After a very regretful visit to a local Italian restaurant, we decided to give Rustler's a try. We do takeout and that was packaged well. I thought the decor was cool and although we only did carry out, the service was friendly. I've been craving nice baked scallops for a while now and mine were fantastic. I want to try a sweet potato next time, but what I ordered was delish. My family highly enjoyed their dishes: burger, steak salad, chicken wings, etc. It was all excellent and I can't wait to go again to try other dishes next time I visit the area. The prices were reasonable, in my opinion. I was pretty surprised at the succulent scallops' eighteen dollars & change. Wow. The other Di Sappointos Restaurant (see what I did there) served little over cooked scallops at almost twice the price. If I had to complain about something, they did forget the mayo on the burger, but we had some at home. It was a very pleasing meal with plenty of food leftover for the next day. I highly recommend it and I bet it's a fun place to dine in also. read more

I have been going to Rustlers since they opened. We usually sit at the bar and get good service. They know what I like to drink and are on top of things. Last night I went with my husband and a few friends. The bar was full so we sat in the dining area. I have never in my life been treated so horribly at a dining establishment. My dirty martini was a straight up vodka martini...I then had to ask twice for olive juice and received an attitude from our server. I do not eat fried food and my group wanted the wagonwheel sampler (all fried) so I ordered the french onion soup and a salad. Well it all arrived together with everyone's meals. I made a comment that I wanted the soup first and she responded by telling me that since we had an appetizer she didnt think I needed it then. ok fine thats not what I said but ok I understand mistakes happen. Then the manager huffs her way over and greets me by saying "So I hear you are being pretty boisterous with your complaining over here..." um are you serious? ok this is where you want to take it. I reply nicely and say that i didnt complain when my drink was wrong..she cut me off by saying "well it looks pretty dirty to me" I then had to explain that I had to ask numerous times for olive juice and dirty it myself at the table. She then says she will take it off and acts like all I wanted was a free meal. No I will gladly pay for (and still tip your rude waitress) but I will NEVER set foot in this establishment even if was the last restaurant in Windham. They did take off my dinner but I couldn't even eat it after that experience. If you really want steak try Buck's and DeSantos blows this place out of the water all around and the staff is actually friendly. read more

Ok really guys? How can you only give three stars to a 10 star restaurant? I can only give 5 stars. But I have been coming five years now and never have I had, a bad meal, bad service, or anything! The girls at the bar are awesome!! Filet, French dip, burgers, you name it, NONE better in the area period!! People come here and you will love it. We live in New Hampshire and crave this place! read more

We recently had Rustler's Steak House of Windham cater our daughter's wedding and they were incredible! Outstanding food, bend over backwards service with attention to all the things we didn't want too, or were to busy to worry about. We highly recommend Rustler's and will definitely use them again if the opportunity presents itself. Several of our guests' declared this the "best food they have ever had at any wedding!" great job and thank you again! read more

Service was no good, was at table for 6-7 minutes before waitress came over, we already had picked out our entrees, while waiting for our table, only to be told they were out of the prime rib and she'd give us more time, suggested the Delmonico (saying it was the same cut) we were told squash was the veg of the day. I love squash so stuck with it he hates it so took the other option coleslaw. When meals came they were both served with carrots it was the hostess that brought our dinners and we said he was supposed to get coleslaw, I don't like carrots so I tried the coleslaw his baked potato was brown on the inside. And we will not return. read more

Worst meal I've had in a long time. I got the Delmonico steak. It didn't have any flavor. My baked potato looked and tasted like it was something they found in the back of the oven. When I cut it open it was brown. I was supposed to get cole slaw with my meal. They brought me carrots. When I asked about the slaw they apologized and said they would bring some right out. When they brought it to me it tasted like they just went back and shredded some cabbage in a bowl and brought it to me. read more

Have been there 3 times with the neighborhood. wonderful food and we found the prices, especially the early bird specials, quite reasonable. They handled our party of 8 flawlessly. The food was excellent !! This is a terrific addition for Windham. Kudos to the fine chef and may we also say it is nice to see Sandy's smiling face greeting us (from Red Sands). read more

