Holy smokes... I am going to have dreams about this sandwich. It is definitely top 3 sandwiches of…read moremy life and maybe the best ever. I had the prosciutto sandwich and my SO had the pastrami and both had nothing but good things to say as we ate. The prosciutto sandwich had balsamic that had just started to soak into the otherwise crunchy bread, with these big chunks of mozzarella and the freshest tomatoes and greens. Alimentari itself is this awesome little deli/grocer with both bagged pastas AND FRESH PASTA/antipasti available to buy, as well as all sorts of goods, breads, coffees, chocolates, beverages and a whole wine selection. Beware that there is no seating inside but definitely do not let this dissuade you from visiting.

This had been recommended to me and it was right next to an appointment I had. So I finally stopped…read morein and overall had a wonderful experience - both ordering and eating. I ordered the smoked turkey sandwich, and the gentleman taking my order pointed to a random piece of focaccia on display on the counter and asked if I'd like my sandwich on that. I don't know what kind of bread if normally comes on, but I have since read about the thicker/crustier bread on some reviews. Gosh am I glad he offered the focaccia. The bread made this sandwich, it was sooo good. It was light and fluffy despite being substantial in size, and had this delightful little crunch from the sea salt on it (not in a salty sense, just in a wonderful texture sense). There was a ton of turkey on it and it was a yummy smoked flavor. The other fixings were standard but complimented the sandwich very well. The sandwich was tasty and filling. All this said, because I paid $16 for my sandwich, I wouldn't make it a regular occurrence, maybe a special treat. But if it's on regular bread, particularly a harder crust bread, I think I'd skip it entirely. You do get a lot of sandwich for your money, but I just can't justify it. So, overall, this is definitely worth trying and deciding for yourself - I don't think you'll be disappointed.

5 stars because these sandwiches were stellar…read more I had the classic 2.0 with the addition of sweet pickled peppers and my SO had the turkey sandwich and we loved them both. The turkey was a hot sandwich while the classic was a cold. The location itself is small, feels like a hole in the wall bar with great cozy vibes. We were lucky enough to bike over on a nice day and so we sat in the outdoor space which is also small but got the job done before we were back on our bikes with happy bellies. We will definitely be revisiting so we can try more of the menu!

I thoroughly enjoyed myself here, that being said, on par with some of the lower reviews - they did…read morerun out of the pork belly sando, they charge for everything extra, and service was pretty slow. But if you were open to just having a nice casual dinner in a retro easy place, this is it. My fiance and I went to meet up with some friends from out of town and from a list of places I wanted to try, they chose this one. Between the two of us, we spent about $60 for this meal, which I suppose now adays is on par with what you can get away with. We also left with half a sandwich because honestly, these guys are huge! -Hot Beef Sando with Cheese (extra): this was a massive sandwich, packed with flavor. The ah jus was on the side and needed for dunking. It hit the spot, was a messy affair, but was very good. The meat wasn't melt in your mouth, it was actually quite dry, but the mix of everything together and the dip made it good overall. - Chili Cup: well spiced, super small cup and charging a dollar for each addition of onion, cheese, and sour cream is murder. Pass on the fixings, the soup doesn't need it, but it's not something i'd get again as it wasn't knock out of the park good. -Homemade Orange Soda: this was great. I love the nostalgia of using Tang and it was more earthy because they put some spices in it. Overall, would get again. -Coleslaw was asian inspired and made well, especially with the mint on top. Be warned though, its the same slaw on the pulled chicken...which speaking of: -Pulled chicken sandwich: It's their meat americanized fusion version of a banh mi. I know they have a vegan one on their menu, but this one felt less like a sandwich. The spices weren't quite asian tho and was interesting with the slaw. I wouldn't say it was my favorite but I did eat a whole half. Happy nomming!

Casetta is one of the best places in Madison. The ingredients are freshly prepared and of the…read morehighest quality. They have a special sandwich every day and I strongly recommend getting it before they run out. Their focaccia is to die for!! Honestly so are their chocolate chip cookies. It's a small spot and gets super busy during lunch so I would expect a long wait that is extremely worth it. All of their employees are incredibly nice and passionate about their job. Shoutout Ella the cashier! She was so funny and gave me the best recommendations - give her a raise!

Stopped by here for lunch on a weekday. I ordered the Paradigm sandwich. The flavor of the sandwich…read morefillings were really good, especially on the marinated bell peppers inside. The sandwich had a good variety of textures throughout - my only wish was that the focaccia was also toasted. I think that would complement the sandwich textures even more. The coveted chocolate chip is *that* good. Thin, crispy edges, chewy center with flat chocolate wafer chips. The salt on top was a wonderful contrast to the sweet chocolate. You also can't beat the price of $2.25 for a good cookie. My only other complaint would be the limited seating. The workers here also try to provide table service and bring your sandwich out to you if you do dine-in. However, there isn't a system for them to find you at the table easily and they are just wandering around looking for you by name. Having a little table # placard would benefit the staff here.

visited wisconsin for the first time and found this hidden gem on tiktok! located in a basement of…read morethis random building but WOW staff were so friendly and welcoming :) since it was my first time, they kinda walked me thru how everything worked and throughly mentioned lil snapchat word of the day for some $$ off. they have free popcorn as well! gave us a stamp card as well! it's a sandwich/ deli spot + a convenient store all in one. they have coffee machines if u wanted something in the morning too.

