Adult grilled cheese panini 8/10 Definitely was a lot more bread than expecting but the flavor of the cheese was good, it just needed more. Also the crust was super crunchy and hard. Italian deli panini 8/10 Pesto was good. But again, a lot of bread, needed more deli meats! read more

See all

Solid brewery in an incredible outdoor space. Enjoyed sitting outside and having a light beer as their dry hopped Pilsner hits the spot. Only knock was the lack of draft IPA. Two out of the three beers were can only and I couldn't try them before going all in read more

Rusty Nickel Brewing Company - Dry Hopped Pilsner - Breweries Near Me - West Seneca, New York

See all

Though we're members of the Mug Club, we haven't been here in a bit. Always great here. Rustifico Mexican Lager for me and Tropical Vapor Rocket for my husband with a pretzel for a snack. Perfect way to end the work week. Staff is always great. You're greeted like they've known you forever. Love the rustic decor. read more

Rusty Nickel Brewing Company - Rustifico - Breweries Near Me - West Seneca, New York

See all

Harvest Host over night at the Rusty Nickel Brewery in West Seneca NY. Really enjoyed their Tropical Vapor Rocket IPA!! Rusty Nickel Brewing Co is a proud NYS Farm Brewery, crafting locally sourced beer and cider since it opened in 2015. The brewery has been awarded for several of its staple beers and has won multiple awards for each of their unique bloody marys. The Tasting Room provides a very comfortable, cabin-in-the-woods feel, with views of the brewery. The full bar features NYS spirits, wine, mead, and cider. Coined by many as a 'hidden gem', Rusty Nickel is nestled in the picturesque, wooded landscape of West Seneca, NY. The brewery's expansive outdoor space boasts one of WNY's most beautiful biergartens, a heated patio, and the perfect place to host any event. This family-friendly brewery with a focus on supporting local is a great place for great food and beverage while offering games, a fire pit to hang and make s'mores, and dozens of fun events year round. read more

See all

Keep in mind that the Rusty Nickel is a very rustic facility. If you like nature, this place is for you. In fact, a deer was grazing on the hill not 30 feet away from our table. The food menu is very limited but the beer was tasty. We had a reservation but couldn't find any staff members when we arrived so we just seated ourselves. read more

Rusty Nickel Brewing Company - Patio area - Breweries Near Me - West Seneca, New York

Stopped by when we were traveling around Buffalo. Great staff. Super friendly and helpful when selecting beer. Definitely will be back when traveling through Buffalo again. read more

See all

Its very pretty in the garden , and there is seating in the garden. Sometimes a band is playing back there ( so relaxing)Beer is great Needs a cocktail list , not everyone drinks beer. Need a little more food selection. read more

This was our first visit to Rusty Nickel Brewing Company and definitely won't be our last. The vibe is very relaxed and welcoming. The beer menu is quite diverse with multiple offerings in each category. The beer was very good and well brewed. There were three bartenders working and we received excellent service. We were able to taste a small sample of the beer before ordering a full pint. I loved The Half Slice Orange Vanilla, which tasted like a creamsicle. My husband's favorite was the I Remember, Buffalo. It was a great experience and a fun afternoon. read more

See all

Three of us stopped here after lunch at the Ebenezer Ale House. I was in the mood for something dessert-y/after dinner drink-ish, so I went with the Cafe Mocha Latte Nitro. I'm no beer expert, but I do love coffee and chocolate, so I did enjoy this. I like the creaminess of a nitro, and it also seems to bring out more sweetness. Their website claims "something for every taste", and that's true: beer (draft, bottles, cans), wine, cocktails, seltzers, ciders, mead. If you can't find a beverage that suits your fancy, that's on you. The atmosphere inside and out is fun and funky. The best part of our visit was sitting outside on a beautiful fall day, just relaxing and sipping a cold one. read more

Rusty Nickel Brewing Company - Breweries Near Me - West Seneca, New York

Nice place! Great outdoor patio and back yard area, also offered board games and outdoor games. Food menu was small but great pricing for what you get! Good drink menu as well. Got a charcuterie board for $12 and was impressed with all the food on the board! read more