Hidden among the many stores and outlets in the Windham Mall, is an intriguing fine dining-family style restaurant by the name of Rustler's Steakhouse. With the option of sitting inside at wood grain tables or outside on a lovely veranda your dining experience could suit the dinner's mood. Other than the bathroom and lobby space being on the smaller side, Rustler's Steakhouse is very nice, the waiter and Maitre d'hotel were very welcoming and helpful. The food was delicious, although the alfredo sauce was a little too thick. Other than that everything was very good. The Shirley Temple was a one of the best ever made. The menu included everything from soups to steaks, even salads. The bathroom was clean. The decorations fit the theme of it being a steakhouse. The dinner will not have to stretch his pocket to eat at Rustler's. The menu prices are fairly low, even for a steak dinner. Rustler's Steakhouse is family friendly, at least from a toddler's age and up.The dining area is small, not very accommodating for wheelchairs or newborns. There's is a bar for those who enjoy a drink every now and then. Over all, Rustler's Steakhouse would rate at 4 stars, the experience was great but the size of lobby and dining area was small, taking away from the first impression, but not by much. read more

Went in today with my aunt and uncle who were visiting from MA-the reviews I read online prior had been mixed, but I wanted to give it a try, as I have been there once before and it was delicious. We went for lunch and they have a great lunch special menu for very reasonable. I got a panini, my uncle got a steak and cheese and my aunt got a buffalo chicken salad. All pretty basic items to prepare but we all loved our meals and the service was great, will be back again for sure. And bud light on tap for 2.50...how can you say no to that! read more

Good food, friendly service, casual place, and GREAT sweet potato fries. I'm never disappointed when I go.

Had the baked stuffed haddock and it was wonderful! Came with a salad, fresh crusty roll and veggie medley. I can honestly say the best I ever had. Husband and I went Friday 4/1/11...Very busy place but if you go to any restaurant opening week you must be prepared to wait a little longer. Was definately worth the wait...will go again when the newness wears off. read more

We had a family gathering here recently and the service and food was excellent. I felt the prices were very reasonable, right in line with other restaurants. I did not hear of a single complaint. Our experience was so good that we have made plans to go back again next year. read more

Not impressed. Everyone had a good time but the food left us wanting. The prices are too high to take kids that are too old for any kiddy menu. Actually, they were on the high side all the way around. Service was OK and the place had a nice atmosphere. The people we went with say they eat there all the time and didn't complain about the food so maybe it was what I ordered or they were having a bad night - doesn't explain the cost though. read more

If I could give it no stars I would. First off food took an hour to come out my table for the most part ordered their top sirloin steaks and ordered them medium or medium rare, well they all came out very very well done to an inedible point. Also one of them came out with a cockroach on the plate. The manager had spoken to us and was very rude. After having three plates sent back and very over cooked chicken tenders and a cockroach on our table the only took half off two plates. We spoke to the manager again politely but she responded again rudely but eventually took some items off the bill. We wanted to have the contact information of the owner and this manager who's name she stated was Hailey claimed she was also the owner but after doing a little research found she had lied about that too and she is not the owner. So long story short very dirty place seeing there's roaches in the kitchen, food is not good, and customer service is appalling. Highly do not recommend. read more

Online menus are $1 cheaper then the menus inside. My boyfriend found red hard plastic in his salad bit down on it and the staff didn't care that he almost choked on it, they just said a casual sorry and claimed it was most likely from a cap to a whip cream can, and didn't do anything about it. When I got my sirloin steak, I ordered it medium, it came out charred and burnt on the outside. It had no flavor other than the charred old meat. My boyfriend tried it and we then decided to say something. We ended up getting my meal, not the entire bill, half off because I didn't want another nasty steak. What made me irate was when they didn't care that there was plastic in his salad, that no one cared. Heartless staff, and bad management on safety and carelessness. I wish I didn't leave the $3 tip for the waitress because she showed no simpathy for my boyfriend almost choking on the plastic!!! Who ever attempted to throw out that plastic piece to that whip cream can should take some time to actually throw it away in the trash and made sure it didn't get into someones salad!!! He is my boyfriend and I love him, I want him around and don't need the careless, heartless staff to make a stupid mistake that could take the most important person away from me!! I will never go there again, and I will tell everyone about this experience. 3 strikes in one night you're out! read more

I have now been to this restaurant twice since it opened and was looking forward to a good steak meal since CHarlie Beiggs closed. The first time I ordered the Prime Rib and ordered it "medium rare." It was literally raw. When I showed it to the waitress, she said "oh is that too raw for you?" They did take $10 off my bill. The next time I went with my best friend, they were out of prime rib so we both ordered the rib eye. Both were undercooked. She sent hers back once and should have still sent it back again. I did not bother. Her side dish of rice was clumped up starch and looked like it had been scraped from the bottom of the pan. I understand we got there at the end of the dinner shift, however, the meal should have been a decent meal for what I was paying. When these things were pointed out to the waitress she nicely acknowledged that they were so and was attentive but did nothing to resolve the problem. That was $50 down the drain. Best thing about both meals was their fresh vegetables. read more