I stopped by Romeo's on a sunny Saturday afternoon. I also went with the Chicken Finger Sub that James K. raves about in his review. And let me tell you, it is truly rave-worthy. Crispy chicken, super fresh roll, melty cheese, and crisp lettuce all lovingly put together by Mrs. Fotinos, the proprietress. Yum! Their Greek-style pizza is also delicious and I hear wonderful things about their home-made Greek dressing (will definitely have to give it a try next time!). Romeo's has been family run for decades, and it really shows in their friendly customer service and quality of food. Overall, a great place to stop by for lunch or pick up a pizza for dinner. read more

Not much to choose from in this town at 8 pm on a Saturday night. I wanted to give this place a good review, I always want to give good reviews. The staff is very friendly and honest. We paid for our food when we ordered it and when it was ready they reminded us we had already paid. We got two steak bomb sandwiches. They were packed with meat but not much flavor. Unfortunately we took our sandwiches to go and walked about 7 minutes back to our air b n b. As soon as we got inside we opened up our sandwiches and the bread was soaked! Very soggy! I was hungry so I tore off most the bread and ate it anyways. I would give it a 1/10. I don't recommend it at all. We got a Reese's peanut butter cookie too. It was beyond delicious 10/10! I highly recommend them! I wish we would have bought more. I have uploaded some photos, including a menu. I will recommend you try them out as they deserve the business! When we go again we will get a bunch of the cookies and try the pizza and salads out. read more

See all

Ordered food online. Once I waited 40 minutes I went to pick it up. They told me they didn't have my order. Had to call my bank because they took out my money and then I had to order from a different company. Unfortunately this isn't the first issue I've had with them. Over the summer they charged my card twice. read more

Romeo's - Pizza Near Me - Exeter, New Hampshire

See all

An Exeter favorite for many years .. Always a great meal and very reasonable prices..

We stayed at a hotel and the staff there told us to order pizza from this place. The reviews about slow delivery are so true. It was hard to get them on the phone to place an order because the line was busy or it would just hang up. The estimated delivery time was an hour!! The pizza was meh: Buffalo chicken pie and cheese. I really wanted to get a margherita pizza but they didn't have that. I got a text from them apologizing for the delay in delivery but it was delivered an hour and a half after ordering!! They should offer more variety, improve delivery times, and have an online ordering option. read more

I started going to Romeos after my regular place closed 4years ago I WILL.NEVER LEAVE ROMEOS They have wonderful food fast and at a good price The Owners and staff work so hard there but always have time to say Hi I eat there 3 times a week Shane the delivery guy is awesome Definitely check Romeos out!! read more

The small Turkey sub is giant for $10, delicious as well!! They were fast and friendly too. read more

Romeo's - Small Turkey Steak Sub with 3 Toppings - Pizza Near Me - Exeter, New Hampshire

This is our favorite place to grab a quick bite to eat for the evening. Always have great service. The food is consistent. We love this place. Definitely recommend. read more

Excellent service, huge servings, amazing food, great prices! Their American Chop Suey is absolutely delicious....the BEST home made meat sauce! You can tell at first bite that this really IS home made! Their home made pita bread is to die for and their home made house dressing is fantastic! read more

Another disappointment. Ordered a Greek salad w a 6-peice Broaster Chicken. What did I get?? 4 legs (which I hate). 2 wings (better) and 1 undercooked breast. Ridiculous and a total rip off. read more

Listen, if your problems are delivery is late and the food is cold on arrival, welcome to today in food service. This is the best place closest to downtown to get commodity pizza, subs, and the other usuals. Everything I've had was completely satisfactory. The best sub anywhere near here is in Gloucester (Virgilio's,) in my experience. If you're in Exeter, the drive to Romeo's is a way better time/value choice than Cape Ann. read more

I really enjoyed the pizza. It was good and hit the spot. The wing dings were fun and the buffalo ones had a lot of sauce on them. Next time I'd get the regular ones to try. Ummm the baklava? Sooooooo good! Idk where they get it from but it's really good. Nice service and clean, welcoming place. I definitely recommend! read more

Great subs!! The people are very nice and I like that you can sit down and eat right away. Brings back old me worries of the sub shops 20+ years ago !! read more

