Always great food and great drinks! I love their Philly cheesesteak sub and their mozzarella wedges

Food was just... OK. Was hoping for a better steak at a steak house.. Service was very slow.

Had a classic midwestern Americana experience here with my family. This reminded me of the places my Ohioan brethren would frequent for a night out that was somewhere between diner and classy. My family loved this place and I thought it was pretty darn tasty, too. Just as long as you remember the beginning descriptions in this review, you too, will understand the four stars. This may be the place my family asks to go to again and again. Steamed veggies, reasonable prices and portions, baked potato, French onion soup in a crock... what more could the over 60 crowd ask for? The answer: nothing. I would definitely come back as the under 60 crowd and patronize the bar aka "Watering Hole" and the deck area. I don't care if the deck is essentially in a parking lot... it's outside, has chairs and tables, and I can drink beer. Sold. I would also return for what looked like a very good burger. They had salads or a veggie burger for vegetarian options. I could throw down a few cold ones and feel pretty damn good about live music outside in the summer. Rustler's, I may not be old, but I'll be back! read more

See all

Coleslaw was tasteless and fish was overcooked and rubbery...disappointed...don't waste your money...I should have gotten a fish sandwich at McDonalds. read more

Rustler's Steak House - Rubbery cheap fish and tasteless coleslaw - Steakhouses Near Me - Windham, Maine

Sat at the bar for 30 minutes my boyfriend finished his beer and still we were not asked if we would like to order... raspberry margarita is absolutely awful. Took two sips never asked what was wrong or If I liked it. read more

I've been here a few times. Average interior but cozy enough. Full bar which is a good thing of course. Although the few times I've been I've had less than good luck with the bar tender. The food is alright nothing that has me coming back over and over. It match's the price is fair. They have nice candle they light on each table for ambience which is nice. The staff I've found to be a toss up. To good and sometimes standoffish. It's in a good location though right off the Main Street in windom. Can't miss it and easy to get too. Plenty of parking, And lots of ways to get in and out of. All in all don't let my bad experiences turn you off. If your out for a new adventure pop in have a drink at the bar or a draft to be safe lol, And scope it out for yourself. read more

The worst meal I have ever had. I am going home feeling ill. The chicken tenders were tasteless, the salad looked old, my loaded mashed potato's tasted like they were half powdered and half real. The server was nice and attentive. We won't be back. Ever. read more

Love the burgers at Rustlers also the salads are great! Sitting in the bar area has a great atmosphere and good service! read more

Rustler's Steak House - Salads and Casual fair for lunch - Steakhouses Near Me - Windham, Maine

See all

They don't even answer the phone. That's poor management. Business is that good? Walked across the street to they're old place Trail N Ales. 10 minute wait. Won't bother with Rustlers again. read more

Food was ok-- steaks tasty, but a bit overpriced. Salads ok. Drinks ok. Service could be better-- had to ask our waitress twice for silverware, but no big deal. Overall, if you didn't feel like cooking, it was alright. Could have done better at home, but it was what it was. I'll go back, but not anytime soon. I usually go eat out in Portland, but figured I would give this a try. read more

I have been eating at Rustler's Steak House for years. Never a disappointment. The food & service is phenomenal.

Extremely rude customer service. I called and asked for information on a gathering. I was rudely told that I would have to speak to the owner. I was all but hung up on. I called, as directed, the next day and the owner. Hailey was every bit as rude. Unbelievable! I would hope that instead of stating "that information is on the website" would not be pointed out like I was an idiot and hadn't looked and also assuming I didn't have questions above and beyond. Would definitely not do business when the owner themself lacks any form of customer service read more

Great food, awesome service from Celeste and nice atmosphere.

