Located in the Eliot Commons Plaza (next to Shipyard Brew Pub), Sabina's Pizzeria (former Pizza Market) is a small family owned pizza place serving up hand made pizzas (12"-14"-16"-20" pies), subs, wraps, burgers, hot dogs, salads, appetizers, pasta dinners, and desserts (cake slices, whoopee pies, Ben & Jerry's pints). Coke products, energy drinks, and beer in the coolers. The place is order at the counter and there are a few tables in the small dining area. They also offer delivery to Eliot and Kittery and deliver beer too! I recently stopped in at Sabina's and ordered a Small 12" House Special Pizza ($14.99 plus tax) to go. The pizza was ready in about 20 minutes as promised. The pizza had plenty of fresh vegetables (mushrooms, tomato slices, green peppers, onions), sliced Italian sausage, Canadian bacon, & pepperoni, tomato sauce, cheese on top of a soft firm thin crust, not too thick on the edges. The pizza tasted pretty good and not too greasy from the toppings. read more

This place is cheap but that's about it. We each had a slice then the rest went uneaten - the tomato sauce had been on the stove fat too long and ate like tomato paste. The crust lacked freshness and a good snap. The cheese was - meh. read more

Sabinas Pizzeria - Large cheese - Pizza Near Me - Eliot, Maine

This place is so bad I'm not even going to take the time to write a lengthy review. "Steak" and cheese sandwich was so low effort I'm pissed and tasted like dog food. If you're not even going to try and hate it that much, get out of the business. read more

The service is completely lacking, absolute rudeness. The food wasn't much better. I went in to grab takeaway and wish I hadn't bothered.

Pizzas are good size and tasty. Crust is thin which for us is great! If you use coupons make sure your total is correct before the delivery person shows up. read more

I ordered a turkey club (turkey, bacon, cheese) and when I got home it was clear I was given ham, almost raw bacon, and no cheese. It also tasted like something was bad. I called and was told that in order to get a refund I had to drive it back to them. Their bread is decent. read more

Sabrina's is a rare treat for my family. We travel a lot around New England and they hands down have some of the best food. Their buffalo chicken pizza is our go to, but their chicken fingers are awesome! We have made it a tradition to stop by before we go to Sandy Hill farm. The staff has always been very kind us as well! read more

Sabinas Pizzeria - two people with emoticions on their faces - Pizza Near Me - Eliot, Maine

I'm just going to start by saying this was the worst food / service I've ever received . Me and some friends ordered 2 pizzas and two salads which cost $63 . OUTRAGEOUS, the salad was pink which indicates toxic lettuce . The dressing was expired . And the pizza was burnt to a crisp and flavorless . Me and all my friends ended up with serious food poising . One friend had to go to the hospital due to the throwing up. When I called to let them know whoever I spoke to ( which I never got a name) was very unpleasant and rude . Saying we couldn't get our money back. I will post photos . Don't eat here. read more

See all

We've been getting pizza here for years. And for years it has been good basic pizza. But when the pizza market was sold to what eventually became Sabina's things improved (except for the decor) for a while. Then things slowly declined. The house special we got for years wasn't the same any more. I'm open to change but not for the worst. And now it's about 50/50 it's good or bad. Inconsistency will kill a business and that is why we only order here once a month. Last night's pizza was a "0". Even my teenager bitched about it and they usually never bitch about plain cheese pizza! This time it was too much sauce and soggy. I hope the September pizza rocks! Wishing...... Update: it's Almost September and last night I ordered a buffalo chicken pizza that was awesome! So I raised my review to 4 stars. Lets see if they can do it twice.... read more

See all

Pretty good place, but I haven't tried anything but the pizza... NY style, thin, crispy, huge slices, good place for grabbing a slice at lunch. People that run the place are awesome as well, good customer service. read more

Overall a great spot! Me and my family usually order the wings or steak and cheese and never get tired of them. The food definitely keeps you coming back for more and is very good. The pizza in my opinion could use more sauce and better cheese. Other than that great spot would recommend! read more

Iam new to Eliot . I tried the pizza here came burnt not good flavor and cost $24.50 for a 14" 3 way plus tip.ill be going somewhere else from now on. read more

The pizza here is quite lack-luster in my book. I am normally a fan of flatter than usual crust, and the large pizza -- to its credit -- is rather huge; but what they out do themselves with in size does not equal taste. The pizza made by this place is rather lifeless. The toppings are decently portioned to the pizza, but the sauce adds no punch whatsoever. The pricing isn't spectacular either. Certainly higher than I would expect a carb-indulging, sin shop to charge for their pies. Not particularly worth the drive, by heaven help me they are only a few miles away from Kittery, and sometimes you need a change of pace. read more

I didn't eat here, and probably never will but I did stop in to pick up lunch for a customer. Not only was the young lady behind the counter unpleasant, she also thought the cash tip I left her wasn't enough and decided to add another $6 for herself on to my credit card. I remember writing the total of the bill on the line above my signature but she must have gone and changed that as well. Maybe if she was more friendly I would have given her a better tip. Customer service goes a long way, babydoll. It was also hot as hell and smelly in there. read more

This restaurant does not require masks for their cooks or for their delivery workers. Do not order food from this place because they do not care about the safety of their workers or their customers. If there was a zero star preference, I would give them zero stars. read more

Overpriced and tasteless. Also they gave me horrible food poisoning and they wouldn't refund me. Never order from here!

