These guys are fantastic, excellent fish cutters. (fillet.) Best fish market in ST Augustine. Fresh fish, rock crab and little necks. We purchased 200 little necks, Tritail, pink snapper, trigger fish and rock crab. Please tip them, they are professionals. read more

I do not eat seafood but all of my family does and they love the mayport shrimp and scallops from here. I am sure they have lots of great other options however I did not even step foot inside but saw so many locals pulling in to grab and go it was a constant flow in and out in the few minutes we were there! My family absolutely loved the seafood and come all the time. It may not look like much when you pass by but don't pass it up when you're craving seafood! I cannot speak on the ambiance but my sister was in and out in minutes! read more

Kyle’s Seafood Market - store front - Seafood Markets Near Me - Saint Augustine, Florida

I love it so much they have all kinds of amazing fish the staff are very friendly and helpful wonderful and they have great knowledge good recommendations it is clean and organized awesome the service is very fast and thank you for your help and hard work to the community I appreciate it you so much keep up the best work awesome food unbelievable place definitely bring family and friends buy amazing fish come here it is awesome I love it so much Hugs Lauren read more

A must stop anytime I am in the area and have even headed here on purpose! Fresh Fresh Fresh seafood! Watching them filet my dinner (Trigger fish tonight.. yum!) is just such a treat. Whether you like crawfish, crab legs, red shrimp, mahi, wahoo or really ANY fish this should be your go to. They also have delicious dips (always get the fish dip) and sauces (homemade tartar sauce) tasty soups both fresh and frozen and don't forget the key lime pie!!! Go! You will be happy like me! Oh and next door is a produce shop with local produce and great prices.. and a CHEESECAKE bakery.. trust me ... check it out! read more

See all

Cozy building contains fresh high quality seafood choices. Try their house made dips! There's usually samples available. The team that works here are all knowledgeable about seafood, friendly, helpful, and strong enough to bring a bushel of oysters to your vehicle. Worth a stop if you're in the area and worth a drive to become your default seafood spot. Also, you can order ahead! This comes in handy around holidays and makes your visit even more simple and straightforward. read more

See all

The staff was amazing and you must get the smoked fish dip!! We are excited to have our seafood boil.

Clams are excellent !!! All different varieties!!! Great selection of fresh fish!!! Very friendly staff!!! read more

Kyle’s Seafood Market - Seafood Markets Near Me - Saint Augustine, Florida

Just amazing! One of the best fish market in the US, their soups and food are to die for and dont want to leave the place, their service is greater! One of the spots to visit if you are in the area. read more

Kyle’s Seafood Market - Seafood Markets Near Me - Saint Augustine, Florida

Easy to overlook, Kyle's is a small storefront operation, so it would seem. However, it's gonna help if you have some idea what you'd like, because they have a lot! Seriously, a lot. All fresh, no smell, just fish. We opted for some local shrimp, smoked salmon, and fresh salmon. All were terrific! They will clean your fish for free. Best local fish shop in the area. read more

Fresh Fish , great professional help with choosing great seafood. This place is great! If you're looking for fresh local seafood, Kyle's has it and it's amazing. read more

Best local seafood in Ponte Vedra / St. Augustine. Will special order hard to get items as well. Great quality and staff!!

Small and local. The guy who served us was helpful. Got some excellent crab dip, and gator tail. You know the seafood is going to be good when a place smells like Kyle's. ;) read more

Kyle’s Seafood Market - Fish and clams - Seafood Markets Near Me - Saint Augustine, Florida

Great selection on fresh seafood. Our shrimp couldn't of been better. We got their container of clam chowder soup also. Great friendly service read more

the place is amazing! The guys here have incredibly fresh fish, and they really take the time to serve you right. Highly recommend!"

Got my birthday fix! Half a bushel of oysters and a Key Lime Pie! Always fresh and delicious! You can't go wrong at Kyles for LOCAL FRESH ST AUGUSTINE OYSTERS! If you're a vendor and are interested in getting the highest quality products I highly recommend them. I wish more restaurants in town served locally sourced, like Kyles! Please patron this place and tell the restaurants you want local, not Appalachacola. We have the briniest and the best! read more

Well done excellent fish and market. Excellent quality and service. Did I mention that they have a home made whole Key Lime pie also. You won't be disappointed. They also sell cooked and smoked fish. read more

When we are in St Augustine this has been my go to for sushi grade sea scallops and shrimp. It's the best seafood that I've ever bought. They now have Royal Red Shrimp. If you've never had them they taste like lobster but the consistency of shrimp. I purchased a large container of Lobster Bisque that was frozen. Brought it back to Greenville, South Carolina. Thawed it and warmed it up to just the right temperature. Oh my gosh, it's amazing. Add a little bit of Sherry, ground white pepper and little bit of sea salt.....better than any seafood restaurant. Next time I'm bringing 2 containers back. read more

