As a retired Coastie, and a local, this is by far the one of the best overall seafood spots and by…read morefar the BEST, seafood boil, best fresh clams and a very nice variety of warm and cold water oysters. Lastly, they have a super yummy steam buckets of oysters that is a must! I have never walked away from this place unhappy!

I am a local and have been coming to this restaurant for 5+ years…read more This used to be a great place, but it's turned into an overpriced tourist trap My last five visits in the last year have all been terrible. The food is smelly, not fresh, the service is at the horrid. The average servers at this restaurant are very entitled and don't know the basics of serving food. Some restaurants can survive. I'm just having good food, others because they've got special service, this restaurant has neither of them. Very sad with the rich heritage that they have and the fact that they can grow their own oysters. Unfortunately, 90% of the time when you go to commanders half the menu isn't even available. So if you like hush puppies and fried crap from China, this is your place. But if you want fresh seafood, there's a whole bunch of others in St Augustine and elsewhere. Not worth spending a couple hundred dollars on several day old fish.

Late lunch on Sunday. We love Seafood Kitchen…read more Having fresh grouper grilled comes with two sides. Always well prepared. Friendly staff great food love this place.

Great food and service. The crab legs were cooked to perfection. We will definitely be back.read more

Stopped in for some fresh shrimp. I could have bought some of everything in there. The fish and…read moreshrimp all looked wonderful. We decided on a couple of pounds of shrimp on sale. We took it to our house and had it for dinner. Very tasty!!

Perhaps it has something to do with the halo effect of being on vacation, but I loved Fisherman's…read moreDock. Could I have really come here three times in five days? I think I did. The first time was shrimp and mahi. The second time was shrimp, mahi, conch fritter batter, and oysters. The third time was for even more shrimp. Are you picking up on a trend? When shopping anywhere, it's clutch to go for the local options, and here it was the shrimp. The largest, local shrimp were just $10 a pound, and they were fabulous. I could eat them every day. Um... I think I pretty much did eat them every day. In part, that is thanks to the flippin' amazing cocktail sauce. Which isn't local. But that doesn't make it any less kickass amazeballs. Kelchner. Remember the name. Delightful, delightful stuff. Even if it happens to be made in Allentown, PA. They have been making it since 1938, when folks weren't fooling around with subpar ingredients. Of course, in St. Augustine we had some datil pepper hot sauce too. The staff was great. All of our questions were answered about where the fish came from. Oysters from Canada. Mahi from Central America (I forget where, maybe Honduras). I appreciated how you could order whole fish, and they would prepare them for you. That way you can inspect the gills and the eyes to pick the best one. We never called ahead to have shrimp peeled and deveined, but the fee per pound to do so felt like a pittance. Most of my shrimp consumption came in the form of boil, peel, and eat, which is good because it slows me down a bit. I shudder to think how many shrimp I would have consumed if they were all ready to shove into my shrimp hole. Without a doubt I'll be back the next time I am in town, which hopefully won't be too long.

I love it so much they have all kinds of amazing fish the staff are very friendly and helpful…read morewonderful and they have great knowledge good recommendations it is clean and organized awesome the service is very fast and thank you for your help and hard work to the community I appreciate it you so much keep up the best work awesome food unbelievable place definitely bring family and friends buy amazing fish come here it is awesome I love it so much Hugs Lauren

A must stop anytime I am in the area and have even headed here on purpose! Fresh Fresh Fresh…read moreseafood! Watching them filet my dinner (Trigger fish tonight.. yum!) is just such a treat. Whether you like crawfish, crab legs, red shrimp, mahi, wahoo or really ANY fish this should be your go to. They also have delicious dips (always get the fish dip) and sauces (homemade tartar sauce) tasty soups both fresh and frozen and don't forget the key lime pie!!! Go! You will be happy like me! Oh and next door is a produce shop with local produce and great prices.. and a CHEESECAKE bakery.. trust me ... check it out!

Did not knock my socks off. Sausages were ok. Service was anything but gracious. I was mostly…read moreignored and when I asked a question she did me the favor or answering. I prefer the Chop House up the road.

First time stopping in! Got great deal on crab claws so much…read morecheaper than the fish market....including some fresh fish! Grass fed beef looks amazing! What a selection I'll be back!

A1A Fisheries was recommended to us by a resident when we asked about fishmongers. We stopped by…read moreand ended up picking up some fresh local pompano, grouper, and flounder for a gathering. There were lots of fish to choose from but the helpful guy behind the counter was happy to answer our questions. Our grillmaster prepared them slightly differently, and I thought they were all excellent and fresh. We'd also grabbed a container of the Dat'l Hook Ya seasoning which paired perfectly with the fish. Definitely swing by A1A Fisheries for your seafood needs. Closed Mondays and Tuesdays.

Very fresh fish, and the staff is knowledgeable and courteous. We keep going back for more.read more

We have been getting our seafood boils from this company for years. It's actually a holiday…read moretradition for us now. This year we got the fancy one with lobster tails, and it was amazing. They give you a pot, seasoning, butter, lemons, and really everything you need for a successful seafood boil! So easy peasy.

We ordered Outer Banks for our SuperBowl party! Delicious! Everyone raved about the food and made…read moreme look like a star! (Of course I gave credit where credit was due!). We ordered The Classic and added a pound of scallops and a pound of shrimp. The sausage is delicious and seafood is so fresh! Everyone ate until we were so stuffed we couldn't take another bite. Spiced perfectly, and the directions are so easy to follow! So so good! We added cornbread muffins and key lime pie to the order as well. The cornbread was so delicious my guests thought it tasted like desert! And I have to know who made the key lime pie! Best key lime that I've had locally! Both were such a fantastic compliment to our meal! I would give more than five stars if I could!

Fresh fish and great customer service, got salmon, tuna and seaweed salad and made a great poke…read morebowl with my purchases. Will definitely be back for more great seafood!

Loved the peel and eat shrimp!! Great price too. $14 and I took some home because there so many…read more Also the sweet potato fries were delicious!

Great friendly service!…read more The order arrive fast and the shrimp were cooked just right. Also, the hush puppies were exceptional.

Service was very quick and the staff was nice! Everything was surprisingly cheap and tasted…read moreAMAZING!! We got the crab cocktail and were flabbergasted to see the amount of crab for such a low price!! It's very cozy and not too loud. Definitely worth visiting!