I love everything here, I use to swear by Amatos, no longer...Sabinas has them beat!! There subs are fresh always... if there is something you don't want on your sub or pizza just let them know. read more

The best ever I ordered very specific things about my food wverything was flawless recomended to anyone in this part of maine prices were great delivery was fast very friendly cant wait to order again 5 stars read more

Having just moved to Eliot from Brooklyn, of all places, I was expecting to have to give up on pizza...but Pizza Market proved me wrong! It's not much to look at, and unfortunately they don't deliver, but the pizza is not bad. read more

My family and I love the extra large cheese for $9.99! You gotta ask for it by name as this price is not on the menu.

I am not a fan of the large but highly processed pizza but I would recommed the steak and cheese sub. Very good bread and again large portions of steak. A small is a typical pizza joints large. read more

Horrible service if I could give no stars I would. I ordered from there and payed with my card, never was delivered, never was called and never was refunded. When I called the manager was rude, short, and extremely unprofessional... she ended up hanging up on me. I used to recommend them but never will again. read more

It's ok. It's by no means the best pizza around but its not bad either if you're in the area. The texture and portions are pretty good but the flavor didn't wow me. Went on a Saturday and the service was fine, just didn't blow me away like I want from really good pizza. Pepperoni was good, the cheese was lacking but passable. Would recommend if you're not picky. read more

I am sad to say after ordering 2 pizza's during the holidays instead of eating leftover turkey my family decided to give Sabina's a try. The pizza was tasteless and well as darn right horrible. I feel terrible giving someone one star, but the price and taste was ridiculous. Going back to our favorite place in Dover. read more

Great pizza, subs and the dirty hippie fries are fantastic! We order from here several times a week and pizza every Saturday. Always greeted with great customer service! read more

Another great pizza place in the area. Located in a small mall in Eliot, they have some of the best pizza around. Similar to Joe's, but much better. Fresh ingredients, great crust, perfectly cooked, or at least the way I like it. Had a feta and spinach pizza the other night that was the best I've ever ordered. Stick with the pizza, some of the other side dishes have been disappointing. read more

WEll I fnally gave it a try....sorry I did... Dirty Carpet and floors greet you...and I mean dirty...Dark dingy...overpriced...Small peperoni pizza 14 bux...was not good tasted awful...there are lots of good pizza spots around here this isn't one of them...pass it by.... read more

I consider myself a pizza lover and coming from NYC, I've had a lot of excellent pizza in my day. When my wife and I moved to the area one of the things I was most worried about was the food, and the pizza specifically. We were pleasantly surprised when we found Pizza Market. It is not quite like NYC pizza, but excellent in it's own right. It has this incredibly fresh taste that I really enjoy. The sauce is great, not too sweet, and the crust is good - I do wish it was a bit more crispy, but whenever we order a pie I always do a quick reheat in the toaster to give it that crunch, I find this helps a lot. I much prefer Pizza Market to other local pizza I've tasted i.e. Joe's New York (yeah right!), Flatbread, Salvario's (sp?), Papa Gino's (I do like their 'Rustic' pizza), etc. Also, the store itself has this traditional feel and the owners are super nice. Definitely the best pizza in the area in my opinion. read more

They delivered pizza and salad and wings to my house which was out of the way for them. The pizza was amazing, the wings were the most tender wings I have ever had out in a restaurant/pizza place. The salad was to die for. I couldn't have had a better meal. I tried to call to let them know but I called too late and they were closed. So kudos to Sabina's. Amazing food. Try them. read more

my boyfriend and i went in here after a disappointing menu for vegetarians next door at the Shipyard pub. They were advertising falafels outside (not sure if it is a regular thing or not), and we decided to try it out. After learning that the owners were from Lebanon, we were sure we would love the authenticity of the falafel - and we were right. crispy falafels piled with as much veggies as you want with a tangy tzatziki sauce rolled in a pita. was delicious and a huge portion for the price we paid. we will definitely be back to try more. read more

Great little pizza place!! Stopped on way back from beach and had a turkey club sub - loaded tons of meat and plenty of bacon and vegs. Love the old school feel to the place - reminds me of my youth - needs a jute box in the corner :) and it would be perfect!! read more