Can't believe I haven't reviewed this place yet! I think we've been here 3 times now, and it will be a staple every time we're in York. Great pizza, a variety of flavor options. Very nice staff. A good variety of drink options, too. Reminds me a little of the local pizza parlor I went to as a kid. read more

York 54 - Meat lover's - Pizza Near Me - York, Maine

Amazing bake on their pie. We ordered the special- it was light on the protein, skimpy. Only minutes from Anchorage Inn. But will go back again for sure. Great flavor profiles on dough, sauce and toppers- semolina grain on the crust- yum, we really enjoyed. read more

York 54 - Sm. Brisket daily special pie (July '26) - Pizza Near Me - York, Maine

pizza yum delish henry is great service perfecto best pizza in york, best pizza in maine. go now

Best pizza in York! My parents live there so I visit at least once a year. I have tried other places but this is the best. Great service, reasonable price for the beach and a quality product. It is not like being in NYC, but now one else does it like this in York. read more

We ordered a large pepperoni and mushroom pizza with three salads. The salads had a lot of ingredients and a great dressing. The pizza had about eight slices and was a decent pizza for the area. read more

York 54 - Pizza Near Me - York, Maine

We had a cheese pizza and a pepperoni/bacon pizza. Both were absolutely delicious. The service was great. Cashier was friendly and helpful as we were clearly new. I heard him talk to several regulars as we sat and ate. About a dozen indoor and a dozen outdoor seats. A few local canned alcohol options, canned THC options, as well all multiple canned sodas and a couple other drinks. Also had gelato, custard, and ice cream although we didn't try it. Prices seemed a little expensive, but not outrageous. Highly recommend. read more

York 54 - 1/2 16" cheese and 1/2 12" pepperoni/bacon pizza - Pizza Near Me - York, Maine

This place is a small pizza/sub shop that also serves ice cream. We ate in. We had the hard cider bbq pizza and a chicken bacon ranch quesadilla with a couple cans of local beer. Everything was very good, large portions so we were able to bring the leftovers home. Lots of fun looking items on the menu. We will definitely be back for takeout. read more

Great place to grab a pizza in a pinch. We were hungry but not looking for anything crazy. Glad we found this pizza joint. We dined in but seemed like the majority of orders were to go. read more

Excellent pizza and worth a stop if shopping at kittery or coming up i95. Call ahead as it is cooked to order! Gluten free pizza uses a cheese like crust and is very good. Very fresh ingredients. Staff friendliness so so and they will turn away customers if close to closing time. Order out mainly just a few tables inside so not much ambiance. Ice cream/gelato available read more

York 54 - Feta, walnut and beet salad - Pizza Near Me - York, Maine

See all

It's... fine. Better places to eat. Garlic bread was not what i expected and would not have again. Pizza is fine, but definitely better fish in the sea. read more

The service was casual wasn't sure to sit or order at the register. There's like 4 little tables to sit at inside. And the pizza was very delicious and the Brie was so creamy and delicious. read more

York 54 - Tomato soup - Pizza Near Me - York, Maine

See all

I get my pizza at only 2 places here and Revolution Tap room in Rochester, NH. This is the best though. Artisan pizza. Friendly staff, go the extra mile for you. I enjoy walking in and talking to the employees, they are friendly and kind. Of Course, the pizza ROCKS! read more

Best pizza by far in the coastal Maine/NH area. Really, really good! The white pizza with caramelized onions is perfection. The puttanesca is bold and salty and wonderful, if you're into strong flavors. Glad they're here. read more

I'm Still on my search for NY style pizza. After reading most of the plethora of positive reviews mentioning pizza & thin crust, I had high hopes. When I first try out a pizza place new to me, I keep it simple, small plain cheese pizza. I called ahead to order. It sounded very busy as I waited for the woman to return to the phone. That, I thought, was a good sign. The pizza was ready 10 minutes sooner than they'd estimated which was nice. I immediately took a picture of the beautiful Looking pie. Aside from some visible burn marks on part of the pizza, the presentation was wonderful! It looked like it'd taste great. I could tell before the first bite that this is not NY style pizza but rather a version of Greek pizza, with the narrow, very crispy crust. As soon as I bit down for the first time I was sorely disappointed. It was like accidentally biting into a piece of decorative fruit by accident, jarring. I'd hoped that the lack of flavor had something to do with it being piping hot. I waited but much to my dismay there was zero flavor except the overwhelming kick of burned bread. I don't normally bring/send food back but I knew that I'd otherwise have to throw away the entire $15 small pizza so I asked them to make me a new one. The lady was very gracious as I apologized for my request & she even offered to bring my new pizza out to my car when it was done. The second pizza was finished right away and it was brought to me in my car. It looks like it's cooked well done this time but not burned this time. The flavor was still absent. If I eat the leftovers, I'll have to add a lot of salt, pepper and grated cheese to make it worth it. read more

