Consistently the best pizza in Mchenry. I have tried many of them, and Rosatis has the best quality ingrediants.

Three cheese baked penne don't bother. It was gross, barely any Marinara sauce despite the young girls claim of 2 ladles of sauce. Paid extra for a tiny meatball and the smothered dry noodles with weird tasting mozzarella and overly seasoned was just an Italians nightmare dinner. Garlic bread was gross, bread tasted stale, soggy on top and tough and chewy on bottom. don't order on Tuesdays! Pizza is hit or miss either good or gross with soggy crusts or burn. They jacked up their delivery fee again now $4.50 hope it all goes to their fast and nice drivers. But expensive fee Esp if you're a great tipper. read more

Poor service. I called and asked for crushed red pepper, and they said they would add it to the order. When the delivery driver showed up, I asked him for the pepper, and he said it was in the box. When I opened the box, it had no pepper, and the pizza was ice cold after waiting almost an hour for. read more

Definitely not coming to Rossatis again! We had a terrible experience yesterday when we ordered an 18 inch pizza and we got a 16 inch pizza. To make the story short we didn't realize until we got home. I asked my husband to check the box and sure indeed it was a 16. He called and asked to remake it and the guy was insisting on giving us a 12" and we said no just make the 18" we ordered that we got charged that. My husband went to go pick it up an the cook came and was requesting for us to give back the 16" we didn't since we already had touched it. He kept arguing with my husband saying I don't understand why u can't just take the 12". He told him it's the principal it's customer service. You messed up and you have to fix it. Definitely not good service. read more

As always the food was amazing and the portions were huge!! Enough for two days! The quality is amazing! read more

Rosati's Pizza - The chief - Pizza Near Me - McHenry, Illinois

See all

We order from here frequently, food is always good and consistent. My previous review had 5 stars but I've gone down the 3 due to the delivery service... the last 4 times we've ordered delivery we have specified "no contact delivery" and I also make a note to leave at side door. Each time the driver disregards our request, if we don't have sleeping baby and dogs that bark whenever someone knocks Will wake up the sleeping baby... it's super frustrating!! And it says right on the receipt "no contact delivery- leave at side door"! What is the point of even offering this option if the driver doesn't pay attention to it..... for the record, it's been a different driver each time, so it's not their fault but maybe they need to be trained to pay attention to the receipt so they know what the customers are asking! read more

I tried to take advantage of your 60th Anniversary promotion which ran on 10/15/24. (Large 2 topping pizza for $3.50) When I tried to order online, your website crashed! I then took a ride to your location, only to be told they weren't taking any new orders. (I was told it was already sold out by 12:00pm.) WHAT KIND OF BS PROMOTION ARE YOU PEOPLE RUNNING HERE? I AM NEVER AGAIN BUYING ANYTHING FROM YOUR COMPANY!!! read more

Horrible pizza. It was so greasy and made me sick to my stomach. Very expensive as well. Never again!

I am a fan of Pizza. every friday night is movies and pizza at my house. First time ordering Rosatis Pizza at McHenry and it was to enjoy the Superbowl game. thanks it was a great choice read more

Best Pizza in town! Always delicious and hot when it arrives. We love this pizza it's our favorite and has been for years. Yum! Thanks Rosatis! read more

Have been a customer all my life. Within the last 6 months, continuous recent orders consisted of: 1: A burnt pizza 2: A 1/2 cheese, 1/2 pepperoni pizza that somehow got sausage added to it (never ordered sausage) 3: A 1/2 pepperoni, 1/2 italian beef & green pepper pizza that had green olives rather than green pepper. For #3, I had someone from out of town visiting and wanted to show them "the best pizza they'd ever had"... Fucking big mistake to order from Rosatis. Who mixes up green pepper and green olives? Yet, who orders green olives with italian beef? Nobody. I walked in to place this order. Spoke extremely clearly. Am always a very generous tipper. Why didn't I call or take the pizzas back? BECAUSE I WAS HUNGRY... And because I've been a customer here for so long, I figured mistakes happen. I very rarely ever complain about food or return food - instead I just don't return. Well, now I'm sitting here about to order a pizza and thinking if it's worth my money and time to gamble and roll the dice with Rosatis and their seemingly incompetent 2020 staff.... ? Not really. Now, I'm not sure if everyone died from Covid and they are short-staffed this year, or what.. Maybe it's the simple fact that the high-school stoners of yesteryear made far better pizza than the little facebook junkies of today. Who knows. Either way, I have to make the choice to get pizza from somewhere else tonight because the last 3 times have pretty much proven I can expect an incorrectly made, sub-par pizza. Management needs to wake up and get off their ass... People can't even make a fucking pizza correctly anymore, and I must ask myself what has this word come to? I'm barely 40 years old, too! Sucks. It was nice knowing you guys. Thanks for 25 years of great food, goodbye! read more

