We ordered takeout since we're from out of town. My wife got clams and I got the Seefood Fra Diavolo. When we got in, the children settled and ready to eat, the food was still super hot and the seafood was PERFECTLY cooked. Shrimp were tender and not over cooked, the clams were expertly cleaned, not a grain of sand and again perfectly cooked. My son, he got the meatball. We don't order out meatballs because all meatballs pail in comparison to my mother's recipe which I make for them. But let me tell you, these meatballs were amazing. Actual flavor, not just breadcrumbs and meat. Extremely well executed entrees. You could not ask for anything better. This place is a New York City quality restaurant and is worth all your time and money. Do. It pass this place up! read more

Although I have been to this place before back in March of 2020 and was pleasantly surprised, our experience on Father's Day was absolutely horrible. I made a reservation at my husbands request. The reservation was for 6 -1/2 people (my granddaughter who is 11 months) at 5pm. I asked for a table upstairs and when I arrived they tried to sit us in the bar area. I informed the woman who was at the front I had asked for a table upstairs and her exact words to me were "ok bye" and she handed me off to a young gentleman (Harrison). That was the 1st mistake she made. He brought us upstairs and the room was very warm. We assumed it was because they hadn't turned the AC on but when we looked it was on 62. We opted to stay up there because by that time they had given away the table that they were trying to offer us. I am not exaggerating when I say we were left upstairs for over 40 minutes before he came back to ask if we wanted drinks or appetizers. Not his fault because it appeared this woman was too busy yapping it up with some older man who was at the bar and the younger woman was just there. Harrison was doing the doordash orders, and everything else. I asked if someone was going to come up soon and this woman with reddish hair with attitude said "umm, yeah". 2nd mistake she made. I went back upstairs and our waiter came back up about 10 minutes later. He took our orders and was left to manage us alone. Overall I think he did the best he could, but there is absolutely NO REASON AT ALL it should have taken 2-1/2 hours for us to order/eat. We didn't order anything complicated, but it seems like everyone downstairs was being tended to while we were just left upstairs in the heat. Having to have my son go downstairs and ask for the check and food containers, is also ridiculous -3rd mistake!! Again, Harrison was great and we do not blame him at all, but this young gentleman should have been given help from the beginning instead of having him do every damn thing. Extremely disappointed and am pretty sure the owners of this place have no idea what their manager does and they seriously need to re-think who they have greeting and TRAIN them properly. She is lucky I didn't lose it on her with the way she responded to me when I asked if someone was going to come up soon. She is absolutely, HORRIBLE. The service was EXTREMELY slow, even though there were BARELY any people there when we walked in. We are locals and we will never go back. read more

I came here back on March 1. So first the place is nice and it is pretty big. Second we were celebrating my sister's birthday and the waitress was very nice. We ordered a lot of different things so we tasted a lot. We had appetizers and they were good. I ordered something similar to chicken Parmesan which was good. The portions are quite large so you can share or have leftovers. I didn't order a drink. My family liked their food and yes I would go back. Overall it was a good experience, but I do think there can be other Italian places which make their own pasta in house. read more

See all

I came here on a date and wish I got to try more of their food but their AC wasn't working so we left kinda early after our appetizer bc we were sweating. We got the fried calamari which was tender and yummy, and also their homemade foccocia bread they give is plenty and delicious!! I could have gone for an extra basket read more

Horrible food. Chicken cutlet old and hard. No flavor in sauce. Not to mention open semolina flour next to the bathroom on the floor. Food storage never to a restroom is wild read more

Scalia & Co Craft Kitchen and Bar - Open bag of flour used for cooking - Pizza Near Me - Monroe, New York

This business lacks the responsibility of making the customer first. The motto is staff first customer last. Second. I've had repeated problems with service at this property. One night I walked in. I was told the kitchen was closed but I'm welcome to have a beer. Next I notice is the server went to the end of the kitchen, picked up two menus and brought it over to two young ladies sitting by the window where you come in. She gave them menus. I took pictures to support my statement. How can the kitchen be closed if you're handing out menus? I tip very well and I take care of my servers. Apparently they don't appreciate it. read more

Scalia & Co Craft Kitchen and Bar - Pizza Near Me - Monroe, New York

Food was decent. Restaurant needs a serious update as does the bathroom. Bathroom door lock, soap dispenser and paper towel dispenser broken. Beer list was incorrect. Weekday lunch menu told you it was the weekday lunch menu on the page before and the bottom. read more

