I've come here a few times in the past several months and the food is always amazing. I hadn't eaten Indian food in several decades and last year felt like trying it again for some reason. I went here and asked what they recommend, since I didn't really understand what anything on the menu was. The guy recommended the chicken karhai and said they could adjust the spice any way I wanted. I asked for mild and it was absolutely delicious. I also got some naan to eat the food with which was also great, and he gave me a free side of rice. I didn't want to change my order because I was worried I wouldn't like anything else but earlier today I tried the chicken tikka masala which I'd heard of before but never eaten and it was even better than the karhai, it will now become my new go-to dish here. $14 for a huge portion, can't go wrong. I usually get it to go but ate in once, the restaurant doesn't look fancy but it's clean and cozy. Surprisingly it always seems pretty empty, I would expect there would be more people coming in. Definitely recommend! read more

Just went here for the first time and everything was delicious. We got the samosa chaat, garlic naan, lotus crepe, chicken and beef shami kabaabs and mango lassi. The flavor profile of every dish was on point. We started with the samosa chaat which are fried flaky pastry balls of potato and peas topped with spiced onions and chickpeas. They were served with a sweet sauce as well as a spicier creamy sauce. Both were good. We loved the sweet sauce. The shamis were patties of the beef and chicken mixed with lentils and spices and cooked with an egg. The lotus crepe was filled with cookie butter and strawberries and topped with more cookie butter and a biscoff cookie We cannot wait to come back here. All the dishes resonated well with us and the staff was friendly and helpful in us deciding on our dishes. read more

See all

Truly authentic Pakistani breakfast. Tasted just like home and everything was delicious. We started off with their hot and delicious puri with the masala channa. Seasoned and spiced perfectly with the fluffy texture of the puri, so so so yummy. I would definitely recommend having the Aloo bujia because without it, the breakfast will not be complete. The Aloo, channa and the beef haleem were perfectly balanced and not too overpowering with their flavors. The Beef haleem hit the spot! With the hot fluffy, and a little crispy naan. They complemented each other very well and if you want a little tang to it, you can add on the extra garlic and onions with it. read more

See all

Came for lunch. Waited and no one approached us. A family of culture came and a waitress came right away to take their order. Short story we left. read more

Redchilli - the outside of a store - Indian Near Me - Selden, New York

Chicken Shawarma Sandwich @halalRedchili Red Chilli 1228 Middle Country Rd, Selden, NY 11784 A lot of people have been sleeping on this Restaurant. It's under NEW management. The food is fantastic and the prices are great. Including the service. Don't listen to the older reviews since that was under the old management. I ordered chicken shawarma, and chicken shish tawook rice platter. It takes about 15 minutes to 20 minutes to make, so please be patient. I ordered for take out. There isn't much seating. The owner is very nice and helped me decide what I should get. Review: (4 out of 5 stars) Everything was pretty good, but the chicken shawarma hit different. It's light, delicious, and it reminded me of the shawarmas I've had in Michigan, which has a huge Arab population. The shawarma sandwich was cut into small pieces and wrapped perfectly which is easy to eat and I liked as it didn't cause the sauce to drip or chicken coming out of the wrap. I would definitely recommend to try their chicken shawarma and the fries. I think it was seasoned with salt, pepper, and some Arab spices too, but I honestly don't know and they were good. The chicken shish tawook comes with onions, tomatoes, and rice. Everything was moist and juicy. I had one chicken that was a bit too chewy, but I ate the others and they were good. - Chicken Shawarma sandwich served with French fries - Chicken Shish Tawook platter served with rice This is an updated place now with a new owner who genuinely wants to run a good and honest business. I believe all the middle eastern part of menu is up to mark. I haven't had much of the Indian part of their menu, except the naan and I'll say it's is ok. However, I'll definitely have to come back and give a full review of the desi food. Let them know Ali sent you, and ask for the Chicken Shawarma. Lastly, don't forget to say Bismillah and Alhamdulilah for everything Follow me on Instagram @Alithehalalfoodie read more

Redchilli - Chicken Shawarma Sandwich - Indian Near Me - Selden, New York

See all

This place seems to go through ownership changes a lot. But the recent owners are nice and good quality is decent. Nice sit down place where you can go with family and friends. They can cater various palates! read more