My whole family loves everything on the menu Best pizza in town , I love the friendly service

ordered the Tuesday night special Ribs for 19.95 with two orders of fries plus two drinks and the spaghetti and meatballs. I got no fries no soda and charged 24.95 for the ribs and didn't get the whole order. What a rip off read more

Rosati's McHenry have never failed us! Our orders have always come exactly as I ask and hands down the best around! Have been getting yummies from them for years and staff is always pleasant and professional. Whenever I ask for something extra like sauces etc..they are always there! Thanks to You folks for making my life a lil easier and happy tummies! read more

With the amount of pizza places in the area, this is our #1 go to place!! The staff is very accommodating with all of our needs, and I'm a picky person so I always have a lot of requests! I think out of the hundreds (literally) of times I've ordered from here, there was just one mess up on my order, and I called right away, and they offered to fix it and bring the new food back out, or to give me a credit for next time. I understand people are human and mistakes are sometimes made, but to order from a place that also understands that and is always willing to make it right, makes ordering from a place like this all the better! Rob, the general manager, runs that store like a very well oiled machine. It's always super clean and the staff is very friendly. I would recommend the lasagna with meat sauce and meatballs, the chef on garlic bread with a side of red sauce, and any and all of their pizzas! I can't wait to try more dishes from here! Also, the chicken Caesar salad is the bomb! read more

How does a Chicagoland eatery screw up an Italian beef sandwich? Ask Rosati's in McHenry. Their dry, chewy, slightly gamey and extremely salty sandwich made me instantly regret my purchase, and wish I'd just gone to Portillo's. Don't get me wrong, they can do pizza, but their Italian beef is embarrassing. For almost $7, it needs to be better. And their service isn't all that great either. I ordered the Italian beef with sweet peppers on it, never got the sweet peppers. Boy, could it have used those sweet peppers! I ordered a 2 liter of Cherry Pepsi with my order, did not get the Pepsi. They had to come back to fulfill the rest of my order. And that's not the first time "I'll be right back!" has happened. Not a good sandwich, service isn't on the ball. Get it together, Rosati's. read more

Ordered last night Dec 22. Temp was -12. Pizza arrived in 30 minutes and was hot AF! We ordered sausage mushroom onion green pep. I was nervous because I had my parents over and a lot of reviews here and other places in Mchenry are so bad. I was super stoked dinner was early and piping hot!! The driver was super sweet too! read more

Great pizza and makes me feel at home. I moved away 5 years ago and it was everything I remembered. Love the pizza here! read more

Rosati's Pizza - Pizza Near Me - McHenry, Illinois

While I love Rosati's, I highly suggest not ordering from this store. My neighbor once ordered a well done pizza, but received a under cooked pizza. When he called in, he got cussed out and hung up on. 2 nights ago, I ordered and made a VERY simple order. Once my food arrived, I noticed I was my mozzarella sticks, and the sauce inside my dough nugget boxed looked like it was shook around.. barely any sauce left in the actual cup. Called in and was very polite about what had happened but received reactions and a irritated delivery driver that came back and treated my like I was the a**hole. read more

Food is fine but, these drivers are getting so.. ridiculous with the amount of tips they're expecting. 4th time a driver asked me if I needed any change back. Paying 30-40% tip gets real old expecting a $8-10 tip on a $27.00 pizza! Give people their change back and let them decide... leaving your change in the car and making it difficult is just rude. I've always tipped well but, when it's overly expected No.. not doing it anymore. read more

Ordered hawaiian pizza, so greasy, and burnt cheese all around pizza, ashamed to offer it to my friends. Had free delivery coupon and was charged delivery, Also requested new menu and driver told me they were out of menus. second time pizza was to greasy to eat will not order pizza from they again. read more

Great pizza! Favorite place! Always hot when delivered. Staff is always extremely nice!

