I was trying to find a decent priced pizza for my family. The place needed to be clean, reasonable and pizza needed to be crispy and fresh. I ordered a large house special and a small cheese for my picky twin who eats like a bird. The pizzas came out (15 min) the were crispy , evenly baked, toppings were very good except the hamburger was a little over cooked. Overall a great meal at a good price and I don't have to worry about dirty hands and flies everywhere. I know that sounds odd but the last 2 places we tried there were dirty floors flies and the pizzas came was burnt partially. I'll try these guys again, maybe on an evening. read more

See all

Great little pizza spot. They have pizza by the slice or whole pies. We had pepperoni by the slice and loved it. Service was nice and fast. Glad we stopped in today. Oh, and they have Dr. Pepper!!! read more

Badger's Island Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Kittery, Maine

I had a craving for an Italian meatball sub so ordered one to pick up a couple nights ago. I picked it up and brought it home. It looked great as expected. I was unpleasantly surprised that it was just luke warm. I bit into it and was so taken aback from it's flavor. It had the strangest weird flavor I have ever experienced when having a meatball or eggplant sub. It was a powerful flavor that made it so unappealing. I figured out it was Cinnamon and a whole lot of cinnamon. I thought I was eating pastry with meatballs. Terrible! I called and spoke to owner or manager and He explained that he had new younger cooks in training. He said sorry about that.. That is fine but he could have offered to replace it with a normal flavored one that too much cinnamon was dumped into. I paid for a threw out a sub that I'd be embarrassed to serve. A professional establishment would have offered to replace the one they messed up. I will be going elsewhere from now on. read more

We now make this our Friday night dinner weekly. We aren't alone because the place is jumping but they move fast. We call in our pizza and salad and Zoila , when we arrive it comes out. Delicious. The salads are why I am posting. The Greek salad is fantastic. I use my own dressing at home but I get TWO DAYS from the salads and they have a mix of lettuce that makes me so happy. Not a plain iceberg. They don't cheep on ingredients and IT SHOWS! Keep up the great work Badgers, we CARE. read more

Badger's Island Pizza - My second day of my salad. I had a Greek salad and ate a full plate two days in a row. The lettuce is mixed baby greens and so appreciated. - Pizza Near Me - Kittery, Maine

I love their calzones and corn nuggets!!! My go to when I can think of what to eat/cook for dinner.

SO good. Staff is always super friendly. Small cheese or pepperoni pizza with a Greek salad is my go to. I mean... it's pizza on an island in Maine haha what more could you ask for! read more

Waited 20 minutes while my order just sat there getting cold before they noticed it was ready.

I know this will sound odd being that they are a pizza shop. But we just had THE BEST FRENCH FRIES!!. I have not tried their puzza yet, but if you are ever in the mood for a snack, you have got to try these fries. They are coated, cooked to order. Absolutely a notch above most fries in the area. read more

Never had a single bad experience here, their food is the perfect casual pizza place fare. If you like the Greek-influened olive oil-heavy style of pizza you tend to get in northern New England, this is definitely a place you'll want to check out. Best chicken parm sub in the area for my money, and the staff are always cool; I make a point to swing by any time I'm in the area. read more

The food is good, but not being able to do an online order for pickup????. SMH!!!!~ I called over 50 times and kept getting a message: "Your call cannot be completed as dialed as the called party is busy." Seriously? IT"S 2025!!!! read more

Really good food and the staff are amazing. They are efficient but always friendly! The pepperoni pizza is super salty, just the way I like it! read more

In Kittery - hands down best pizza! Unique options, Hugh quality - worth it! Friendly staff as well - highly recommend

Badger's Island Pizzeria makes decent pizza and it's a cute little place. The slices seemed a little small but the fact that you can order pizza by the slice is a big plus. Toppings are fresh & my guess is that all slices start off as cheese pizza and are then made to order with whatever topping you want. My wife thought they skimped on the sauce but I didn't notice. One of the cool things about this pizzeria is the location. They're across the street from Hebert Brothers, which is one of the best local spots to pick up some seafood. Although I wasn't blown away by the pizza, it's hard to seriously judge the place based on a couple of reheated slices so I'll be back. Maybe next time I'll go for a chicken parm sub or some linguini with meatballs. And they're open for breakfast. Until 11AM, you can get the usual omelets, pancakes, french toast, etc. If you're hungry while traveling between Portsmouth and the Kittery outlet malls, you'll probably get the best deal at Badger's Island Pizza. read more