Rusty Nickel Brewing Company - Breweries Near Me - West Seneca, New York

Great beer selection with multiple styles available. Also have liquor and wine and some food options. I didn't do any of the IPAs while I was here this time but the stouts and lagers I had were all good. read more

Awesome beer and major vibes! Loved the seasonal decor on the patio and the hazy ipa was so bomb! read more

See all

Stopped here after visiting Niagara Falls. They have a nice selection of brews, and heated/covered outdoor space. No food available, but a restaurant next door read more

Rusty Nickel Brewing Company - Partial flight including cream ale, mead, and a stout - Breweries Near Me - West Seneca, New York

I was so happy to stop by today and see Ted behind the bar. A Buffalo legend! So, obviously the service was the best in wny! There is a great selection of varieties of beers on tap, and with our group of 10, we tried a lot of them. I had the seltzer and the orange cream ale. Both are fantastic! Love the beer garden out back. There is a coy pond, gorgeous flowers, tons of patio furniture, and I'm told it is dog friendly too. Cheers! read more

Rusty Nickel Brewing Company - Beer garden - Breweries Near Me - West Seneca, New York

See all

I'm in love with this place! I wish I could bring it back to California. It was rustic and green and had lovely areas to sit. The beer was good and the all around vibes were lovely. I wish I had more time to go when they actually have live shows as it is obvious this place is a really good time. If I come back to this area I will come back here again! read more

Great service and superb customer service from the team at the end of the day we love that place thanks!

Lazy day stop for a few cold ones and some grub courtesy of Yankee bbq. Had a chance to try the bomb pop inspired blue raspberry, cherry, lime sour and a great session IPA. We were welcomed immediately by staff, she helped to decide on our beer choices with friendly input from who I assumed to be a regular at the bar. Since it was a bit small inside we opted to go outdoors. The space was very nice! It was raining this day but the covered patio was spacious and dry! We lucked out to have the Yankee Bbq food truck on-site. Loganberry glazed pool burnt ends and brisket nachos really made the visit complete. read more

See all

Good drinks and atmosphere but the bartenders are pretty rude. Stood in line for 30 minutes for a drink and the bartenders friends kept skipping the line and going right to the bar. As soon as I said something the bartender looked at me and said "if you don't like it walk". Pretty good way to treat your customers. I won't be back. read more

Attended the Harvest Festival. Music was so-so, but the real issue was the 45 minute wait for a beer! Only 2 lines inside with maybe 6 bartenders. It looked like it should have gone faster, but waited twice for 45 minutes each time to get a beverage. By the time I made it to a bartender the second time they were out of both items I wanted to order. No additional service outside etc. This place has the space to host a large event, but they do it poorly. read more

Sweet & lowkey atmosphere. Games at tables to play which was a lot of fun! Large beer selection, no cocktails. They did have a selection of wine- the 21 brix Ella's white was delicious. The bartender was very pleasant and quick to serve us! read more

Great outdoor patio area and a nice selection of drast beer. Also have cans to go. read more

Rusty Nickel Brewing Company - Breweries Near Me - West Seneca, New York

See all

Tried a variety flight of 6 , sours, ciders, IPA... everything was delicious. The staff were so welcoming to us & the dogs. Great experience ! read more

Rusty Nickel Brewing Company - Breweries Near Me - West Seneca, New York

The patio at Rusty Nickel is one of the best in the area. And they have the best parties, too. read more

We love going to small craft breweries where the minute you step in the door, you feel like you are with family. The staff and Owners of Rusty Nickel are doing it all right. The quaint bar with the rustic atmosphere is amazing. I have been to hundreds of breweries and have tried thousands of different craft brews, I have never had a beer at Rusty Nickel that disappointed. I love the variety and flavors they have to offer. Parking lot may look swamped because of the business out front, don't be alarmed, pull in and drive to the back where the brewery is and go in.. you will not be disappointed. Thanks for the hospitality and we will continue to support your local business. read more

