https://youtu.be/KSXdwWeHJxU as (EVIDENCE)…read more FORMAL COMPLAINT AND COMPLETE ACCOUNT OF EVENTS Christian Brothers Automotive - Tyler, Texas ## CORPORATE PROMISE VS LOCAL EXPERIENCE Christian Brothers Automotive promotes a customer experience called "The Nice Difference," implying professionalism, communication, transparency, and respect. This location is independently owned and operated, meaning the responsibility to deliver that standard falls on local management. What I experienced was the opposite. --- ## ENTRY AND INITIAL INTERACTION Upon entering the Tyler location, I was not acknowledged. There was no greeting, no indication that assistance would be provided, and no basic customer engagement. I had to initiate interaction myself to be acknowledged. Phoebe, the service writer, eventually engaged and stated that I would receive updates throughout the process, including: * Text messages * Emails * Photos documenting the work This communication was never delivered. --- ## COMMUNICATION FAILURE The promised updates did not occur. What I did receive was not a valid diagnostic explanation. The communication provided: * Contained no clear diagnostic breakdown * Redirected me to call the shop * Displayed an estimate marked as "authorized," which I did not approve At this point, I had not paid for any services because I had not retrieved the vehicle and required clarification before proceeding. --- ## DIAGNOSTIC CONCERNS I asked a direct and reasonable question: "What exactly was completed during the $160 diagnostic?" I was told that multiple hours had been spent and that additional time would be required, potentially increasing the diagnostic cost to a much higher amount. I then asked why a scan tool or diagnostic computer was not used first to narrow down the issue before moving into a wiring-based diagnostic process. This is standard practice in modern diagnostics: * OBD2 scan tools * Live data monitoring * Fault code analysis * Circuit isolation prior to invasive work These questions were not answered clearly. The responses were vague, dismissive, and did not provide a technical explanation of what was actually performed. --- ## ESCALATION WITHOUT TRANSPARENCY Instead of addressing my questions or connecting me to the technician working on the vehicle, I was: * Placed on hold * Transferred to the service manager (Ryan) I was not informed this would be an escalation, nor was the situation clearly communicated to me prior to the transfer. --- ## PHONE INTERACTION - INTERRUPTION AND TONE When Ryan joined the call: * He did not establish context * He did not acknowledge the situation * He immediately adopted a condescending tone From the beginning of the call, I was repeatedly interrupted and not allowed to complete my explanations. --- ## STRUCTURED TRANSCRIPT EXCERPTS (WITH INTERRUPTION IDENTIFICATION) Speaker Key: YOU = Customer RYAN = Service Manager --- INTERRUPTION #1 YOU: "She didn't even try to--" RYAN: "So either you let me explain it to you or you can voluntarily come get your vehicle." --- INTERRUPTION #2 YOU: "She didn't even try to explain it to me, sir. She did not--" RYAN: "She has tried multiple times." --- INTERRUPTION #3 YOU: "You didn't even give me a chance to explain--" RYAN: "You have not given her the chance to explain, sir." --- INTERRUPTION #4 YOU: "I'm trying to talk to you, so don't interrupt me--" RYAN: "If you want me to treat you the same, you need to not interrupt me as well." --- INTERRUPTION #5 YOU: "Okay, so what I was trying to explain to you--" RYAN: "This conversation is over." --- INTERRUPTION #6 YOU: "You didn't even give me a chance to explain at all--" RYAN: "And how many chances have you given me and my advisor--" --- INTERRUPTION #7 YOU: "Well then we will go ahead and address that she never gave me the chance--" RYAN: "Once again--" --- INTERRUPTION #8 YOU: "And you yourself keep interrupting me like you're doing right now--" RYAN: "And you're not interrupting, sir?" --- INTERRUPTION #9 YOU: "If you would be quiet for a minute--" RYAN: "No sir." --- INTERRUPTION #10 YOU: "If you would be quiet for a minute you would be able to allow me to explain--" RYAN: "No sir." --- INTERRUPTION #11 YOU: "See you're interrupting me again--" RYAN: "I'm officially ending this conversation." --- ## INTERRUPTION SUMMARY Based on the transcript provided: * You were interrupted at least 11 times * Each interruption occurred while attempting to: * Explain lack of communication * Clarify unauthorized estimate * Understand diagnostic process At no point was a full explanation allowed to be completed. --- ## CONVERSATION TERMINATION Instead of resolving the issue: * The conversation was shut down * I was told to retrieve my vehicle * No clarification was provided --- ## REFUSAL TO ESCALATE I requested to speak with the owner. * I was told the owner was present * I was denied the opportunity to speak with him ---

I recently acquired a 2006 PT Cruiser. It had been parked in a garage for a couple of years. I was…read morehaving electrical problems and AC problems and tried a local service center that misdiagnosed the problems and over charged me severely. I decided to give Christian Brothers a call. They performed a few very professional diagnostic tests, identified the problems and corrected the same day as the tests. I will definitely take my PT Cruiser to Christian Brothers for all my vehicle maintenance. They are professional and very courteous.

