Friendly servers and always checked on us for drink refills etc, they were right on it. The steak tip salad I had was excellent, the steak was perfect as far as I'm concerned. Great selection of appetizers, especially the mozzarella half moons. I've been twice so far and will probably return again. read more

Change of pace for the husband we don't normally head to the Windham area for dinner. He was in the mood for steak so he chose the place. Our waitress was sweet and knowledgeable! I was amazed at how big the inside was. Food was delicious. I do enjoy a nicely cooked wing and these were very good! read more

Rustler's Steak House - Wings - Steakhouses Near Me - Windham, Maine

See all

We stop here almost every time we are in the area around Lake Sebago. It's a big place with lots of tables, a big bar and a good size parking lot. AST this point, we've ordered a bunch of different things and they've all been good - burgers, haddock, and more. Plenty of good drink options too. Service has been good every time too! read more

Not the best experience. At the bar and you would think you would get attention but no. I was less than impressed with the steak tips. It was cut up steak and lots of sauce. The mashed was ok. No one asked me how my meal was :(. Visiting Windham and will not return to this restaurant. read more

The service was slow. The waitress never checked back on drinks or food. Bake potato was still hard. Ordered a well done burn it steak, came out medium with pink. Coleslaw was not fresh. Rustlers is a great place normally it was first time on a busy Friday night. read more

We just left Rustler's and we are very satisfied! Burgers were delicious and fish and chip perfect Waitress was great and very attentive Definitely we will.be regulars read more

Busy Friday night before Christmas , was hoping to miss the supper rush but hit the noisy bar rush instead . Had to wait for a table because no one was around to clean the tables people had left from . Had the same waitress from the last visit . Was not any better . Long wait for food , excessive then it was cold . The stuffed baked scallops were not great and even worse cold ,high light again was the bacon wrapped scallops and crab Rangoons . Please add your non alcoholic beverages to a menu . And non carbonated as well . The worst thing was the employee coughing all over the place . It's bad enough the customers coming in sick and spreading that around for the holidays . If you're sick and dealing with food please at least wear a mask . read more

See all

We had not been to Rustler's since they moved. While I like the space it is definitely smaller, which made for a wait to be seated on a busy night and then wait a long time for our meal. There is a huge bar and they seat right around that which is not my preference to be right up against strangers, but was the only option to get a space. There might be more seating for families upstairs but a table was not apparently an option for a party of 2. The food was excellent. I had the baked stuffed scallops, which I would recommend. A good amount of fresh large scallops with a healthy helping of delicious seafood stuffing and newburg sauce. The stuffing had small, but still discernible pieces of real lobster meat. I could not finish everything - and I really gave it a try! My husband had a burger with cheese and bacon. This was juicy and delicious. He had onion rings that were light and crispy. Great meal that would warrant 5 stars but for the wait issue and lack of table seating. read more

Rustler's Steak House - Baked stuffed scallops - Steakhouses Near Me - Windham, Maine

See all

We wanted to try lunch today and decided to go even though the ratings weren't that high. The atmosphere and the wait staff was great. The food though was not. We got the combo appetizer platter. It was really over cooked. The chicken fingers were really tough. I had a burger and asked for medium. It was very well done to the point of it being hard to eat. Was hoping for the experience to be good so we could add a higher rating. read more

My party of three was told we would have a 25 minute wait and were put on the waiting list. We waited for 45 minutes, during the course of which, multiple similar sized groups that came in after us skipped us on the list. We were the only group remaining and were being ignored and side eyed by the staff. Ultimately left to eat elsewhere. Awful service. read more

Maddie was a wonderful server but our entrees were soo disappointing. The house salads had wilted lettuce. The scallop and haddock bakes were burnt on the bottom. My husband's first chicken was undercooked. It just felt like the kitchen didn't care. The sides were delicious with the exception of the baked potato. I had read that on a review and have to concur. The Cole slaw was delightful as well as the house vegetables. For the price we would never go again and would say try other places for dinner. read more

Rustler's Steak House - Overcooked baked that disappointed us. - Steakhouses Near Me - Windham, Maine

See all

We got to the restaurant a short time prior to closing - not our preference but nothing else was open, and/or they were hosting holiday parties. Even so, everyone was still polite and helpful. Our food was cooked well, and came out quickly. Opted for the prime rib and scallops. By the time we finished, we were the last two in the restaurant besides staff. Again, they didn't rush us but I also didn't want them to have to stay just because of us so we didn't stay too long. The restaurant was comfortable enough but not "cozy". Beer menu was nice and I appreciate they have several Maine-brewed options. read more