Kyle’s Seafood Market - Lobster Bisque - Seafood Markets Near Me - Saint Augustine, Florida

Yes! Hands down recommended if you want a taste of the local catches. I also highly recommend trying their soup; they have a variety of soups that they make and freeze them but also have 2-3 on special that were never frozen and fresh in a cup that you can bring it home. They even allow you to sample the soup on the counter. I really loved their seafood medley - probably one of the best seafood soup I've had for a while! It was $17 and I had it for 2 meals! Definitely get them ~oyster in the area is more saltier than New England... I guess with warmer water the oyster tastes changes but still delicious ! Clams were awesome and juicy but salty in nature. Lots of locals come here to get ingredients for cooking so definitely stop by if you love preparing your own gourmet seafood meal at home. read more

Kyle’s Seafood Market - the menu and prices - Seafood Markets Near Me - Saint Augustine, Florida

See all

We are staying at an Airbnb for New Years Eve weekend. Restaurant reservations are hard to come by for New Years Eve so we decided to make our own dinner. We researched seafood markets and Kyle's had great reviews. When we arrived this morning the line was out the door. We figured the fish must be pretty good with so many people waiting. We ended up getting beautiful dry scallops and a piece of smoked mullet. Their offerings were so fresh. Lots of people had preordered bushels of oysters. They were so popular that you couldn't get them unless preordered. The staff is fun, efficient and very friendly. read more

Kyle’s Seafood Market - Small but mighty! Lots of locals waiting to pick up their seafood. - Seafood Markets Near Me - Saint Augustine, Florida

This IS the place to buy the best fresh seafood in Saint Augustine! Our second trip to Saint Augustine and our second trip to Kyle's!

After 9 years we are back at Kyle's for fresh local seafood. Same quality and service. Nothing beats the best. read more

See all

A small seafood market but has many wonderful fish selection. Their jumbo shrimps are very good. Prices are reasonable.

Fantastic service and the quality of fish cannot be beat. The fresh off the boat catch, is prepared exactly how you want it. The fishmongers here are kind and extremely helpful. Thank you Kyle's team for your continued services to the community. If I didn't live over 300 miles away, I would pick up fresh catch every day. I stop in every time I visit and then pick up some fresh fish to take home. Stop in and see this little gem, you won't regret it. read more

Kyle’s Seafood Market - Fresh off the boat flounder. Prepared exactly as you request, just like all the other fresh catch. - Seafood Markets Near Me - Saint Augustine, Florida

See all

We stopped by this highly rated seafood market encounter to St Augustine in Christmas weekend. The tiny shop was packed with shoppers stocking up for the holiday on local seafoods. Iced counters were full of shrimp, lobster, fresh fish and other shellfish. There was a busy energy in the room that was intimidating as people shouted their orders. I took a sample of the crab bisque which was out of this world good. The prices were at the top of my range. I settled for a pound of large shrimp for $16, which they packed in ice for me. Service is super friendly and quick. The shrimp was delicious. This ended up being the only place we saw local seafood on our visit. Area grocery stores carried imported or farm raised products. Parking is tight. There is a farm stand next door with great prices on local produce. Check that out too. read more

Kyle’s Seafood Market - 10 lb lobster - Seafood Markets Near Me - Saint Augustine, Florida

First time customer. Was excited to see the variety of products. Bought Grouper, scallops and a crab dip. Grouper and scallops were good. Went to eat the crab dip two days later and noticed the wasn't an use by, prep or expiration date on the tub. Called Kyle's asking how long the dip is good for. He said, "It's good until it starts to smell bad!" Not only is that disgusting but unsafe. Makes me wonder how the handle the product. Pretty sure it's against food code. Will recommend or return. #foodborneillness read more

Okay, I haven't physically been to the store, my mother in law who happens to live in St. Augustine served some Minorcan clam Chowder during thanksgiving weekend and I was very impressed, as a woman of the Caribbean I am very picky about anything that may have seafood in it. Having traveled for work for a few years and eating out constantly I have tried many clam chowders none like a minorcan clam chowder and this right here is a masterpiece of flavors! Having raved so much about this clam chowder my Mother in law served some to me during Christmas and sent me home with my own frozen container to enjoy in Orlando. As a self proclaimed foodie and very big seafood snob I have to say this is amazing and if you are local to the area it's a must try! I will be heading back to St.Augustine and will be paying them a visit because I need to see what other amazing goodies they have available. Secretly hoping this is a soup that will be readily available all year long because I am planning on stocking up during my next visit to being back to Orlando. Bravo!!! Job well done, this soup is simply Divine! read more

Kyle’s Seafood Market - Best clam chowder in the USA! - Seafood Markets Near Me - Saint Augustine, Florida