I have ways had a great experience taking my car to be serviced at Fairway Auto Center and I highly…read morerecommend them. They are professional, honest and dependable. I won't go anywhere else to have my car serviced.

Professional, courteous, and fast service! The staff always explains what needs to be done and the…read morecost before servicing my car. I won't go anywhere else. Highly recommend!

After having brake pads installed incorrectly by another repair shop, and having problems. I…read moreresearched and found Atlas Automotive. They quickly diagnosed that the original work was faulty and would need to be repaired. There was also an additional problem found. They took photos as proof for the needed repairs. I found Atlas Automotive to be honest, reputable, with quality work done quickly. Austin and Morgan's customer service was on point and the reception area was clean, comfortable with complimentary drinks offered. Very good experience. 5 Stars.

I am so happy to have found Atlas Automotive! They did a great job, for a fair price, and went…read moreabove and beyond with their customer service! From the beginning to the end, they worked to make sure everything was done properly and in a timely manner. I am definitely a loyal customer and will tell everyone about how well they took care of me and my car. Thank you!

We have used Premier Auto Repair for our car needs for approximately 3 years. Everytime we've…read moreneeded help with repairs, they have been concerned with our concerns and always discuss parts and labor cost in a clear manner. We have found Mr. Mike, Joe and all the staff extremely understanding and they are very reasonable with pricing. They have worked with us on 3 of our vehicles and we could not be happier with Premier Auto Repair.

I called the week before and made an appointment with Michael and he gave me an appointment for…read moreMonday( today) to bring my car at 0800 when they open. Its a Hyundai Kona. At desk, Joe , took my information. Went to run errands and came back twice to the car shop to check on the status of car and every single time my car has not been worked on, Joe ( help at front desk) kept saying your car is next and will be an hour or so for diagnostic. Here came 13:30 almost 14:00 and my car has not been worked on at all . It sat in their lot for 6 hrs for nothing. All I asked is for clean, clear communication and not feel I was being given the run around when my car was going to be worked on. I even felt this helper at the front desk ( Joe) might have been prejudiced against me being a petite latina woman. Michael was very professional but this Joe person does not have any customer service skills. They may have 5 rating review that is why I took my car there for a diagnostic but a 5 rating review was not my experience today. I lost one day now I have to take another day off and find another location to service my car. I have a busy schedule and this was just not right. And its ok lets say they are a busy shop but communicate clearly. And I asked why did I make an appointment to bring the car in then???? Was given some BS answer.

Mr Mike is one of the most honest mechanics I've ever met. He handles most of the maintenance on my…read morevehicles, I own a car service and he has always shot me straight with any issues with the car. I don't ever have to question whether the work is done correctly or if we're "doing too much". I will forever recommend Mr Mike to anyone who needs service.

From the owner: Fifties oil change and service center is changing the way people view the automotive service…read moreindustry one happy customer at a time. At Fifties, we take care of you and your car.

my moms best friend recommended Mike's Automotive. My A/C had stopped working and I took it over…read moreand even though their power was out, they got it fixed and called me to come get it in less than 3 hours. and it was a reasonable price as well. Very friendly on the phone and in person. Its a little bit of a drive for me, but i would definitely go back and recommend them to anyone else. Thanks!

We have come to depend on Mike and his team to repair our vehicles & get us up & running again &…read morethey have been nothing but honest, friendly, responsive, & fairly priced. Within a few months of one another, both of our vehicles needed repair work. They got my car back up & running in no time, & let us know that we needed a more specialized shop for the issue with our Jeep. More recently my car needed headlight repair work done & again, they were honest, friendly, responsive, & fairly priced. I will always come back to Mike's shop & refer everyone I know to him for repairs!

They will say they've checked your car but they really didn't…read more They will say they rotate your tires But they really won't They will keep your car all day But won't provide a call Back or a solution until I finally got someone to answer me after calling 3 times within 10 minutes Horrible service worse mechanics won't be back

I rent from enterprise frequently and sometimes put a lot of miles on my rentals. Firestone in…read moreTyler handles all of their maintenance and they have always taken good care of me