This was our first time being here. The parking lot was full and I can why . Our food was delicious and cooked perfectly. We sat at the bar when we saw two empty seats as it was very busy . Rustic looking inside and pretty loud which was fine for us. Caesar salad was real good. I got the tenderloin and was cooked to perfection! My husband got the steak tips with a sweet chili sauce on them . We will definitely go back when in the mood for steak . read more

See all

Yes, it's a bit small inside , but the food was good, the service was good, and prices are reasonable. Also, they do have outdoor seating. We chose to sit inside and were able to get a booth, although most of the tables are close to the bar. We ordered the beef tips and the walnut cranberry salad, which was served with warm balsamic on the side. Very good, and I would recommend a visit. read more

See all

Not a fan! Perhaps not a "regular" and well noted after being ignored not given a menu nor water nor even asked how my food was. And handed a meal with none of the items the menu said it came with. Would be different if they were short staffed, but there were like six waiters/waitresses and I truly felt I was ignored because I was from "away". Will never go again. read more

We've been here twice since last review- Had grilled prime rib, and delmonico- both medium rare, both just superb- service was quick, efficient, attentive, but we went for lunch, not dinner. A very wet, rainy Saturday- light crowd, so not noisy- We will go for lunch in the future, not dinner. read more

Great food and good prices with friendly service. Yes the restaurant is a bit small and can feel a bit cramped, but the food is well worth it. read more

See all

Worst service and BLT I've ever had. if you don't like crunchy bacon don't order from here. waitress walked by 5 times didn't even ask how the food was or anything. Come out throwing debit card after not leaving tip. Do not eat here read more

3 of us walked in for dinner, hostess was very nice, seated us right away. I put my arm on the table and noticed it was very sticky. When the waitress came over, I asked her if she could wipe the table, it was very sticky. She took our order and disappeared. The food runner came out with the appetizer and i notice she had a dish towel in her belt. I asked her if she could wipe the table and she said let me grab the spray bottle i will be right back. She was back in a flash!! About 10 minutes later the same food runner brought out our dinners. This is when everything went south, The food was over cooked, the baked potatoes were as hard as a rock. Finally the waitress came over and said how is everything, 3 of us wanted to scream at her all at once. She said the potatoes are not baked they are seamed. She said if she new that she would have told us not to get them GREAT!! The salads came out after the meal was served. I always thought the salads came out before the meal. Let me wrap this up we are never going back again !! read more

First time at Rustler's since they mover locations. I had dinner at the old place once and it was so bad I never returned. My wife and I decided to try the new location and were pleasant surprised. Waitress was very good. The short rib raviolis appetizers were excellent. My wife had baked stuffed scallops. I had scallops with lemon favored bread crumbs. Both meals were very good. Arrived hot and the waitress waited for us to finish our appetizers before she brought the main meal. Our only disappointment was being seated next to a table of screaming kids. They also seated another party with kids near us. The dinning room was not crowded at the time. Our fault for not speaking up. We would definitely return. read more

Saturday evening 8pm 15 minute wait. Service was great food was pretty good except that we both got cold baked potatoes so no way the butter would melt. Prime rib is recommended. read more

We arrived at Rustler's on a Friday evening around 6 PM, six people in our party and we were seated at once. Our server was Liz, and she was amazing! Food was great and cooked to order, and portions were plentiful. read more

See all

The appetizer was just your traditional fried foods and tasted alright. The ribs fell right off the bone and were cooked well. Very delicious. Seasonal veggies had a good seasoning mixture. Fries, well are fries. The service was friendly and on top of it even when it was busy, kept checking in with us and got everything we needed in time. The restaurant is beautifully decorated and styled as well. read more

Rustler's Steak House - Mozzarella Wedges, Potatoes Skins, and Wings - Sampler - Steakhouses Near Me - Windham, Maine

See all

Food was great and priced fairly in my opinion. The service was great as well, but the environment was really loud. I'm not sure if that's because the bar and restaurant share the same space, but it can be hard to hear your group members on really busy nights. read more

Awful food. The NY strip looked like my mother's pot roast. Server was pleasant but didn't really do much. Seems more like a loud bar than a dinner place. Won't go back. read more

Rustlers has moved to where Gilbert's Chowder house used to be. We had lunch here memorial weekend. It wasn't busy and sitting outside wasn't set up yet. Rustlers has done a lot of work inside. Very nice. The staff were nice and the service was very good. I ordered the Reuben sandwich and it was hot and delicious. My two friends order fish and chips. They said it was very good. But it was chunks of fish on a bed of lettuce, the meal came with fries and cole slaw. Being Mainers we have never had haddock served that way. We will go back when the outside seating is opened. read more

We love going there, everyone is so nice. Food is so good, kids love it too. Its a tread to go there for sure.