Good food and drinks. Chili and French onion are delicious, solid wings and poutine and burgers most things I have tried

Rustler's formerly was Charlie Biegg's, which was a fairly decent restaurant. Now under a new name and managed by different people Windham has a venue that has many similarities to Biegg's. However, there is a caveat about dining in Windham asserted by someone like me who had lived in the town for many years. Windham's restaurants are all unremarkable, bland, sterile and devoid of any risk in terms of aesthetic and menu, which is why I almost always go to Portland for dinner. Rustler's does just fine catering to its demographic, which is a known commodity. Their menu is American and average. Their food is decent yet just not my cup of tea. Windham needs an extraordinary restaurant; it's not Rustler's and sadly, in my mind, remains a mythical venue that may never exist. read more

The bar service is great!! Their lunch menu is great they have $10 meals during the week! The portions are huge you won't leave hungry! I enjoy their specials too, they make "fried balls" which change weekly and have various stuffings!! The wings are very good too, buffalo or garlic parm, get them extra crispy, yum!! read more

We recently just bought a house in Raymond and I have to say, this place is so UNDERRATED! Let me startt by saying they are by far the BEST frenchfries I have ever had In my life (and I'm old)! The apps and drinks were amazing and the burger was cooked perfectly! Isabelle, our waitress was amazing, she was funny attentive and did not stop!! We all got something different, my boys are VERY picky, 1 got shrimp (my family owns a seafood restaurant) and the other only orders chicken fingers everywhere he goes and there had to be at least a chicken and a half- they ate all of it! My husband's open faced prime rib sandwich was gone in 7 minutes flat and rivaled his favorite place. Can't wait to come back! read more

Great steaks and chocolate martinis! First time at Sebago and this restaurant was one of the favorites of the trip!

I have been here many times. The food is always very consistent and the steak is always cooked perfect. It does get very busy so be prepared for a wait especially on Friday and Saturday. read more

We visit this steak house frequently. Usually we have good meals and pretty good service. I'm 2-starring it because this time and the last time we've had overdone burger, forgotten soup, fatty steak and terrible service. We usually give 3 tries after bad service because everyone has bad days. These last two visits were the same person and the same crappy service. Waited 8 minutes for drinks after waiting 5 minutes before she came to the table. There was literally 2 tables occupied when we were seated. After bringing the wrong drink to the table she took our order and disappeared. The OTHER waitress brought out our appetizer and the hostess helped get the correct drink. I'm not sure what she was doing but it obviously wasn't her job. If she's the head waitress, she should be demoted. read more

First time visiting, unfortunately service was slow, orders were incorrect (4 out of 9 people) and food was burned or over cooked (3 out of 9). Our server wasn't the problem, but several parties arrived and left before we did, as well as one or two who arrived and left before we even got our meals. This was a weeknight durning dinner service. read more

There aren't a lot of quality restaurants in the Windham area, so after being turned away from a fully reserved Franco's Bistro, my family decided to try our luck at Rustlers Steakhouse, despite the disheartening reviews. The service at Rustlers in excellent. The waitress was polite and friendly, and tended to all our needs. The restaurant has a quaint rustic feel to it, and the menu is exactly what you would expect at a steakhouse. My party started out with Nachos for the appetizer. The Nachos were average at best. The chips were soggy and the cheese tasted very processed. The chicken was mediocre, and there wasn't enough on the dish itself. For my entree, I ordered the NY Strip Steak, rare. The steak was cooked very well, however could have used some more seasoning. The real let down on my dish was the fact that half of the steak was inedible due to it being bound together by tough gristle that was very hard to cut through. To make this issue even worse, the plate which my steak was served on was so small it became difficult to cut my steak. The mashed potatoes that came with my steak tasted instant mashed potatoes you could buy at the super market, and my vegetables were undercooked and tasted frozen. Although Rustlers features good service, the food is average. For 24 dollars, I would not pay for the NY Strip Steak. You are probably better off driving to Portland to get a nice meal if you have the time, or try Francos Bistro. read more