I was blown away by what was behind the small rustic wood building! Been by it several times going to the restaurant in front of it which we were eating at this day. We looked up the beer menu and found some awesome sounding beers so we walked across the lot , through the doors into a secluded but large , peaceful out door patio with plenty of tables and nooks . Good for groups or two people! And the beers didn't disappoint!! Plenty of unique flavors to satisfy all taste buds! Highly recommend going to this cool hangout! read more

Rusty Nickel Brewing Company - Breweries Near Me - West Seneca, New York

See all

I'm a big fan of the vibe at Rusty Nickel. I miss sitting in their beer garden on a nice summer night. My company hosts our annual fantasy football draft here. The staff is super accommodating. They're currently offering an extensive menu of crowlers for folks who need local craft beer, wine, liquor, mixed drinks and even Bloody Mary's during quarantine. I picked up Horn's Up - which was disappointing, kind of a tasteless Belgian beer. But I LOVE the Taste O'Havens which is like a beer creamsicle. I've always been a big fan of that one. And the Choco Haze which is a porter. Both amazing. I placed my order over the phone and was able to pickup in 20 minutes. Bless you Rusty Nickel. I can't wait to visit the new downtown location (when this crap is over). read more

Rusty Nickel Brewing Company - Cool Crowler! - Breweries Near Me - West Seneca, New York

I've been here several times and have enjoyed each time. This is a very small boutique brewery, so spending time here always feels very intimate and homey. There is a nice selection of beer and wine, and for cider drinkers like myself there are usually 2-3 options which is a refreshing surprise from some breweries. There is a huge outdoor space with a covered patio which is great for outdoor drinks all year long thanks to the heaters in the roof. The downside is always parking as the lot is not huge. I would recommend getting here earlier in the evening to make sure you get a spot. read more

Rusty Nickel Brewing Company - Breweries Near Me - West Seneca, New York

Really fun Halloween trivia night!! the sweet wine tasted amazing and the pork carnitas nachos were great for sharing. fun atmosphere and great night! read more

Rusty Nickel Brewing Company - brix thirsty elephant wine - Breweries Near Me - West Seneca, New York

A pleasant setting with a back rustic beer garden. There are lots of Edison lights hanging over a tree covered outdoor area behind the small brewery. There are quite a few of their brewed beers to chose from as well as a few others. You need to enter from Seneca St. At Ebenezer Ale House as the brewery sits behind the restaurant and shares a small parking lot. It's a nice relaxing place to hang out with friends and the beer was good too. read more

Rusty Nickel Brewing Company - Part of outdoor beer garden at Rusty Nickel Brewery. - Breweries Near Me - West Seneca, New York

See all

So much fun with my friends for a couples night out!! The beer selection was awesome as they had so many I had a hard time choosing which one I wanted to do for the tasting. The only set back was the menu selection for food was small and limited. We couldn't find something we all wanted for dinner so we didn't end up staying for dinner just drinks. But I definitely recommend for a night out for drinks and a bar snack. We will be back to try more beer options!! read more

Rusty Nickel Brewing Company - Beer tasting - Breweries Near Me - West Seneca, New York

Small brewery in the back parking lot of Ebenezer Ale House on Seneca St. The brewery had great service and a great selection of beer, plus other cocktails. read more

Incredible atmosphere, the patio is the best I've seen by far. Great landscaping, pond, fires. The drinks and bartenders are always great and they always offer samples of the drafts. There isn't a better place to be if you're looking to get some drinks outside. read more

Rusty Nickel Brewing Company - Breweries Near Me - West Seneca, New York

I was in the mood for some brews and thought about filling my growler that has been collecting dust on the top of my refrigerator. That idea brought me to Rusty Nickel Brewery, which lies right behind the Ebenezer Ale House in West Seneca. As you can see from the picture, they offer a variety of options of beer. The woman behind the bar allowed me to sample a few of the brews before making my final decision on the Gingerbread Stout. It cost me just under $24 to fill that bad boy, which is more than I would normally spend but I felt good splurging on a high quality beer that a local business produces. I was also thanked by whom I assume is the owner for the purchase. Once COVID numbers ease up, I highly recommend taking advantage of their space. They occasionally have live music, board games, and a great patio space! I'm happy I made the decision to fill my growler there! read more

