today my wife and I stopped for lunch (12:10pm) and ordered the hot roast beef lunch, and the meatloaf lunch. Both came to us cold. The meatloaf was overcooked and tasted terrible. The mashed potatoes were cold and covered in the same out of a can brown gravy as our entre. My wife had requested that they heat her plate in the microwave as her food was cold. The server brought it back and gave it to the wrong table. We had to yell at her and let her know that that was ours. I usually stay for pie, but I didn't want to ruin that part of the Shcmuckers experience. Nothing Home Cooking about it. I will still purchase their pies, but will not sit to eat again. read more