Very Good Indian food; they also have a Buffet. The food is very tasty & not too spicy and very delicious. I would say that the food seems to be of an authentic homemade style of cuisine NOT a restaurant style of cuisine. The actual restaurant is very modest to put it nicely. Therefore my suggestion would be to utilize as a tasty takeout place.. Or as a simple "Humble" Mom & Pop traditional Indian restaurant. read more

Redchilli - Red Chili Indian Restaurant. - Indian Near Me - Selden, New York

First time under the new management. My wife and I Had the brown rice and vegetable samosas, they were great! Freshly Made, spicy but not hot full of flavor, the brown rice was light and heavenly! Would have given them another star but instead of the expected tamarind sauce they gave us a cup of ketchup! In a middle eastern restaurant??? Must have been a mistake! Anyway the food is excellent, can't wait to go back! read more

Terribly slow service. I was forced to wait 30 minutes for 5 naan. The food was barely edible and tasteless, and the person behind the counter is passive and rude. I've been here a few times and got overcharged twice, so watch out for that too. read more

One of my boys introduced me to Redchili and I was not disappointed, esp. with their chicken and lamb combination platter. It could be a lil' bit more spicier, but that's just me; otherwise, you'll find me downing two servings at once. Count me as a fan, not to mention a believer that Suffolk County has its share of good Halal food. read more

gave me a shawarma for a different order that had been sitting on the counter getting soggy instead of making me one fresh when i ordered it and it was overall a bad soggy shawarma and fries that i had to reheat at home read more

We catered food from here last night. Everything was delicious and fresh. The falafel was very flavorful and Was perfectly fried. The mixed grill platter was excellent . Chicken very flavorful and juicy. Lamb perfectly cooked and seasoned as was the kufta. It came with salad, delicious naan and really good hummus. Will definitely be adding this restaurant to our list of go to places. Looking forward to trying their Indian next time. Thank you for a delicious dinner! read more

I ordered biryani for Diwali party, that too last minute and my order was taken and customized as per my liking. The veg & non- veg biryani was really appreciated by my guests. Thank you Red Chille! read more

Worst food ive had in years... this place is under new management and the food is terrible. I bought the Chicken Buryani. Was that chicken in there? If it was, there were 2 tiny pieces of chicken and they were on the bone. There was more bone than chicken. The one piece of chicken was nothing but gristle. I started coming here in the early spring of 2021 under the old management... food was excellent then. A few hours after eating, I got sick. Will never come back there again. read more

Best chicken biryani in existence!!! And I have had it in India!! this is more flavorful, to me!! The tandoori chicken legs are outrageous!!! the obligatory raita is top shelf!! Oh!! did I mention my favorite aloo paratha !! Makes me feel like I'm back in Hyderabad!! read more

The food was absolutely delicious the curry plates it just melts in your mouth My wife and i on our first visit we will eat here again

Twice ordered curry dishes from here, both chicken curry & lamb vindaloo. First time = very 'soupy' for a curry dish, contacted the owner - PayPal credit for the dish delivered. Hummus great, that's great. Second time, curry dishes are complete water. Will not order dishes from them again in the future! It's like getting a bad egg-roll from a Chinese place, that's their staple dish (curry) You potential customers got this? $60 dollars each time x2 read more

New owner and name for this location. Similar menu. The young lady behind the counter was very friendly. This is clearly a family run business and nice to see. Food was very good and fresh. Try the Tawa Keema. You'll start sweating as soon as you smell it. It's that spicy. Here's a tip- eat the salad after the chicken to help take the edge of the heat. Nan is fresh. The basmatti rice was cooked just right. Goat was so good that I started to Baaaaaa. Great place for something different to try. Sylvester knows best! read more

Don't buy from this place they are very rude and gives terrible serious. I tried to order something over the phone and because they were busy the guy gave a huge attitude. Never ordering again. First off I order from this place alot on uber eats this was the first time i called. So for them to speak to me so rudely just because I questioned the price was very disappointing and unprofessional. Now im totally turned off from this restaurant. read more