See all

We found this place on the Yelp app. It's a small place with four or five tables. Mostly a take out place. We ordered a bacon and hamburg pizza which was loaded with toppings. The DO NOT skimp! Lots of flavor. The dough is terrific and not much of a flop. Under carriage was nice. Got an order of garlic bread which was large and tasty! Maybe the best topping pizza on the seacoast! You guys do a great job! Be back soon. read more

York 54 - Bacon and burger pizza! - Pizza Near Me - York, Maine

Stopped back this year, for sandwiches and salads for lunch. The Caesar Padini was fantastic, as was the regular Caesar side salad. The hot Italian on flatbread was out of this world good as well.. Another year, another great visit. read more

York 54 - Hot Italian - Pizza Near Me - York, Maine

This place is small and the pizza oven made it warm on a summer day but the food is AMAZING! My husband and I both got sandwiches and they were delicious! We can't wait to go back and try other sandwiches and the pizza. The service was nice and the beer was cold. We will definitely be back! We went back a second time and had two personal pizzas and garlic cheese bread. My husband and I both loved our pizzas and the personal size is a good value for the cost. I had the white pizza bacon feta and asparagus so unique and yummy and my husband had a personal pizza built with bacon and pineapple. The garlic and cheese bread sticks were more than enough to share in the smallest size and the marinara dip that came with it was so yummy with chunky pieces of tomato in it- could've eaten it with a spoon it was so yummy! The garlic bread was delicious but very garlicky. The beer is canned but there are a lot of great local craft beer options. read more

See all

Been here several times and I can't say enough how good the food is! Service was great too! Very friendly and helpful! Phantom Gourmet needs to stop in here!!!! Amazing! read more

We ordered pickup after a long day at the beach. It did not disappoint. Would highly recommend!

Their pizzas are very unique and always good. Their specials are truly special and always a good price and as delicious as everything else on the menu. The staff is great and the food comes out fast and pipe hot! read more

The perfect 10 was perfect just like their score very friendly folks When in York ME. a must have. read more

The best pizza around! We had a large 4 cheese pizza with four vegetarian additions. It was very tasty and the crust was thin enough. Our only critical comment is that the pizza was too heavy on salt and a little too much garlic for our taste, but still very good. read more

Walked in one night and no one was seated eating in. I asked to be seated to eat there and we were told any food would take 50-55 minutes because they were busy making takeout orders. I'm sorry, I thought people dining in take priority? Anyway, we placed the order to go. She said 50 minutes. I was back in 40 and my food was already sitting there getting cold. By the time I got home, the pizza was barely warm. This is what happens when kids run your restaurant and the owner is busy with his other establishments. Do better. read more

Great thin crust pizza and good customer service. Even though my favorite pizza is no longer on the menu, they made something very close. The salad is great also read more

The best gluten feee pizza I have ever had. Period. I've been meaning to write this for awhile. Always great meals. They got us through the pandemic!! Everyone go there - now!Well done York 54!! read more

It's a small place with four or five tables. Mostly a take out place. We ordered a bacon and hamburg pizza which was loaded with toppings. The DO NOT skimp! Lots of flavor. The dough is terrific and not much of a flop. Under carriage was nice. Maybe the best topping pizza on the seacoast! 9.0 on the Barstool Sports scale! The price was about $20 for the pizza, but well worth it! Reasonable compared to many other places too. read more

Big fan of these sandwiches, basically a flatbread pizza folded in half - delicious! Plus they have gelato, definitely worth stopping in here. read more

