It was very busy when we got here but we able to order our food and wait for a table, which was fine with us. The staff was friendly and apologetic because of the wait and rush. We got a seat and a few minutes water our delicious food came out! I had curry chicken salad and my Hubby the buffalo chicken quesadilla. The food was amazing!!! So delicious and fresh with great flavor!!! read more

York 54 - a sandwich and chips on a plate - Pizza Near Me - York, Maine

We placed an order online. The information on screen while placing the order was that it would be ready before 7:00 pm (order was placed just after 6:00 pm). Once the order was finalized we got a text saying the order would be ready after 7:00 pm. We didn't think much of this because it was a Saturday night. That was the last communication we received. I called the restaurant at 7:15 and was told the order was "all set". The food was ready and was sitting there waiting for us to pick it up. I just think they need to have a way to tell people their order is ready. read more

Delicious pizza got what we ordered the pizza was ready when we came and picked it up good cheese to sauce ratio the crust it crispy but not hard or not to soft read more

We stopped here on our way back to NH after an afternoon at the beach. Even though they were closing (the open sign literally shut off as my husband was ordering), they made us an amazing veggie pizza - loaded with broccoli, garlic, caramelized onions and spinach. Delicious! read more

Excellent! We ordered two pizzas and the basil pesto bread for takeout. Food was ready exactly when they said and was steaming hot walking out to the car on a chilly January evening. Toppings were fresh and the thin crust was perfectly baked. Really enjoyed the basil pesto bread too. We'll be going back next time in York! read more

Did take out pizza. It was ok. Was better last time we tried it a couple years ago. A little pricey.

Excellent unique pizza location-very small inside but adds to the charm and intimate dinning setting everything that came out looked AMAZING! read more

Great unassuming restaurant with friendly staff. Our family is big and we all have different tastes. And my husband doesn't eat cheese! Yes, I know "the horrors! " We ordered on-line during a busy Friday during the summer season.The boys had had pizza, which was homemade and crispy and had a nice amount of cheese on it. I ordered the Southwestern fajita. It was crispy, flavorful and had just the right amount of heat. It came with a spicy dill dipping sauce. My husband had the hamburger fajita and he said the onions were crunchy the meat was flavorful, the actual fajita bread was toasted to ultimate crispiness! I also ordered the Street corn and it was good although I prefer a more burnt taste.Everything was freshly made here and I really like that. It's been 3 years here in York, Maine and we finally found our go to pizza sandwich place. read more

So very good! Went here based on Yelp reviews and a mad pizza craving! This place delivers on quality, variety and service. The pizza and salad were fresh, and delicious. Honestly it was hard to make a choice on what to order. I guess that's reason enough to go back! It's small and in a plaza, and probably often missed unless you are a local. I really enjoyed the charm and sincerity of staff. A great find! read more

York 54 - Pizza Near Me - York, Maine

See all

After having a few beers at SoMe Brewery, we needed something to absorb all of the alcohol before our drive home. I looked on Yelp and saw that York 54 was right next door and had great reviews so we have it a shot. The place is small and you can see everything being cooked from pretty much where ever you're sitting in the restaurant. We decided to get the margherita pizza. The ingredients tasted so fresh and the pizza was cooked perfectly! Next time we're in the area we will be back to try something different off of their menu. Highly recommended if you're in the Yorke area looking for pizza! read more

Excellent pizza, very imaginative options. Caesar salad is great. It is a little expensive, but worth it. This is the best pizza in the Kittery area (yes it is in York, and yes, we drive from Kittery). read more

The pizza here is great! We started with the Baby Kale and Beets salad. We ordered one large salad and they were very nice to split it between the two of us. The salad was very good and fresh. For pizza we got the Weather Report and the Winter Harvest. The toppings were tasty and the crust was perfect. This is a small restaurant with about 8-10 tables and a bar. We went there on a Saturday night and it was quiet; it seemed like most of the business was for take-out or delivery. I enjoyed their pizza more than When Pig's Fly in Kittery. However, if you are with a group of people for a night out you may prefer When Pig's Fly. read more

York 54 - Winter Harvest Vegetable. Outstanding! Perfect crust, toppings, and just the right size. - Pizza Near Me - York, Maine

See all

Good pizza for Maine...hot and fresh...a little skimpy with toppings...definitely call ahead as hours vary due to Covid-19

What an amazing spot to stumble upon on our way south on 95. My red curry pizza was basically a spicy Thai salad with chicken on top of pizza dough Perfection. And my husband had the creamy white sauce one with asparagus and bacon. DELICIOUS. we will be back the next time we are anywhere nearby!!! read more

I don't if all of the ingredients had expired or what, but the pizza we ordered tasted like we were eating actual trash. People will tell you it's 'fancy' or gourmet, but any big box chain pizza place is at minimum 100x better. Don't waste your money on this over priced garbage. My wife and I had 1 slice and threw away $50 worth of pizza. If you are the owner of this restaurant, please consider selling it or turning the site into a gas station or something more useful. read more