THE HOSPITALITY IS AMAZING. This is a family owned business and the owners and workers will treat you as one of their own. the food is also amazing and feels homemade. Love this place and would recommend to anyone and everyone. i wish I could give 6 stars as a rating. read more

Every once in a while I get a craving for South East Asian cuisine and am notorious for Traveling as far as Queens to get my fix! After a long tiring day of work, I called my wife to ask what was on the menu tonight, only to be disappointed to learn nothing at all! I suggested to go out to a nice local Indian restaurant as i had been fantasizing about chicken Tikka, Lamb kebabs, Biryani, Naan, and so on and so on. I asked my buddy google for assistance and it directed me to Red Chilli. My 1st impression walking into this establishment.... is it a restaurant or a supermarket? I took a deep breath and walked towards the gentleman behind the counter, expecting at least a smile or maybe a hello? Neither. We sat down and waited for a server only to find the gentleman behind the counter walk over, hand us a TAKE OUT MENU, and proceeded to take our order. I asked for refreshment options and was told to walk to a refrigerator and help myself to any pop of my liking. I usually judge a new Indian restaurant by there 4 main entrees to determine if it makes my list: Biryani, Mix Tikka Grill (usually consists of lamb, chicken, beef, fish), chicken Tikka Masala, and Naan Bread. Biryani: Good! Mix Grill: fish was tasty, Lamb kebabs were a day old and cold, some chicken kebabs were undercooked, Beef Kebabs had a weird smell which I didn't want to adventure with. Chicken Masala- the butter sauce had flavor however chicken undercooked. Naan: on point! It had the right consistency. Check please? The server/owner/cook brought over my bill... to add insult to injury they added the gratuity to the bill. I overheard the other table object to this and the server/owner told them that it was a new law? No sir, you're wrong!!! The percentage of gratuity is based on quality of services provided and shouldn't be forced onto the customers. It's a awful practice to do business as it deters repeat business! The whole ride back home I violently fantasized about rushing home and hugging my toilet. Good luck to the Owner! read more

Worst food ever!!!!....... They don't know how chilli chicken is made. It's an Indo-Chinese dish with garlic, ginger, onions and chilli. But they made it with tomatoes, like a curry. And on top of that they say this is the how it is made. Don't ever think of trying any Indian food from here. You will never get that taste it's complete waist of money and time. They should shut it down and stop fooling people. read more

This food is overpriced for the quality- the meat curries are expensive but contain really low quantity and quality of meat- chicken is mostly bone. Flavor's pretty good but sometimes bland for Pakistani food... There's a lot of oil and water for the cost. chicken keema is tasty though- and naan is reliable read more

UNDER NEW MANAGEMENT! This place is Finger licking good. Absolutely delicious. I love coming here. They cook everything fresh and to perfection. Their naan is to die for and their Indian breakfast is my new favorite. I alway try new dishes every time I go and they are all so good. 5/5 read more

This business STOLE money from my brother. They took ADVANTAGE of a YOUNG child and overcharged him by $5. When we called them, they started screaming at us and they ended the call. They claimed to not know how much my brother gave them. Does that make sense? This is a HORRIBLE business and the customer service is rude and mean. They don't respect their customers in any way, shape, and/or form. Also, my brother paid with cash and there is a sign on the cash register that states that tax does not apply with cash payment, but they charged tax. The customer service employees at the establishment are idiots and they are rude. I would not recommend this restaurant to ANYONE. read more

It was super good and the restaurant was friendly, if I had one complaint I would have wanted more rice with my curry but it was still very yummy. I got it with the garlic naan as well that I enjoyed. I hope to go back soon! read more

so good 10/10 i love their chicken tikki masala and their chicken biryani !!!! 100% recommend to go, service is amazing

Come back Time Out to Eat! First off it is half the size of the place now. Behind the wall where the dining room was were piles of boxes. So strange. Went for the buffet. Walked in and needed to wait to be seated because the woman was on the phone and the man was too busy looking at his cell phone to be bothered. Sat, had to ask for a drink. They pointed to the drink fridge and we had to get our own. Also had to ask for water and silverware. More than half the trays of food were empty and we had to wait for more to be cooked. When the food finally came out it was average, nothing to rave about. Probably won't go back. We miss you TOTE!! read more