This place was amazing! Even during the height of all the Covid stuff going on, their service was amazing. Their food was too notch. We split nachos and balsamic walnut salad for apps, and the salad was to die for. So delicious, we didn't take long to clear that plate. The entrees were equally delicious and the seadog blueberry beer was a great addition to the meal. Definitely will be back when we are in the area! Sorry the photo is half eaten but it was too good to stop for a picture at the beginning !!! read more

Rustler's Steak House - Balsamic Walnut Cranberry Salad - Steakhouses Near Me - Windham, Maine

See all

Had to give a local business a second chance, it has been almost a year since the last trip. Little has changed. This time, the prime rib was juicy but again had little or no flavor. All it takes is a simple rub on the meet before cooking. read more

If you want to go rustlers in windhzm maine be prepared to wait over a hour for your food.. not even busy ... terrible service .. never go there again read more

Service: good Ambiance: local bar/restaurant, fairly comfortable Food: pretty bad. All around. I would be hard pressed to return. read more

I ordered the Chicken Stir Fry w Steak Tips, it was phenomenal! Great place to eat in the Windham Area

Great food and service tonight! So much better when the tourists are not around! Huge portions and lively ambiance.

Had lunch there today. I had a very unimpressive salad that was mostly mixed greens that you can buy in a bag at the grocery store. The service was very good. No complaints there. read more

Excellent!!! Staff was great and friendly Food was outstanding!!! Love the place and I live out of state

The two stars are for the staff. The food is awful. Salty, soggy, pedestrian, greasy poor quality pub food. The family next to us had a similar experience. The woman liked hers, but everyone else at there table was as grossed out as we were. If you have a bland pallet and enjoy salt and mush, this is the place for you. read more

My family ate at Rustlers last night for my daughters birthday dinner. We sat at the outdoor seating. Our waitress took forever to take our order, over an hour. It was in the evening and the wind was picking up, so we asked if we could go inside. Oh no she said there is no room. I told her it was my daughters birthday at the beginning of our dinner and I would like to get her a piece of cake or cupcake at the end of dinner. We were there for over 2 1/2 hours and we had to ask for our checks. She did not ask us if we needed desert. When she knew we were upset she sent another staff member out to speak with us and this lady made tons of excuses as to why the service was not good. She said it was her birthday too and wanted our sympathy. I told her that I asked for a cupcake or similar and she shouted, "We don't serve cupcakes"! I said anything would have been better than what we were offered which was nothing. Then she proceed to say we automatically put on a 20% gratuity and that really set me off. Her timing was already bad. She became hostile and aggressive which really ruined our experience there. I told her we were local Mainers and I hope you don't treat vacationers like that. I will never go back. The food was good but that's about all. I feel bad that my daughter and grandchildren had to experience the madness that came out of it. read more

This place is so cute and offers food picky and refined eaters alike. I really like how the staff seem like family. They are so cute.

Completely remodeled and beautiful inside. Outside seating recently opened. We've recently gone twice for dinner and once for drinks and an app. We tried dinner a second time hoping for a better outcome . The service is always top notch but the entrees are mediocre at best. For a steak house, I would not recommend the steak. However the wings and bacon wrapped scallops were fabulous. read more

Is it a coincidence that almost all of the reviews are from out of state visitors? Interesting, isn't it? At any rate - It's standard, if not above standard grub. You're going in basically for good bar food. I tend to think their steaks are on the average side, and are pricey. The rest though? Goooood stuff. I've been probably 25 times. The nachos are a mountain of gooey delicious, the wings are always good, with lots of different choices for sauces, their burgers are big, juicy, sexy masses of beef, and there are some unique choices for burgers. Sitting on the bar side is the way to go. It's cozy, high top seating, right next to the bar. The dining room is a bit antiquated, I guess, it just feels different. Bar side is lively and fun. read more