I want to write a good review so bad because the food really is good but the service here is so god awful that it's not worth it. I always get felivery since it's hard to get there and even though I go over my order multiple times to make sure it's right, the order is always messed up. I tried calling about the incorrect order to come up with a solution and instead got yelled at by the manager saying "You still got food didn't you?" I've never been so insulted in my life. All of that over asking for a simple refund of a messed up pasta order for only $8. I've officially given up trying with this location and instead opt to drive to Crystal Lake to pick up. At least there I'm treated with respect. read more

this location lied to us and charged us for what was supposed to be a Free replacement pizza. They messed up an order about a month ago and forgot an ingredient we paid for. When we realized we did not get any sausage, we called them. they agreed that it did not make sense to bring out a pizza right away as we were eating the one they messed up before we realized it was missing the sausage. they offered a free replacement credit on our account. when we went to use that free pizza credit they charged us $10 to use it!!! never heard of such nonsense. just a way for a business to rip off long time customers! read more

Fantastic service with a friendly smile. Ask for a chief on garlic bread its amazing. Have never been dissapointed with service or food quality. read more

Rosati's Pizza - Smallest slice of cheese pizza. 3.50 - Pizza Near Me - McHenry, Illinois

See all

Rosati's in Mchenry came through once again! I had a small family dinner to provide and they made it super easy and super good despite my changing the order on them 3 times! Customer service went above and beyond and Rob even came out to my place of business to check on the details so that they would have everything just the way we wanted it. Folks these are people who care! Food was delicious-5 stars from the whole family! read more

We were craving Italian food for dinner and decided to try Rosati's. The food arrived in good time but there was nothing fresh about it. We ordered the spaghetti and meatballs dinner which came with garlic bread and salad. The salad... whew. Honestly it looked like it came out of a bag. If I had wanted salad from Jewel with a couple of tomatoes tossed in and dressing out of a to-go packet, I could've done that myself at home. Half the greens were bruised and brown. The garlic bread looked like it had been cooked that morning and possibly reheated in the microwave; it felt soggy in the middle and tough and chewy around the edges. Flavor was alright but not enough to make up for the lack of freshness. The spaghetti didn't seem fresh either. What I make myself at home actually tastes better. Maybe it was just old and reheated, like the bread. The sauce was strange in that I could taste something fresh and delicious in it (spices maybe?) but the actual sauce seemed, again, old and reheated. You know when your spaghetti sauce has sat in the fridge and the water starts to separate? That's how it was. Same with the meatballs. It had potential but it just seemed stale. I wish I were exaggerating, but that was my honest experience. read more

Their pastas have been great tasting comfort food for me through a tough time and they've been willing to work with me on changes I've had to make for my health. Thank you it has meant a lot. read more

This place will no longer get my business, they allow their minor staff to be yelled at by manager Jim. Store manager Rob no better by allowing it. Very unprofessional. read more

Today I was feeling like an Italian beef, so I called up Rosati's for a pick-up order. When I got there, the man working told me that they overcooked my sandwich, so he was making a whole new one, because he wanted it to be as tasty as it could be. I really appreciated that they didn't just give me gross, overcooked food! He also gave me $3 off of my order and free pops since I had to wait. Great customer service and very, very nice workers! Also my Italian beef with mozzarella cheese (The Cheef) was suuuuuper super delicious. read more

The food here is decent. But the management is short sighted. Walked in to place my order. Looked at the menu and saw some coupons on the menu, score! Then they say I can't use the coupons because they want them to be used on a future visit! That is seriously low class...here is this thing, it is a cool thing, but you are not allowed to use it. This is my first time with a coupon issue here but I have seen them put up a fight before. They are going to chase away customers over a few dollars. Their food cannot overcome a tacky attitude towards the customer. read more

