I live in Missouri, have all my life. I go to New York yearly and every year I get this place. SO GOOD! the garlic knots are to die for and lets not forget about the pizza! the pizza is always so cheesy and the dough is amazing as well. the service is very good! I go in, order, and within maybe 7 minutes I'm walking out with possibly the best pizza ever in my hands. the workers have always been so nice as well! great experience overall. I look forward to this pizza every year and the minute I get on the plane to go back to Missouri, I wish i had more lol! read more

Yoooo!!!! Really good pizza! Me and my little dude took a bike ride on the trail and stopped by on the way back. The pizza is filling, good dough layer, great sauce, with a decently snappy undercarriage. I have to let the rest of the family try to see if we can make this a 5 star rating. read more

Amendola's Pizzeria & Restaurant - Pizza Near Me - Monroe, New York

The place was very clean and smelled good. The food is to drool for. Staff is genuine nice. Go there for ur moneys worth.

Been here before, but only just now writing a review of this place. Amendola's is a pizza place in town where one can either take out pizza, (and other pizzeria foods, in which i haven't tried), or dine in. The dining room is kind of tight though, so fitting a party of 8 may be difficult. i was young so don't remember the taste of the food that much. My mom picked up some pizza on 3/3/23, that way i can eat a meat free meal because of lent on fridays. The quickest pizza was a cheese pizza, although if it wasn't so early, i would have went for a mushroom or spinach pizza. My mom brought home a silcian pizza, and a cheese pizza slice, and it was good! read more

Amendola's is my go-to spot! The guys are so nice, and the food is Excellent! Some of our family favorites, Salad Pizza, Sicilian slice, eggplant parm, pasta fagioli and their homemade tacos are to die for!! read more

The pizza tasted like uncooked dough. The coke was actually cold but it was unfortunately flat. The garlic knots had different seasoning on them and it had so much oil on them we couldn't even eat it. read more

Amendola's Pizzeria & Restaurant - Garlic knots - Pizza Near Me - Monroe, New York

See all

Love the food here. Always did, always will. Same staff and owner worked with previous owner for 10 years. If it ain't broke, don't fix it!

My dad has been coming to Amendolas since '83 when they first opened up! To this day it's the only pizza joint we"ll go to. Amendolas is a family owned and Sam the owner is most definitely a family man. When I was younger he told me if I caught a fish in the pond across the street, he'd give me a free cannoli. Week later I caught a fish and retrieved my free cannoli!!! Just like any other small business, Amendolas took a hit due to Covid. But that didn't stop Sam from setting up shop outside to continue serving his loyal customers! Pizza, Pasta dinners, Stromboli, hero's, antipasto, wings, tenders etc are all just scrumptious! You also have to try Amendolas very own brand of Soda, with many different flavors to choose from, Black cherry being my favorite! read more

By far the best pizza in Monroe. The crust was crispy and had a nice chew. The sauce was not overly sweet or salty. Overall a great choice!

It was the second time we ordered fro this restaurant and the pizza was flat and flavorless. I will not buy anything from Amendola again. Owner of the establishment should make more of an effort to keep customers and make good quality food. read more

The best cheese slice in ny .. which means the best cheese slice in the world .. I have no ties to this joint .. this is real read more

Amendola's Pizzeria & Restaurant - a slice of pizza - Pizza Near Me - Monroe, New York

I grew up in Monroe and go back to visit my parents regularly and I love to come to Amendola's to have lunch.The pizza is delicious.! They recently did some renovations to the place, the new carpet and fresh paint in the back is a good update. read more

Best pizza in the area. They also have the crispiest tastiest chicken wings. Ate here since a kid and it's just as good. Sam is still making the pizzas. Amazing read more

I was living in memory lane about my time spent in Monroe and remembered this place, which is quite a compliment. Probably the best pizza in all of Orange County and the food was very good too. Every bit as good as NYC pizza places. The service is always nice and friendly as well Can't go wrong here. read more

If you're getting plain pizza, this is you're best bet around here. It's good hot, cold, fresh, old; reheats very well. This is the kind of pizza you find yourself munching on the next morning out of the fridge, if there's any left to begin with. With every large pie you get a coupon; 10 coupons gets you a free large pie. read more

Had pizza party Saturday. Bought 10 pizzas - all different flavors and combos - sandwiches, antipasta. All the food was delicious. This is our go to place for pizza. Thank you Sam and crew. read more

If you're like me, you are always searching for a better pizza. I've lived in Chester, New York for fifteen years and no matter where I go, I keep coming back to Amendola's. Today I tried their brand-name Root Beer and it is incredible. The woman and two gentlemen working are as pleasant as anyone could ask. There's nothing flashy here, just the best pizza. read more

Great food but please, renovate your restaurant! It is outdated and super depressing.

Best cheese pizza in the area. Trust me you will not regret it. The quality is also much better. They are also very nice.

This place continues to have the best pizza in the Monroe area. The crust is just right...not too thick and not too thin. Their sauce is delicious, and the cheese is nicely gooey. I also love their eggplant parm hero. The owner and staff couldn't be nicer. Very friendly and very accommodating for special orders. read more

Great Pizza - Probably the best in Monroe. A staple of the Monroe main street for decades.

There are nearly 12 Pizzeria's in the Monroe area (all of which I have tried) but I go to Amendolas EVERY time. Best pizza ever and the food is delicious too. read more

Ummm.. I cannot believe the reviews of this place. This was a mediocre experience in every sense of the word. Pizza just ok, we moved here from jersey and we're hoping this would be our go to spot. Very disappointing. The spinach calzone was rubbery and inedible. This is the first time Yelp has failed me. Very sad.. read more

Best pizza in the town of Monroe!!!! People are very nice and welcoming. I been coming here for years and there pizza has always been the same Bc they are very consistent. I highly recommend to anyone and everyone!!!!! read more

Amendola's has the best pizza in town! We just had two pies for a small family lunch and I am a happy girl. My only wish would be for them to offer delivery and then I would be the happiest camper : ) Their dinners are nice as well; my favorite is the Cavatappi with a side of meatballs. Speaking of Mr. Amendola's meatballs -- out of this world! They are basic, nicely seasoned, old school meatballs, and I am a huge fan. read more

Grew up eating pizza from this joint. Pretty much the best pie you can get in the area. Dinner plates are decent, heros are okay. If you're in monroe, and want a good slice, stop here. read more

Great pizza, heros, dinners & even better wings. These are not traditional wings they r better. Try them I thing u will like them!

By far the worst pizza on Monroe. The service is poor - they got the order wrong. I'll never go back.

Incredible italian home cooking! Eggplant parm hero is amazing! Pizza is the best! Friendly and helpful staff. Always a great experience! read more

Excellent pie... Sauce, dough and cheese are of the highest quality. Have not tried anything else except pizza though.

Amendolas is the best pizzeria in the area hands down, the food is delicious, always consistent awesome staff, very appreciative of their customers. It shows why Mr.Amendola has been in business for so many years he treats the customers right unlike the nasty over priced little dung-beetle Gino's down the street. Pleasant, delicious, great experience, great prices 10/10! read more

the worst spaghetti and meatballs/sausages we ever had. the meatballs were boiled and at 1/2 filler (talk about wheres the beef?) the sausage was also boiled and mostly fat. the tomato sauce tasted like tomato paste from a can.at a cost of $26.00 . it was insulting! stick with the pizza guys. t read more