This pizza was some of the best I've had. Dough was delicious. It is not greasy or too filling. Crust is crispy and so delicious. Service was okay, they were swamped and understaffed but the pizza made up for it!!! read more

See all

Super friendly, sweet staff. The food was surprisingly delicious. Who'd have thought of apple on pizza? Man, but the genius chef definitely knows what's up. I got the Hard Cider BBQ pizza and I had to save one piece because I knew that I would regret not having a taste of that pizza again for a late night snack. Just absolutely fantastic. Can't wait to go back and try Joe's, too! read more

York 54 - Hard Cider BBQ pizza. Get it. Eat it. Love it. - Pizza Near Me - York, Maine

This is the first place we ate out at since we got to the area and we are thoroughly impressed!!! The food is delicious and fresh! We had the wings, Brussels sprouts, The Perfect 10 pizza and the Sweet Fig & Salami pizza. The wings were cooked perfectly, I think they may've been baked and seasoned with the right amount of sweet and heat! And I don't really like Brussels sprouts but these were very tasty!! The perfect 10 pizza was so fresh tasting!! I am pretty sure they make their own pizza sauce too!! And the Sweet Fig & Salami pizza was my favorite with the sweetness from the fig and saltiness from the salami and savoriness from the caramelized onions!! Oh so yummy!! The staff there were friendly and helpful to someone who's never been there. The food was served piping hot on serving tiles!! We are going back there for sure a few more times before we leave the area! read more

Outstanding little hidden gem... We never would have noticed it driving by. Fortunately we found the place on Yelp with very positive reviews. It lived up to the reviews, the pesto pizza was outstanding, the prices were very reasonable, and the staff was super helpful and friendly. Will definitely be back! read more

Tiny pizza spot with plenty of flavor and delicious food. Tables may be hard to come by but the wait is well worth it - it seems like a lot of locals order to go for this reason. Personal to large sized pizza and salads top the menu. We tried the seasonal salad (candied walnuts and blue cheese) and split two personal pizzas, margarita and white with garlic. Everything was delicious and was topped off with a local craft beer. read more

See all

York 54 is small... and busy, but probably my favorite pizza in Southern Maine. Many a time I have wandered over after a happy hour drink or 2 at wiggly bridge for some garlic bread and a pie. I would recommend getting one of the house specialties or if you are brave a Build your own. My favorite is Sausage, Ricotta, spinach and roasted garlic. They also have a pretty decent selection of craft beer and cider. York 54 is definitely worth a stop if you are in the area. read more

York 54 - Custom pizza - Pizza Near Me - York, Maine

See all

Our family decided to have dinner here last night based on the glowing yelp reviews. My wife I shared a small pizza. We created our own with ham and pineapple as toppings. We both thought the pizza was very good and would recommend it if you are in the area and in the mood for pizza. My son ordered a hard cider pizza which he devoured. So overall, it was a very good dining experience. read more

Missed stopping here last year and made a point to try it this year. It does look like a takeout joint and does have very limited seating. But get a drink and wait. It's very worth it. Fantastic selection of local brew not on tap. Great selection of pizzas or make you own. Made in a brick oven and served hot on a tile right to table. Crust perfect, fresh toppings, and full of flavor. Can understand when so many take out orders. It is a perfect break from all the seafood that can overwhelm you while here. From Georgia and highly recommend. read more

The best pizza around! And beet salad is my favorite! Delish! Seasonal choices like the veggies that are our most local are always added to specials. Gluten free choices for some GF friends too! read more

The best. My wife and I have been here a handful of times now, and it remains some of the best food we've ever eaten. Seriously. To the naked eye, it's a humble pizza place run by an extremely talented chef and staff -- and we love it. The Thai Red Curry Chicken Pizza is a thing of beauty, with complex but simply enjoyable flavors and total happiness in every bite. Pair it with a local beer, tack on the incredibly friendly service, and you've got a winner. We can't wait to go back. read more

York 54 - Red Thai Curry Chicken Pizza. Seriously amazing. - Pizza Near Me - York, Maine

See all

Great pizza! Great people! I just got married and we are in York Maine on our honeymoon! We love food and are trying to check out all the best spots around. This one was great. read more

I've stopped into this spot twice over the past few years- and both times had a great meal! Most recently, the husband and I went for a light lunch. Perfect personal size pizza- though served more of a flatbread style. Mine was a vegetarian portion, olives, tomato, spinach and feta, with beautiful wedges of artichoke hearts....and per request, a white sauce rather than traditional red. The husband had a harvest type with apples, squash, arugula and the most amazing bits of thick crisp bacon that will make you tear up with joy! All served by a most lovely lady who bustled around the small restaurant like she was happy to be there. I love when a person loves what they do......and the entire staff must love their jobs- they do them so well! Stop in and try something different. read more