Extended family was in town and we didn't feel like cooking. What could we get that everyone likes, isn't too expensive and is close to home? Boom. Rosati's. Ordered up baked mostaccioli, baked lasagna, salad, breadsticks and a cheese pizza. Guy on the phone told us to ask about a calendar when we got there for 10% off the order. I show up and do just that and the owner/manager/boss is NOT happy. Apparently this isn't how it works. He's a bit rude, tells me how it's supposed to work, but then apologizes for being rude. Probably just frustrated with his employees for getting it wrong. The fact that he recognized he was being tough made up for it, plus it made me feel like I was in an old timey Italian Chicago hole in the wall. That's right...I kinda liked it. Get home with the goods and my mom says, "Where's the cheese pizza?" They forgot it. Call them back and they drive 10 miles to the house to deliver it without question. So how in the heck does this place get 4 stars after all that? The baked lasagna. WOW. It's...magical. I kept going back for more. My brother-in-law did the same. We both remarked on how good it was. And then it was gone. The rest? Fine. Good and hearty. But the lasagna is something special. Something I'd endure rudeness and a forgotten pizza for. Getting it again when I go back. Yum. read more

Worst pizza in McHenry. If you want quality pizza that isn't a floppy, soggy mess then order from Buddyz or Papa Saverios. Rosati's in McHenry is the worst pizza place in the state. STEER CLEAR! read more

You have got to be friggin kidding me. I waited for 50,minutes from the time I placed an order for lasagna and a rack of ribs. Requested light sauce and have never had so much sauce slopped on ribs before. Last time I ordered ribs you happily charged me for a full rack but sent me home with a half. Called the manager(who didn't want to be bothered talking to me, thanks Rob, very unprofessional) but made sure I knew that he was offended by my complaint. Fine. This will be my last time there(god knows I don't want to offend anyone) but be sure that every review site will hear from me often! read more

I used to order from here at least 2-3 times a month and get my order the same way. But the last time I called the phone girl told me they can't make my order that way I normally get it that way I assured her they have done this numerous times idc if it cost extra she said she can't do it with attitude. There's a ton of pizza places in the area I'll start going to one with better costumer service!!! read more

I ordered catering for my son and daughter-in-law's baby shower, but since it was right around Thanksgiving, I dropped the ball and ordered with short notice. Rob really came through for us! Food was delivered hot and plenty of it! Everyone loved it! Thank you Rosati's !!!!! read more

DO NOT PURCHASE GIFT CARDS: On December 22, 2021, I stopped in the McHenry IL location to purchase a gift card for my brother. I advised front counter employee Joy that it was for my brother in Indiana. Joy stated the cards were only good for the store I purchased them from. I advised Joy that this was not a gift certificate/coupon and a plastic gift card should apply to all Rosati's locations. Joy went in the back room and returned stating the cards are now able to be used at any location. I purchased the card for $25. My brother in Indiana told me his Rosati's in Carmel IN would not accept it. The manager only accepted a 12 digit code and the one I purchased was 16 digits and needed a pin number. My brother even showed him the $25 balance on the Rosati's website. On December 27, I spoke with front counter employee Lisa at the McHenry IL location and explained the above situation. Lisa asked me for my credit card last 4 digits and would have the district manager contact me on December 28. I advised Lisa to just credit back my card the $25 since this has put me in an embarrassing situation with my brother. I did not receive any contact from the district manager, so I called McHenry store back on January 3 and spoke to the store manager Jason. He remembered my gift card issue and asked for all the info on my receipt. He stated he would look into the matter. As of January 6, I have not received any resolution to this issue. Guess I'll purchase a gift card from one of their competitors hassle free after Rosati's credits back my money. read more

we ordered a small Sausage pizza with olives and they gave us s extra cheese pizza with olives. the bread was horrible cut and dry.

Was nothing special. Ordered almost $100 worth of carry out for a party. The crust was plain and given to the dog, the pizza was nothing to rave about and the pasta was 60% sauce .... went in to pick up the order; the parking lot is awfully small and it's at a bad intersection to get in and out from. The building itself it's old and run down. With all the pizza options in town I wouldn't choose this one. read more

Great food. Nice people. Place is always clean. I'm originally from Chicago and this is the closest to city pizza I've had. Beefs are good along with their salads. Would definitely recommend. read more