Rusty Nickel Brewing Company - Breweries Near Me - West Seneca, New York

See all

This place is awesome! Absolutely loved it! The beers are great and the vibe is amazing. The outdoor seating has great ambience. And the staff, omg, they are super friendly. I am definitely coming back here with a bunch of friends. read more

Can I write this while tipsy? I can? Awesome. This place has three stouts. That's like 3 more than some places that call themselves "Biergarten". I had: Slice o' Havens (with orange peel but not overly fruity), oatmeal cookie ale (yes you need this in your life), peated Scotch ale (not too peaty, don't worry), and chocolate milk money (one of the many stouts). I sampled several others. The beer is a solid 4.5. Just wish they told me two of my selections were on nitro! :( The issue is food. Basic munchies are very basic. Tots, fingers, pizza, nothing is good, it's just there. Even though a brewery deserves to be judged on its beer, I'm rounding down because if you choose to offer food, you gotta make it good. Heads up. But if all you want is beer, round up to 5 stars and have at! read more

Rusty Nickel Brewing Company - Selection 2/8/18 - Breweries Near Me - West Seneca, New York

Came for some drinks with a group of friends and really enjoyed my time. The location was off the beaten path located in the parking lot behind Ebenezer Ale House in West Seneca. The decor is rustic and feels like home. The beers on tap have fun names and great flavor. The food was more snack/bar food but their tater tots were delicious! There's an outdoor patio that I look forward to checking out when it gets warmer out. read more

See all

This is a really cool place to stop for some good craft beers. Service is always awesome and the atmosphere is great. Every time we stop in they are making improvements. Good music as well. And, it's on the Beer Trail. We will be back and we would definitely recommend this establishment to others. read more

I just went here for the first time and am now kicking myself for not going sooner! My fiance and I shared a flight and a few beers and ended up trying quite a bit of the menu. There was basically no beer I didn't like, and that's rare. They have a really nice patio and more space than I expected. Excited to come back here again! read more

Supposed to be in Dominican Republic on the beach at Hard Rock...and I kept my week off! So new plan to enjoy vacay?! Sunday Brunch from Rusty Nickel! I wouldn't normally splurge on a 32 oz of Bloody Mary for $20 because I'm be only one drinking it but ya know what? I'm on vacation! So I also got a bacon egg and cheese breakfast sandwich for $4. Cost was $26 ish before my 20% tip. I ordered ahead and had to wait for my sandwich to be made, but what else do I have to do? I opted for a bacon, egg and cheese sandwich. It came on some good bread I would guess Al Cohen white, but not sure. Bacon was cooked nicely, but I didn't expect the fried eggs. Yep there were two. I would have preferred scrambled, but don't know if that was an option. The Bloody Mary came in a 32 oz van with two skewers of goodies. When I got home I rimmed my glass with some celery salt and assembled my garnish aka unwrapped the Slim Jim and added it to the premade skewer. The Bloody is tasty, but I think there is maybe beer in it. It's subtle, but I am a non beer drinker. I know I got it from a brewery but maybe mention that. Anyhow, it was a nice treat! read more

See all

Came for their anniversary party yesterday and the vibes were amazing! Their outside area is awesome! Lots of trees, tables, chairs, and live music! The band (I need to find out who they were) was also really good! It was a mix of country, bluegrass, maybe even rock. Beer selection was decent (I didn't find anything I loved but I enjoyed trying a few!). For food, we had their pretzel sticks which I wouldn't order again. There dry, small, and not worth it in my opinion. They had a bbq food truck out there as well, which was nice. I'd definitely come back to try more beer and just enjoy the outdoor set up that they have. read more