York 54 - Pizza Near Me - York, Maine

See all

First time but won't be the last. I was looking for a spot between Portsmouth and Wells to meet up with family visiting from out of town. What's the first thing one does? Yelp of course. The reviews were mostly great with a couple of clunkers. I figured the odds were in my favor. Well, I'm glad I didn't listen to the naysayers. We lucked out that it wasn't a super busy Friday night. We grabbed one of the last two tables. It was steady inside but not crazy. The two gals that were handling the counter and tables did a great job. They were friendly, attentive & knowledgeable about the unique offerings. I overheard them telling a call in order that it was going to be 45 minutes, yikes! We ordered a large salad w/ beets, candied pecans & blue cheese. Yum, beautiful to look at, nice flavor, fresh and enough for 3 of us to split before our pizzas. Yes, pizzas, each of us got our own personal pizza. I went with the Kind, a white pizza w/ roasted garlic & mushrooms. It was very good, nice crust...served on flooring tiles. We also had the Big, sliced apples, candied pecans again...cheese, don't remember what it was now but it was really good. Next time that's going to be my choice. Lastly, we got the red curry pizza for those who just can't choose between Thai and pizza. It was like a fresh Thai salad on a pizza with a zing from the sriracha glaze. All in all a success. Our server checked on us, chit chatted a bit with the "first time here?", "where you from" questions. As we left one of the gals thanked us and wished us a good night and as we got to the door a guy working the ovens also thanked us (he had the air of ownership/management). It's nice to be genuinely appreciated. Just a nice casual spot. I'm already planning on heading back for another dinner! read more

My friend and I had a delicious lunch here. I had a salad and she tried one of the pizzas. Artisan quality. Definitely worth a stop if you are in the area. read more

York 54 - Pizza Near Me - York, Maine

Loved this place. We stoped by today for a bit and certainly glad we did. We had the Hard Cider BBQ pizza and it was delicious. The ingredients were fresh and of good quality. The chicken was really good not the low quality that most restaurants use. And the bacon was crispy not soggy like the other guys. I will definitely be back again and look forward to my next visit. I'd like to try everything on the menu. read more

York 54 - Pizza Near Me - York, Maine

Y54, an offbeat name, but the food is fantastic. Had pizza with sausage and roasted red peppers, and a delicate white sauce, not tomato sauce.. Sublime, delicate, savory. a real professional chef at work creating mouth watering meals. i cant wait to return! give it a try, you wont be sorry! read more

My wife got us take out from here, and I wasn't impressed. The food wasn't gross or stratospherically overpriced, it was just nothing special. And the portions were so paltry that my 7 year old (who doesn't eat) devoured a whole flatbread pizza and still complained of hunger. Even as I write this, I remember eating there, it just wasn't memorable enough for me to recall. I just remember it being a tapas style portion. Not to discourage anyone, but I'll get my pizza elsewhere. read more

Moved from Detroit. Been living in Maine for about 6 years. I've found nothing but junk pizza in New England. This is the best pizza in York county. Hands down. read more

Ordered take out from here on the first day of vacation. Enjoyed a few of the different pizzas with their flavor combinations. Great wings!

One of the best pizza's I've ever had..the perfect 10 is ridiculously great! We came all the way from Houston, TX. When you get tired of all the chowder and lobster rolls on vacation up here, definitely try this place! read more

York 54 - I rest my case - Pizza Near Me - York, Maine

This is the place to go for unigue pizza topping combinations, hearty sandwiches, and delicious salads. Very good quality food! Cooks and staff are extremely kind and helpful. We love to get takeout from here when we want something different. If you are looking for plain cheese or pepperoni, head down to Anthony's or YOrk house of pizza. That's not what you'll find here read more

Great fresh ingredients. Phenomenal pizza and a great friendly staff makes this a go to for a quick bite to eat. Very creative menu! Cannot go wrong here! read more

York 54 - The perfect ten is a perfect ten! - Pizza Near Me - York, Maine

I knew from the first time I went here when they opened that this place would be great. Everything from their pizzas to the sandwiches are the best around. read more

I ordered the salad special today, Summer berry salad. Very fresh and ripe Blueberries, strawberries, raspberries , toasted almonds and feta on top of arugula with a honey dressing. It was so delicious! I ate it 7 hrs ago and am still thinking about it. Hope it's still a special tomorrow because I'll be back. Thank you York 54!!! read more

York 54 found the paradoxical sweet spot by offering a thick, thin crust pizza. The sausage, roasted pepper, red onion and 54 dust known as the Super Sausage pizza is a pleasure every time. I usually avoid bone in chicken wings, but the order that passed by our table was too appealing to neglect. The 54 wings are varnished with a siracha lime and honey sauce that lived up to my ocular expectations and were a perfect compliment for our pizza. The freshness of ingredients at York 54 have never disappointed; the salads look especially attractive. read more