Honestly, I am a Scalia fan. I have been coming here for years and the food never disappoints. The people are very nice. There are always menu changes with some staple Italian plates. Very homemade taste. The butcher is right next door, which is the same owner with Italian cuts and favorites. Ambiance is nice, good fine wine. SIMI is in the tap so imagine how good their drinks are!! read more

Scalia & Co Craft Kitchen and Bar - Their focaccia, what can I tell you stupendo!! - Pizza Near Me - Monroe, New York

See all

I don't know what is going on, this used to be a great restaurant. We went last night. The pizza was burnt, the service was chaotic, the restaurant was way too hot. We had a new waitress, and she was a sweetheart, but it was apparent that she was not trained properly. She gave me the bill for another table and charged it to my credit card. When I approached the hostess, she was condescending to myself and the new waitress. I will not be spending my hard-earned money there anymore. read more

Amazing food and service always! The prosciutto & burrata appetizer was amazing.. I made my boyfriend get his own lol. I ordered the lobster and shrimp ravioli for my entree, and my boyfriend ordered the salmon, and they were both SO delicious! For desert, we both got the tiramisu, and it literally melted in our mouths, so yummy. Very generous portions and again, great, home welcoming service. 10/10 recommend! read more

See all

I've been coming here for years and always had a good meal and great service. Their meatballs are my absolute favorite!!! Today I stopped in for lunch and the service was just off today. Food of course was on point. Prices also increased since I last was here which is understandable because of our economy. You do get a lot for what you pay for though, so it is worth it in my opinion. They gave warm focaccia bread when we sat down. Usually I'm not a fan of it but today it was actually pretty good! read more

Scalia & Co Craft Kitchen and Bar - Spaghetti and meatballs! - Pizza Near Me - Monroe, New York

Our family had dinner at Scalia last night. The food and drinks were great and the service was amazing. They went above and beyond. Our 3 little kids loved our server. He kept giving them high fives. The hostess, server, bartender, and manager couldn't have been any nicer. A great experience all around. read more

Single handedly the best red sauce I've ever had. I ordered the "Gravy". It's a classic Sunday Sauce with sausage, veal, meatballs and ricotta. My mind was blown! Antipasto was perfect, shrimp cocktail was perfect, bread was perfect, cannoli was perfect. Service was outstanding, super attentive. Ambiance was classy and cool. 5 stars! read more

Scalia & Co Craft Kitchen and Bar - Pizza Near Me - Monroe, New York

See all

We have been coming to Scalia since the first day it opened. It used to be good, but lately has gone downhill significantly. On our last visit for brunch, we ordered chicken and waffles and hamburger with egg. Unfortunately, we had to send both items back. It was obvious that Chicken cutlets were microwaved as the breading popped, separated and meat was rubbery. How can the Italian place mess that staple of a food? For brunch burger, they missed three ingredients, so it basically was an overcooked burger with egg. The home potatoes that came with it also were precooked previously maybe a few good days prior as they were dark in color and spoiled. Terrible experience. The place was mostly empty on Sunday. Such a shame to see such a decline. We will never eat there again. read more

The food here is good. The drinks are spectacular. The only reason I gave 4 stars and not 5 was due to the dessert being meh

Have shopped in this plaza for a few months now since moving to the area and finally decided to give this place a try. Sadly, my partner and I won't be going back. In general the place is nice and the food was good, but there were many fruit flies in the dining area and the service we received was curt and not welcoming. I had my plate and silverware taken from right in front of me while I was signing the receipt without checking if I had finished first. I don't need the red carpet rolled out for me, but it just seemed rude. read more

The atmosphere is welcoming. The food is amazing! The service perfect as well as the Deli next door!! Definitely will be my new favorite place in Monroe NY! read more

Beautiful bar and interior. Love that the wines are on tap. My friend and I were the only ones there and yet felt like a burden to the staff. We sat at the bar. We just wanted a drink and a few apps. The pizzette was awesome (prosciutto and arugula and fig) as were the meatballs! The complimentary breadsticks with oil and balsamic were amazing too! I'd def try again. Just wish we felt a little more welcome. read more

Another visit - another good time at Scalia! Drinks are on point, they make a delicious Elderflower martini, they even freeze a fresh flower inside a ball of ice. My husband ordered a baked shrimp dish, he said is was "good". The bolognese sauce isn't as great as others I have had but they have gluten free pasta so that's a huge plus for me! Service is great, it's a small place and there's always someone to grab nearby if you need anything. read more

Scalia & Co Craft Kitchen and Bar - GF pasta bolognese - Pizza Near Me - Monroe, New York