This place has gone downhill since it was sold. It used to be a steady go to for subs and pizza, and even loved Maria's manicotti .... after the sale, it was ok and we figured they just needed to get their bearings ... we expected some changes because of course the new owners need to make it their own ... the little metal grates in the bottom of the pizza boxes were a nice touch to keep crust from getting soggy and add a bit of extra warmth on the take-out/delivery .... but both the pizza and subs have gone steadily downhill .... tonight's delivery was abysmal ... stuff was hot enough but pizza was far too doughy and not flavorful ... and the meatball sub was not even meatballs ... it was loose ground meat, very little cheese, and it was burnt ... my daughter threw it away .... Done ... totally done ... no more read more

We have not ordered from here for years We did tonight Food was really good! Romeo's is now added to our rotation

Excellent pizza, once it arrived, but dining out is SO MUCH more than the food. While we may order from there as takeout in the future, we will never eat there again. The ambience is dated, dirty, and off-putting. Last decorated in the 1970's, I'm guessing. One table was occupied when we arrived; every other table was unclean. We had to request cleaning. We ordered a pizza and a Greek salad. The salad was inexplicably slow to arrive, and eventually was delivered with the pizza. It was a nice-ish salad: cold and crisp, with too-thick creamy dressing, and fully iceberg lettuce( no green color, at all). The pizza was very fresh & hot, and what I think of as a thicker-crusted Greek-American pizza. Weird experience with almost confusion/chaos behind the counter. Never again. read more

Greek pizza with no grease. What in the hell? Love the pizza. Give them a try. Service is good and timely. I highly recommend.

The food is always fresh and delicious! The staff is all very friendly and helpful. I have never had a complaint about Romeo's. The only thing that has happened before that others may complain about is they forgot a side of hot peppers once. But that isn't a big deal at all and they fixed it by giving us the hots that got left behind. So like I said this place is great! Also their pita bread is absolutely amazing! Best I've had around NH at least. read more

I remove 1st review & take it back. The new owner is awesome, cares about the customer & they're attentive. Awreome steak tip sandwiches, lasagna, & Greek salads. All good!! read more

I think Romeos is under new ownership. For years I looked forward to their delicious meat pie. A few weeks ago, I had it and it was horrible. I tried it again last night, thinking the last batch was just a fluke. It wasn't. Both times it was horrible. 1st time, shame on you. 2nd time, shame on me. Sorry, but you lost my business. read more

Might be the worst pizza I have ever had. Cold, soggy, sad and clinging to life, do not revive.

This is the best pizza around - a classic pizza just like I remember from being a kid and watching Home Alone 2 when he opens the steamy cheese pizza. Absolutely delicious, affordable and great cold too! read more

Amazing salads with the freshest ingredients. I ordered the Greek chicken kabob and it came with homemade Greek dressing and a huge fluffy pita bread. Seriously best take out salad I've had anywhere in this area. My friend had the fruity spinach salad and loved hers too. read more

I'm usually not a huge pizza person but I swear this is the best pizza I have ever eaten. The crust was perfect. Thick with just enough crispy on the bottom. Plenty amount of ingredients and TASTY!! read more

Purchased 4 sandwiches today New Years Eve afternoon. The Steak sub and Italian were fine but the was hardly any sauce on the meatball and the chicken parmigiana. Meatballs very dry with no sauce, very disappointed. Pizza is the past has been good. Dry sandwiches was a surprise. read more

I have gone to Romeo's for about 30 years for their steak bomb, it was one of the best in the county, with quality melted cheese on the steak. Last night I had one made by the new owners. It was a cold piece of un-melted poor quality cheese on the bottom of the roll. There were almost no pepper and onions. That will be the last time I go there. read more

I like Romeo's and will go there again, although last 5 times I went there my bread was water logged the worst thing I hate in my sub is have a wet sub it's been so bad that the sub is falling through the bottom of the bag because it is so wet just needs to be fixed I'll give it one more chance read more

This isn't something that I normally do. Honestly, I've never left a review online for any food I've ever eaten. I went into this place on December 22nd 2020 and ordered a large cheese and a large pepperoni pizza and I have to say, that without a doubt, this place made the worst pizza I've ever tasted. I could have made a cardboard cutout of a pizza and it would have tasted the same as what I ate that night. I wanted to call them so bad and complain and tell them I wanted my money back because the pizza was that bad. The crust was horrible and the pizza had absolutely no taste whatsoever. This place was a one and done for me. read more