The best place! My favorite spot that I came to in college. They have a word of the day where you…read moreget a free drink. They have the best breakfast sandwiches and don't sleep on the regular sandwiches and salad too. The workers are so kind. Highly recommend!

The best REAL Philly cheesesteaks in Madison! Rolls straight outta Philly-the best!…read moreThe rest of the menu looks great and the hand cut fries were awesome. Friendly service and owner was super nice! We will be back often and looking forward to trying more.

Good, yummy, greasy food. 10/10 recommend. Italian beef was loaded with meat. Wings were not dry…read moreand really good. Just wish the patty melt's burger meeat had more meat but it was really good.

Good food. Only time I drink Kool Aid and I look forward to it every time they were under staffed…read morebartender is a hard worker running back and forth to help the line good guy give him a raise!

My bread was dry, and I'm not even positive there was any type of sauce on my sub. French onion…read moresoup has almost no cheese.

Decent little stop. Think it would be a lot more lively and fun if we didn't come right when it…read moreopened, but it was good! Delicious cheese curds - seriously some of the best I've had. My table ordered the brat, some tomato soup, and the fish fry special (classic wisconsin lunch). Our server was kind, food came out quick, no complaints.

First time trying cheese curds and they were wonderful. The sriracha sauce was delicious and a bit…read morespicy. Bartender recommended the Patty Melt and did not disappoint. Finally, the Krombacher beer was delish. Excellence service and great food.

Food meets butcher shop meets artisanal cooking goods…read more We ordered the New Haven clam pizza. Seemed to be a lot of pick up orders while we dined in. Small corner, maybe fits about 6 adults at counter seating (no tables). They had some games - connect four, hook on the ring and cribbage. Cute little kids area too. Pizza: well this was big for us as a party of two so we have the other half left over. The crust was so crunchy. Toppings were delicious! Real clams, creamy. I thought this pizza got better with each bite. Super cheesy, pulls apart. Would definitely come back to order their other ones!

I was there on a Saturday for lunch. Inside there were some seatings. There were some good outdoor…read moreseatings as well. Patrons except me were enjoying food in the outdoor seating. I went for a New Haven clam pizza. It was really cheesy and flavorful. I liked it more than the clam pizza in New Haven. The pizza was big and will probably be good for 3 folks. They also had fresh meat. Display mean looked fresh. I went for roasted garlic herb butter. When added to rice, it made rice very flavorful.

Great sandwich's our favorite is the Otto. An Italian sub with lots of wonderful flavors. My…read morehusband loves the antipasto! Cute little deli with lots of specialty ingredients for Italian dishes. Friendly service usually really busy.

Been reading reviews from many sites. Everyone loves the lasagna, it was mid at best. He's better…read morefrom freezer section of grocery store. Loosely told my wife that her mom's is better and I don't care for that much. It was supposed to be cheese with some meat, there was barely any cheese at all. The meat was mealy and smelled old. The salsa were boring and tasteless. Seriously it's not hard to actually season your salads. No one does at any store's deli section and this was not any better. You can't out Mayo on warm noodles it's fries out the Mayo arms it is no longer a sauce. I will say the potato salad was very potatoee that's about it on that one. The singer were really good but also there are 2 sides to a same, put sauce in both sides it's not hard. The desserts were great as well. Wish the other things were worth going back for I'm always looking for a good deli with fresh salads but this isn't the place.

My kids and grandkids had lunch here today and it is much more than a bread bakery. So much more,…read moreand all really good. The outside is pretty nondescript, but inside it is warm and inviting. The bakery case is filled with lots of yummy treats and the menu board has something for every taste, all freshly made. The Egg Salad has a Pesto addition which is really good, and all the other dishes were beyond good. The fruit was super fresh and very tasty. There are two small cozy dining areas. One has a window into the bakery area and the grandkids enjoyed watching the pastry chef work her magic. Parking is in the street or the small adjacent parking lot. While the location is accessible, the dining areas are a bit tight for a wheelchair. However, those at the tables would be happy to make room as needed.

This stylish bakery and cafe is a great place for lunch or dinner…read more I had the golden beet Reuben with sauerkraut on their caraway rye bread, which was absolutely delicious! This is a great vegetarian sandwich - I'm not sure if it can be made vegan. The kid's turkey sandwich is really nice and comes on a freshly baked roll with a generous side of fresh fruit-it doesn't come with mayo or another spread, so you might want to ask for. The bread was delicious and I was sad, but not surprised, there were almost no loaves left for purchase. The only negative was the greens served with the sandwich. The mixed greens were fresh, but had almost no dressing or any other veggies or toppings included.