My family was in Maine for a family wedding. We had 30 people at our rental home. We called Saturday to place an order for ten pizzas. The woman on the phone was lovely. She asked me To hold on while she checked. The man she checked with was rude and disrespectful to her, as I could hear the conversation. He yelled at her "absolutely not, that Oder will take All our oven space, tell her no. We will run out of dough." He didn't take Our order, which is fine. My objection was how rude he was to the young woman answering the phones. And we got thinking what's the difference if five people call and order 2 pizzas each!‍we gave our money to Anthony's and the pizza was great! My family was in Maine for a family wedding. We had 30 people at our rental home. We called Saturday to place an order for ten pizzas. The woman on the phone was lovely. She asked me To hold on while she checked. The man she checked with was rude and disrespectful to her, as I could hear the conversation. He yelled at her "absolutely not, that Oder will take All our oven space, tell her no. We will run out of dough." He didn't take Our order, which is fine. My objection was how rude he was to the young woman answering the phones. And we got thinking what's the difference if five people call and order 2 pizzas each!‍we gave our money to Anthony's and the pizza was great! read more

Quite a range of menu offerings and the food was delicious!!! Sorry I don't have photos to post but we were so impressed and hungry we devoured it all without thinking about a photo - lol. The only reason for the 4 stars rather than 5 was the lack of ambiance. Service was spot on though and it always makes the meal better when you know staff is happy and friendly. See you there! read more

Went for the first time for lunch today -- honestly one of the best tuna sandwiches I've ever had. Joe also let me sample their new custard which was incredible... bought some to keep in the freezer for after dinner but it barely survived the car ride home. Can't wait to try other things on their menu! read more

Pizza is Awesome and tasty!! Very good!! Great service and in a timely manner!! Great food!!

Last year I enjoyed York 54 for this pizza (highly recommend) but this year after eating out so much I really wanted a salad. I know, weird. But the salad did not disappoint! I got the Cesar salad with chicken and prosciutto and a flat bread. Holy cow. Amazing. The dressing was homemade (the croutons too I think) and it was FULL of toppings. And the flat bread was delicious. There was so much salad that I had leftovers for the following night. My partner got a sandwich that looked amazing and he really enjoyed. This is a great stop that is sure to please everyone!! read more

Perfect lunch place fresh ingredients.made to order live the pizza calzones sandwiches soup salads you name it. Why the heck did I never review this before.??? What a great place to eat. They really know what they are doing. Stop by, good beer selection too! read more

York 54 - Specials and beers - Pizza Near Me - York, Maine

See all

Best food around never have had any problems the staff is always super nice I love talking to the one older dude in super good shape thats always on the salad line he always a kind and super out going guy. read more

I live in the New York Metro area - a place known for great pizza. I am also on a gluten-free diet and blessed to have pizzerias near me who make GF pizza. That all aside, the Four Cheese Gluten Free Pizza with Pepperoni I just had from York 54 was the best pizza I've had in years. OUTSTANDING! My wife had the Summer Garden pizza and my twin sons both had the Southwest Quesadilla and likewise thought they were great. I also recommend the Sriracha wings! read more

If you like be treated as if you are a burden on someone's time, order from York 54. I live in town and have been here no less than 5 times. I leave upset every time. The pizza is good. Priced about twice as much as it should be, but tasty none-the-less. My issue is with the front of house staff (the bakers are actually quite friendly). Anyway, I am done with this place after going in 12 minutes early for my pizza that was ordered for 5:30. I walked in at 5:18 to see it sitting on the warmer. The last time I ordered they told me 30 minutes so I went in 25 minutes later to find my pizza cold and the staff rude once again. read more

Delicious pizza! Flat bread style. Great service! We've been a few times now, always good. read more

You're going to think I'm prone to hyperbole but I'm not. This is one of the best little restaraunts I've ever been to. It's just a little flatbread and salad place--just a step up from takeout. Everything I've had is delicious. Feta, asparagus and bacon pizza was delicious--good bacon. The blue cheese apple flatbread is fantastic. I think about it when I'm in Florida. The peach and berry and greens salad was very fresh and excellent, as was another specialty salad with pistachios and something else. Homemade dressing was light and perfectly pulled the salad together. You're going to want to try this--the salads even impress my husband who usually insists that "a salad is a salad." Great food. read more

Enjoyed dining here once, but went to go back tonight and their doors are locked. Online and even the sign out front say they're open 11am- 8am Monday's and it's 5:15. If you're going to post your hours online and out front, please make sure they're accurate! Probably won't risk going back since we don't know if they will be open. read more

York 54 - Incorrect daily hours - Pizza Near Me - York, Maine

Doesn't look like much when you walk past, but the pizza here is phenomenal! The only reason we didn't give 5 stars is because the wait was 30+ minutes, which was a bit long to wait. I'd recommend their "Perfect 10" pizza, very delicious! read more