Badger's Island Pizza - the front of the restaurant - Pizza Near Me - Kittery, Maine

Well, finally a great cheese steak pizza... loaded with steak not sprinkled on. Cheese and mushroom added to enhance this delicious pie. Delivery was quick and friendly. Will be back soon! read more

Badger's Island Pizza - 1/2 inch of steak!!!! - Pizza Near Me - Kittery, Maine

See all

We stopped in after a walk across the bridge. We had the pizza which was really good. It's more of a Greek style pizza. Nice and spicy with just enough oil on it. Cheese was very good as well as was the dough. Price was reasonable. Would go back for sure! read more

Website not updated and rude person on the phone at 7:25 PM. No delivery and only pickup for winter hours. Is the pandemic not Winter hours every day. They don't care. Shop Local somewhere else. read more

I just called there to place an order for mozzarella sticks the way to answer the phone very upset and angrily said the grill is off we close in 20 minutes can I still help you..... covid or no Covid you don't ever answer a phone like that way to run a business people!!!! read more

The pizza is really, really good. They are not skimpy with the topping add-ons, either. However we order delivery from them frequently and something seems to be wrong every time. Last time we ordered a steak bomb..it was literally a soggy sub roll with JUST steak..no other toppings. They kindly offered to bring a new one, or to give us a 1/2 credit for the item (ehh). We ended up calling for take out the following evening, and they gave us a different dinner order for free instead. Hence the 4 stars for customer service. I would not recommend anything besides the pizza at Badgers island. We have tried various dinner choices there and they have always been sub-par. read more

Excellent pizza can't wait to come here again. So much cheese and so tasty. Restaurant is kinda on the small side though. read more

Badger's Island Pizza - the outside of the restaurant - Pizza Near Me - Kittery, Maine

This place has it all (including lobster rolls)! Calzones are filled with a ton of meat and cheese. The salads are made fresh with grilled chicken. The sandwiches and wraps are a great choice for lunch. The only downside of Badger's Island Pizza is the fact that they don't have desserts. You would think with a menu as diverse as theirs, they would at least have cookies or brownies. Delivery is pretty fast and the staff is always friendly. Hopefully, one day in the near future they will have desserts! read more

Badger's Island Pizza - Chicken Caesar salad - Pizza Near Me - Kittery, Maine

Lobstah Roll. Looking for a quick lunch & saw their sandwich board outside while on an impromtu sightseeing jaunt Monday (4/29). Not expecting much for $6.75 but was totally & pleasantly surprised. First, the place had a good lunch crowd, esp. considering how bridge construction's turned their location into a cul-de-sac. But friendly if curious looks from the faces of the locals on break kept me company while I waited a few minutes for my order. (What, is he out catching the lobstah himself?) No. Making up a nicely sized side of fresh battered fries (enough to feel like I ate something, but not to fill me up but not too much to enjoy the roll) I wasn't expecting for the price. The lobster was sweet, fresh, & enough, garnished w/iceberg & chopped tomatoes. Don't have a lot of grounds for comparison, but this really, really hit the spot, and after city felt like a fantastic deal, too. read more

This place serves delicious meat lover pizza and it is so much better than Joe's greasy NY pizza for sure. Nice beer selection. The GM, Kellie, even greeted us with smile as we dined in close to 10:30. If you are looking for inexpensive, mouth watering pizza, you definitely should check this place out. Don't forget to ask Kellie about her Ninja name. read more

Small location close to the memorial bridge and downtown Portsmouth. Staff was managing a large amount of to-go's when I arrived but greeted me quickly and took my order. Although it took some time to get my food out the staff was appologetic and made me feel welcome. If youre there at the right time there may even be some free samples to be had! Parking is limited but walk from down town and see the river front! read more

I love the pizza here! Always fresh, always correct, always delicious! The service is always good, and fast. Prices are fair. My favorite pizza place in the area. Hands down. read more

Fast, friendly and pretty darned good pizza. Surprised by some of the whining reviews though..... especially by locals...... too bad.