Best Indian food Ive had in the states. Good portions for reasonable price. Goat was tender and delicious. Everything was very fresh. Would definitely go again! read more

I found its listing on Yelp! On the website they claimed to serve authentic South Indian cuisine ....I was a little surprised with that....because they had also listed Indian, Pakistani and Halal ! This halal is a tell-tale sign that it cannot be an Indian Restaurant and it is difficult to believe that a Pakistani restaurant can serve authentic South Indian food ?!! I thought may be its a joint venture....sure enough, when we reached there, the two gentlemen at the counter looked little uncomfortable ! I saw that there was a big table set near the counter and it looked like that Red Chilli we're hosting a cute kid's 3rd birthday party! They conveniently forgot to mention this on their website!! I had driven there with my friends after driving 10 miles. They said that you can sit and have the meal there but they have a birthday party starting at 7:30 PM....so we have to be done by that time....I glanced at my watch as the gentleman was giving this information....lit was 7:30 PM at the dot !! I drew his attention....he didn't look baffled....just insisted that we should just order for take out....meanwhile the guest for the party had started coming in....they all looked at us with little unease.... We started looking at their takeout menu - The whole South Indian Cuisine section was crossed out by a dark sharpee ! There - he ended my suspense....when I enquired about it....the man just looked straight into my eyes and said "oh! that was from the previous "owner" !!....meaning it was left over from Red Chilli's previous incarnation ....in which it was owned by an Indian. We still ordered the food, instead of walking out - because I did not want the onlookers to think of their venue for their b'day party as some lame swindlers....It is definitely false advertising on their website that they serve South Indian cuisine....let alone authentic ! As soon as we ordered and paid for it....the man instructed (not requested) us to go and sit near the entrance/waiting area....my friends were still fetching their drinks from the cooler, mentioned by the previous reviewer.... Food ? Just OK....nothing special, not even average.... We ordered two biryanis - none of them came with yogurt ! I have always eaten biryani - Indian - Hyderabadi, Pakistani whatever, with a thick, liquid yogurt prep. Because there are various spices in its preparation.... In Summary, I will never ever go there again and unfortunately can never recommend to anybody to do so either... Very unprofessional behavior.... read more

Loved the Biryani, samosa chaat and tikka masala. Nice seating area and timely service. Would go again.

First time trying it with the new owner. My husband ordered the goat and I had a gyro on pita. Both were very good. Took a while to get the food.....I would recommend calling to order if you want to pick up just in case they are busy. I definitely would go back! read more

I'm not sure what some other reviewers are talking about, but ever since the new ownership, I've only had good experiences here. Food is authentic Indo-pak cuisine and family run which is a plus. Every time I've been there the service has been great. Had their chicken makhni and it was great - would recommend. Definitely recommend this spot for those looking for some quality Indian food. read more

Ordered a family meal for just 4 people for Thanksgiving - A whole tandoori chicken chargha, brown rice, mashed potatoes, and salad. To be fair, the food was delicious. HOWEVER, the portion of mashed potatoes was totally ridiculous. I think they used a total of one potato to make this quantity. Also, they totally forgot to include the salad. For $60, this was a total rip-off and I regret not driving the extra 20 minutes to Hicksville to save $30 for the same meal. read more

The best Halal Indian Pakistani food in New York and Long Island very good food fresh

Loved the new owners and food, until tonight. When the older man working laughed at me trying to ask for extra sauce (said I'd pay!!) and hung up the phone on me. The younger girls are extremely nice and helpful. Food is delicious. But I Wasn't even done ordering and the man was so rude. I assume the owner. We order once a week from here. Not again! read more

We had heard really good things about this place but unfortunately didn't like the food at all. The spinach we ordered was really watery and had a weird smell to it. Chicken makhani was okay. Not much to write home about. read more

Everything is delicious, really humble people running the place, great hole in the wall spot tucked away in the corner of a strip mall you would never know this gem was here. read more

Food is AMAZING with excellent service! The staff is very friendly and the food came out very quick. You definitely get your dollars worth here! read more

We ate here last night and we spotted a cockroach on the wall next to us after being just about done with our meal...was hard to digest our food afterwards read more