We were greeted by what appeared to be a 15 year old by dressed so casually I wasn't sure he even worked there, in fact all the waitstaff has ripped jeans. We were led to a table in the back corner by the waitress station where we were able to listen in on them gossiping and eating the entire meal. There shouldn't even be a table back there. It was very uncomfortable because the employees were like three feet away from my back. I guess you have to be morbidly obese to get a decent table. I had the bacon cheeseburger... I think they had a cutesy name for it but I forget. It was alright. 1/2 lb of meat was more than my bun could handle and I ended up eating the last half with a fork. The fries, however, were fantastic! My partner in crime got the French dip- I was told it was a bit too smoky in flavor... why would it be smokey? Beats me. Service was prompt and impersonal and that works for me. I would come again as long as I could sit somewhere else. read more

Stopped in for a quick bite after a long day off shopping. Food was great. Our server was excellent so charming and cheerful her name was Isabelle i believe. Probably some of the best service ive had in a very long time. Would definitely recommend visiting this restaurant and hopefully your lucky enough to enjoy her amazing service!!! read more

Been a half dozen times, it's consistently good and the barmaids are very nice and always smiling. Nice folks, NOT a tourist spot. Food is quite good and seafood chowder is very nice. (Although I overheard a couple of beer salespeople from Boston dissing us Mainers as well as the owners of Punkin Valley in Bridgton. BAD form. They were young snowflakes sans class. I'd fire the Harpoon beer reps myself. Ya Bub, I heard ya trying to impress the girls you chump.) read more

So...our waitress was great and very attentive. Stay away from the baked stuffed scallops as best you can. I have had microwave dinners better than this. They were not baked stuffed. It was like scallops with cheese whiz on them. read more

The service was 5 star. We sat at the bar (wanted to watch the Pats game). The food? BLAH! The entree that is, my steak tips were grisly and just not tasty (the garlic mushroom sauce was). My sister's NY strip steak was good. Maybe she'll leave a better review? Garlic Parm chicken wings for the app, very good. BIG. Beer was fresh and tasty. But I came here for STEAK. Parking can get tight. read more

Rustler's is a solid steakhouse in the Windham area. When they first opened they carried some really unique meats like bison, and elk maybe. Those offerings have not continued to date. But the menu items they carry they do very well. They have 12 beers on tap. 2-4 I would consider micro-brews. I would encourage Rustler's to bring back unique offerings and challenge them to get more local or "craft" with their tap list. Rustler's deserves a ton of credit for the special dinners and events they try to draw us in. They also offer space for private events. The wagon wheel sampler will not disappoint. Burgers to steaks you'll be pleased! I really like their sweet potato fries. Thursday's seem to be BBQ plate, I have plan for that. read more

Over the last year the quality has been declining. I came in for lunch today and ordered a basic cheeseburger. The patty was the same quality as a bubba burger you can buy at wal-mart grocery. My wife's steak was thin, tough and fatty. Baked Potato was small, dry and lacked any luster. When Rustlers first opened it was a good value for the money. My last 3-times here has proven otherwise. read more

I've read some of the poor reviews of Rustlers.....this is not one of them. Preface, I went for lunch, and I didn't eat any meat items. The parking lot is expansive, no issues parking. The decor isn't modern, but it was clean and met anyone's standards for a business lunch. The service was excellent, very attentive. I ordered an appetizer for the group....Parmesan garlic wings....these were very good....crispy, good garlic aroma, and enough cheese to make it flavorful, without being bulky texturally. I thought these were some of the best I've had....reminding me of Roule's Roadside in Portland in the 90's. I had the blackened scallop Caesar ....again, very good. Seven mid sized scallops, nicely blacked end with good crust and moist texture. A solid salad. I had a martini...perfectly poured and created.....for a mid tier food spot....I have nothing to complain about. We had good lunch food, good service, easy access, I'm giving it a solid 3 1/2 stars....that said, I'll try the beef next sitting. read more