See all

We started off nicely -- and were seated at a booth near the kitchen. The waitstaff seemed pleasant and experienced. We ordered drinks and they brought out a warm focaccia like bread with olive oil - Mg husband said this was pretty good. Then, we ordered a caprese appetizer -- I thought the tomato & olive mixture was quite tasty. However, I had ordered a steak salad - which was soaked in balsamic and the steak had no flavor. My husband's margherita pizza was okay -- maybe a bit more basil or a tastier sauce would have helped. The menu online had more options than what we were provided at the table, but I appreciated the call-outs that indicated what was gluten-free. It did make ordering much easier. read more

See all

My family and I had a wonderful experience dinning at the restaurant my mother is very sick now with cancer and it was her birthday violeta the waitress was so sweet and wonderful and very fast with our food and made us feel very welcome and was so kind to us she made the whole night special ask for her when eating at the restaurant and she's very pretty too jennifer read more

Great Italian food. Loved the pizza and Sunday gravy! Stopped by here on the way home from Legoland with the family.

I love to dine in here, I'm not too crazy about the family Togo meals. But if you're dining in, the food is delicious!

Yummy pizza and rice balls. Visited during Christmas time and it was nicely decorated for the holidays. Friendly service. read more

Scalia & Co Craft Kitchen and Bar - Bar area - Pizza Near Me - Monroe, New York

Was in the area heard good things about it this place. Took out a dinner and a Cesar salad. I ordered la Rosa Grande which is chicken and shrimp with vodka sauce covered with mozzarella. Sorry to say it wasn't good at all. Chicken was reheated and dry. There was no vodka sauce it was dried out marinara . Shrimp was good but the whole dish didn't work. Also ordered a grilled chicken Cesar salad. The chicken was like out of a bag. No marks and little wet. Place is kinda expensive for the quality. Pretty place and everyone was very nice. But I don't think I'll be returning. read more

I thought this place was pretty average. I've had better Italian food then this restaurant. I thought the prices for lunch time was pretty expensive as well. The bread that they put out on the table was really good. I gotten the penna al vodka with chicken and shrimp. You can barely taste any of the seasoning for the pasta , and my food came out luke warm to cold which I wasn't happy about and the pasta was semi hard / chewy not my favorite. The fritta calamari we gotten the medium portion but it looked more like a small portion and it was alright. Not sure if I'll return , maybe if they have restaurant week but way too expensive and the portions I thought was on the small side and I still felt hungry afterwards. read more

Scalia & Co Craft Kitchen and Bar - Penna Al Vodka , medium portion of the fritta calamari. - Pizza Near Me - Monroe, New York

The cannolis are to die for. I got both kinds on the menu and I will definitely be back. Their signature cannoli with pistachio was amazing and the classic never disappoints. I will definitely be coming back for these. read more

We hosted our sons 1st communion upstairs with a brunch buffet. The food for delicious and the service was outstanding. Thank you for making our day extra special. read more

Scalia & Co Craft Kitchen and Bar - Cake take set up and favors - Pizza Near Me - Monroe, New York

See all

Came back for valentines day . Lorddd. Came in and they gave us a vday prefix menu had to ask if we could order off regular menu. My shrimp was soo tough. Super gross and my boyfriend and my boyfriends chicken parm was very bland will not be returning. read more

Scalia & Co Craft Kitchen and Bar - Chicken Cutlet ala Parmigiano Dinner - Pizza Near Me - Monroe, New York

See all

My boyfriend and I had the best restaurant experience in a long time and lucky us it was "restaurant week" where we were provided a fixed price 3-course menu, and because we already knew Scalia's would be a hit we came with our appetite. We always love the vibe and our waitress was above and beyond kind, there was a drink that didn't meet mine or Jays pallet so we unfortunately had to replace it with a house Riesling( which has to be at least a 10%). The short rib bolognaise caught my eye from the moment we walked and saw specials wall, but I knew Jay would've went for that, so I went for something different the squid ink pasta. To start we got a ceasar salad and the poached pear salad both were absolutely delightful. The main dishes were saucy rich and fresh of course the short rib Bolognese was the star but the squid ink pasta was amazing in its own right. For dessert the peanut butter pie was an amazing experience. This was the best date night we've had in a while. Thank you for having us read more

Scalia & Co Craft Kitchen and Bar - Short rib bolognese pasta dinner squid ink and shrimp pasta dinner - Pizza Near Me - Monroe, New York