We stopped in for a slice because our train was late. As we where waiting the train arrived. We had to run to park and grab our luggage. As we were about to get on the train the employee had our pizza for us. He went above and beyond. Thanks Romeos. read more

This is the home of the Greatest Chicken Finger Sub. I get cravings for them regularly and wish I was closer to Exeter, or my matter transporter wasn't on the fritz. read more

I was doing a pick up from this restaurant. Upon arrival I let them know I was there to pick up the order but it wasn't ready. I decided I'd use the restroom while I waited but I walked into the bathroom and left it as fast as I could. It screamed unsanitary - there was urine on the toilet and on the floor in front of the toilet. There was no hand soap or paper towels. As a matter of fact, there was NO hand sanitizer, and there was none to be found any where inside the restaurant either. When I walked out of the bathroom I spotted some sanitizer surface wipes. The container was almost empty and the wipes that were in it were dry. Thankfully I happen to wait across the restaurant near the front windows and I found another container of surface wipes, which I did successfully use to clean my hands, even if they weren't meant to be used for my hands. I needed something! Anything to feel clean after touching those bathroom door handles. I was handed a piping hot plate of food in a brown paper bag. By the time I got to the delivery about 5 min later, the brown paper bag had gotten so hot, the moisture it created started to rip the bag. I delivered an extremely unflattering meal to a customer who I'm sure was not happy, and my hands were scalding from handling the meal order. This place has more issues than any other place I've experienced but esp with covid regulations not in place besides social distance, I would strongly not recommend eating from this place. read more

Dropped in for a slice and all they had was veggie. As one of previous reviewers mentioned, the staff was very nice, however, it was the worst pizza I've ever had. I can only hope their regular pizza is better but I won't be going back to find out. read more

New resident to the area and stumbled upon Romeo's....Great subs and salads!!! I haven't tried the pizza yet but both the Meatball and Italian subs were AWESOME and the salads were full of fresh veggies (and warm chicken). Have been back a few times and told all out neighbors about them! read more

Food is SOOOOOO BAD. and the people are weird. Also the restaurant smells like old food.

The Chicken Finger Sub is legendary. Been going here since I was a student at Phillips Exeter years ago, and every time I'm in town I stop by. This is an Exeter staple, and as far as I know, this is always either the meet-up location or the first lunch stop for PEA students upon returning for reunions, random meet-ups, just-passing-throughs, or when they're just in the mood to reminisce. Go here! Get the Chicken Finger Sub. #RCFS read more

I've been coming here for 25 years. The pizza is thicker crust than I care for. They excel on subs. The salads are healthy and dressing taste homemade. It is a simple, basic place where we get take out or where I used to take my son after an athletic event. The prices are very reasonable. The owners are usually close by and are easy to chat with. They are an Exeter institution. read more

Really really wanted some good buff chicken pizza. Thought this might be the place but it was not. I ordered a large fry and a small buff Chicken pizza. The French frys were amazing great but the pizza that's another story. The crust was like card board the cheese was like rubber and the chicken was like plastic. read more

LARGE COMBO PIE OR DIE. Jeezuz H Christ is it GREAT. All the time customer, never sick. Thank you.

I go to Romeo's Pizza and Sub Shop very often (almost daily). I love the ham and cheese sub made by Olga, the meatball sub, the new corn chowder, the many pizza variations, and the Greek salad. Also, the family owners: Peter and Olga are two of the nicest people I have met and they are very good to their part-time employees: Chelsea, Alex, Erin, Dylan, and Sarah, etc. Peter and I talk about the Greek economy (I am an economist) and both Peter and Olga teach me some Greek sayings. In general, it is a relaxed, wholesome, and often fun atmosphere. It is a very clean pizza place with many booths. Peter and Olga work so hard and so many hours that I suggest that Wikipedia put their photos under the word "work" ! Yasou [transliterated from Greek] ! read more

My family loves it here. Big portions, great customer service, and reasonable prices. Romeo's has the best salads in town, only place that offers spinach salads....love them!! Only place in town that delivers crunchy fries!! Not my favorite pizza in town, but mostly because I don't like the thicker crust. read more