Is there suddenly a shortage of shrimp and clams in the state of Maine? I stared at the Rustler's menu for a good 20 minutes and couldn't find a single dish served on Saturday night that included either of these items. I understand Rustlers is technically a steakhouse, but c'mon folks, we're in Maine. I'm a die-hard seafood person while my husband is a steak and burger guy. Most steakhouses we've been to offer at least one shrimp or clam dish or a surf and turf option that uses one of those ingredients. Honestly, the complete lack of those items on the menu make it pretty unlikely that my husband and I will return to this place, even though the food we did order was decent. I thought the service was good. We were seated immediately. The food came out quickly and my toddler's chicken fingers were good. I actually love the batter they use on the chicken fingers. It reminded me of being a kid and eating at the old school seafood places down in Old Orchard. Yum! My husband ordered a bacon cheeseburger and said it's the best one he's ever had at a restaurant.I got the seafood (ie scallop and fish) chowder and honestly was not a fan. It tasted like a bottle of white wine had been dumped in it and It was way too boozy... completely lacking that buttery richness one looks for in a chowder. I think the wine could work in a seafood chowder, just in a much smaller volume :) The bread they put on the table was awesome and possibly even homemade??? I also love that they use Cabot butter with the rolls. Yum!!! read more

My baked potato was cold. Got a new one, it was hot, but it was OLD. Must have been sitting around for hours. The salad dressing was terrible. They should ASK people if they want the salad, as I am sure much of what they put out was wasted. My friend ordered riblets, they looked burnt, and didn't even resemble riblets. My other friend was sick after she ate her sandwich. Not impressed read more

We had a graduation party here for our son. We chose the buffet. The good was outstanding as was the wait staff. Everything was great.

This place is the best place on the planet earth excellent prices, great staff low wait and superb food however no keto options whatever that means read more

Food was great, excellent fries! Very quick service.. Good drink specials, friendly staff.

Went there last night with two other couples. The wait was tolerable. We sat under the tent. Server was slow to take our drink order and it arrived in 15 minutes. A total of 1/2 hour for our server to acknowledge us and then to get our drinks. She was very pleasant but seemed to be in a hurry the entire time we asked for anything. Two in the party had fish and chips that were barely warm. I had the walnut salad which was good . Can we talk about the smoking? Outside or not I do not want to smell cigarette smoke. Because the tent is set up in the parking lot people were over by their cars smoking and there's is a roped off area next to the tent for smoking. The smoke still drifted in to the tent which had open sides. This was a total put off for me and I will not return. read more

Abysmal service, inconsistent. My husband ordered two cocktails, the first arrived in a pint glass, the second in a rocks glass, both were the same price. The food was fine, but our server was supremely inconvenienced by our presence. She maybe spoke a total of 10 words during our entire experience. read more

Excellent service. Very pleasant employees. We had already sat down and ordered then decided to check Yelp. We got a little nervous when reading some recent reviews but no problem for us. My wife, daughter and myself all ordered the filet. They were all cooked perfectly, one medium well and two medium. The salads and dinner rolls were very good. I loved the mashed and gravy. My wife really enjoyed the sweet potatoes and my daughter also loved her fries. Nice clean and cozy place. I took a peek in the bar area and looks real comfortable, full tables in there as well with some TVs. A nice patio outside also( 90 degrees and humid so we stayed inside). We will definitely be back. read more

Ok service. Bad and tasteless food. The top sirloin was stringy and dry. My chicken tenders were overcooked and dry read more

Went here after St. Joseph's graduation and was underwhelmed. We were a large party and there was a second large party upstairs with us. The waitress had no help serving the two tables, so after waiting an hour because the kitchen was behind, it took this poor woman forever to serve our entire table. Ordered the Top Sirloin medium and there wasn't any pink in the middle at all and no flavor. Why not complain? We were starving and had already waited an hour!!! Too bad a steak house can't do steak well read more