Kyle's Seafood in St Augustine is an excellent place to buy your seafood!!! Royal Reds were outrageously delish!!! (Reasonably priced) Knowledgeable fellow behind the counter....might have been Kyle ... soft shell crabs cleaned beautifully and all other fish looked excellent, clean and well trimmed The place smelled like a fresh fish market but not like fish if you know what I mean. I will stop by there anytime I'm in the St Aug.area. P.S......There is a nice bakery and a produce store in the same plaza. read more

Kyle's always has the freshest fish and are willing to prep your seafood however you prefer. I had them peel but leave the tails on my royal reds and they were exactly as I requested. I have never been disappointed by the quality of their fish. read more

Big variety and always fresh. Excellent smoked fish. We have been customers for years

I believe it was fellow Yelper Elizabeth M. that mentioned this place to me a while ago and I was interested in paying them a visit, but I put it off and eventually forgot about it. Then much later in an online discussion about where to get smoked mullet from, Kyle's came back up again. It was right after Thanksgiving and I was really trying to be good by eating the rest of the holiday's leftovers but I needed a break in creating various turkey concoctions. On an errand run, I decided to drive down to St. Augustine. The place was small but loaded with all kinds of fish. The guys behind the counter were super attentive and friendly. One pointed me straight to the mullet in the refrigerated case behind me and I'm glad that I came when I did as there were only a few fillets left. For what's considered a "trash fish" people had been snapping those up quick. I also saw a little lonely half of smoked salmon hanging out beside the mullet and taking pity on it, picked it up as well. I checked out what else they had just to get an idea of what else they carried that was interesting and saw key lime pie, multiple kinds of seafood dips, octopus, breaded shark bites (wuuuuutt?), and all sorts of shellfish. I decided then and there that I'd be back for all of them. The prices for the two mullet fillets and the salmon were less than a single dinner at my favorite seafood spot. That made the drive well-worth it. I reheated a mullet fillet and the salmon for dinner and ohhhhhhhh my god....that brought me back to the first time I had it many years ago. The smokiness was encapsulated in every part of it and I fell in love with the taste all over again. I shouldn't have waited so long to try them out. I'm completely sold and will try hard not to make weekly trips to this place. read more

Kyle’s Seafood Market - Smoked Mullet and a piece of smoked salmon - Seafood Markets Near Me - Saint Augustine, Florida

Great place ! Best oysters! I love going here when it's game day or before a big event to get fresh seafood!

Amazing variety and EXTREMELY friendly service! Skillfully filleted a piece of grouper the exact size I needed. Pricey but totally worth it! read more

See all

This place may not look much from the outside but is full of fresh fish . Not sure who the get that called it "my house" but he was very knowledgeable & very generous . I got an extra bag of mullet roe by telling him how much I liked them , after I got my second bag of fish eggs . Regarding the fish , all fish heya were shinny & burgundy gills & if you are not a fisherman that means is freshly caught & kept super fresh . Chances are 48 hours or less . Flash freeze will also keep the fish fresh but it usually leaves parts of gills still frozen . Go get your fresh fish & enjoy it . read more

Kyle’s Seafood Market - Front entrance - Seafood Markets Near Me - Saint Augustine, Florida

When you type seafood in Yelp there's a reason why Kyle's seafood market comes up first. Small and perfect shop for all your seafood needs. Customer service is great. Seafood is fresh. If you can't find what you need here then go eat a burger bud. read more

Kyle’s Seafood Market - Made poke ginger and spicy ahi bowls. With the ahi from kyles - Seafood Markets Near Me - Saint Augustine, Florida

See all

Excellent variety of fish. Fresh and good. We enjoyed the quality and taste. We will be going back this week

We have been patronizing Kyle's for several years now. We have never been disappointed in their fish, and other amazing delicacies (try the smoked fish dip). The staff is consistently accommodating. We strongly recommend. read more

I have only tried two of their menu items. Their shrimp and the key lime pie. The shrimp are so fresh and flavorful. I can't imagine better shrimp. We also like the key lime pie. I am not an expert on key lime pies but everyone eating it gives it high marks. I want to try other menu items, maybe next time. read more

Kyle's is a great place to pick up FRESH seafood. I stopped in today and picked up a couple of fresh shrimp for a shrimp boil tonight. The owner is very friendly and helpful. Over the next couple of months, the state is going to be repairing the road and neighboring bridge. It may take a little bit more effort to get there, but this business needs you to stop by. Pics to follow. read more

Great place for fresh seafood & more. Soups, Smoked Salmon Shrimp's & a Datil cocktail sauce that's off the charts. My go to place for fresh seafood in St Augustine Fl read more

We found this gem a few years back. Always the freshest fish with a knowledgeable staff ready to answer questions. This time it was Fish Spread and Mutton Snapper as the chosen delectables. They did not disappoint! Pan seared the Snapper and it was awesome! Can't wait to get back there! read more

Kyle’s Seafood Market - Mutton Snapper - Seafood Markets Near Me - Saint Augustine, Florida