Great food experience. A lot of people come here in groups so expect a lil noise but anything else is great. Been there for a few years Boneless Pork Chop Arrabiata DinnerChicken Parm Lovely environment Great service Chicken ParmPork Chops read more

Tonight we attended comedy night. Was excited because always loved their food. For advertised comedy and all you can eat (buffet) package at $55 ea... NO SERVICE FEE OR GRATUITY INCLUDED LISTED ON AD...we got a bill for 2 at $200!!! $110 + 53 DRINKS + OPERATONG FEE + 20% GRATUITY (Again...buffet). The buffet food was average far below their normal quality and put out apple pastry and butter cookies. We had to ask for cannolis advertised. Shame on Scalias!!! read more

2 times I've visited. The first time was great. Sat at the bar and the service and food were both great. The second time we got sat by the kitchen. Too much noise, and traffic passing our table. The food is enough to make me want to go back though. I had the pizza and a chicken park with shrimp on it which was really excellent. Would recommend both. read more

Every time I go here I'm greeted the food is good. I've had all of their lunch specials where they have an appetizer lunch and dessert.My. Favorite is Bolognese sauce on pastta. Their red sauce is great. Ive had their lemon garlic pasta with clam. Very good. And of course their desserts.The whole family is nice I shop next door to little Italy where they sell food too. It's just nice and I hope they will always be open. God blless. read more

Worth the price and quality home style Italian food made Fresh daily Oysters and raw clams are so fresh Owners are amazing (we love you guys like our own family) Friendly and personable full bar What more can I say? Go eat for yourselves you won't be disappointed read more

August: Scalia's food may not always be delivered hot or even warm via DoorDash, though today's simple truffle burger and truffle fries aioli order is presented to perfection! Thanks for the delivery Victoria W! -- End of July: Management reached out most graciously, much appreciated. Having become very concerned over DoorDash all too regularly delivering hot foods that are cold on arrival, I try to keep to ordering dishes since then that are simple, minimal as possible. I think post-Covid, DoorDash will be rendered futile, and as we'll largely have more sophisticated tastes, the restaurant arena will change drastically, where only the freshest and most creative survive. -- Giving Scalia the benefit of the doubt from its Pre-COVID-19 times, ordering twice this week, the food is not only late by over an hour an a half, the oysters shucked an hour earlier -- become inedible on delivery (sadly, wasted to the trash bin), each "hot" food ordered is delivered stone cold, unapologetically. Prior to COVID-19, I loved Scalia and its side Deli. The food now being "consistently" of low caliber brings the restaurant in a sad new light, as. read more

See all

Ate with my family and there was a lot of us. Great service and lots of food for all. Drinks were enjoyable as well. Actually I don't go for a lot of pasta, but I did try their lobster appetizer, which was fresh, light and served with cocktail sauce and another light sauce on the plate. I ordered a caprese salad for my entree' and was expecting the typical salad greens, tomato and mozzarella. The waiter recommended the entree caprese salad, which came with a big portion of heavily seasoned grilled chicken, greens, red peppers and a homemade mozzarella. I am very sensitive to garlic, so I normally would not have ordered the chicken on the salad, BUT it looked so good I decided to take the consequences of eating food seasoned with garlic--and it was so worth it! The prices seemed a little steep for this area, but the tasty food, wine, atmosphere and service were right on point. They are very busy at night--be sure to have a reservation! read more

See all

What a hidden gem in Monroe! Came here with a group of friends and they did not disappoint! We had the calamari and burrata as appetizers and they were both delicious. I would highly recommend the spring pizza (off their special menu). It was piled high with prosciutto, arugula, and spring peas. The fra diablo pasta hit the spot as it contained lots of seafood and was actually spicy, contrary to most of the other restaurants. Our waiter was very funny and joked with us all night. I will be back the next time I'm in the area! read more

Scalia & Co Craft Kitchen and Bar - Burratta - Pizza Near Me - Monroe, New York

Let me start by saying I've only had take out from here, so I've never dealt with any of the staff or can't comment on the overall dining experience. But the take out is unbelievable. We've had Many different things here and everyone of them have been delicious. From family trays, to appetizers and even burgers! We love them. Best Italian food in Monroe hands down, probably the whole county! Strangely enough they serve the absolute best burgers I had in the area, must try! read more

Scalia & Co Craft Kitchen and Bar - Brunch burger with truffle fries! Best burger I've had in Orange County! 5 star - Pizza Near Me - Monroe, New York

See all

Yum yum yum. And you feel like family. Antipasto and Sunday gravy. You won't be disappointed with anything. Go enjoy