The delivery people are real nice but I have to say something about my orders being messed up every other time. I don't usually complain but I got bacon in my calzone that was not edible.They even admitted it and said they replaced it with good bacon.That's fine but you would think they would offer to make it right but all I got was a "sorry about that". I figured I'd give them another chance and got american cheese on my chicken parm. Who does that? It was way better when Peter owned it. Anyway I'm going elsewhere. read more

I don't normally ever leave reviews but I felt it necessary to. I normally buy from this place every week if not more. I normally don't have issues. It was much better when the Greeks owned it but my kids still enjoy it so we go here. Tonight we ordered food to go so we could head over to the play in the park- we ordered 2 pizzas, a sub, garlic bread and a Greek Salad- No onions as I am highly allergic and will go into anaphylactic shock. A friend of mine waited while we left to go get seats at the park. When we sorted all the food my salad had onions under neath the purple cabbage which I could not eat due to my allergy--- and the loaded steak and cheese sub (onions and peppers for him) had nothing on it but steak and a little cheese- my garlic bread which I asked for cheese on came soaked in garlic oil and No cheese. The pizzas were fine. When I called and asked for the manager Kellie Huddleston, she was extremely rude, in a condescending manner asked me what I wanted her to do about it. I said just credit the sub as I will not be returning to the establishment because of her rude response and tone with me. She said great that's fine and then proceeded to harass me and go as far as saying I lived on 6 Cutts road and threw onion rings at her driver. First off everyone in Kittery who knows me or my family knows I've never lived on cutts road-just to belittle a person like that and be so condescending when I could have ended up in the hospital for your mistake had I eaten it; then I can assure you - you would not have gotten a phone call or Yelp review- it would have been a phone call from my attorney. Anyone who wants to be respected and not degraded and to find a nice little pizza joint DO NOT WASTE YOUR TIME OR MONEY HERE! read more

Ugh .. I used to work here in the late 80's not the same owners and no where near good. Had to give phone order several times to make sure it was right. Not that hard ugh!! Food so mediocre. Pizza over cooked and skimpy on sauce. Sandwiches large but skimpy on everything. Disappointing. Sorry read more

Awful! Food not fit for my dog. Incompetent staff and operation. Better off going hungry. Surprised they are even in business. So many other better choices. read more

Calzone's are very good. They really do take up half a pizza pan. I've had their pizza many times, which is good, but this was the first time I tried a calzone. I recommend the meat calzone. Price for small calzone was $9 but I got 2 meals from it. read more

Badger's Island Pizza - Calzone is HUGE! This is the meat calzone. - Pizza Near Me - Kittery, Maine

You're general good pricing and tasty pizza joint. Their pizzas are not very greasy and there is good flavor in what they make. I can only speak for the pizza but they're worth a go. Buffalo chicken is the best style around compared to other pizza joints. read more

Pick up process was extremely disorganized. By the time the kid figured out which order was mine the pizza was ice cold. Very disappointed. Everyone in line had no idea what the process was. read more

We have been faithful customers since we moved back 4 years ago. However, the last few times we have noticed that they have been using a different crust. It is not as good as it used to be. We are going to start looking for different pizza places. read more

Working nearby, we sometimes come here for lunch. The food is good, made fresh, and is fast. It's a little pricier than some other places you will find nearby, but the portions are substantial. Warning: the large calzone can feed 3-4 people! Very friendly staff, and the regulars are entertaining! read more

Good food. Substantial portions for the price. Wife got a "small" calzone that took up half of a large pizza pan. I got the lasagna, which was a bit different than normal lasagna. They used thick fettucinni noodles rather than the large lasagna noodles. The guy whom I presume was the owner was very concerned that everything was good and offered plenty of extra sauces for my wife's calzone. Good service, old pizza place atmosphere, and good food. read more

Best pizza within 50 miles of the Maine/New Hampshire border. Bonus is they serve beer/wine and have lobster rolls!

Stop in for the excellent bargain 'lobsta' roll. Return for the pizza. These guys are a bit strange but GOOD.

Super friendly service and no frills, satisfying pizza. A nice, relaible pizza place to keep in your back pocket.

Its your typical house of pizza, parking can be tough, Quality has been slipping last few times I have been my items have been put together real sloppy (think McDonalds when they are busy). The pizza crust has changed and I am not impressed. I feel they are just milking the place and don't care. They do sell pizza by the slice which is convenient. read more

OWNER IS RUDE! Food was gross!! I ordered a chicken parm sub toasted w/extra cheese. When it finally arrived over an hour later, it was soggy & had a wad of melted cheese at the bottom....totally gross. I called to ask for a refund of my $16 (including tip & a salad) & the person who answered kept talking over me & wouldn't really listen to what I had to say. They called to owner to ask about the refund. He called me back & w/a stern voice told me that I told his employee to shut up(I did not) & that he wasn't going to "allow a customer to speak to his employee like that". He wouldn't listen to my side of the story, refused to refund me & told me never to order from his store again! Who does that? Such horrible customer service & yucky food! read more

See all